*EDIT*
Alright so I definitely appreciate all of the advice I’ve received here. I thought I’d clarify a couple of things that some people asked about or commented on and I’ve gotta clear up.
Okay so the sending out of wish lists and/or gift ideas…damn, several people seem to think this is tacky or rude. Alright, fine, your opinion, but our family prefers this and we ask each other every year to please do this. Yes, my older sister started doing this many years ago when her children were very young, and she did it because she lives several states away and we (my parents and I) don’t get to see her kids, her, or my BIL often enough to know their preferences or sizes. We thought it was useful and personally would rather know what they like and don’t like so we don’t waste money getting them something they won’t use or will just donate. I asked my in-laws if they would also like to start doing this email thing because they were asking us what sorts of gifts the kids, my hubs, and myself would like, and they all said yes, that’d be really helpful. The only issue I really have is getting my step kids to add to their wishlists lol. Teenagers. One funnyish thing is that my MIL once gifted my stepdaughter, who was 5 or 6 at the time, a school uniform (our district requires them) for Christmas. Now, we were super-proud of stepdaughter because she was so gracious when she opened and revealed it (it was so much like that old Vine of the little kid unwrapping the avocado), but later, she did tell us she didn’t like it and was confused by it. I guess when she opened it, my MIL figured out she wasn’t into it, because she started defensively saying “it was on the wishlist!” I’d made the mistake of including stuff on the list of things the kids both wanted and needed. I’ve since corrected this and the kids are in charge of their own lists.
When my husband and I started living together, I adopted their Christmas traditions because I didn’t have any. I’m Jewish. I’m always free that day lol (except when it’s time to have my Chinese food and head to the movies 🤣). We do Christmas differently than other families as well because my hubs has kids from previous relationships, so when they are in town for their school breaks, we all get together for the kids to open their gifts because they’re all back with their moms on Christmas Day. On the 25th, they’re back with their moms, and the adults (MIL, my husband, SIL, and now the two spouses) get together to open gifts and eat. Things have changed a bit now since our kids are older and we’ve had them twice on Christmas Day. We have been able to make some lovely traditions with our kids that we enjoy, but on that day, we do meet up so everyone can exchange gifts.
My husband and his mom do butt heads occasionally and argue with each other. There are things about her character that do really annoy him. I’m sure a lot of you are correct that she is being narcissistic and playing a mind game with him. He’s frustrated that she says all the time that she’s on a fixed income or a budget, then gets all the rest of us nice gifts (and plenty of them) and he gets 3 or 4 things that won’t be used and will sit around. She truly does get him Vienna sausages and Beanie Weenies. Every year. Giggles and smirks when he opens them. His sister has apparently said to her that that’s a cruddy gift (I don’t personally remember this comment, but he says she said it). For him, it’s not about “oh, I deserve gifts,” it’s more that she doesn’t, and hasn’t, ever seemed to take time to get to know him as an adult.
He’s aware of this post. He appreciates that I’ve taken the time to ask for advice. And yes, in June. Why now? Because I wanted months to think about what to do to possibly make this better for him, the man I love. He does so much for me and for our family. I wanted to at least TRY to do something for him in this regard. Those of you who recognized that, thank you. Sorry if that bothers some of you…? Don’t comment, then?
***
Reddit, I could use some help, please. For context, my hubs is in his 40s and my SIL is in her 30s.
Over the years, my MIL has been giving my husband, her son, lousy gifts for Christmas. She gives him really silly things he’s never expressed interest in, like brightly colored hats and hoodies, and she always gives him the same snacks he enjoyed when he was a child but really doesn’t eat now. She also doesn’t get him a lot of gifts, and everyone else gets a lot more. It’s honestly upsetting and disheartening to see him open her presents on Christmas morning and seeing his face fall in disappointment. I hate that when we drive away, we’re always left talking about this particular topic because I know how hurt he is. Frankly, I’m tired of it.
For the past several years, I’ve taken a page out of my older sister’s book and sent an email or text out to the family members with ideas and links to things that my hubs, stepkids, and I would enjoy receiving. I initially started doing this because she was getting our kids socks and underwear every year because she seemed to think it was funny and they were getting sick of it, so I decided to quietly do something about it. So one year, I wrote at the end of the email (after listing the things they like) all the things they DO NOT like or want. I also said that we’d just bought them all new undies and socks, so there was no need to get them new ones this year and to save money on that one. None of our kids have received them since. We all also have Amazon wishlists, so people can just buy things off of that easily. What’s super-frustrating is 3 things:
MIL will buy stuff for me and for my stepkids that are on the wishlists or that have been mentioned in emails/texts. She doesn’t follow the suggestions I make for gifts for HIM. I am always sure to be very specific about what he likes and what would make excellent gifts for him in that list, and it’s like she chooses to ignore it or something.
his sister does an awesome job with gifts. She pays attention to said lists and emails, and I make sure to drop lots of comments that morning to really hint to my MIL that she should do the same thing: “wow, you really know he loves that show!” Or “you read my email of suggestions really thoroughly this year, huh?”
Lastly, MIL gets his sister and her hubs lots of stuff that they clearly want. It’s like she really pays attention to our BIL and his preferences, and dotes on his younger sister. SIL and MIL are pretty tight, too, so my MIL always seems to know what they want and need.
For birthdays, my MIL gives all of us “car tag money.” Now, in our state, it used to cost over $100 to replace your car tag every year, and you did it in your birth month. Obviously, not a bad gift. Years ago, though, this law and amount changed to only $20 ($21 if you have the tag mailed to you), and so my MIL loves giving all of her kids this gift. My hubs and I personally find it lazy and cheap. I myself would prefer a more thoughtful gift she’d put work into.
I’ve thought about talking to my SIL about this, but she’s going to have a baby a month before Christmas, and she’s also really close to my MIL and I’m concerned she’ll get offended and defensive.
Anyway Reddit, any suggestions for combatting this? It breaks my heart every year on Christmas to see my beloved hurting and sad.