r/GooseBumps • u/Business_Ad_2050 • Oct 16 '23
r/GooseBumps • u/[deleted] • Oct 14 '23
DISCUSSION I don't get the hate
Spoilers too, I can't use 2 flairs though
Let me preface by saying: I expected some of the hate. Two boys kissed and those of you with two braincells got real scared and angry. If that's you, grow up please.
The hate OUTSIDE of that though feels like people who are way too nostalgic/attached to the past.
I'm in my late twenties and have been a fan pretty much since birth. I've read the original 62 at least 3 times over and I can't even count how many times I've watched the show, and I really enjoy the reboot. Depending on how the last 5 episodes play out its even possible I could love it.
Don't get me wrong, especially after the movies, and especially Haunted Halloween, I wanted an anthology just as much as anyone. Especially since if they made a season based on the Horrorland books it could've been an anthology AND a connected story, just like those books, and had a better shot of pleasing both sides of this argument. And all that is to say I still love it, and I think I know why.
I'm not saying this negatively or to be mean about anyone, just saying how I view the series vs others here.
I went in wanting to like it and ready to find things to enjoy and I honestly think, rather it was from the first press release nearly 2 years ago saying it wasn't gonna be an anthology or from the trailer needle dropping Travis Scott's titular song, a lot of you went in with the exact opposite intentions.
My reason for saying that is so much of the criticism about the show (including the unfortunate homophobia) is almost all the same sentiments being parroted around each other in a little echo chamber of what feels like the Jerryboree scene of Rick And Morty. Everyone is just saying the same stuff and smiling when someone else does too.
It's not that that's inherently wrong, obviously if there's a major issue, multiple people will pick up on it and thus state it, but almost all the accusations about its lack of quality share a lot of claims that at least I personally see very little evidence for.
This show does not remotely feel like Stranger Things or Riverdale nor does it feel like the writers attempt at capturing that. It just happens to have a similar-ish setting. I also have no idea how it could be both Stranger Things AND Riverdale yet I often see the two lumped together into a ball to be thrown at this show.
Oh but what about the mask? Boo hoo it doesn't look exactly like the books. They took a new direction, and even as someone who enjoys the show its not one I'm a huge fan of but I do think it's interesting to see them try a new angle of something we already seen perfectly tackled in the 90s show. And honestly? Go Eat Worms and Cuckoo Clock were both beefed up so significantly from their books and episodes, that I'm sure most of this sub would agree were some of the worst, that I can't say I mind the trade off.
Especially with scenes like the football scene in episode 1 and the worm chase in 4, I legitimately can't say I understand the people saying there's absolutely NOTHING worth watching this for.
What it ultimately comes down to for me, in theory and in the kindest way possible, is... it feels like a lot of people here are really stuck on the past and are kind of just mad/sad/annoyed and or grappling with the fact that media, or at least this kind or type of media, isn't being made FOR them anymore. We can consume this, we can enjoy or hate it, but the fact of the matter is we AREN'T the target audience anymore, at least not the main one. Which is why there will be Easter eggs, call backs and what not, but it's not going to be made to cater to us and I think based on the generation goosebumps originally came out, this is the first time a lot of the OG fans of it are really experiencing that.
It was never going to have the original theme or intro. We've known for nearly 2.5 years at this point it wasn't going to be an anthology. We've known for 2 or 3 month which books they'd be adapting. We've known since the first trailer the mask wouldn't look like the book version. If you seen all of those flags and they appeared red to you and you still got on the ride and were shocked you didn't like it, that's on you. Not the writers, not the actors, not the directors.
You're not wrong for not liking it, but the sheer amount of negative reviews I've seen from people outright stating they thought they wouldn't like it from the start is a little disappointing...
r/GooseBumps • u/Purplepepperpipes • Jan 05 '26
SCORE OF THE WEEK Just a belated little Christmas gift I received in the mail today NSFW
When I opened an unassuming AusPost package this morning, I wasn't expecting to be slapped by a nostalgia hit with a crude and quirky Aussie twist.
Fun Fact: To get the glow pic, I had the pleasure of sitting in my closet on a hot Australian afternoon while trying to get a bright enough glow and clear focus (it....worked well enough)
r/GooseBumps • u/Gunch90 • Oct 22 '23
DISCUSSION Am I the only one thats super upset whith what they did to the new slappy?
