TL;DR: Samsung broke my phone, has revoked my warranty and refuses to repair or replace it. Also, Samsung support is the 7th layer of Hell.
November 23, 2018
I bought an unlocked Samsung Galaxy S9+ from Amazon with a one year warranty. The phone has been great (one of the best Android phones I've ever had). I use it for personal use as well as for work. The phone has never been rooted/jailbroken. My work has security policies in place that will not allow rooted phones to work with corporate resources.
August 1, 2019
An OTA update appeared for my phone. I assume it was a security patch, but do not recall this detail. I started the install process and it failed at some point. Alas, I did not take notice as to what step it failed at. The phone rebooted and got stuck in a boot loop. It would display the Samsung slash screen for a few seconds, and then reboot again, then repeat the process.
I presume the failed update corrupted the boot loader to the point where it could not move past that stage. I tried the usual key combinations to either force a restart (didn't help) or get me to the bootloader menu where I could initiate safe mode. It would not allow me to get to the bootloader menu, instead it reported that the bootloader was locked because it detected a custom bootloader image. Again, I presume this is because the bootloader is corrupted and no longer matches the official signatures.
I then contacted Samsung support via chat. The tech assisting me had me try all the same things I just tried again. When that didn't work, he simply stopped responding to me. I then called Samsung support and they opened a ticket for me and confirmed that my phone was still under warranty. They had me go through all the same steps again. When that didn't work they referred me to an officially sanctioned Samsung repair shop.
I took my phone to them, they hooked it up to their tester and within 5 minutes told me they could not fix my phone and I would have to send it to Samsung for repair. I called Samsung with the latest status and they sent me shipping label to send my phone in for repair. Unlike Google or Apple, they do not send replacement phones first. They expected me to just give up my phone no questions asked.
August 2, 2019
I mailed my phone to Samsung repair in Houston, TX.
August 7, 2019
I received an email that Samsung repair has received my phone. Note, this is the only written communication I have ever received from Samsung support.
August 13, 2019
I received my phone back from Samsung with a note saying that they diagnosed my phone as being rooted (it wasn't) and that therefore the device was un-repairable. No further notes on what the next steps should be.
Call #1
Called support and referenced my ticket number. After explaining the situation to them, they looked into their notes and told me the same thing. They had determined that my phone was rooted and therefore they could not repair it. When I disputed that it was rooted, the tech put me on hold while he tried to find more details about the repair attempt. I was then hung up on.
Call #2
Called back, referenced the ticket number again, and had to explain the whole situation again. The tech looked into their notes and then tells me my phone is not under warranty. I ask how that is possible since it has been less than a year and the previous calls had all confirmed that my phone was still under warranty. Confirmed the IMEI number to be the correct one. Tech looked into the case notes and found that since Samsung Repair had determined my phone to be rooted, they revoked my warranty.
Tech explains that nothing can be done. They believe I have a rooted phone and therefore they have no obligation to fix my problem. I ask him to escalate the issue. He refuses.
I spent the next 45 minutes arguing with the tech, asking him to escalate it, to start the dispute process, and to transfer me to a supervisor. He refuses all of it, saying he is not authorized to do any of that, and that the supervisor will tell me the same thing he just told me.
I finally convince him to transfer me to a supervisor, but he says "she is on a call". I tell him I will wait. He doesn't like that answer and says he can't transfer me because she is on a call. I don't understand what is so magical about being on a call that makes it impossible to be transferred. He finally relents and transfers me to the supervisor, where I am promptly hung up upon again.
I tweeted at Samsung support, hoping that would help. It hasn't yet.
Call #3
Called back, referenced the ticket number again, and had to explain the whole situation again. I asked to get an email response to the ticket. Either a dump of the ticket entirely, or at least an email stating that Samsung was refusing to help. The tech would not do this as it is against policy.
I asked to be transferred to a supervisor, and to my surprise she actually did it without any arguing. I spoke to the supervisor who seemed very understanding. It was here I found out Samsung repair didn't even try to repair the phone. They simply looked at it enough to determine that it was rooted and then immediately sent it back.
The supervisor said she would open a different type of ticket (customer support vs. repair) to try to get them to waive the "rooted device" blocker. If that was successful, I would have to send the phone back again for repair, and they would either repair or replace it. She couldn't guarantee that they would waive the blocker though.
She told me someone would call me at 9:00am EST the next day and I would get an email update with status of the new ticket. She also reiterated that they couldn't email me contents of any of the existing tickets nor could they send me anything written about why they were refusing to honor the warranty. She claimed their system does not allow it.
I had now spent about 4 hours talking to Samsung support and went to bed.
August 14, 2019
Not surprisingly, I received no communication whatsoever from Samsung. No calls, no emails, nothing.
Takeaways:
Samsung broke my phone, revoked my warranty, and is refusing to repair or fix it.
Samsung support is hell. It seems designed at every step of the way to disenfranchise the customer to the point where they give up. They are not interested in helping. Techs have the freedom to lie to customers and to hang up on them with no reprisals.
I have no way to prove that my phone was not rooted at this point. It is simply my word against theirs. I believe it is plausible that a corrupted bootloader will look like a rooted phone, but they don't seem to care.
I likely will never be a Samsung customer again after the way I have been treated.
Next Steps:
I could file a report with the FTC. This will likely require me to send a certified letter to Samsung and wait for a response. I am not hopeful this will result in anything productive.
I could possibly sue them in small claims court. I am not sure this is worth my time and/or effort at this point.
I could try to get a grassroots movement started by drawing more attention to the issue by posting on reddit.
Anything else I can or should be trying?
AUGUST 16 UPDATE
Two positive things have happened.
Thanks to suggestions from /u/sonofsmog and /u/lobie81 , I contacted Amazon and told them the story and asked them if there was anything they could do. The customer service was great. The dude asked his lead to go outside of policy and issue me a one-time refund for the device. It wasn't full price, but it was pretty close.
Thanks to suggestions from /u/Sable-Knight, /u/Guardianes15, and others, I was able to finally get the phone into download mode. I was then able to use Odin to flash the stock firmware on the device. It was a little sketchy because I had trouble keeping the battery charged, and I had to chase down a Windows machine, but it worked! My phone now boots.
I've decided to decline the refund that Amazon gave me. I'm going to keep the phone (for now). The customer experience from Samsung was so bad, that I don't think my next phone will be a Samsung.
Thanks everyone for all the great suggestions!