Hi folks, I think writers shouldn't write terms of use, and I hope that we as a community will consider some of the downsides of doing so before presenting it as a solution to various problems.
[I've detailed my opinion below. I hope that you read and enjoy it, and if you don't enjoy it, then I hope it's at least thought provoking. I encourage you to leave your own thoughts below.
Just a quick disclaimer for your informed reading, I do talk about monetization in here, primarily the monetization of voice acting using scripts. I myself have used my own brand, built on reddit, to promote my own Patreon. I've put audios of myself behind paywalls. And now, on with the show.
Three stories.
Once upon a time, I started writing. VA encourage me to send her sfw scripts, dozens of scripts, which she would then fill and upload to her youtube channel. As of writing, the videos made with my scripts on her channel have amassed over 600,000 views. The associated advertisement revenue is somewhere between $200 and $600. In addition, these audios promoted her Patreon, which on rare occasions featured audios based on my scripts. I didn’t know any better. She always made so much noise about how much she stuck up for writers, but somehow it never occurred to her that they were outsourcing part of their business to me, and not paying me. Not in equity, not in cash, not in kind. That’s not ethical, whatever their intentions. It was a slow and expensive lesson to realize that she only messaged me when she wanted something from me. I had a business partner whom I mistook for a friend.
Upon another time, over a year later, I was in a much different situation. I was posting on reddit, connecting with other creators, and had a better sense of my worth. I was approached by a VA who wanted to post a script fill on her Patreon. I hadn’t heard of her, so I asked her for my standard $15. She dutifully paid me, and sure enough, a few days later she told me she posted it. Out of curiosity, I checked out her page. I think it was her first audio, maybe her first audio ever. As of today, it is also her latest. I don’t think she recouped her $15. We can focus on the proposition that perhaps starting a Patreon right out of the gate is not a successful way of launching an audio porn business, but I’ll take for granted that she didn’t know any better. I took advantage of them, regardless of my intentions. I’d bumped into a novice, and mistook them for an entrepreneur.
Upon a third time, quite recently actually, it came to light that a certain performer was using scripts, including mine, from reddit on his youtube and Patreon. From one side of his mouth he apologized, and from the other he renounced responsibility. It was, apparently, my fault for not clearly posting that he could do no such thing with my scripts. As if I should nail a “No Trespassing” sign on my front door. He was a bad actor, a plunderer who took what he wanted and rationalized it afterward. But you don’t have to mistake foe for friend.
The unifying thread between these stories, if there is any, has something to do with the uncertainty of human relationships. I constantly need to use my best judgement, so hesitant to commit myself to future questions before they are ripe. Lately, there has been a lively discussion about writer’s terms of use. Very intelligent, serious people have promoted terms of use as a useful tool to protect writers and help guide voice actors. I’m going to lay out why I disagree; I think terms of use are ineffective or inefficient ways of solving the problems they are proposed to fix, I think they weaken writers instead of empower them, and I think they’re a red herring on the actual responsibility of considerate adaption.
Consider the first ailment, that certain voice actors might go too far with a script, doing something with the script that, if the actor had asked the writer beforehand, the writer would have reject. This is indeed a serious problem. It is supposed that, before the actor does such a thing, they will carefully read the terms and conditions, correctly understand it, and conform to it, thus avoiding the problem. A VA with a certain personality will in fact do that.
But I have the strong suspicion that such a meticulous person is also the sort of person such that, if they wanted to do something outside of the folkways of GWA, they would just ask the writer for permission. I get these kinds of questions all the time, even when the script has a compact terms of use already granting their request. I don’t believe in magic spells. There are no words that, if printed in a large enough font, will cause careless people to be careful, nor force devils to be angels. The power of the contract has always been an extension of the power of those who enforce them. And there’s very little you can do to someone who’s abused a writer other than boo them and report their audios, which as it turns out, you can do perfectly well without a contract.
The response is thus: while such a supposed contract might not stop the villain, it will prove 100% that they’re in the right, and thus guarantee public support. What a remarkably threadbare comfort.
Consider the second ailment, that terms of use can guide actors into understanding the writer’s expectations. Perhaps I’ve been here simply too long, but is there really any doubt about writer’s expectations? Our arrangement has never been particularly obscure. I find the GWA new user’s guide to be remarkably cogent on this point, and if the issue is compliance with the base rules, surely every writer including these base rules on their script offer is not the most effective way of solving this problem. The new user guide is prominently featured on the GWA sidebar, what more must we do? These base terms do in fact instruct performers to ask before doing anything remotely objectionable, and set the correct expectation. It’s not the writer’s job to clarify in the universe of all possible adaptations of a script what they will and won’t allow, but upon the actor to tell the writer what they want to do and allow them to make an informed decision. Not that anybody asked me, but I think how the mods have messaged this point is immaculate.
