r/GameDevelopment • • May 16 '25

Discussion I got fired from my game dev job after 4 years

1.5k Upvotes

I was recently fired from my game dev job. I've worked there for 4 years as an engineer and I've worked on 6 different shipped titles doing console porting. I loved this job but in my 4 years the company has grown to the point where they are aiming for AAA territory, which means company culture is out the window and it's suddenly all about money.

I was ultimately fired because I didn't have enough experience with Unreal Engine. My experience up until this year has all been Unity or custom engines.

If anything, let this be a lesson to future game devs to learn Unreal and get good at it (C++, not just blueprints). That seems to be where the industry is heading. But also, don't back yourself into a corner. When I started working on games, Unity was what people were using.

Feel free to ask me almost anything. (Lots of NDA stuff)


r/GameDevelopment • • Jul 02 '25

Discussion I spent 4 years making my dream game, and it flopped.

1.3k Upvotes

Hey Reddit,

I’m a web dev with 15+ years of experience and a lifelong gamer. For years, I had an idea for a game and finally decided to build it.

It started small and low-poly, but as the team grew, so did the scope. We switched to realistic graphics, scrapped everything, and started over. After years of evenings and weekends, we launched on Steam.

It’s a multiplayer game in alpha, and we’ve made about $1,000, with a max of 8 players all-time peak. It still needs a ton of work, and honestly, I’m burned out and questioning if the idea was ever as good as I thought.

But even if it flopped, I don’t regret it. I learned more about game dev, teamwork, and myself than I ever would have otherwise.

If you’re making your own indie game: scope carefully, don’t skip marketing, and take care of yourself along the way.

EDIT:

First, I want to share the name of the game: Rage of Mechs.

I also want to thank everyone here for the feedback and comments. This post reached more than 500k views, and I’ve read so many encouraging and constructive messages that it truly motivated me to keep going. That’s awesome!

A lot of you mentioned wanting a single-player mode, and it’s something we’re seriously considering for the future. The Rage of Mechs universe is big and rich with lore, and I have ideas for interesting stories that could be explored through a single-player experience to bring this world to life in a deeper way.

Many also pointed out issues with the Steam page, especially the trailer, so the trailer was already reworked as well. We’re also planning a brand new approach to marketing.

Lastly, we want to build a community where players can share ideas, give feedback, and help us shape a better version of the game together. If you’d like to join our Discord, feel free to check my profile for the link or message me!

Thank you all again for taking the time to comment and share your thoughts. It means a lot, and it’s given me the energy to keep moving forward.


r/GameDevelopment • • Mar 08 '25

Newbie Question Nobody who wish-list my game bought it

835 Upvotes

I recently released a game on steam and it has done very poorly. It had about 150 wishlist's at the time of release and has sold 7 copies (all friends and family).

0 people (accept the above mentioned friends and family) who wish-list the game have bought it.

It's very cheap and on release sale.

I was never doing this for the money but I've made $10 - so once you remove the steam app fee I'm actually down $90 after about 300 hours of legitimate hard and at times stressful work. Both developing and advertising.

I'd be okay with that if I got the joy of knowing I made something that people enjoy, but nobody is even playing the game.

The game is simple, both in art and game-play, deliberately so - but it isn't bad, it's a fun little 2 hour puzzle.

I was originally making this post to ask if a 0% conversion rate on wishlist's was normal but now I just think i needed the catharsis of admitting that I wasted 300 hours on this.


r/GameDevelopment • • Sep 17 '25

Discussion My game was banned from Steam Store for seemingly having 'adult content'. I reappealed and they admitted mistake, but this time they claim I have no rights to my own game.

720 Upvotes

---
EDIT2: After almost 4 months since original post the game is fully back on track: I released the demo without any issues with verification process, and now both Steam Store page and full game build passed it too! So it turns out the only thing Valve had issue with is not enough safe-guarding against chat.

