r/GraphicsProgramming • u/PeterBrobby • Apr 15 '24
Is Vulkan a failed API?
I know it's modern and can do things that older APIs like OpenGL can't but how many developers are benefiting from the added verbosity and complexity?
The OpenGL reddit has more members and higher engagement than the Vulkan reddit despite the fact that OpenGL hasn't been updated in 7 years.
Personally, I would prefer if an API like Metal had cross platform support, it's modern and far less verbose.
0
Upvotes
1
u/hishnash Dec 14 '25
What do you mean locked down? I would not consider metal any more locked down than any other graphics api.
I am not sure metal is stagnant either, We have seen a lot of rather huge changes with MTL4.
As to if you recommend it that depends the platform your looking to build for of course.
However if you looking to for a first api top tart learning graphics dev with MTL is a great place to start.
Since you can start out with higher level concepts leaving thing like memory and tracking up to the driver and then gradually adopt lower level untracked models it is a great api for new-comers to the industry.
And more those with more experience who just want to play around with new ideas and do not want to spend 3 weeks re-implementing a memory manager when they are interested in a new way achieving some new visual effect. Once you lock down the effect sure you can port it over to all the apis you need to target but MTL is a great place to start out as a playground domain.