r/GithubCopilot • • May 13 '26

Discussions The new GitHub Copilot pricing system actually benefits me (and I genuinely don’t understand how some people are spending $1000+)

Back in March, I almost fully exhausted my basic Copilot plan: $9.29 USD used.
I ran the simulation with the new pricing system, and I would’ve spent $8.59 USD instead.

And considering every plan now gets extra FLEX quota (in my case, an additional $5), I could theoretically use it even more than before.

What really made me go WTF was seeing people here going from paying $10… to consuming $500, $1000, or even more.
Genuine question: how are you even doing that?

I feel like I use AI a lot, but seeing those numbers makes me think I’m actually using it pretty moderately.

My workflow usually looks like this:

• I use AI whenever something is difficult to quickly translate into code.
• I heavily use autocomplete and next suggestions. For me, that’s where the biggest productivity boost comes from.
• I work at the feature or file level. I almost never give it full project context because most of the time it just adds noise.
• When I debug with AI, I try to actually understand the issue so I don’t repeat the same mistake later.
• If a traditional tool solves the problem better (debugger, logs, profiler, docs, etc.), I prefer that over dumping thousands of lines of code into a model.
• I avoid frontier models for simple tasks. Seriously, you do not need Opus for CRUD apps. GPT 5.4 mini is already more than enough.

So I genuinely wonder if a lot of people are using AI as a complete replacement for the development process, or directly for their own thinking.

Because looking at some of these usage numbers, I imagine prompts like:

• “Build me a complete Uber-like app with no bugs.”
• “Create the commit, push it to GitHub, and review the entire project for improvements.”
• “Analyze ALL my code and spend 10 minutes thinking of the best possible variable name using Opus.”

And let’s be honest, Copilot is just one of the first companies to stop massively subsidizing usage. The other AI providers are burning money too. I wouldn’t be surprised if this pricing model becomes the industry standard very soon.

Bragging about how much you consume only reflects dependency and poor engineering judgment, which is exactly what AI companies were hoping for.

1 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

7

u/Significant_Spend564 May 13 '26

You wouldnt have spent $8 instead. You are still paying for the $10 subscription. In this case you pay the exact same. Its impossible to save money with the new system.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

Obviously I’d still be paying the same $10 subscription. My point wasn’t about “saving money,” but that my current usage pattern already fits comfortably within the new system.

And with the extra FLEX quota they announced yesterday, I’d effectively have even more usage headroom than before.

The difference is that while many people are trying to reduce their usage 20x to avoid paying hundreds of dollars, I could probably use it significantly more and still stay within the limit.

3

u/Significant_Spend564 May 13 '26

You do not get more value than before. The 200 Premium requests could easily go over $50 of value when working on large projects, which is why people who used to be spending $10 are getting projections for $50-500+ under the new system.

The measly $5 in flex credits is absolutely nothing in comparison to the value we used to get.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

Ah, sure, I completely agree with that. GitHub Copilot was probably one of the biggest token subsidies in the entire industry. They were basically absorbing massive costs, and now they’ve simply moved closer to actual API pricing.

And even now, they’re still subsidizing things like unlimited autocomplete and next suggestions.

My point is that if even Microsoft couldn’t sustain that level of subsidy indefinitely, companies that depend almost entirely on AI, like OpenAI or Anthropic, probably won’t be able to either. Many of them are still in the customer acquisition phase and burning money to grow.

But I also think that if someone is genuinely projecting $1000 or $5000 per month in AI usage, it’s worth questioning the development practices they’re using. I feel like I already rely on AI quite a lot, and even then, I still have plenty of margin left.

I can understand spending 5x or even 10x more than me. But 100x? Seriously? Do those people even remember what it’s like to program something by hand?

3

u/Wrapzii May 13 '26

Full agentic workflows… I give it a document with implementation guidelines and specs and end goals for each and let it eat it up. It does the full implementation with unit tests and everything. I’m on the $10 plan spent $20 this month so far and it would cost me over $800 next month… I also write entire separate apps for debugging and stuff all the time. Doing any of this you need either codex or 4.6 sonnet. You cannot use the small models for this and most of the time it’s medium or heavy for thinking. I have about 4hrs a day to program I usually have 2 sessions running at once. I used to run 3 sessions on 2 different apps at the same time before rate limits… also use it for reverse engineering. Any little project throughout the week I think of that can improve my life at all is just a prompt away. Also forking stuff off github to adapt it better for my needs without having to spend weeks figuring out their codebase to modify things is super nice.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

3 sessions at the same time? Do you even fully understand the code those agents are producing?

How is that maintainable long term? Or does the codebase eventually become effectively AI-read-only?

I can understand this workflow for personal projects, prototypes, or quick internal tools, but does this actually scale in enterprise environments? It honestly sounds like a black box where the human gradually loses the full mental model of the system.