I'm happy things are heading the right way, and I hope this will be a lesson to other indie developers struggling with such hardships to not surrender that easily and reappeal if you believe you were treated unfairly. I hope the game release will finally reach the happy ending, it was quite the journey with Valve release process alone.
---
EDIT: After 2 weeks Valve answered to my reappeal, I provided Unity-chan licenses and explained where they can find other license files.
This time they told me exactly what they saw wrong: they managed to get NSFW response from chat model, so it never was licensing issue. But more importantly: they gave me a chance to fix the model and let me apply for review one more time to have game brought back!
This time I'm going to make completely sure there is no way to generate such things, probably add extra censor measures on top of switching model. Unity-chan is supposed to be cheerful and cute, not... this
---

For context, I am working on a game called Unity-Chan: Desktop Companion. It is a game with AI chat plus desktop mascot and virtual room with minigames. By design is just cozy and cute, no adult stuff here.

I was working on the game for a while, and when the time for Valve build reviews came, there still were some issues but purely technical and informative. For example I forgot to create Mod directory on first launch, or didn't include licensing files.

All feedback was very detailed and cooperation went well. That was until they decided to completely delist my game. They set the rule that 'Adult games with AI chat are not allowed', and told me they can refund my shop fee.

It made me so confused, as I couldn't grasp what could pass as adult content, I even started suspecting that maybe head patting animation might be the case? So I created message asking them what they see as adult content and reappealed.

After 2 weeks I received another vague message that they admitted mistake, but this time they believe I have no rights to publish my game. That made me even more confused. I created the game as solo developed, Unity-chan has her own license and as character is allowed to be used (I even contacted Unity Technologies Support to be sure of it). Every extra asset I either bought or are free and attributed it if it was necessary.

I am so disappointed in how vague their last responses were, even if I wanted to fix things they saw as wrong I can't because they didn't point what is to correct.

Did anyone had such hardships during publishing the game on Steam? What they could possibly mean by 'not having the necessary rights to distribute this product' other than things I mentioned?


r/GameDevelopment • • Dec 03 '25

Resource Indie dev Chequered Ink puts together $10 10,000 game assets pack so developers "don't feel the need to turn to AI" (xpost from /r/gaming)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
681 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Jul 25 '25

Postmortem My indie game has a 34.4% refund rate. Here's the raw data and what went wrong.

580 Upvotes

CAN BE IGNORED

TL;DR: First indie game: 34.4% refund rate, $119 net revenue. First puzzle was broken but I never noticed because I solved it from memory while testing.

Zero playtesting with real people. PLAYTEST PLAYTEST PLAYTEST - it's literally the most important thing and I completely skipped it. Fixed everything after launch but damage was done.

Background: Dr. Voss' Escape Room - a 4-player co-op puzzle game where friends solve mysteries in a laboratory. Solo dev, no previous commercial experience.

Game: https://store.steampowered.com/app/3342410/Dr_Voss_Escape_Room/

WHAT I LEARNED

2 weeks after launching my first commercial game, I'm ready to share the brutal numbers. Maybe this data can help someone else avoid my mistakes.

The Raw Numbers:

  • Units sold: 90

  • Units refunded: 31 (34.4% refund rate)

  • Gross revenue: $205

  • Net revenue: $119 (after refunds/taxes)

  • Median playtime: 34 minutes

  • Wishlists: 346

Refund Reasons (the painful truth):

  • Game too difficult: 10 refunds

  • Not fun: 4 refunds

  • Performance/crash issues: 8 refunds

  • Other technical problems: 6 refunds

  • Purchased by accident: 2 refunds

  • Accessibility/system requirements: 2 refunds

What This Data Actually Means:

34 minutes median playtime = people quit fast My game is supposed to be 1-3 hours. Most people didn't even finish the first area.

346 wishlists → 90 sales = 26% conversion Not terrible, but the 34% refund rate killed any momentum.

The Most Embarrassing Discovery: The first puzzle was completely broken. I had tested it "hundreds of times" but I had memorized the solution and wasn't actually looking at what players saw. Classic developer blindness. I was solving it from memory while players stared at a broken puzzle. This is why i believe so many people quit in the first 34 minutes.

