r/GraphicsProgramming • u/SnoozeDoggyDog • Aug 28 '20
What are some cloud-based solutions for path-tracing/volumetric path tracing?
There's already long since been general cloud-based ray-tracing solutions...
https://software.intel.com/content/www/us/en/develop/articles/tracing-rays-through-the-cloud.html
https://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/6322/sponsored_feature_changing_the_.php?print=1
But are there any solutions for path-tracing or volumetric path tracing?
4
u/snerp Aug 29 '20
are you asking how to do path tracing, or asking how to do cloud streaming? streaming a game from a cloud machine shouldn't really care what type of method is used to render... it's just video output either way.
-4
u/SnoozeDoggyDog Aug 29 '20
Ordinary or even low-level ray-tracing for a finished product, especially a game, is extremely hardware-intensive/computationally-expensive. More accurate path-tracing, even more so; possibly impossible on most current local hardware.
I'm looking for cloud-based full path-tracing so that even low-level hardware can run it without issue.
8
u/snerp Aug 29 '20
I'm looking for cloud-based full path-tracing so that even low-level hardware can run it without issue.
so, you don't have a path tracer already? You'll need to figure that out as step one.
Then, basically, you need to rent a bunch of gpus from azure/aws/whatever, get your tracer running in that environment, and then also run a streaming service to get input and output.
based on how long it's taken microsoft to get their streaming thing going, it seems like a really hard problem to actually stream games effectively: https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/10/21362384/microsoft-xcloud-game-streaming-xbox-game-pass-ultimate-beta-date
-4
u/SnoozeDoggyDog Aug 29 '20
Isn't the majority of MS Flight Simulator mostly Azure cloud-rendered?
7
u/snerp Aug 29 '20
I don't think so, doesn't it just download map data from bing or something like that? I'm not finding any references to it being rendered anywhere besides on your pc
-4
u/SnoozeDoggyDog Aug 29 '20
It seems to be the process, at least partially:
Using a base mesh and textures, the game utilises your internet connection to stream even higher quality terrain data onto your PC as you play, via the Azure cloud. It is a novel way to boost the game's fidelity and diversity that I've yet to see in any other release. This is indeed a fully fledged 'power of the cloud' implementation that delivers something that just wouldn't be possible to the same fidelity with a conventional download.
It's not just environment detail that's streamed in either. Flight Simulator also accurately renders the real-time world location of actual planes in your vicinity.
https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2020-flight-simulator-preview-tech-analysis
Microsoft and Asobo are constantly working on cloud technology to, for example, stream some of the more detailed scenery to your computer on demand, chances are we’ll see regular content updates for these various editions as well.
https://www.flightlineweekly.com/post/microsoft-s-flight-simulator-2020-as-real-as-it-gets
10
u/snerp Aug 29 '20
That's streaming content, maps and terrain data like I said. They aren't streaming rendered frames.
3
u/the_Demongod Aug 29 '20
Are you talking about streaming this in real-time, or doing it offline e.g. rendering scenes in 3D modeling software?
0
u/SnoozeDoggyDog Aug 29 '20
The finished product being streamed in real-time.
3
u/the_Demongod Aug 29 '20
Latency will be an issue, as the companies trying to develop remote gaming platforms are discovering. What are you doing that raytracing is inadequate for, but path tracing isn't? As you said, path tracing is an immensely intensive process that is not viable in real time on modern hardware (probably even on a server), but ray tracing isn't, and depending on what you're doing, raytracing isn't necessarily even that expensive.
0
u/SnoozeDoggyDog Aug 29 '20
Doesn't path-tracing provide more accurate, more realistic results than just standard ray-tracing, as well as more complex lighting and reflections?
Volumetric path tracing adds light scattering on top of this.
2
u/the_Demongod Aug 29 '20
It does, but it's way, way more computationally intensive than ray tracing. Like, orders of magnitude slower, for a fully path-traced image. It's the true physics approach to integrating the light field that hits every surface, but the benefit is not even close to worth it for real-time applications, because ordinary cutting edge ray tracing with some light fragment shader ray-marching added in can get you 90% of the way there at a vastly lower cost. I doubt anyone will ever try to use path tracing for real-time graphics because ray tracing gets you almost all the physical correctness at vastly better performance. Even full-on 3D rendering engines like Blender's Cycles renderer use raytracing, not path tracing.
1
u/vwibrasivat Aug 29 '20 edited Aug 29 '20
rebusFarm
sheepit render farm (possibly free)
fox render farm
garagefarm.net
superrendersfarm.com
1
0
u/daffy_ch Aug 29 '20
OTOY is probably the best known company trying to get full path tracing streamed to low weight devices.
Their real-time path tracer Brigade in action
https://twitter.com/otoy/status/1289388770345721857?s=21
Their blockchain based rendering and later streaming network:
Here is a playlist with all their SIGGRAPH and GTC & GDC talks:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLML0nNWRCHfr5ojOURqpfPLsDMJIh_9i0
4
u/ShillingAintEZ Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 29 '20
Your links are about games streaming their video. What is the difference in ray tracing and path tracing? What are you trying to do?