r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Nov 08 '23

Western Asia Israel’s Assault on Gaza Echoes the British Raj’s Response to the Revolt of 1857

Thumbnail thediplomat.com
0 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Apr 06 '24

General & Others Geopolitical observers that are not stooges of the Modi government

0 Upvotes

Hi folks I wanted to know your views on the credibility of so-called geopolitical experts such as Sushant Sareen, Abhijit Aiyer Mitra , Major Gaurav Arya etc. I have heard their analysis (especially AIM) and do believe that they may have some expertise. But their clear hero worship of the current government and ( especially Sushant Sareen and Gaurav Arya’s) inability to analyse and call our mistakes of the current government makes me question their standing in the strategic community. Also I do not know if these guys have made academic contributions or are passouts from legitimate strategic schools. AIM for example has pretty flimsy credentials. Additionally who are some legit experts that I should be following who aren’t merely RW lackeys but are relatively apolitical


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Nov 15 '23

United States Boys, We have arrived we started commenting and criticizing the US openly.

30 Upvotes

S Jaishankar use to say if you are commenting on others, then expect to get comments back one day.

That day is from today. We are pronouncing ourselves as superpower and better yet a vishwaguru and vishwamitra (we should bring our own terms cause we operate differently)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cI8Yns-nSuw

For context, certain things are planted in interviews to send a message and also pay attention to who is asking the question.

Important timestamp

Canada can cope 1

Comment on American politics (basically reciprocating the interference [meant for corporate donors]) 2

Indian take over of Indian Ocean 3

Where the US failed 4

Bangladesh as a model for India's sphere of influence (public response to US meddling) 5


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Sep 10 '24

General & Others India vs. China. Tired of false projections by News Media.

28 Upvotes

Let's say India and China decide to brawl.

  • Russia will join China, most probably indirectly will support it. (Of course, out of India and China it will choose China looking into the past partnerships and common enemies and interests)

  • USA will stand neutral and won't support either. (Well, nothing to win or lose in India vs China for them)

  • India might have to gather allies which can be Japan and S. Korea both of which oppose China.

  • They both will decline partnering with India. (They both are US oriented and will follow up what it does)

  • China will gather allies too of course. Pakistan and Myanmar. (Military states are easy to fool as they only talk in power which China has in abundance)

  • Soon India will exhaust out of resources and internal funds to manage war on and off fronts. (War likes crazy money, rich will flee to other countries and poor will become poorer and so India will start collapsing internally)

  • China will win, a one-sided agreement will be passed to give huge lands in north and eastern sea areas to China.

The only real way to win this war was to Ally with USA which in turn will have gotten us support from S. Korea and Japan too. This would although result in World War 3 or maybe Asian War 1, but would have benefitted us greatly.

Why do I think is hard to gather support of USA is because of our current global stance. We pretend to be everyone's friend. Russia vs Ukraine, neutral. Israel vs Palestine, neutral. We are friend of our friend's friends but at the same time friend of our friends' enemies too. This gives us this image of not so trustworthy nation which might turn as per situations benefit us. It is too risky to support such a nation.

For example, take Israel vs Palestine. Countries who support Israel are often seen as USA friendly by the US as they align with their own ideologies of democracy and liberty. Whereas those who support Palestine are seen as Militant and not USA friendly. India well is establishing a neutral stance so the world won't if we are diplomatic or militant.

So, the world is not sure of what type of thinking India has. We have to more openly support sides and emphasize on showing the world our ideals. We can't cry on roads asking strangers who don't know us t help only those of our friends we make in long term help us.

Can you agree more??


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Jul 10 '24

General & Others Why India will become a superpower

Thumbnail
ft.com
0 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Dec 24 '23

United States South Carolina Moment: Is Vivek Ramaswamy Why US Establishment Has Suddenly Turned Hostile to India?

1 Upvotes

In the South Carolina debates for the Republican primary of the 2016 US presidential race, Trump famously responded to jabs from NeoCon opponent Jeb Bush, by blasting his brother George W Bush for having wrecked the country with the ill-conceived and ill-managed invasion of Iraq. This stirred a hornet's nest among the NeoCons, who had been counting on riding Jeb's coattails back to power in the Whitehouse, having pumped billions into his presidential campaign for this purpose.