The Fixes I Should Have Made Pre-Launch:

  1. Playtest with ANYONE - I thought it was perfectly fine so I didn't bother letting anyone playtest. Huge mistake.

  2. Start stupid simple - If tutorial puzzle takes >10 minutes, it's too hard

  3. Add hints - "Figure it out" isn't game design

  4. Performance test on potato PCs - 8 crashes/performance refunds could've been avoided

  5. Actually watch someone else play - Don't just ask "did it work?" Watch them struggle.

What I'm Learning:

  • Low revenue stings, but the data is a "goldmine" for improvement (Atleast for me and hopefully for other solo devs)

  • 34% refund rate taught me more than any game dev course

  • Some negative reviews were actually helpful bug reports

  • Players who stay past 1 hour rarely refund

The Humbling Reality: Making a game that I enjoyed ≠ making a game others enjoy. The market doesn't care about your clever design if players can't understand it.

Has anyone else shipped their first game to similar brutal numbers? How did you bounce back?

Edit: Honestly, I'm actually surprised I sold that many copies for my first game. Seeing real failure data helps more than another "I made $10k in my first month" success story."

Update: I've since patched all these issues, fixed the broken puzzle, improved performance, and made it easier to navigate through the puzzles. But the damage to the game's momentum was already done. First impressions on Steam are everything.


r/GameDevelopment • • Nov 25 '25

Discussion Why does everyone think making a video game is easy?

577 Upvotes

I’ve been making video games for 25 years, mainly on the art side, and I’ve watched how we went from having to build a custom engine and custom tools for every single game, to what we have now: tons of engines, tools, and ready-to-use asset packs, basically a giant buffet. But even though installing an engine and messing around is more accessible now, the creative side is harder than ever.

Video games are probably the most complex art form that exists today. I’m not saying they’re “better,” just that they’re the most difficult to control, master, and execute compared to music, film, painting, etc. Getting a game concept to click from every angle, art, sound, design, progression, gameplay, is a massive puzzle.

Despite that, there’s this weird belief that making a game is easy, and that anyone, with no technical skills, no design background, no artistic experience, can make one just because they’ve played games their whole life.

How many times has someone asked you whether they should use Unity or Unreal for their “next big hit”?
Something like: “A game like GTA, but more violent, with a bigger world and more realistic graphics…”

It’s as ridiculous as thinking that, because you’ve eaten food your whole life and you know what tastes “good” or “bad,” you’re automatically ready to become a chef and open your own restaurant.

And just to be clear: I’m not trying to attack people who are excited about their ideas. It’s not their fault, they simply don’t know what they don’t know. That’s why I wonder:

Do we need more real, technical visibility in mainstream media about how games are actually made?
I’m not talking about Ubisoft’s marketing “making-of” videos where they interview people who didn’t even work on the game and just repeat obvious statements. I mean actual development, the ugly parts, the impossible parts, the miracles needed just to get a game to function at all.

So yeah, go ahead and downvote me if you want. I’m just putting it out there.


r/GameDevelopment • • Apr 02 '26

Question Husband is pouring his soul into making a game... what can I do?

486 Upvotes

My husband is building a game and I want to help him succeed (but I have no idea what I’m doing)

My husband has been pouring everything into building his game. Late nights until 3 am, constant iteration, thinking about mechanics, story, design, he’s all in. I can tell this really matters to him, and I want to show up in a way that actually helps, not just cheer from the sidelines.

The problem is… I don’t come from a gaming or dev background at all. I don’t fully understand the process, the timelines, or even what makes a game “click” with people. I don’t want to overstep or distract him.

For those of you who’ve built games (or followed indie dev journeys closely):

  • What actually helps from a partner/friend perspective?

  • What are small but high-impact things I could do to support him emotionally and help build interest in the game?

I care about him, and I care about what he’s building. Just trying to figure out how to show up in a way that actually moves the needle and not just feels supportive on the surface.

Appreciate any real advice

update: wow, thank you so much everyone! I’ll make sure to keep pushing him and just being someone he can fall back on . I’ll try to update you all on the progress he is making and my role in the journey too!

also, just want to say that some of you are giving me too much credit - I’m just being a partner and don’t need recognition for doing my job to be supportive :) it’s the bare minimum of what I can offer!

update 2: yes I used chat gpt to clean up my thoughts, is that a bad thing? I’m a rambler and I didn’t want to post my rambled thoughts lol.


r/GameDevelopment • • Sep 01 '26 Regret

Newbie Question I just found out that im working on a game with ChatGPT... and not my Brother

463 Upvotes

Hey, this is my first post regarding anything like that, so I don't really know how I'm supposed to really do that. I'm just gonna start, I guess.

