Hey everyone,
I've got a 6-speed DQ250 DSG. I've been chasing a strange intermittent thud for months and can't seem to get a definitive diagnosis.
The issue mainly happens at low speeds (roughly 8–40 km/h), particularly when slowing down or getting back on the accelerator after coasting. It feels like something in the drivetrain briefly gets stuck or binds, then suddenly releases with a thud/clunk. Sometimes there's a tiny RPM bump and occasionally a faint rattle afterwards.
The weird part is that it doesn't necessarily happen during gear changes. I've reproduced it while the gearbox remains in 2nd gear, including when creeping along at around 20 km/h without touching the brakes and then gently applying throttle.
A few other observations:
- Shifting into Neutral before stopping completely eliminates the main thud.
- It seems worse with more passengers or during warmer drives, although some drives are almost completely smooth.
- Braking very gently can sometimes prevent it.
- Occasionally feels like a two-stage clunk coming from the front.
- Recently selected Reverse, released the brake, and the car sat still for about half a second to a second before a small clunk and then began creeping backwards.
- Gear changes are generally smooth, sometimes slightly firm, but there's no obvious slipping, persistent judder or violent jerking. The car pulls perfectly under acceleration.
I've already had a DSG fluid service and readaptation performed at a specialist. I've also tested with the Haldex fuse removed (no difference), installed dogbone inserts (no improvement), and had the mounts inspected without any obvious failure identified.
I've taken it to multiple VW specialists. Some say it's normal DQ250 behaviour, while another recommended replacing the entire transmission based on hearing a noise with the car on a hoist. No one has demonstrated an actual internal gearbox fault or identified a confirmed fault code explaining the issue.
I'm starting to suspect excessive drivetrain backlash, a worn engine/transmission mount, or some kind of DSG clutch engagement/control issue.
Has anyone experienced something similar, particularly a thud during torque reversal WITHOUT an actual gear change? I'd really appreciate any ideas on what to inspect or log before throwing thousands at a replacement transmission.