r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '15
Is this a legit subreddit?
This seems more like a parody subreddit than anything.
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Feb 04 '15
This seems more like a parody subreddit than anything.
r/Geocentrism • u/aresman71 • Feb 08 '15
If you're going to propose that the entire scientific community is covering up the fact that relativity is false, you have to at least come up with some plausible reason as to why they would go through such a monumental effort to cover it up. After all, it's not as if relativity was immediately accepted by the scientific community -- it was quite an extraordinary claim that required lots of support before being widely accepted. It itself was overturning Galilean relativity, which had been the accepted theory since, essentially, the beginning of modern science.
I keep seeing references to the scientific community's idolization of Einstein, with the point being that relativity is now too sacred to be challenged in mainstream science. But this isn't true! Remember the faster-than-light neutrino result from 2011? Scientists were really excited to be possibly proving Einstein wrong. There was no cover-up of these results, which were potentially disastrous for special relativity; on the contrary, it was widely publicized, and the pop-sci magazine Discover even named it the most important scientific discovery of 2011. Upon close inspection, they found that the results were erroneous, but for a while, mainstream science was legitimately challenging the theory of relativity, which is something that scientists who know relativity is false but are all pretending it is true would never do (unless, of course, the whole incident was fabricated for precisely this purpose and they're playing an incredibly subtle and clever game).
In order for me to believe geocentrism, I'll have to believe that either a few fringe scientists understand relativity better than anyone in mainstream science (i.e. they have discovered flaws in it that mainstream science hasn't), or that mainstream scientists are aware that relativity is untrue and are covering it up for some reason. Both of these seem like very large stretches of the imagination to me, so perhaps I'm missing some third possibility, or perhaps there is an incentive for keeping the non-relativistic truth secret that I'm missing. I'm eager to hear other people's thoughts on this matter!
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Apr 25 '15
So do you folks actually believe this?
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Feb 23 '15
The planets had to have been in a specific position to be able to boost Voyager I out of the solar system. Their positions were calculated assuming that geocentrism is not a factor. How do you explain the planets being where they were supposed to?
And don't say it's a government conspiracy covering up the evidence of geocentrism because although it is possible that it is being covered up that's not the discussion we're having here.
r/Geocentrism • u/Toon_DB • Feb 22 '15
I am new here and very fasinated by everything I read so far. I have a simpele question. What is your number 1 piece of evidence that the sun is rotating around the earth, and not the other way round? I hope you can convince me :)
r/Geocentrism • u/conundri • Dec 21 '14
r/Geocentrism • u/conundri • Dec 21 '14
r/Geocentrism • u/Prestigious_You_1401 • Nov 14 '20
"We know that the difference between a heliocentric theory and a geocentric theory is one of relative motion only, and that such a difference has no physical significance."
"Today we cannot say that the Copernican theory is "right" and the Ptolemaic theory is "wrong in any meaningful sense. The two theories are physically equivalent to one another," -Sir Fred Hoyle(Astronomy and Cosmology, p.416
"[A]ll this evidence that the universe looks the same whichever direction we look in might seem to suggest there is something special about our place in the universe. In particular, it might seem that if we observe all other galaxies to be moving away from us, then we must be at the center of the universe… We [reject] it only on grounds of modesty" (A brief history of time)
"So which is real, the Ptolemaic or Copernican system? Although it is not uncommon for people to say the Copernicus proved Ptolemy wrong, that is not true" -Stephen Hawking(The Grand Design, p.41)
"A great deal of research had been carried out concerning the influence of the Earth's movement. The results were always negative." -Henri Poicare' (La science et I'hyothese, p.182
Such a condition would imply that we occupy a unique position in the universe, analogous in a sense, to the ancient conception of a central earth… This hypothesis cannot be disproved, but it is unwelcome…therefore we disregard this possibility… the unwelcome supposition of a favored location must be avoided at all costs…such a favored position is intolerable.. Therefore, in order to restore homogeneity, and to escape the horror of a unique position…must be compensated by spatial curvature. There seems to be no other escape." -Edwin Hubble(The Observational Approach to Cosmology, pp. 50-51,58-59)