My brother told me that he works on a new game project and would need some assets for said game.
So I asked him what exactly that project is and what assets he needs.

He wanted to make a Pixelart Roguelike game.
After talking about the game a bit, I told him that I could try and help him with the assets. And I think he liked the idea (or even wanted to ask me to do it without asking me to do it), cause I already had drawn assets for his projects before (which he in the end abandoned).

So I learnt to make pixelart, cause I've never done that before.

And after a bit of trial and error I was able to pixel some assets that I think where okayish for that little game. Then I got told more and more about how "little" that game is supposed to be. Not gonna lie, I think it's really not a small game. The player supposedly has to climb a tower with 100 floors, each floor has enemies the player has to beat in order to pass on to the next floor, after every 10 floors there is a boss and the theme of the floors change.

So far so good I thought, then he told about how the player is able to use 78 different cards, with different abilities and 4 different weapon types and 5 damage/element types and armor and amulets and and and... You get the Idea. So in my opinion quite a lot for a first time "little" game.

But what really made me scratch my head, was how disconnected everything felt...

Well, anyway, I just found out that my brother is using ChatGPT for the game, when I went into his room to ask him something (The door was open and his laptop was facing the doorway), so I saw that some code was open and wanted to take a closer look (I know, that is not quite the greatest thing to do..) And basically, all of the requests were asking ChatGPT to code that or improve this and what not...

Which shocked me cause he specifically said that he wanted to make the project without AI...

I even tried to ask him about it later, when he returned, but he just straight up denied it, even with ChatGPT still open. Which just makes me sad...

I mean he's in his 3rd year learning programming, does he do it all just with AI? Like I'm so confused.

What should I do now, just continue as normal? Pixel those sprites just for them to be used by the AI in its twisted amalgamation of a game project?

Or is it maybe even normal that you just tell AI to code your game nowadays?

I really thought it would be a nice little project I could help my brother out with and not just make some soulless AI nonsense...

**Update:**

Thank you for all your opinions on the matter it really helped me to put the whole situation in perspective. Even if I didn't expect to get that many opinions, that fast.

Me and my brother got to talk about the whole situation and the use of AI in the code of the game. It seems to be normal to an extent to use it when writing code. Although we both agreed that it was used in an unhealthy way.

We probably will change up a lot of things about the game, or even shelf it for now (maybe even for good).

We still are trying to work with each other as we are not really on any bad terms. Maybe will even work on a truly small scale game for the both of us, just to get some more experience.


r/GameDevelopment • • Jan 06 '23

Resource Before/After rotoscoping for my game

428 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Apr 22 '21

He is speed

Post image
358 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Oct 17 '21

Show-off We're making a zombie game that uses IRL map data so you can play where you live!

357 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Jan 19 '26

Discussion Not to be a dick but can we maybe ban the constant stream of "I have a super awesome idea for the perfect video game, how do I make it immediately? I have no money or relevant skills or experience but my cousins fiance majored in computer science so I can probably figure it out." posts?

335 Upvotes

Like with an automod or something?

I know everyone needs to start somewhere but ffs theres like 10 of those posts a day and theyre all exactly the same, can we just get like a sticky or something telling people who ask such questions to watch a youtube tutorial and download godot and also to seriously temper their expectations of what a human being can achieve without budget or experience?

like at least confine it to a "where to get started" questions megathread or something


r/GameDevelopment • • Mar 18 '23

Game developers be like!

Post image
315 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Dec 05 '25 Bravo

Resource Here are 20 subreddits that allow you to promote your games

312 Upvotes

Wanted to share because marketing is hard and even harder when you're budget is non-existent T_T

(Obviously the type/content of self-promotion you can post is going to dependent on the subreddit)

please comment any that i might have missed!

edit: if u found this list helpful, i have a catalog with more, since i couldn't post all them here <3

edit 2: removed game-specific communities as pointed out by others. adding some more down below that are allowed towards anyone:

  • r/GamingDetails (266K)

  • r/iosgaming (244K): Promotions allowed on Saturdays only with weekend messaging rules.