0

u/Seldom_Popup May 14 '26

Agents produce more than enough shell commands and tool calls just to understand codes or search logs. Do you check all the commands? Figuring out if the grep regex are bug free?

-2

u/Wrapzii May 13 '26

Do I understand it? I wrote the document telling it how I want it written?
Some of my smaller projects are just one offs that I don’t care what the code does as long as the software does what I asked.

I’m not writing for enterprise. I code 4 hours a day on my own stuff. Why would the human lose the mental model of the system if they wrote the documents outlining the features and how to implement them? I have instructions based on initial code for it to follow the same schema. If you are going to maintain a large codebase I would slightly change how I’m promoting and give it more documentation on how exactly I want it structured but I’m not. I also go to ask mode and sit there and have hour long conversations about singular features before I write my document for implementation.

2

u/Seldom_Popup May 14 '26

AI code doesn't have soul in them! //TODO insert anti GenAI art comment here

what ppl image coding with ai: Write a script to plot 3rd column in this log file, and submit this script to Apple Store

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

Ah, nice. Could you mention at least a couple of them? :)

2

u/cetinkosem May 15 '26

So that we can aviod them, right? 😁

17

u/Charming-Author4877 May 13 '26 edited May 13 '26

What's the recipe for a banana garlic cupcake ?

1

u/ViceroyOfCool Jun 03 '26

Well this aged... poorly.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

Why? The people I described who spent $1,000 experienced exactly what I expected, they used it all up in a single day. For people like me, I'm showing here that I spent $9.29 USD, and under this new plan, it would be $8.59 + an extra $5 for FLEX, which is better for me.

The only downside was for the students, they're really having a hard time! They're only offered 200 AI credits, now that's extremely limited 😞

2

u/shuozhe May 13 '26

Cost at our workplace will double prolly (~5.5k current cost -> 12k with 70$ promotion).

I glanced over our top 10 users, it's ~100-200$ (with ~50$ currently for extra requests). The exception for #1, his cost reduced from 39 to ~20. I think it depends a lot on which model you are using and what kind of question you are asking.

2

u/FinancialBandicoot75 May 13 '26

Vibing is the reason and using it to make things with not understanding what they are doing, comes at a cost.

I barely creeped over pro+ costs so I am keeping it, but I’m a seasoned developer.

1

u/Longjumping_Elk6089 May 13 '26

Use agent mode and we can talk

1

u/Seldom_Popup May 14 '26

I used $400 last month by new pricing, with only $39 spent. Your imaging promots arn't too far off, except I don't create new app every day and most importantly I request agent to end with tool askQuestions, braging it in all md and chat box, so I could spend only one requenst every project.

1

u/tvolodi May 14 '26

Man, 50% of developers are not developers anymore already. And 90% will be not in next several months. All job is done by agents. Human code development is transformed to hobby activities or high qualified job (like some C# language developer). Artificial developers / robots / agents are real developers today. And they are very hungry for tokens. My new budget is above $3000.

1

u/alterego200 May 19 '26

POLL: Will the new pricing system cause you or your company to stop using GitHub Copilot?

Please reply or upvote a YES / NO / MAYBE / other (fill in) answer.

I'm trying to gauge how this will affect their stock price and whether this is an indicator of the AI bubble being about to pop or not.

Thanks everyone.

1

u/More-Low2880 Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26

I'm canceling. As a technical architect working on a large enterprise app on the side I was using copilot as like having a good jr/mid developer working with me and splitting the workload. With this new pricing its a total waste of money and I will go from a simple $10 Pro sub to around $150/mo bill. No thanks. So many comments from people saying it replaces developers is funny. We wont be replaced any time soon. Software development requirements both human business interaction and domain understanding for custom requirements and technical skills way beyond what AI can do accurately. Yes people can develop apps with it but without the person at the prompt walking AI through everything and ensuring it isnt making a load of mistakes, bad decisions, improper app security decisions, architecture and performance decisions good luck. I'm going to try an find a replacement. There are many other options but the value with Copilot is gone for me other then the free code complete and AI changeset descriptions.

1

u/jefersondossantos Aug 04 '26

os créditos que eu gastava em um mês com folga, expiraram em 2 dias. Migrei para claude

1

u/iyinusa Jun 08 '26

So, what's is your consumption today, since you have now adopted the pricing model since June 1?

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '26

[deleted]

1

u/FinancialBandicoot75 May 13 '26

Or maybe use auto and planning and get better results

1

u/Enough_Possibility41 May 13 '26

I am Sonnet 4.6 enjoyer, i had $800+ estimated bill.

1

u/muckscott May 13 '26

Same here. Pretty minimal usage too, maybe a couple hours every couple days last month and it's racked up to that cost. Insane. They're begging people to cancel.