r/GoldenRealm • u/Shade-RHB • Apr 10 '14
More thoughts on reset
Was talking with people tonight, and the general impossibility of rebuilding anything like the town we have now. It's just not happening.
And the current structure of the new town is a rigid, lifeless grid. I can't even properly fit my existing builds into it without going grossly out of the rules for bidding. There's no places for special premium builds, and it's all ugly savannah with it's hideous brown grass.
But a valid point was made in that much of town is currently occupied by abandoned relic builds, giving little incentive for anyone new to work in town.
If we're open to editing things around to help increase interest, instead of wiping all the beautiful things we've done, why don't we instead use edit on the exiting world and start pruning out dead branches.
If I recall correctly there are commands that can restore a chunk to it's default seed state. Why don't instead edit relic builds away to a museum zone (if they seem worthy of saving), or just flat out wipe them back to seed state if they're an incomplete relic of someone who is no longer playing.
We could empty out half the town without unravelling the essential beauty and majesty we have achieved with it. It's got green hills, mountain views, lovely rivers through the town, and premium plots for grand, epic builds. Everything the rigid savannah grid of the new town location does not.
As it stands everyone is boxed into identical boxes with no variety, no working with the landscape to find the natural flow and beauty. It's just a grid.
And the map seed as a whole looks really boring. It's just one giant land mass.
Instead of throwing out a good thing we have going, why don't we try to revitalize it? Clear out dead wood so fresh things can thrive? Moving from beautiful to boring I can't imagine is going to excite anyone. It sure isn't exciting me. I feel almost no buzz for a reset at this point.
Maybe 2 or 3 people who go "oh that might be nice", but where's the 15-20 people chomping at the bit for a new world? We've had that every previous time, and it's just not here now. I think instead of revitalizing, this is going to be final nail in the coffin. The modded people are not going to come back in meaningful numbers. We can make space for new people without destroying all that's been done.
I reiterate, I think this is a TERRIBLE IDEA. It is too soon, done for the wrong reasons, without the eagerness of the community behind it. You're trying to recapture the vitality and passion we had right after the reset into the current map (which I agree was a beautiful, wonderful thing), but the circumstances now are NOT analogous. There is almost no pent up demand for it.
Saw has said those on modded are mostly not coming back. I've gotten almost no excitement from anyone currently playing. The only argument I've heard that seems remotely valid is "make it more enticing for new people coming in", but I think that can be done without wiping. We just need to clear out the relics and revitalize town.
Making a rigid, lifeless, far LESS interesting town to replace it, on a less interesting map with insufficient landscape variety, will not excite anybody.
Moon