I feel like one of the big traits to Slappy is that hes silly. Like hed just a puppet and he can walk around and do things. The disney+ show took him too serious and he ended up with a cringe teen. His voice is not fitting and the design is god awful. I hate they gave him human hair. He cant even move on his own besides yknow moving his head but he cant walk around on his own. I have never been this upset about a thing I love
r/GooseBumps • u/MerryKookaburra • Oct 16 '23
Anyone get freaked out seeing ep 3s title
As a trans person and old school goosebumps nerd. I was fucking terrified of the Cuckoo Clock of Doom being adapted with a trans dude lead. Luckily it was like a timeloop thing, but I remember that book, it was the first one I read that got me hooked. I was terrified I was gonna get a time jumpy thing where a trans dude would be sent back to his pre transition dysphoria days which would be such a way to make the original more terrifying. I'm happy they didn't go that direction as visceral trans flashbacks are overdone in media, but boy was I worried.
r/GooseBumps • u/Linkhylian22 • Aug 27 '25
Animating Goosebumps Covers Pt.2
Hey everyone! I have a couple others i just got finished with, wanted to share to get some feedback, any suggestions or any requests on what cover you would like to see. Thanks! Enjoy!
r/GooseBumps • u/DanTheBanHandler • Feb 18 '24
MEME I enjoy reading Goosebumps books, I do not enjoy the books
r/GooseBumps • u/Crafter235 • Dec 01 '23
MEME I feel the new show is just a masquerade for a Culture War
r/GooseBumps • u/PicturesinRed • Oct 27 '23
TV SERIES Probably a broken record, but this new show would work better as an anthology
I honestly would prefer it in the format of the original show where each episode is a book adaption, even if they have like 3 parters for each episode. I would have liked that more than just generic teen life drama with hints of GB here and there.
I think the reason they don't wanna do the anthology route is because the new generation of fans are all about latching onto familiar celebs and following that celeb around and following all their socials and they need returning cast to latch onto and with the anthology route it would be introducing different people each time.
I think Nightmare Room, Deadtime Stories and The Haunting Hour are three examples of how to do this type of show the correct way. I liked all three of them. But I'm not too much into this new show, because of it just being the typical teen soap opera. I don't really want to invest in these characters, I just want a new story each time with its own twists and turns.
r/GooseBumps • u/GoosebumpsFaN1101 • Aug 21 '25
DISCUSSION Do You Think M Night Shyamalan Stole a Lot of the Plot Twists In his Movies from Goosebumps
r/GooseBumps • u/Status-Avocado5831 • Jul 24 '26
Iām sure Iāll find a way but a mask and a house?!?!
r/GooseBumps • u/Lilcommy • Oct 16 '23
TV SERIES The new Disney+ show is 100% unwatchable.
I'm 4 minutes and 30 seconds into the first episode and they didn't use the OG intro music. I can't watch this.
Yes this is a joke.
r/GooseBumps • u/alexh2795 • Dec 03 '25
DISCUSSION Just noticed something disturbing about the TV episode "Don't go to Sleep"
Uhh....why is 12-year-old Matt Amsterdam marrying a grown woman in one of his realities?
Yeah...disturbing. Now imagine if it was a grown man marrying a girl in the story.
r/GooseBumps • u/[deleted] • Oct 16 '23
If you donāt like the new series because itās inclusive there is a door that should hit you on your way out.
The title said it all.
r/GooseBumps • u/aRandomEddsworldFan • Jan 26 '26
DISCUSSION Ive been hyperfixating on goosebump and remembered how much it sucks to be a Horror
Even when I was little I was just like āhow are these guys even aliveā
No wonder they like scaring people but do they have to be pinched by a human specifically or if they pinch themselves by setting something heavy down does that count?