  • r/macgaming (235k): Limited self-promo: once daily, with detailed info and formatting requirements.

  • r/pcgaming (4M):  Promotion allowed only when balanced by non-promotional posts; ads restricted.


r/GameDevelopment • • Sep 27 '25

Question Got an offer from a huge publisher, unsure what to do

302 Upvotes

Posting on a throwaway here, trying to keep this as anonymous as possible but all I’ll say is, I have a game I’ve been solo developing for the last 1 year. My game has amassed over 50,000 wishlists on Steam and I’ve gotten millions of views across my socials regarding my game.

I was approached by a large publisher (think the likes of Devolver Digital, Team17, 505Games) wanting to publish my game. No specific cut has been mentioned yet, nothing has been signed either. All that was mentioned was somewhere around 20-25% (potentially lower since I already have an audience).

On one hand I am semi confident I could probably sell 100,000 units on my own, but with a publisher of this size I’m convinced it could be much more than that.

Should I do it? What things should I be aware of?

UPDATE: I’ve decided to not go forth. Reasons being:

  • I’m already 90% finished with development

  • I have had zero problem getting to 50k wishlists myself, so another 50k through a steam next fest / the next 6 months shouldn't be hard theoretically

  • I don't need funding - essentially, from my understanding, publishers won't really try too hard to make your game do well if there isn't any risk in it for them. If I published a game that was fully bootstrapped and self-funded. What's in it for them? It's a no-loss scenario for them and pretty high risk scenario for us (20-30% cut to devolver)

For those asking in the comments, the game I’m working on is called “DEADLINE DELIVERY” on Steam!


r/GameDevelopment • • Sep 07 '26

Inspiration It finally happened

301 Upvotes

10+ years.

72,961,945 incomplete projects.

52,925 times "what happened to that game you were making?" was asked.

$0 made.

I finally finished making a game.

EDIT: it is online at https://wordspool.app


r/GameDevelopment • • Apr 23 '21

We’ve all been there.

Post image
298 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Jul 12 '21

Show-off Improved running animation?

287 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Apr 19 '22

Show-off Meet our basic enemy. Now upgraded and polished!

276 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Aug 01 '20

Always has been

Post image
263 Upvotes

r/GameDevelopment • • Jun 03 '26

Discussion I work in playtesting and I think most indie devs are solving the wrong problem

247 Upvotes

Okay so I keep seeing this pattern all over on Reddit. Indie devs post their game looking for playtesters (on r/playtesters, r/playmygame...), not a lot of interaction, so I guess not a lot try it, and eventually the conclusion becomes "players just don't want to help anymore" or "people are lazy now" or something along those lines. 

I get why people end up there. if you spend 2 years making something and the response is silence, that silence might feels personal after a while. FYI I work at Play2Review so I spend a stupid amount of time around early playtests and I genuinely think most teams are sometimes trying to solve the wrong problem

And I think most of the time it isn't a feedback problem but more something like "this already feels like effort before I even know if I care" issue. Dont forget that most gamers have dozens of Steam games they PAID for and haven't played. You have to compete with those for that gamers time and attention. 

Have a look at it, a stranger scrolls past your post after work while half distracted watching YouTube or replying to Discord messages or whatever. Their brain is making this super fast unconscious decision about whether clicking your game is going to feel exciting or draining, or maybe both. And a lot of playtest posts accidentally feel draining immediately.

Tell me that you never seen this pattern? : 

  • external download links

  • giant paragraphs explaining lore

  • "looking for honest feedback!!"

  •  vague genre descriptions

  • five screenshots where nothing understandable is happening

I’m sure that people don't consciously think "this game looks bad" but they just quietly leave. Making a good game and making people care are two separate skills. 

The weird thing is I used to assume rough games naturally struggled more because players judge polish too hard or whatever, but after watching a ton of sessions I honestly don't even think that's true anymore.