In a possible repeat of history, in the latest Republican primary debate, upstart challenger Vivek Ramaswamy similarly blasted NeoCon opponent Nikki Haley of South Carolina as "Dick Cheney in heels", calling her a corrupt Bush-Cheney warmonger and servant of the military-industrial complex. This looks to have again stirred a hornet's nest among the NeoCons, who've been backing Nikki 's run for the Whitehouse, hoping to ride her coattails back into power, and use her as a vehicle for a new war against Iran.

The sudden unexpected outbreak of war between Israel vs Hamas & Hezbollah, has produced sudden shifts in the dynamics of the US presidential race. Suddenly multiple large billionaire donors are switching away from backing Ron DeSantis (who'd been the 2nd-highest polling candidate and rival to Trump), to instead backing Nikki Haley. This is happening because the wealthy elites in America are now suddenly feeling a strong imperative for war on Iran, and NeoCon Nikki is seen as the best route to making this happen. (As we know, Iran is the main source of funding/support for both Hamas and Hezbollah.) Even Zelensky, the previous darling of US establishment for carrying out their war on Russia, is now being told to bide his time and perhaps even seek talks with Putin. American warmongers are now quietly running away from war with Russia, and towards their newer preferred war with Iran -- much as they'd quickly ran away from Afghanistan so that they could quickly start their newer preferred war on Russia.

What does this have to do with India? "Oppo Research" (aka. dirt-digging) done by the contestants in this current US presidential race has unearthed instances of Vivek Ramaswamy praising Modi, and has been used to claim Vivek is "right-wing Modi hindutva fascist". (Note that in contrast to Nikki Haley, Vivek Ramaswamy does not attempt to hide his Indian roots and faith) Therefore any opportunity to vilify Modi can be used as an attack vector against troublemaker Vivek Ramaswamy. Showing India's ruling govt as a rogue regime engaged in assassinations and other nasty stuff is then useful and timely. In a similar vein, Lefty bastion BBC deliberately ran their hit-piece against Modi ("The Modi Question") because they were hoping to use it to cast aspersions against the non-Lefty brown guy who'd just moved into 10 Downing Street. So these things are from the same playbook.

The prime concern of America's warmongering elites right now is to get their war-horse Nikki into the Whitehouse, so that they can get their war on Iran. Joe Biden's Dhritarashtra presidency has now run its course, having served its purpose in bringing war against Russia. He'll be discarded in due course, with a seamless switchover to NeoCon Nikki as the next president from the Republican side - just like surefootedly shifting from one foot to the other.

Their main obstacle has been Donald Trump, who of course has been bogged down with every kind of legal case being filed against him. But Vivek Ramaswamy has increasingly emerged as a new thorn in the side, with his spirited defense of Trump, and his recent raining of fire on NeoCon Nikki, the preferred new war-horse candidate of the war lobby.

Skeptics will claim "But we India! We so big! We so impressive! No foreigners will mess with us just because of their own silly election politics! Don't be ridiculous paranoid!" The fact is that foreigners are not as in awe of India as we imagine them to be. Even lightweight Trudeau in lightweight Canada is easily willing to sacrifice relations with us for the sake of domestic political fortunes. In the case of US politics, their big money lobbies are very powerful and are playing for very high stakes. They strongly intend to get their war on Iran, and anyone even vaguely seen as standing in their way will be swept aside, howsoever crudely and no matter what the collateral damage to relations with India and Modi.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whX35NKthQw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K45-9oimA9w

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwWQj4n6A8M

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Whtw3qKQnQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZS7BdN0l1w

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpZGR_eTbAI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiVhtJLx76c

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4v9vGM-uiSc


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Nov 28 '23

South Asia India's growing isolation

0 Upvotes

Even though our claims of being Viswa guru has heightened especially after the well-executed G20 summit this year, I am feeling India is growing more isolated and its foreign policy is in a quagmire.

