I'm 20F, when I was six my parents found out I had "perfect IQ" (I didn't learn this until recently), severe dyslexia, and sensory processing issues. If you're a parent of a "gifted" child, I hope this gives you some idea of what to expect if you follow some of the advice I've seen on this sub. From my perspective, my parents did a fantastic job handling my status as a "gifted" student. They:
- Never told me I was "gifted"
- Complimented me on working hard instead of being smart
- Worked their asses off to pay for a private school for 2nd-8th grade where I got one-on-one reading and math classes
- Taught me study skills because they thought that I'd hit a point where I'd need to start working to learn
- Made me do activities I don't have natural talent at (violin) to teach me not to expect to succeed at everything
- Got me a therapist so I learned to cope with my anxiety early on
Not telling me I was gifted didn't work at all. Label or no label, everyone in the class can tell, and that feeling of being different makes forming friendships hard. I didn't have many friends until high school. The friends I did have were much older than me, sometimes by four or five years. These friendships wouldn't last long because I couldn't relate to what was actually going on in their lives (e.g., when, in 5th grade, my friend who was in 9th grade tried to talk to me about dating/boys and I was totally baffled).
My parents definitely succeeded in teaching me that being smart doesn't make you better than other people. That's actually a really hard idea to get into a kid's head when their teachers, their peers, and society as a whole puts such a high value on "smartness." There were a couple years in middle school where it really went to my head, but I got over it by high school.
High school went really well for me. I joined my school's FRC robotics team and it was a great enviroment for me. I could wax poetic about all the lessons I learned in high school robotics competitions, but what mattered most was that it was an intellectual challenge that I truly enjoyed even when I didn't win. I also formed great friendships with people closer to me own age (1 to 3 years older than me).
My parents didn't push me to be competitive with college applications. I'm really glad I didn't waste my time doing SAT prep or extracurriculars I didn't enjoy - those precious remaining years of childhood are better spent with friends. I got into some top-tier colleges but chose my state school because it was cheaper and I didn't really see what I'd get out of a competitive environment.
My parent and teachers warned me that I would need to start working hard to get good grades in college, so my first semester I was really diligent and kept on top of everything (thanks, study skills lessons). In my second semester, I started dating someone and quickly discovered that I could miss lectures and skip studying and still do fine. In sophomore year, I made the conscious decision to stop studying and focus most of my energy on friendships and extracurricular activities. This has gone really well for me - while I've continued to get mostly A's, I've formed a lot of relationships that I think will last for my whole life and participated in activities (e.g. student senate) that feel meaningful to me.
Honestly I feel that this could very well continue for the rest of my life - in internships I usually just work a couple hours in the morning and then put in headphones, listen to a podcast, and pretend to work until my eight hours are up. My bosses have said I am their most hardworking employee when in reality I am just phoning it in. Once I lied about what subject I study so I could get an internship I was totally unprepared for (I got an audiology internship but I study mechanical engineering) - that went really well and I walked away with a lot of new skills. Right now my biggest goal is to find a job when I get out of college where I can work from home with flexible hours so that I can spend most of my time volunteering.
Making friends with people much older than me is a challenge that resurfaced in college. In sophomore year, I started dating a 23 year old (I was 18). She was really frustrated with me because, although I seemed mature most of the time, I didn't have the life experience to relate to her. A lot of people assume I'm older than I am and then are surprised when I act like a twenty year old. Other times, people my age don't seek out my friendship because hey think I'm too old (e.g., one time I learned that someone I wanted to make friends with was avoiding me because he thought I was a professor). This is a challenge that I'm very much still in the process of figuring out how to handle.
Overall, I'm really happy with my life right now and I'm so thankful that my parents taught me to value things besides academics. If you currently have a "gifted kid," here is my advice to you:
- Never let them believe that being smart is the most important thing. Not only is this untrue, it's also really hard to make friends if you act even a little bit superior to the people around you.
- Show them that the reward of good study skills/not procrastinating is free time.
- Don't push them to be the best academically. Just because you could be top of your class doesn't mean that will make you happy. It's better to spend time doing what you love and being with friends.
Looking at this subreddit, it's easy to imagine that "gifted people" don't go on to lead happy lives. That's not true at all! Being good at academics can give you so many opportunities to enjoy your life and do meaningful work.