"The data were almost unbelievable. There was only one other possible conclusion to draw, that the earth was at rest. This of course, was preposterous." -Bernard Jaffe(Michelson and the speed of light)
"Ironically, aerospace engineers assume an 'earth-centered, earth fixed' coordinate system when launching and flying satellites. The Global Positioning System (GPS) does the same for navigation on earth and in space" -Joseph A. Strada
"…as we see only redshifts whichever direction we look in the sky, the only way in which this could be consistent with a gravitational explanation is if the earth is situated at the center of an inhomogeous Universe." -Paul Davies
"Obviously it matters little if we think of the earth as turning about on its axis, or if we view it at rest while the fixed stars revolve around it. Geometrically these are exactly the same case of a relative rotation of the earth and the fixed stars with respect to one another" -Ernst Mach
"But when you look at CMB map, you also see that the structure that is observer, is in fact, in a weird way, correlated with the plane of the earth around the sun. Is this Copernicus coming back to haunt us? That's crazy. We're looking out at the whole universe. There's no way there should be a correlation of structure with our motion of the earth around the sun-the plane of the earth around the sun - the ecliptic. That would say we are truly the center of the universe. The new results are either telling us that all of science is wrong and we are at the center of the universe, or maybe our data is simply incorrect or…maybe there's something wrong with our theories.." -Lawrence Krauss
"Spiral galaxies tend to spin in one direction above our equator and in the opposite direction below it" -Michael Lougo (U of MI) survey of 15,158 rotating spiral galaxies, up to 1.2b light years away(New Scientist,10-2011)
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Mar 31 '15
I'm genuinely curious, if y'all are not trolling, what more proof you need than what's already available?
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Mar 08 '18
It seems to me that any intelligent person, that legitimately researches Flat Earth, will see that it's nonsensical. Many will give up there, they will say to themselves, "Well the earth is not flat, and science must be right about everything".
What do you think? I know that there is a word for this in Propaganda strategy but I forget what it is.
r/Geocentrism • u/Tandence • May 06 '15
hey, just a question about how this is supposed to work: so if the entire universe revolves around a stationary earth, objects further away would have to travel faster, and within a relatively short distance from earth objects would have to be going faster than light, which is impossible. am I missing something about this theory or about relativity? like is it the fabric of the universe that is spinning, not the actual objects?
edit: I think the way I phrased this made it sound like I believed in this theory, I was just trying to learn about it.
r/Geocentrism • u/thewiremother • Mar 12 '15
As I understand it, the geocentric theory holds that the earth is not moving what-so-ever. How does it account for this observable and measurable phenomenon?
r/Geocentrism • u/lordLies • Feb 09 '15
r/Geocentrism • u/almightybob1 • Jan 09 '16
Hello /r/geocentrism. I got here from /r/space and have been reading your wiki. It seems you reject the theory of relativity and time dilation. I wonder how then do you account for the results of the Hafele-Keating experiment or the Ives-Stilwell experiment, since as far as I can tell this is not addressed in the wiki.
r/Geocentrism • u/luke-jr • Dec 08 '15
I'm interested in learning more about the geocentrist position. The Principle just became available for DVD purchase. Has anyone seen it? Is it a good and accurate overview of geocentrism?
r/Geocentrism • u/Outofmany • Oct 21 '15
I am a geocentric flat earther. I identify more as a flat earther rather than a 'mere' geocentrist but I am also a redditor and bizarrely (IMO) there is no genuine flat earth subreddit. I'm in an odd situation whereby I disagree with you on some key issues and yet I am also a huge ally and a strong supporter of your views and your efforts. You guys appear to have a good knowledge base, and I find myself to be a bit weak in regard to the geocentric arguments (I just can't seem to find good, deeper explanations on how to approach space and heavenly bodies.) So any links etc would be most appreciated.
r/Geocentrism • u/[deleted] • Oct 08 '15
EDIT: Note, I added some additional questions at the bottom.
I started off just writing a couple of questions about inertia, but two questions spawned four more, and on it went, so here we are. Do take your time. There are a lot of questions and they get progressively harder in the end, so feel free to talk to Dr. Bennett or do some independent research. You don't have to answer all the questions at once, either, obviously. Mainly I'm just trying to learn the basics of A.L.F.A., not trying to prove or disprove anything.
In this comment you wrote:
Inertia is caused by the inertial ether. I thought I explained this already? A bullet keeps going for the same reason an iceberg keeps moving in the water when pushed, except in the case of a bullet it's ether, not water, and the ether is frictionless.