In the neighbourhood, even excluding long term rival Pakistan, relationships with most others have gone south. We had ruffles with China where we lost soldiers and our land (in maps and in reality). Subramanian swamy claims 4000+ sq km was taken. Other neutral experts claim 2000+. From Nepal, after the events related to India raising issues with its new constitution, we had lost good will and now even Nepal is claiming Indian land with ridiculous maps. They have grown more cozier to China and China is even building a railway line across the Himalayas with which we will lose the higher ground as the gateway for Nepal. From Bangladesh, we had good start with solving many of the border issues and fixing the land archipelagos but people to people relations are going sour even with shared Bengali heritage. The right-wing narrative of Bangladeshis as pests, rats intruding and infesting India to justify NRC and also didn't help. The government will follow the people later. Maldives election was just run on Anti-India sloganeering this time and the 'Evict India' sloganeer won the election, and he has promised to replace China with India. We have become a non-player in Afghanistan again after US exit and the puppets fall. Bhutan doesn't want Big brother India's mediation or opinions and has started fixing border issues with China directly. Myanmar is unstable again and we need to see what is going to happen with the Junta. In Myanmar, by hook or crook, China will make sure there is no threat to their access to Indian ocean through Myanmar fearing an eventual blockade of Malaca strait in a war with the empire. Sri Lanka is playing the balancing game, and we don't know when it is going to topple.

On the global front, Pakistan is growing closer to Russia and with multiple meetings happening between the premiers in the last one year. Russian sensitivity to Indian emotions is fast disappearing and they may be behind the back push for Pakistan to apply for BRICs membership. The advantage is Pakistan has no reputation and doesn't fear being clubbed as an evil or being labelled as a double agent as it has even more dirty labels already in the bag. India is seen as a reluctant member of BRICs as BRICs is being touted increasingly as a resistance force of the global south. India just wants to have the economic benefits from BRICs while not wanting to be seen together with in the company of the other rebellious members who are being vilified more and more as evil in the anglosphere. India is also a QUAD member. And as we see with events lately US will just kick our ass even for a global non player like Canada. All the hugs and dinner are just for the optics. They just want to use India as a pawn against China and a launch board for an eventual war? with China.

In the middle east, we grew more warmer to Israel over the years while maintaining the balance with Arabs. Modi has gone and collected the highest civilian awards from most Arab nations. The IMEC corridor for which India was enthusiastic during last G20 has evaporated for the near future with the latest developments in middle east. We are not seen as a player or even a mediator and we see Arab delegations running to China in the initial weeks while we were left standing with just warm relations with Arabs and Israelis.

Even with a strong unquestioned majoritarian government, India is more of a status quoist and our foreign policy achievements are yet to be seen. Jaishankar's antics and tit for tat replies and Doval doctrine are yet to deliver any actual tangible results. What do you say? Where do we see us by the end of the next decade in the evolving multi polar world?

Please don't shoot the messenger.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Apr 14 '24

General & Others Is it WW3? I don't want it to happen.

3 Upvotes

India never supports war. But, India is fed up with the WEST behavior. Recent stance of MEAIndia has been more inclined towards middle east and Russia. Even though India is not ally to any, but it is very interesting to see how India goes about Iran-Israel conflict?


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • May 28 '25

French military responds to reported downing of Rafael jets in India-Pakistan clash: media

Thumbnail
globaltimes.cn
3 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Apr 26 '25

Strategic Doctrines Time to Rethink India's "No First Use" Nuclear Policy?

2 Upvotes

I think it's high time India revisits its No First Use (NFU) nuclear policy. While NFU made sense decades ago to appear responsible and peaceful, the situation has changed, especially with a neighbor like Pakistan.

We are dealing with a country that has a radicalized, corrupt army, and safe heaven for terrorism that make rational decision-making questionable. Sticking to NFU is basically saying, "We’ll wait and absorb a nuclear hit before we respond." That’s just not smart anymore.

Why give the first-move advantage to someone we already know plays dirty? We should keep the option open for a first strike when national survival is at stake. Deterrence should be strong, not passive.

Also, the way Pakistan keeps bragging about their nuclear weapons every time there’s a confrontation with India, it really feels like they’re eager to use them. Our NFU policy may actually give them more confidence, because they think we won’t strike first no matter what.

Curious to know what others think. Is it time to drop NFU and update our doctrine to reflect today’s realities?


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Mar 04 '26

South Asia On Pakistan, India TV channels are feku

0 Upvotes

According to Indian media, Afghanistan, a country without any air force, struck the vital Nur Khan Air Base in its ongoing conflict with Pakistan. It's like an attack in Delhi Cantonment that gets ignored by local residents and the entire world media.

These are mainstream English channels which are carrying this "news"

You will see similar such stories around the Indus Water Treaty. What none of them will tell you is that India can hold only 0.4% of western rivers which were given to Pakistan. None of them will tell you that this number won't cross 3% for a few years at least, even with all the current projects.

