r/GlobalPolitics • • Feb 25 '22

Had A Really Insightful Conversation with My Ukrainian Coworker About the Ukraine/Russia Situation: Summary Below

11 Upvotes

I have ADHD and one thing that has consistently fascinated me for years is politics, particularly international relations. However, despite filling my head with theory, current events, scandals, and policy proposals all day, rarely do I ever get to "talk-shop" with someone. If anything, I'll infodump while they look for a way to change the subject. Besides that, keeping up with international relations oftentimes feels more draining than anything else, just horror after horror with no one to talk to except your internet-bubble (if they haven't shunned you for thought-crime yet), so I'm always a bit excited for and opportunity to utilize my knowledge in person, especially if they know even more than me!

That's what happened today. I'd been doing my research on the Russia/Ukraine situation and forming my opinion (presently boils down to: avoid nuclear war at all costs, but how), when I brought the subject up to my co-worker (originally from Ukraine, but stateside for many years now). As someone who grew up in the area and had a deep familiarity with the politics and local sentiment (still has lot's of family there) it was so enlightening to combine what we hear to their experiences in Ukraine.

Quick (not so quick) summary of the situation so far. The U.S. has been implicated in numerous various anti-democratic/imperialistic coups throughout recent history. In 2014, the USA and the European Union supported a joint coup aimed at overthrowing the democratically elected pro-Russian government in Ukraine and replacing it with a hand-picked government loyal to the U.S. global hegemony.

My coworker explained to me this situation if much more depth. For years prior to the 2014 American-led coup, Ukraine was suffering extreme economic devastation due to political corruption and the resulting prolonged civil-unrest which was heightened when (former) Ukrainian president Yanukovych refused to begin the process of joining the European Union, which most Ukrainians supported, seeing EU membership as the only way of ending the political corruption and economic woes facing their country. During this time, Yanukovych had repeatedly requested financial assistance from the U.S./EU in bailing Ukraine out of their dire economic straits, a request that was repeatedly ignored.

Russia on the other hand, who likely had a hand in encouraging Yanukovych to veto the country's decision to pursue EU membership, agreed to offer financial assistance to Ukraine. For Russia, besides preventing the further growth of a diametrically opposed, US-loyal, NATO conglomerate, this aid had the added benefit of strengthening Russia's ties with a "buffer-state" many of which had already been lost to NATO. Apparently Putin, much like the former USSR, considers a protective sphere of satellite states necessary to Russia's security, fearing a possible future where they're surrounded on all sides by NATO countries and vulnerable to invasion.

The U.S. response to this budding alliance was to heavily fund the already present anti-Yanukovych/pro-EU protests and instigate riots and other forms of unrest aimed at toppling Yanukovych's presidency. After several months of protest over Yanukovych's resistance to EU integration, the coup/revolution was ultimately successful as Yanukovych fled to Southern Russia in apparent exile. According to my coworker, most Ukrainians (as well as many Russians) view Putin and his inner circle (many in the Ukrainian government) as a corrupt, authoritarian oligarchs, just as the West portrays them to be and were generally supportive of the U.S. led coup to oust Yanukovych and install pro-EU opposition leaders into the new government.

Russia, who had a long-time military naval contract in Ukraine's Crimean territory was apparently unwilling to relinquish the strategic peninsula to the West and instigated pro-Russian protests of their own among the population, culminating in the storming of Crimea's Supreme Council by a heavily-armed unmarked-militia group (presumably Russian agitators) who then forced the council to install a pro-Russian government in Crimea led by Sergey Aksyonov who then held a referendum to declare Crimea's independence from Ukraine. Russia then annexed the territory as "federal subjects" and solidified their military presence there. This all happened January to March 2014.

That brings us to the present day. Ukraine has been steadily integrating into the EU for several years now, while Moscow has been growing increasingly agitated. Perhaps emboldened by their success in Crimea, Putin apparently feels confident attempting a similar plot in Northern Ukraine considering the stage was already well set. You see, pro-Russian separatists groups arose in Ukraine essentially as soon as Yanukovych was deposed. According to my coworker, much of the older population in Ukraine, having once belonged to the Soviet Union, still feel that Ukraine is inherently a part of Russia. Ukrainian forces have been fighting these separatist forces in the mostly Russian-speaking region of Ukraine known as Donbas (further divided into the regions of Donetsk and Luhansk) for eight years now. Apparently Moscow has been covertly funding and arming these separatists while the U.S. has been supporting their opposition, including various alt-right neo-nazi militia groups. Apparently, these neo-nazi militia groups have been somewhat instrumental in maintaining Ukraine's new government, having originally been some of the most ardent supporters of the right-wing nationalist movement which sought to replace former president Yanukovych.

