So, I've been replaying GTA 4 over the past couple of days. It's the first time I've played it in more than seven years. Over all these years, I've seen posts, comments, and videos online insisting that this is the best GTA game, sometimes to an aggressive degree, where people would call you stupid or a child for thinking otherwise.
I myself loved GTA 4, but I never considered it the best. For starters, I've had much more fun playing GTA 5 and San Andreas. But I wanted to give it another try before the release of GTA 6 to see what all the buzz was about and maybe discover something I'd missed during my initial experience with this supposedly "best" GTA game.
And man, after playing it extensively for a couple of days, I can confidently say that this is not my favorite GTA. I mean, don't get me wrong. I still think it's a great game and easily one of the top three entries in the franchise, but man, it feels restrictive.
Most, if not all, of the missions involve pretty basic stuff we've done a thousand times in other GTA and open-world games: deliver this, assassinate that guy, chase this guy, etc. I get that they were trying to give the franchise a more grounded and realistic approach, but simply making a game darker and more serious doesn't automatically make it fun.
And as impressive as the Euphoria physics engine in this game is, I still think it's very overrated. In my opinion, it's not the make or break feature that some people make it out to be. I also absolutely hate the stiff driving in this game. I don't care how you try to defend it, it's just not for me.
Again, don't get me wrong, the game can still be a lot of fun. The story is great, the characters are amazing, the city is fun to explore, and the combat is enjoyable without auto aim. But honestly, I just had a lot more fun with GTA 5 and San Andreas.
It's also worth mentioning that GTA 4 lacks a lot of fun features that were present in San Andreas and later brought back in GTA 5, such as character and car customization.
Overall, the restrictive and repetitive gameplay, the fact that the first three hours are incredibly boring, and a realistic approach that comes at the expense of fun make it a weaker entry than GTA 5 and San Andreas in my eyes.
Even though it has objectively strong merits, such as impressive physics and a well written story, those things don't make up for the fact that it's simply not as fun to play.
At the end of the day, I love the game, but I can totally see why many people hated it when it came out, and why some even preferred Saints Row 2!