Hi everyone, looking for a sanity check on my gold scheme math before I head to the store this month.
I have two identical gold schemes maturing right now. Across both, I’ve paid a total of ₹6.6 Lakhs over 8 installments at various gold rates, accumulating a total weight of 48.512 grams (an average purchase rate of ~₹13,605/gram).
Right now, the gold rate has dropped to ₹11,465/gram, and I’m trying to decide between two ways to close this out:
Option 1: Redeem the accumulated gold weight (48.512g)
I get the 75% discount on making charges (assuming a 20% base making charge, I pay the remaining 5%).
However, they calculate that 5% making charge on my average paid value (₹6.6L) rather than today’s lower gold rate.
This means paying ₹33,000 extra out of pocket, bringing my total spend to ₹6,93,000 for 48.512g (~₹14,285/gram effective rate).
Option 2: Take the ₹6.6L principal value back and buy fresh at today's rate
Assuming they let me convert the ₹6.6L into a direct store purchase without penalties, I’d buy at today’s rate of ₹11,465/gram and pay the full 20% making charge (effective rate of ₹13,758/gram).
For ₹6,60,000 (₹0 extra out of pocket), I would get 47.972 grams.
The Dilemma: On paper, Option 2 saves me ₹33,000 in cash while only giving up ~0.54 grams of gold (worth about ₹6,200 today)—plus I might be able to negotiate down the 20% making charges on a direct ₹6.6L purchase.
Has anyone dealt with Malabar when gold prices drop below their scheme average? Do they allow taking the principal amount back for a fresh purchase at the current rate without penalizing you, or is there a catch in their terms I should watch out for?