Prior to the revolution, Ukraine's military was already insufficiently armed and trained, so after it's downfall and rebirth, the new government incorporated many of these right-wing militia groups into the military to help combat separatists. The Ukrainian military, along with these various militias, has received training, weapons, and funding from the U.S./EU ever since. Donbas was first captured by separatist forces all the way back in April 2014 shortly whereafter they declared their independence and requested to be made part of Russia. Russia never officially accepted their proposal, but has maintained a steady presence in these regions, backing the rebels primarily as a tool for keeping Ukraine from joining NATO. After failed peace negotiations in 2014, a new cease-fire was negotiated in 2015 with the help of France and Germany, which was signed by representatives of Ukraine, Russia and the Donetsk and Luhansk rebels.

Under this ceasefire agreement, Ukraine recognized a special political status of the separatist regions, allowing them to establish their own police force and have a say in appointing local prosecutors and judges. It also declared that Ukraine could only regain control of Donbas after the separatist state's obtained full self-rule and hold OSCE-monitored local elections. Most think these stipulations basically ensure that the pro-Russian separatists will remain in control of Donetsk and Luhansk indefinitely. Some Ukrainians viewed this Agreement as little more than selling-out to Russia and oppose the deal. That brings us to the present day.

Russia formally recognized the independence of the Donetsk and Luhansk Republics and, with the apparent consent of their separatist leaders, advanced troops into their provinces to "keep the peace". The U.S. and several NATO members obviously view this as an escalation and provocation, however, Russia insists that it has not invaded Ukraine at all, but is only aiding an independent ally in their struggle against terrorist (right-wing militia groups) occupation.

The truth is, they're both right and both wrong since these region's (Donbas, as well as Ukraine at large) never truly had any autonomy or sovereignty, but have instead been highly manipulated as pawns in a Russian/Western proxy war for close to two-decades. In the interest of avoiding war, France and Germany are calling for the upholding of the 2015 ceasefire agreement which they all signed and, at this stage, I think that is the safest thing to do, although if history has taught us anything, it's that appeasement doesn't really work out.


r/GlobalPolitics • • Dec 16 '24

Inauguration Day 2025

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Feb 28 '22

Ukraine applies to join EU immediately as 28th member; officials begin peace talks. "Just now the President of Ukraine V. Zelensky signed a historic document-application for Ukraine's membership in the European Union,"

Thumbnail
upi.com
8 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Jun 21 '20

Ten captured Indian soldiers released by China as evidence grows Beijing planned Ladakh ambush

Thumbnail
us.yahoo.com
8 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Mar 27 '25

Elon Musk pressured Reddit’s CEO on content moderation

Thumbnail
theverge.com
7 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Oct 11 '24

U.N. accuses Israel of firing on its peacekeepers in southern Lebanon

Thumbnail
pbs.org
7 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Oct 07 '24

US Has Sent Record $18B in Military Aid to Israel in Past Year — at a Minimum

Thumbnail
truthout.org
7 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Apr 07 '26

Chinese University of Michigan researcher DIES after 'hostile questioning by feds'

Thumbnail
dailymail.co.uk
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Dec 09 '24

Unexpected House Guest.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Nov 04 '24

Israel Bombs Polio Vaccination Center in Area Marked for Humanitarian Pause

Thumbnail
truthout.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Oct 26 '24

1948: Einstein-Arendt letter to the New York Times An open letter to the New York Times expressing great alarm that Zionists implicated in atrociti…

Thumbnail
libcom.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Oct 14 '24

The New York Times Finally Admits Gaza is an Outdoor Prison

Thumbnail
counterpunch.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Sep 27 '24

Israeli Bombs Displace 140,000 Children as Lebanon Braces for Possible Invasion

Thumbnail
truthout.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Aug 12 '24

Israel’s Morning Prayer Massacre Is Part of an Escalation of Attacks on Schools

Thumbnail
truthout.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Jun 16 '24

Israel Killed My 13-Year-Old Son. There Is No Father’s Day in Gaza.

Thumbnail
truthout.org
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Jan 26 '24

Netanyahu must be removed, say top former Israeli national security officials | CNN

Thumbnail
cnn.com
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Mar 01 '22

Japan's lower house on Tuesday adopted a resolution condemning Russia's invasion of Ukraine in "the strongest possible terms," urging Russian troops to immediately stop the attack and withdraw from the Eastern European nation.

Thumbnail
english.kyodonews.net
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Feb 23 '22

Russia signed the ‘Budapest Memorandum’ in 1994 to recognise Ukraine’s ‘territorial integrity’, Don’t let them forget

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Apr 03 '21

The US says China is committing genocide against the Uyghurs. Here's some of the most chilling evidence.

Thumbnail
us.yahoo.com
6 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Aug 17 '26

Tiny Dick Energy

Post image
5 Upvotes

What a handsome couple.


r/GlobalPolitics • • Apr 19 '25

Trump’s trade policies threaten to strengthen China, not weaken it

Thumbnail
msnbc.com
5 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Dec 03 '24

Gaza Has Highest Number of Child Amputees Per Capita in the World, UN Says

Thumbnail
truthout.org
5 Upvotes

r/GlobalPolitics • • Nov 20 '24

A Gazan Father and Son Died in Israeli Custody. Their Family Only Found Out After Petitioning the High Court

Thumbnail haaretz.com
5 Upvotes