I've seen “ugly” broken prototypes pull in tons of players because the core idea was instantly readable. 15 seconds of footage and you just got it- not because it looked good, but because the fantasy was obvious. Like “Oh okay I'm a little robot digging through giant machine”s. “Oh okay this shotgun sends enemies flying across the room”. You understood what kind of fun this was going to be before you even decided if you wanted it. 

And then I've seen polished games with clean UI and beautiful Steam pages get almost no traction because the whole thing felt weirdly cautious. Like the page was afraid to commit to what made the game interesting in the first place.  So everything becomes "a challenging adventure with unique mechanics" which could describe literally anything and nothing at the same time.

I also think devs underestimate how tired people are now in general. Even as someone who literally does playtesting stuff for work, there are moments where I open a post and see:

download here -> create account -> verify email -> fill survey after session.. and my brain instantly goes "yeah maybe tomorrow" and tomorrow never come (not gonna lie)

The bad part is that teams then try to fix feedback quality when the real issue is nobody got curious enough to click in the first place. So they rewrite survey questions or add analytics or spend weeks optimizing onboarding for players who never even downloaded the build, when sometimes the fix is honestly smaller than that ↓

  • put the gameplay clip first

  • show the coolest thing immediately

  • say who the game is actually for

  • remove steps

  • stop writing store pages like you're filing taxes

And in other good examples exist and are not just due to luck. Find them by going to any sub related to gamedev, sort them by top, then sort by all time or this year. You’ll find a bunch of good examples of best practices. Do not reinvent the wheel, but make it yours.

I don't know, maybe I'm overthinking this because I spend too much time around early builds, aha. But I'm curious if other people doing player research or community testing see the same thing, because the pattern feels REALLY consistent from where I'm standing to see at Play2review. Maybe if we add something like "roast my art" on our website, it would benefit the indie dev community aha. 


r/GameDevelopment • • Feb 22 '25

Discussion Game dev is hard. Don't make it harder on yourself

245 Upvotes

Been scrolling through the sub and seeing a lot of posts from people feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or just straight-up wondering if they’re even good enough to make games. And I get it. Game dev is tough. It’s frustrating, it’s time-consuming, and sometimes it feels like no matter how much you learn, there’s always something else blocking your progress.

And you know what makes it worse? That little voice in your head telling you:

💭 “This is too simple. Real games are way more complex.”
💭 “I need to add more features or it’s not impressive.”
💭 “Nobody will care about a basic game.”

That mindset? It’s a creativity killer. And it’s the reason so many people start making games and never actually finish one.

Here’s the truth: Simple games are not bad games.

Some of the best, most iconic games ever made have incredibly basic mechanics. But they’re polished, intuitive, and satisfying. Complexity doesn’t make a game good, execution does .

Look, if you’re just starting out, here’s what you should really focus on:

Make something stupidly simple

I mean really simple. Strip it down to its core mechanic and focus on that. You’re not making Elden Ring on your first try. You’re making a game that you can actually finish.

Finishing a game is a skill.

And just like any skill, you have to practice it. Completing a small project gives you the experience and confidence to take on bigger ones. If you keep starting massive projects and never finishing them, you’re not actually learning game development, you’re just learning how to start projects.

Polish > Features

It’s easy to think, “I’ll just add this extra mechanic, and then my game will be good.” But a simple, well-executed idea will always be more enjoyable than a bloated, half-broken mess. Less is more.

Simplicity ≠ Lack of Depth

A game that’s easy to understand doesn’t mean it’s easy to master. Think about games like Tetris, Celeste, Vampire Survivors. Super simple concepts, but endless depth. Your game doesn’t need to be complex to be fun.

Don’t make game dev harder than it already is.

It’s already a massive challenge, so don’t sabotage yourself by aiming too big, too fast. Keep it small. Keep it achievable. And keep going.

So, let’s hear it: What’s the first game you ever actually finished? Even if it was a buggy mess, even if it barely worked, even if it was just a crappy Pong clone, you finished it. And that’s what matters.

Drop your stories below, I’d love to hear them!

Good luck everyone :)


r/GameDevelopment • • Sep 13 '21

Show-off I am working on a day and night cycle for the different seasons in my game.

238 Upvotes