r/GenderCynical • u/Subrosian_Smithy • Dec 21 '15
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Dec 19 '15
"I am a REAL woman not a faggot in a dress!"
lip marvelous offer practice automatic melodic roof person cover plate
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/maco-is-stupid • Jul 06 '20
I had bad vibes already when i saw only the word women in the description of the subreddit, then i noped as fast as i saw the rules
r/GenderCynical • u/ramen_diet • Dec 20 '15
Puberty blockers and hormones no different from lobotomies.
np.reddit.comr/GenderCynical • u/doodlebug_firefy • Dec 21 '15
So Shanko has been obsessing about trans women for 5 years.
Imagine the good she could have done for society in that time if she wasn't batshit insane...
r/GenderCynical • u/flutterguy123 • Dec 19 '15
How do they spend this much time talking about trans people only to have no idea what hormones actually do?
np.reddit.comr/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Dec 20 '15
Pingers No Pinging
deliver label modern employ command amusing wrench pocket dinosaurs squeeze
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/Subrosian_Smithy • Dec 20 '15
"I know this reaction is problematic even for a gender critical feminist, but I'm sorry, I laugh when I see men who look utterly ridiculous as 'women' transitioning. They just seem so absurd and pathetic."
np.reddit.comr/GenderCynical • u/ryu238 • Feb 03 '18
Please help me show that trans women suffer as badly as ciswomen
r/GenderCynical • u/ramen_diet • Dec 20 '15
While millennials fixate on men who think they're women, conservatives are dismantling women's health care.
np.reddit.comr/GenderCynical • u/GCy-throwaway • Dec 20 '15
Translating GC newspeak. (Or, "FYI We're not 'Gender Critical', anymore because Gender is fake and bad.")
So a local group (Atlanta area) that I am a part of put on a meeting recently to discuss gender criticism.
We may or may not have held a hate rally which had little-to-nothing to do with critical theory of gender.
The turn out was rather small (go figure) but that gave us time to really address things rather than having to go deep into the 101 that a big group brings.
The jerk was strong.
This led me to some ideas that I just want to throw out into the GC ether here...
Here's the bread!
Using the words masculine/feminine are antithetical to my goal of gender abolition and I think I should cease using them entirely.
https://digitalcomposting.files.wordpress.com/2010/10/no_yinyang.png
They are shorthand for the stereotypes that hurt me and my sisters.
All AMAB people love gender roles and stereotypes, and none have ever been harmed by them.
Instead of using them I am going to try to use the specific traits that I mean. For example, instead of saying "People see me as kinda masculine", I would say instead "People see me as assertive and uncompromising" or maybe "People see me as a person who wears practical/work-type clothing and pays little attention to the way she looks".
Previously, when I used the words masculine and feminine I meant something completely other than that which is a healthy conception of masculinity or feminity. I'm going to correct that by pretending the words don't exist, and not using a short hand which accepts unhealthy gender roles as essential, even if it means saying what I meant in the first place. I'm just that rad.
In the same way I think that the phrase "gender non-conforming" is not a useful phrase and reinforces the concept of gender (after all if someone is gender non-conforming there must be someone gender conforming).
I've decided that a new word hurts my feefees. In other news, saying "anti-fascist" now reinforces fascism.
I understand its popularity within the radfem/GC community but I still think that using it is a little bit of a hindrance in imagining the true dynamic of gender.
I don't care that this is a useful concept, concepts make thinking whatever I want harder.
No woman is gender conforming.
Horse is the most horse horse...
She may be a person concerned with the way she looks. She may perform the beauty rituals that many see as oppressive.
Sometimes girls do girl things.
She may DO or BE a lot of things but no matter what there is a degree to which she does not fit her gender stereotype. So if EVERY woman is gender non-conforming then what is the use of the term?
... But no horse is Horse, therefore, horses do not exist. QED.
Again I think it is better to be more specific. For example instead of saying "Mary is gender non-conforming" maybe consider "Mary is often read as male in public due to her restricted mannerisms and mode of dress" or "Mary often ignores social cues of "politeness" in order to make her point. This often makes people uncomfortable."