What can you do?
Stick to print media like The Indian Express, TheHindu or others and get your news from western media outlets like Al Jazeera or BBC.

All of these will have their own bias, but at least they won't fall for stuff like this.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Jun 18 '24

East Asia & Australia Australia quietly expelled four Indian spies who targeted politicians and defence tech

Thumbnail
independent.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Sep 19 '25

South Asia Do you all guys think Indian Foreign Policy is at it's lowest point since 1947 ?

0 Upvotes

So I have been watching few events that made me believe that it is, here we are failing to maintain one partner ie US. On the contrary terrorist nation Pakistan is maintaining 3 sided relationship with china USA and Russia apart form that they have signed a mutual defense pact with Saudi Arabia (Biggest Voice of Gulf). Incase if India launces any attackonS Pakistan it will be considered attack on Saudi. Apart from that our relationship with our neighbours is also very futile and unfriendly. All the above statements make me believe that we are indeed on our lowest point. I am open to any discussion


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Feb 05 '24

China Short-sighted and narrow minded china policy

0 Upvotes

The world has been under western hegemony for a few centuries now and we've suffered for it. As has china though to a much lesser extent. Is it not in our interest when china challenges and destroys western hegemony ? Also good relations with China solves our hostile neighbourhood issue for good. Why don't people see that. It's just mindless and reflexive hostility against China without any consideration of our own interests.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Jul 31 '25

Grand Strategy Modi's foreign policy has failed

0 Upvotes

Modi voter for the last 3 times. While I disagree with many things done by the current govt - not expanding the tax base, not moving fast on our external defence procurement needs etc. nothing is more obvious than the spectacular foreign policy failure of this government over the last 5 years.

  1. It is a bipolar world - China & US. We have alienated both. CHINA - China and India have had historical issues and if India indeed hoped to best it, the it needed to be more prepared before it tried. The sheer reliance on Chinese trade is astounding. You could ban the Apps but not the phones. China is a major producer in most critical sectors with atleast 40-50% worlds market share. Till we are self reliant there is no shaking this shaklehold.

US - We tried maneuvering to the US camp and in a post Biden world that has failed. Nothing is predictable anymore.

2) India / Pakistan & Op Sindoor - Full credit to the government they have basically debunked the nuclear bogey which Pakistan dangled for years and led to Congress inaction. But this govt too has not gone for the jugular when they had the chance. It is an open secret Op Sindoor was 'paused' because the US probably indicated consequences , most likely trade & tarrifs. Now that's happened too with the 25% tarriff + Penalty. We had a great opportunity to take Pakistan to the cleaners. In a prolonged war, India would have had a massive leg up.Instead, we've been hyphenated with them. We sent foreign delegations and what did it serve. We don't need to justify our actions. Not like the foreign outreaches got us anything tangible.

My sense - Modi had an opportunity here to send a strong message to the whole world. Had we decisively demolished Pakistani Military infrastructure, even more than what we did without fearing consequences of a trade sanction, we'd be in a far stronger position to negotiate. We need to learn from the Chinese, they have taken a position of strength and it is working for them. Infact the Taiwanese president cancelled a trip to Mexico because the US denied permission to land. They didn't want the Chinese irritated before they close a trade deal. Modi with his strong man image has acquiesced.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Sep 08 '25

South Asia Blindsided by Trump, Modi is learning hard lessons about India's place in the new world order | Mukul Kesavan

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
0 Upvotes

Blindsided by Trump, Modi is learning hard lessons about India’s place in the new world order Mukul Kesavan


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Feb 20 '25

Western Asia Where Modi goes, Adani follows: Inside the billionaire’s latest deal in Qatar

Thumbnail
newslaundry.com
1 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Sep 08 '23

International Organizations India should quit the Brics

Thumbnail
business-standard.com
0 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Apr 24 '24

United States US State Dept Accuses India of Anti-Semitism for Pushing Conspiracies Against George Soros

Thumbnail
thewire.in
5 Upvotes

r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Aug 17 '25

Great Power Rivalry From being the strategic lynchpin in the Indo-Pacific to being treated a liquidatable asset, India has rapidly losing its leverage in US.

0 Upvotes

Non alignment is no longer a choice, it’s India’s forced reality! And its the inept bureaucracy that is to be blamed

For last 25 years, successive US administrations from Bush to Biden have framed India as the potential counterweight to China.

