r/GithubCopilot • • 1d ago • Diamonds are Forever 1

Help/Doubt ❓ A humble request to Github Copilot team

Please do not disable local harness. I will keep it as short as possible.

I am an old school developer who is still using default light theme in VS code. Probably one among the early adopters of VS code. I do a lot of the coding myself and my copilot is always on the ask mode - most of the time.

I use copilot for:

  1. describing my own plans implementation plants to AI and thereby helping me to pick the right plan, potential future issues which could open up on further implementations, etc.,

  2. Simple helper methods like time formatting.

  3. Doc strings review for ease of understanding.

One day suddenly, when I asked Copilot to evaluate my plans, I saw a lot of files got edited without the keep diff prompt. I was usually in ask mode and it got disappeared as well.

The suggestions were super bad and generic. It felt like suddenly copilot lost memory and behaved like a child. I thought ask mode is removed as a part of update and tried asking few questions and all the answers were not relevant to my codebase at all.

Only God knows, How much time I spent to figure out there is this new harness introduced and after reverting everything went fine.

My queries usually involves AI agent to analyze multiple files, perhaps most of the existing architecture to give me back an answer. Local harness has been a pretty good companion for this but Copilot harness is mostly bad. It is like asking a project specific question to ChatGPT on a private browser window.

Fast forward, I tried this today there is an improvement but it still feels a lot missing. A new feature should introduce some awesome experiences but every-time there are complaints.

I also use lots and lots of BYOK.

Please try to consider my opinion.

Thank you!

50 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

9

u/lppedd VS Code User 💻 1d ago edited 1d ago

copilot lost memory and behaved like a child

The Copilot harness has its own memory, which relies on the cloud for the most part (I'm not sure a BYOK solution would be able to use it!). It does not read the usual memory files Local uses, and does not support the same granularity Local offers.

Please upvote https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues/344924 and https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues/342279, as reusing the same memory strategy is essential in the long run. I do not want to rely on the cloud, or on a Copilot-specific format that's not easily inspectable.

2

u/Anonboy403 1d ago

I have upvoted them both and hoping for resolution!

5

u/Anonboy403 1d ago

Fellow developers if there are any alternatives or solutions for my use case, Kindly let me know. I moved from gemini code assist after them deprecating it, Tried continue and other open source extensions - unsatisfactory results. Came to Copilot and happy so far with my local harness.

2

u/unrulywind 1d ago

I'm with you. I use copilot in vs code to curate my Obsidian Vaults with project documents and constantly will have it edit things, knowing that I will type right over the green diffs on half of its work before I accept them. The online harness has no method to do this. I have seriously considered forking an older version of VS Code just for my use.

For coding, I have moved on to use Codex on one screen while keeping vs code open on the other, and using git diffs. It's a completely different workflow, but it seems we are going to be forced into it.

1

u/Anonboy403 1d ago

Thank you for your suggestion. One thing I learned is to never make a long term investment on these AI coding tools. First I purchased Gemini Pro plan while Google decided to stop it and moved towards Antigravity. Now, I was planning to purchase a bulk of prepaid AI credits on Gemini AI studio to off load all the documentation to flash models and VS code team decided to call it off.

2

u/sudochmod 1d ago

I use Oh My Pi. Works amazing local.

1

u/Anonboy403 1d ago

Thank you, I will give it a try!

2

u/Temporary_Wolf9358 1d ago

local harness works better for deep file analysis too, the model gets context without the noise of a fresh prompt every time. I keep a persistent session open with the project loaded.

1

u/Anonboy403 1d ago

Totally agree!

3

u/tecedu 1d ago

Honestly yeah the copilot harness is such trash, its feels so vibe codey related, and thats not the worst part, its just soooo slow and laggy compared to the local harnesses.

I am using local for right now, and stopped using that altogether and using pi with gh copilot instead for anything long term project based code but I still check everything in vscode

2

u/zaq_pathan 1d ago

+1.
The copilot harness is very slow and laggy compared to local. Also, for some reason, cloud harness goes all over the place when using tools which the local can perfectly handle without any explanatory text. Example: connecting to unix VM via terminal

Also, hate the file changes shown by cloud harness whereas local shows them one by one perfectly

2

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hello /u/Anonboy403. Looks like you have posted a query. Once your query is resolved, please reply the solution comment with "!solved" to help everyone else know the solution and mark the post as solved.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/karelkral 1d ago

I switched to a new harness and I see the changes in the Git changes window.

1

u/P4R4DOXZ 1d ago

And please move teh "Agents" window and everything to it out of the vscode!