Instead of using "gender non-conforming" I'm going to use totally different ideas, which have almost nothing to do with gender non-/conformity to discuss things other than gender and gender non-/conformity. Uhmmm.. Why was I talking about gender non-conformity again?
I am NOT trying to say that you MUST use this language.
I'm just an aspiring dictator tho. I haven't gotten my epaulets yet.
Lord knows there are more important things to give your energy to.
I understand that applying this idea would include renaming this subreddit and an entire field of academic study, so don't take me too seriously.
I merely want to put forward the idea that the way we talk CREATES the way we think and as womyn who want to live in a world without these stereotypes we need all the tools we can acquire.
If we just never say words for things we don't like, they go away forever!!
(no TERFs were harmed in the making of this satire.)
More deep thoughts from OP's comments:
I KNOW it is so much easier to say "... yeah but you're feminine" when I mean "... yeah but you wear delicate clothing and at least publicly defer to men's bullshit"
Is that what this person thinks femininity is? wearing delicate clothing and deferrence to men? That's so sad.
but I think making specific points like the second sentence is going to be an important project (at least for myself).
So.. being gender critical, then. That's a bold strategy, cotton.
To continue to use such terms, [masculine and feminine] even in a value neutral way simply reinforces the erroneous notion that such things are "naturally" linked to one's sex.
I mean, one could use the terms to refer to things which are naturally linked to sex/gender. But that would mean acknowledging that there are things which are naturally linked to sex and gender. So that's a no go.
Alternately, one could use the words to refer to the ideas of masculinity and femininity which are widely accepted in dismantling them. Like how many feminists use the phrase "toxic masculinity." or #masculinitysofragile. But no, lets just delete these words for forever. That's better, right?
Why talk about "feminine/masculine actions" in a world where feminine/masculine mean something other than what you are meaning to convey? Why not just use "female/male actions"?
Maybe because male and female aren't adjectives?
I full-on agree about "identity". Ugh I have found myself consciously distancing myself from that term in lots of spaces. It is a term that basically has no meaning anymore.
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Dec 20 '15
GenderCynical Discord Now Available
jellyfish station stupendous marry soft butter capable innocent quaint roll
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • May 31 '18
When irony knocks...
spotted spoon silky groovy aware imminent lip theory reminiscent wild
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Oct 06 '15
Let's play: "Troll or No Troll'
wipe entertain office cable school heavy mighty profit aware abounding
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Sep 10 '15
Groped by a gay guy? Grab his genetalia and twist it.
ten hard-to-find treatment ad hoc angle apparatus paltry decide society test
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/OrpheumApogee • Sep 13 '19
What does one say when a hate group icon dies?
Not sure what to feel about Magdelen Burns. Hate obviously eats people up inside, and this person spent the last three precious years of her life shitting on trans women.
Awesome legacy, I guess. This must be what it felt like when Jesse Helms or Strom Thurmond died.
r/GenderCynical • u/agreatgreendragon • Jul 09 '18
best article about the cotton ceiling to post to r/actuallesbians?
i feel like if people are able to properly understand the meaning of the transactivisttm message the terf seed won't sprout
r/GenderCynical • u/cassicade • Aug 07 '16
I thought this maybe interesting, sorry if off topic
r/GenderCynical • u/WhoYouCouldBe • Feb 05 '16
Sassy, "sexist" Drag Queen talking about their sex life in my class makes me feel uncomfortable, can I shoehorn in trans-hate and label them an autogen-pervert too?
np.reddit.comr/GenderCynical • u/emptycel • Oct 07 '19
gendercritical and inceltears user sent me a demeaning message 5 months ago, calling me a “little girl”
r/GenderCynical • u/Aleksandra_Sokolova • Sep 28 '15
Now they're into Holocaust jokes
r/GenderCynical • u/mollymollykelkel • Aug 11 '14
User tries to be critical in gender_critical, but we won't have any of that, will we?
existence crawl sand tender reach judicious one quickest instinctive encourage
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
r/GenderCynical • u/CrystalCastlesII • Dec 22 '15