The keyword here is potential: an emerging power with latent military, economic, and diplomatic heft worth cultivating patiently.

However, as last 6 months have shown, it has failed rather spectacularly in move beyond this hypothetical based-in-future potential to on-ground performance today. Not even at a middling power level. And I think we don’t give enough blame on the notoriously slow, unimaginative and inward looking bureaucracy, esp the IFS corp.

That Trump administration is ruthlessly transactional is not great insight. But what is interesting is its unashamed tilt to (A) utility and (B) loyalty and remarkable flexibility to modify ideological or principled positions in order to drive advantage. This has happened never before with any US administration.

(A) Failed to develop an early leverage with Trump: Trump like to show a win - a demonstratable and marketable win! And his biggest foreign policy plank was/ is stopping wars - both Russia Ukraine and Middle east. India had unique diplomatic position between Russia–Ukraine and had the golden chance to transform potential into power. Modi was arguably the only global leader with genuine access to both Moscow and Kyiv, and a working relationship with the White House. Yet India opted for cautious neutrality — a strategic fence-sit that yielded zero leverage

Contrast this with Asim Muneer - He dialed White House (through his best friend General Kurilla) and gave them an early counter terrorism win by handing over the Abbey Gate operarive without asking an immediate return of favor (the favors obviously came later during Op. Sindoor for him)

Give him a win first and then later curry favors - India probably had the once in a century opportunity that was squandered rather spectacularly.

(B) Lack of undisputed victory over Pakistan during Op. Sindoor - surely India had tactical victories, but the mere fact that Pakistan survived (infact thrived with the whole Rafael downing narrative) is enough strategic problem. It exposed critical weakness in its capacity to function as a credible Indo-Pacific balancer. If it is so easy for China to activate Pakistan and distract India, how can India ever become a peer to China militaristically, is not lost on anyone. Esp the Trump administration. India makes Quad weak and redundant.

Trump administration would actively question if India indeed has the capacity to perform or is a liability.

It’s no coincidence that Trump targeted India to send a message to Russia a clear warning on secondary tarriffs. It is a clear signal that India’s perceived strategic utility has diminished; it is no longer protected as a “special partner” but can be leveraged as a bargaining chip.

But the real question is Why? - while we can all blame the visible face, i.e., the government and PM (as we all should), I think the real culprit, that gets away without much flack, is the lethargic and unimaginative bureaucracy. Not just civilian but also military.

It is the bureaucracy that needs to think outside the box and think of levers that can work. But instead this one is so complacent that it just likes to sit in its cushy chair and call it “non alignment” or “principled stance “. The way the world is moving, the principled stance will not just be left behind, it will actively be targeted to send message to the adversaries, just like how Trump is using India to send a message to Putin.

Thoughts?


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Sep 11 '26

BRICS India’s real objective should be to make BRICS ineffective

Thumbnail
theprint.in
0 Upvotes

India’s interest lies in sabotaging BRICS to the extent it can, lest China turn it into a juggernaut that flattens Indian interests. There is no way to dance around this problem anymore.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Jul 13 '24

Russia Is India slowly using its political capital as it builds ties with Russia?

4 Upvotes
  1. The PM of India visited Russia on the day when Russia bombed a children’s hospital in Kyiv. Doesn’t it send a message the Indian government tolerates such an action by Russia?

  2. India knows that Russia is more dependable based on the past. We know from USA’s past actions that USA is pretty transactional and likely that it will throw India under the bus if say- China would no longer be a competition to USA. But in the current scenario when Russia is accused of war crimes, does it make sense for India to maintain a low profile in its relations with Russia?


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Mar 01 '26

Strategic Infrastructure Do you think India is better off in the last 10 years than the entire period after independence in every sense?

6 Upvotes

please state your views on the above matter. I personally think India is somewhat better off than the previous government's tenure as the current government is not much into financial corruption. They probably made all the money they need to make with demonitisation. Also india is showcasing a better position in geopolitics than before.

This is just my opinion and if you think that's wrong, please enlighten me in the comments.


r/GeopoliticsIndia • • Nov 01 '23

Western Asia Israel-Gaza War: 'Deeply flawed' Benjamin Netanyahu on India's abstention in UN vote

Thumbnail
livemint.com
26 Upvotes