r/Gerrymandering • u/rygor_12345 • Jan 03 '22
r/Gerrymandering • u/jeffman1991 • May 14 '24
Senate Seats are the most gerrymandered thing.
So, I’m just a country boy from Arkansas, which is a state with a large land mass, but not a huge population. We can argue about statehood all day, but I can’t see to grasp why we don’t consider redrawing state lines. My state has a population of over 3 million, which I believe is on the lower tier, but still sizeable enough in land mass to be a state. Look at states like Rhode Island, Vermont, and New Hampshire. Those states all have small land masses. You could fit all 3 of those states in the land mass of my state. You could also fit the population of all 3 of those states within my state. Most of the people in those states have over 3x the representation that I do in the senate. Take a large state like California and compare. Rhode Island residents have over 25x as much representation in the senate. I think a fair split would be to take states like California and Texas and split them, while forcing states like New Hampshire, Vermont, and Rhode Island to consolidate with other nearby states. Politically speaking, this would probably be a wash. Northern California would vote red. Part of split Texas would turn purple or maybe full blue. The consolidated New England states would stay blue more than likely. Delaware needs to go too. We shouldn’t have states with less than 1 million people and such a small land mass. North and South Dakota can consolidate too. Large land mass, but so little population. You have to draw the line somewhere. If you don’t agree, then make my town of 63,000 people a state so we can get 2 senate seats.
r/Gerrymandering • u/seamslegit • Mar 27 '17
Why Obama's Retirement Is Totally Different From Every Other President
r/Gerrymandering • u/Funzonibro49 • Oct 21 '25
fair districts
1, Calculate the geographic center of the state. 2, going in north south east and west form districts equaling congressional number until state total is reached
r/Gerrymandering • u/Motor-Ad-8858 • Feb 25 '22
AP News: House offers new congressional map to appease DeSantis
r/Gerrymandering • u/Iwouldlikesomecoffee • Apr 14 '22
Voting in adjacent districts
I’ve been thinking about the following rule change: Add the elections for all neighboring districts to each ballot.
It seems like a simple way to greatly increase the difficulty of gerrymandering, but maybe there’s some reason it wouldn’t work (other than the impossibility of passing any effective anti-gerrymandering law). Does anyone have thoughts or a reference? It seems simple enough that others have surely considered it.
r/Gerrymandering • u/Cranky_1 • Apr 30 '21
Gerrymandering Solved! The 99% Plan
Simple solution: Every voting distract (both Congressional and State) in the USA must be drawn 99% similar (number of registered voters in 2 major parties) as ALL adjacent districts. A computer program can easily do this. Local adjustments can be made. Minimize tricks played by BOTH major political parties when in power. Voters should choose political leaders, not visa-versa.
r/Gerrymandering • u/[deleted] • Jan 01 '19
Proportional Representation with 3-4 congressional districts that are drawn up by an open non-partisan redistricting committee would virtually eliminate gerrymandering.
r/Gerrymandering • u/TryNotToAnyways2 • 26d ago
An alternative to concept of representation
We should proportion electoral votes and representation off of the number of elevators instead of maps based on population. That way, areas with more elevators would get a greater representation. Any area without an elevator would have to rely on a representative from an area with an elevator.
I know, this sounds silly and elevators don't actually represent anything other than density and population distribution. However, it would likely be fairer than the current districts that divide population based on how they are expected to vote. Obviously, I am not being serious - It's a thought exercise. But the representation would be more likely to model the actual population and where they live.
r/Gerrymandering • u/David_Meyers • Jun 13 '19
The leaders of No Labels say it's time to move past gerrymandering reform
"Nearly half the states have some form of nonpartisan or bipartisan redistricting commission, and yet political polarization – in Washington and state capitals – keeps worsening. In-depth studies of redistricting suggest that gerrymandering is a fairly small part of the problem. ... [T]he problem is largely us, the American people, as we gerrymander ourselves by choosing to live with ideologically like-minded neighbors."
r/Gerrymandering • u/BurntPopcornSmell • May 20 '26
What if we didn’t have to list a party when registering to vote?
Basically the title. I was thinking that’s the data they use to gerrymander, why not remove party from the registration process?
r/Gerrymandering • u/punkthesystem • Jul 14 '20
Why Redistricting Reform Goes Off the Rails
r/Gerrymandering • u/superegz • Dec 01 '19
Podcast #30 – can our voting system really be “fair”? A discussion on whether it’s ever possible for a single-member voting system to be “fair” in the context of the final defeat of the South Australian fairness clause.
r/Gerrymandering • u/mrfett779 • May 07 '26
Tennesse voting to pick up those seats and being racially discriminatory.
r/Gerrymandering • u/MEB389 • May 22 '18
Good Law | Bad Law #71 - Is This The End To Partisan Gerrymandering In PA? W/ Ben Geffen
r/Gerrymandering • u/unforced_errand • May 12 '23
True proportional representation
Why are legislative districts winner takes all? It seems to me that it would make more sense to split each among the top 3-5 candidates (with RCV from a field of 6-10), with each getting a legislative vote strength proportional to their share of the election.
Obviously you would need to either consolidate districts or increase the size of the legislature. On the other hand you wouldn't be limited to keeping districts equal population wise. Metropolitan areas could have fewer representatives with more voting strength.
Another bonus is that candidates would be competing less against their ideological opponents and more against those with positions close to theirs, which would mean more people voting for the candidate they like the most, instead of the one they dislike the least.
It would also mean that every vote would have a measurable, albeit individually insignificant effect.
r/Gerrymandering • u/Mattsmom0 • Aug 01 '17
How about this?
What if we registered (or re-registered) as independents -- no party. Wouldn't that affect gerrymandered districts?
r/Gerrymandering • u/Prozeum • Jan 12 '24
What's considered the most Gerrymandered districts? All all Gerrymandered districts considered "Bad"?
r/Gerrymandering • u/[deleted] • Jun 28 '22
What if EVERYONE in the country registered as REPUBLICAN or INDEPENDENT?
Gerrymandering happens in both parties (but it seems to me that Republicans are more aggressive than Democrats). But what if EVERYONE registers as INDEPENDENT? Wouldn't that make gerrymandering impossible or am I totally off base here? Thoughts?
r/Gerrymandering • u/indraneel • May 28 '21
Princeton Gerrymandering Project's having a map contest! Draw redistricting plans for seven key states across four crucial categories! Deadline to submit is June 15
r/Gerrymandering • u/jspinelle_psu • Dec 13 '19
File under "kids these days"
I host and produce a podcast called Democracy Works that examines issues related to democracy. This week's episode features an interview with the winner of the Draw the Lines PA mapping competition's youth division. We talk about how he became interested in gerrymandering, as well as impeachment and generational divides in politics. Episode here.