Imagine youāre talking to your friend when they accidentally get pinched by a door or something, unless itās specifically humans then at least itās manageable
r/GooseBumps • u/Kayla_canadian • Mar 15 '26
Ewwww
Iāve been seeing a lot of posts about this book so decided to read this one next and WOW itās a stinker. Kinda stinks like Chicken Sh*t. Does it get worse than this one ? Iāve currently read 36/62.
r/GooseBumps • u/FieldofJudgement • Nov 21 '23
TV SERIES Hate to say it, but what I've learnt from the new show is that Gen Z are boring. While the books and original show had characters with hobbies, the new show has kids just sitting on phones and getting emotional about love drama. They made a Horror Land episode 50% about teen love & text messages..
r/GooseBumps • u/theradioheadflan • May 28 '24
Another wacky and relatable Goosebumps meme!
r/GooseBumps • u/Fancy_Standard_6777 • Jul 24 '25
DISCUSSION What are your opinions on Slime doesnāt pay? (Yes I used a fan made cover)
I heard about this book being a lost gem along with ādead dogs still fetchā but I was very happy to hear that it did get published, just not as a goosebumps book like it was intended. This was a fine book, I did feel for the main character and honestly she didnāt deserve all this. Her little brother is a monster but I could see this as a goosebumps episode of some kind. It has that charm to it but it feels too modern. Thereās constant talk about AirPods, YouTube and cell phones and idk it just feels like itās not going to hold up well but I understand why itās here. I wonder what an original goosebumps story would have been. But whatās your opinion on the book if youāve read it?
r/GooseBumps • u/[deleted] • Oct 28 '23
TV SERIES The new show signs have been called Goosebumps-ish (it's good but it's not the books)
Or title it Goosebumps: the story the books were based on. (Not actually but as a twist)
Let's be clear: I'm enjoying the show. I think it's actually pretty good and out of the other remade horror anthologies-turned-one-story shows, it works much better.
That said, it's not Goosebumps. It has a loose connection to the books and show. And if you wanted to make it interesting, you could have one of the characters start writing Goosebumps books at the end of the series, naming themself R.L. Stine.
While it is good, it's not what I thought I was getting, and I blame the Disney brand for that. While it's more mature than the kids show was, it's still not what it could be. What I was expecting, and I think what some folks wanted, was HBO levels of actual death and gore and story. Ideally in the anthology format, of course, though I do like the idea of having each book happen at the same school. So a pure anthology format isn't necessary.
I was mostly let down by the stories not being as explored as they could have been. We had 3 pics taken with the death camera and none of them were that bad, nor did they end in death. Really, the opening episode should have had at least one seemingly main character for gruesomely because of the camera.
r/GooseBumps • u/Doodles_n_Scribbles • Oct 11 '24
DISCUSSION Old Millennial Whines about TV Show She Hasn't Even Watched
I have a weird theory about horror, that it's the inverse of the Superhero genre. In superhero comics, heroes are often defined by their villain. Likewise, in horror, the monster/slasher/thing that what be scary is defined by their victims/survivors.
There is no Freddy Krueger without Nancy. There is no Dracula without John and Mina Harker. There are no Deadites without Ash Williams.
In that vein, I take issue with this 2015 Goosebumps film and the tv show last year because they ignore the kids who actually had to face the monsters in their original stories.
Like, Isabella is not Carly Beth. They have completely personalities as far as I've heard. Isabella gets revenge through online means, versus more meek Carly Beth. And I'm assuming the haunted mask (which, by the way, that design sucks, 30 years of advancements in FX makeup and you make the Haunted Mask, THE most iconic goose villain, a doll mask?) brings out that interior sadism and makes her see the error of her ways. A decent concept, but I'd have rather had Ana Yi Puig just play Carly Beth with all her anxiety and dread. Instead of drawing out what's already there, I like that the mask transforms her in the book, turning her into something she's not.
Similarly, I just feel like there's a tone problem. The series seems too serious. Goosebumps is supposed to be goofy. It's not like Fear Street with its axe murdering cheer leaders, the monsters of goosebumps are tubs of silly putty and witches obsessed with please and thank you.
I would be ok with a more continuous narrative for Goosebumps, but I want the characters from the books. Evan Ross, Lucy Dark, the Deeps, Ricky Beamer, and I want the monsters to be untouched. Don't make them related to each other. And no, I don't care who they cast.
That was my problem with the 2015 film as well. The only goose kid present is Hannah.
r/GooseBumps • u/65GhoserReddit65 • Jan 03 '24