If ether is frictionless:
A. How does a bullet push it to make it follow along with the bullet?
B. How does it push a bullet along once it's moving, if it is frictionless?
The inertial aether is proposed to explain inertia without Newton's First Law.
In this dialogue Dr. Bennett appeals to Aristotle and says that any motion requires a persistent cause. So, a bullet fired in space that travels at a constant velocity would ordinarily stop, except for the fact the inertial aether is giving it a constant push to keep going, providing the persistent cause for the motion.
C. Why does a moving bullet require a cause of movement, but not a moving aether?
D. If "pushing" something to get it moving takes energy, or work, or effort, how can the aether keep on pushing something indefinitely? Where is this energy coming from?
While we're on the subject of inertia and Newton's laws, are we doing away with all of Newton's laws? If so:
E. Are perpetual motion machines possible? If not, what inhibits their function? If so, why haven't we been able to build one?
F. What aether dynamic is responsible for Newton's Third Law, about equal and opposite reactions?
These questions are a little trickier:
G. If aether is frictionless, what is aether drag and why should it be felt by a pendulum bob?
H. What's the force that's pulling stuff towards the Earth's center?
Let's see if we can be a little specific about anything, or if it's all just handwaving and make-believe:
I. How much increased stellar aberration does A.L.F.A. predict for Airy's water-filled telescope, if it is 3 meters long and mounted on the ISS?
J. What properties are conserved by inertial aether?
K. What's the difference between an object in motion and an object at rest? Is there something we can measure?
Let's go deeper: If Einstein and Newton are out, then Feynman is out and Quantum Electrodynamics are out.
L. How is the color of gold versus silver explained?
M. Why is an oil slick rainbowy?
N. How do polarized sunglasses completely block reflections of your dashboard in your windshield, unless you turn them sideways?
And deeper: relativity is out, but what about the Standard Model of particle physics?
O. Does A.L.F.A. reject the Standard Model?
P. If so, how does an event like the discovery of the Higgs boson within the predicted energy range occur? Is there an alternative model of sub-atomic particles that's accepted by A.L.F.A.?
Q. If not, how does A.L.F.A. respond to the recent Nobel Prize in Physics, which was awarded to scientists for determining that neutrinos have mass through an application of special relativity?
What about straight quantum mechanics?
R. Does the A.L.F.A. explanation of the two-slit experiment differ from mainstream physics when performed with photons?
S. What about with electrons?
Actually, this raises some odd questions which relate to the very first questions I posed:
T. Does a photon have inertial aether flowing with it?
U. Does an electron?
V. What's the A.L.F.A. explanation for Bremsstrahlung?
W. What's the A.L.F.A. explanation for Cherenkov radiation?
X. We've measured the bending of light around the sun. I assume A.L.F.A. would says that the light was bent by the aether flow. How much would A.L.F.A. predict light would bend around Jupiter? As far as I know, this experiment has not yet been performed.
Y. What are open questions for A.L.F.A. that I haven't asked yet?
Z. On the ALFA Challenge blog, Bennett writes: "If the FP swings E-W on the equator( blue , above) the westward aether flow will boost the speed by v = kr/T and slow the eastward swing by –v . Electronic timing of the swings should detect this effect of the aether’s circulation. The mainstream physics model of a rotating Earth would not have this effect." What's the coefficient k theorized to be? ;)
I'm out of alphabet, but I have one more question. Some time ago you posted an image with a bunch of spinning aether vortices and you said it was an illustration of how the solar system worked. People didn't like it because there were vortices crossing each other without interacting, and if there's a separate vortex for every planet and moon, you'd need one for every asteroid and satellite and space probe and grain of dust, and that ends up being a whole lot of space vortices that just happen to line up with the laws of gravity. Do you still stand by that multi-vortex idea, or are all the planets and things carrying their inertial aether with them, which keeps them going in their orbits? Or something else? At the time you said this idea was just in development and not final, so I'm wondering how you're seeing solar system mechanics currently.
Additional simple questions:
How does A.L.F.A. model the Cavendish experiment?
How fast are the outer planets moving if the solar system is circling the Earth every 24 hours?
If stellar aberration is caused by aether drag as the light passes through the transversally moving aether between the star and Earth, the LIGO experiments (which use 4km perpendicular detectors) would see oscillating deflections with annual and diurnal periodicity, since the aether must needs be changing velocity periodically to explain the observation of different types of stellar aberration. How come this has not been observed?