Now, I do concede custom terms have their use. If I can pick on my good friend u/dominaexcrucior, she has a very thorough terms of use. In the improv section, it makes entirely clear a few things that she absolutely does not want performers to do. I’m sure these relate to her personally, so I’ll examine the particulars no further, but I’ll be damned if I can find a script where she doesn’t make those improvisation restrictions abundantly clear. I’m entirely open to the possibility that this document, as well as notes on the scripts themselves, helps considerate performer avoid a faux pas. I don’t want anyone to take away from this that they shouldn’t write a terms of use document if they have expectations that are particular to themselves, only, that if they do not have such universal requirements, trying to write a terms of use can have two serious problems.
The first being, the actual contextual relationship between the writer and the actor simply has too much variety to capture in a single document. It’s entirely valid for a writer to have complicated feelings about becoming a factor in another’s business endeavor, or to want to treat hobbyists differently from entrepreneurs, or wanting to treat people with whom they have an ongoing reciprocal relationship different than strangers.
By posting a single terms of use, you’re forced to capture all the complexity, all the factors that would impact how to decide how to handle each individual request, or else surrender, and simplify your terms to treat everybody largely the same. I took a stab at writing a document to handle a specific, common case of an actor wanting to host their fill on Patreon, and my goodness, it is exceedingly difficult to write in a way that binds without ambiguity and enlightens with brevity. This is, really, work fit for a lawyer, and I can’t imagine getting an attorney to understand the full nuances of my wants without at least an hour interview. The point isn’t the cost itself, but that the writer must take on that cost in order to both have a terms of use that resolves the two original problems and also lets the writer keep their original preferences in all their human complexity. The power to individually consider requests is a great and useful, and not easily replaced.
If you’ll pardon a subsection, there’s also the rather noodley problem of posting terms of use often means having to quantify how much a license to use a script costs. Different actors are capable of extracting different amounts of value from a script, just as private commissioners, video game studios, and movies all extract different amounts of value from the work of a voice actor. I’ll go out on a limb and say that actors who rely on editors, writers, and artists should pay these people proportionally, just as surely as they pay their platform providers proportional to their revenue. The alternative, that actors should source their materials as cheaply as possible, feels to me a violation of our communal good will. I honestly think a world were writers are paid proportionally is the better world. There, the writer who’s willing to license for costs as low as free would not be undercutting other writers. Because actors cannot reduce costs by switching writers, they would have all the incentive to work with those with whom they make the most satisfying art. Writers setting fixed prices precludes this better world.
You may find my focus on commercial uses of audio porn a bit gauche. This is, after all, a community focused on free content, but the shadow of commercialism is inescapable, and I do truly believe we have to talk about the elephant in the room. For an aspiring adult voice actor, their single most important financial asset is their audience. Their costs of production are largely fixed, and their revenue is multiplied by the number of people who have experienced their work. There is no successful business model for growth that does not include posting free audios, largely on reddit, largely without paying the writers who worked on those scripts at all.
If an actor ever decides to try their hand at making money through audio porn, everything they’ve made before that is, retroactively, part of their business model. Free content builds their brand, then their brand promotes their paid content, then profit. Yes, it is different than directly monetizing a script by putting a fill of it behind a pay-wall, but it’s still a commercial use, and we would do well to remember that. When we forget it, we end up in the strange situation where actors get upset at GWA’s limitation on how scripts sourced from there are capitalized. We forget that everything people provide to this community, their words, their voices, the often unsung art of editing and sound design, is a privilege. It’s a genuine privilege to be part of this share-and-share-alike bazaar. Nothing we borrow from it is ours to keep.
It is easy to forget that GWA isn’t like the real world. In the real world, copyright is an iron yoke. We have nothing, no rights to see or know or perform, one word of a play without the written permission of the author. In the real word, authors charge money for people to read their works. Imagine! And how much more they charge for performers to adapt their precious words. Martin made his millions on the television. We have drawn a small circle on this corner of the internet where those rules are relaxed, and the circle is held together with a wish and prayer, and in some real day in the future it’s going to be taken away from us by the admins, and we’ll miss these days. This is our Camelot. This is the best it ever will be. So for heaven’s sake, stop trying to carry the magic out into the daylight. Outside of reddit, nobody has given permission for anybody to do anything with their scripts or audios. That’s just the default of the real world, it’s the default on the GWA guide, and writers don’t need to post a terms of use to affirm, yes, all rights reserved.
And, voila, we have finally come to the second problem. The formulation that writers need to post terms of use presupposes it’s the writer’s responsibility to communicate what permissions they’re giving to, well, everyone and anyone. But they simply aren't responsible for that. You want permission? Ask us. Give us the information we need to make an informed decision. Yes, I understand that can be quite an inconvenience if you have, let’s say, a schedule for uploading content on your Patreon and you might need to take an extra day to find the best price, but I hope that you will be consoled by the notion that you treated your writer like a human being.
Consider my terms of use. “Ok to improvise. Ask me before posting off of reddit.”
It’s still one line too long, by my reckoning.