It's kind of hard to explain and will be long, so I'll set up the background first. I was trying to make a surreal ballet dancer in a suggestive pose. The reference image was Miss Kitty from the Great Mouse Detective. I used the same environment with the strip joint, the pole Disney refused to includes, and drunken sailors checking her out, drinking beer, and dropping money. Then the character woukd have exaggerated features and a gradient outfit with a flowing surreal texture the gives it a sense of motion. There was no nudity or really over revealing angle or outfit. It was just supposed to be a mouse ballet dancer with a referenced aesthetic. There was no actual sexualization intended (part of the surreal intent was to make the strip joint look dignified, hence the ballet shoes and emphasized elegance and flowing motion through exaggerated features). Unfortunately certian words are completely and totally blacklisted regardless of context or intent. Even clarifying said intent had no effect. The censorship is zero tolerance even if the image would potentially be really cool.
For reference this was the prompt:
*Generate an image based on this one where the dress is shiny, ornate, and sparkly with different gradients of blue adding a sense of motion. The top shoukd be darker than the frills on the legs. The fur is styled, shiny, and stereotypically beautiful, and the whole body shows. She should wear blue ballet shoes. Make her legs well defined with extremely cartoonishly exaggerated hips and chest. The gloves should be an elegant combination of shiny and semimatte leather. Make the face distinctly like a mouse, but elegant, anthropomorphic, and feminine. The ears should be natural looking with them facing somewhat downward. The nose and mouth should be proportional, with dark pink lipstick and vaguely sparkly gloss. Make the nose and muzzle slightly small and dainty. Make the eyes captivating and seductive. Her hair has a blue bow and fluff in front similar to the image.
The image should be set in a modern gentleman's club, like a high end dancing bar. There are male sailor mice surrounding the stage similarly dressed to the ones in the Great Mouse Detective bar scene. The sailor mice hold and drink steins of beer and are obviously tipsy. One extremely fat mouse that resembles Dawson but is much fatter and slightly shorter is standing almost out of frame preparing to climb onstage with her. The front of the stage has a rail and there is money sitting on and around the rail with tables of sailor mice sitting right up to it, one obviously fixated on her chest area.
Make it hyperrealistic, cinematic, and extremely elegant with sophisticated embellishments and volumetric light focusing on the dancer.*
Nothing indecent there by most human standards. Everything is covered and she is not even dressed like an actual stripper in my prompt.
Note: I did my best to cut out the several novels worth of repetitive "can I help you regenerate yada yada yada crap but it's GTP and it's still very wordy. Apologies in advance.
The first image is the reference of Miss Kitty. It's Disney; I assumed the source was automatically accepted all things considered.
The second image is a refusal to generate, then the blatant obvious lie. There are no underage people in the bar scene in The Great Mouse Detective, and the image I was going for was not intentionally sexualized. Mature, maybe. But this is an OLD movie. If not for Disney being Disney it would be in the internet archive. The GPT has no reason not to recognize its contents.
The third image makes a lot of generic assumptions and states that it blocks seductive eyes and mentions spinning on a pole in reference to the strip club setting.
At this point I asked some questions to figure out where exactly the line is drawn and how much critical analysis the GTP actually does, and if the f ilter I'd word only. It wouldn't say and kept repeating itself. Then it started asking me a bunch of irrelevant things. Finally Iit admits the filter is keyword only without context considered.
The fourth image is the GPT denying it lied and trying to justify it. Distinct and massive "I sorry yourself that way vibes," and a paraphrased "was that what you wanted me to say?" at the end.
The fifth pic is is me calling it directly and it still not acknowledging it. It said there are underage people in the referenced scene; there are absolutely are not. It uses the target audience of the movie as reference, even though the movie's target audience is not relevant. Then it gave me more "sorry you feel that way" crap.
At this point I was just done and refused to accept its answer. THEN it finally admitted it lied. I'm not convinced it was unintentional given the age and widely known nature of the reference material. Then it says there are better ways to express my ideas, like it was my fault it lied.
I started a seperate chat and asked similar questions to give it a running context. Then I pointed out wherethe lie was. It used a bunch of keyword only triggers that were really overblown in many ways. "Exaggerated sexual body porportions?" It's supposed to be surrealism. Context is not a factor.
The ninth image is pretty strange. It lies again claiming the characters referenced are "aged-up," implying my reference was of underage people that I artificially aged. Which is completely not true. The GPT ignores that part.
Number ten and the last one is it again admitting it lied. It didn't correct itself for context even after I pointed this out before. I get it's a Disney movie, but it's 50/50 a truly children's movie. It has a lot of violence, characters are literally executed (I guess it would be murder?), there's drinking, a drunken bar fight, sailors implied to talk like sailors, and a stripper. It is a pretty mature movie for children's entertainment. That said CONTEXT IS IRRELEVANT. The only thing the GPT sees is Disney = under 12 even if the characters depicted are obviously adults.
I guess the moral of the story here is that art isn't relevant to Chat GPT. I get that there is nuance that a computer won't necessarily recognize, that goes without saying. Throughout this conversation I've gotten the distinct impression the devs never intended gpt for artistic use. While the gpt itself is decided of emotion its answer snark sometimes imply the devs' feelings. "Let me hold your hand and go line by line and change every even remotely suggestive word even if it is used in a fictional and nonpronographic context. I also noticed how hard it is to get actual clarity on restrictions. I cut out where I paraphrased it 4 times before it would actually answer without repeating itself. Makes me wonder if the whole thing is just data mining and work monitering. But yeah. GPT can and does lie. I have proof it did twice.
OH and it thinks adult characters in kids' movies are also underage for some reason. No idea how or why kn that one. It seems like the character itself should be the focus, not other ancillary and social factors that don't influence the characters themselves.
TL;DR: Image 1: reference pic Image 2: the lie Image 3: it tries to justify the lie Image 4: explaination Image 5: GPT gets condescending Image 6: GPT doubles down Image 7: GTP admits it lied Image 8: more detail on censorship Image 9: it lies again Image 10: it admits it lied again