r/GMO • u/ajsdklf9df • Sep 28 '14
Every comment critical of GMOs I make on reddit is down-voted to hell.
So perhaps in this sub I can get educational replies in addition to the down-votes.
Here are my main problems with GMOs.
In the developed world the agricultural market is a train wreck of government interference. We over-produce food, we waste a lot, we have massive subsides, price supports and various marketing restrictions. Into this mess we add GMOs. They are in my opinion not in any way necessary for developed world consumers.
But they could lower prices! Sure. But not as much as reducing the government interference would. If your primary concern is lower food prices, start with the regulations and trade restrictions.
But they reduce pesticide use! They reduce some pesticide use, and increase the use of others. But the ones they increase could be better than alternatives! Sure. One worse alternative - Atrazine was banned in the EU years ago. And hopefully it will be banned in the US and Canada too eventually. Plus weeds tend to adapt to pesticides. But only if people use the GMOs and pesticides wrongly! True. But people are people. They will always screw up.
By GMOs are more profitable! Sure, they are good for agricultural producers. But in the developed world those are already hugely subsidized. Why would I want to help them even more? For a developed world consumer GMOs seem genuinely superfluous at best.
Organics use pesticides too! Sure, but I am only aware of two types of grandfathered organic pesticides. First: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotenone Luckily in the United States and Canada, all uses of rotenone except as a piscicide are being phased out. And second copper sulphates. But copper has very low toxicity. You'd have to consume a huge amount to have any problems. Source: http://npic.orst.edu/factsheets/cuso4gen.html
But GMOs can help to make things better! Maybe. Recent research indicates genetic engineering lags behind conventional breeding in efforts to create drought-resistant maize: http://www.nature.com/news/cross-bred-crops-get-fit-faster-1.15940 Beyond that, better is relative. The most common tomato in the US is know as bulletproof because it takes a lot of abuse without problems, thus it is easy to transport. For any for-profit company the main focus is profitability. That profitability results in better tasting, or better in any way foods, only if that is profitable. As "bulletproof" tomatoes show, taste is not always on the path to the most profitable type of food.
Norman Borlaug!!!
Norman Borlaug is great, and here is why:
Nothing he did involved GMO, it was just traditional breeding.
It was a public project, the resulting seeds were released for free for everyone to use.
It used pre-existing wheat varieties. He used a Japanese dwarf variety to get stems strong enough to not collapse under the weight of the extra grain.
What's different about GMO:
GMOs tend to be privately funded and owned, and seeds are licensed.
Mono culture. Where is the next special variety going to come from, if everyone around the world grows the same variety? From where could we quickly borrow a stronger stem from, or natural resistance to a new wheat rust?
To me Norman Borlaug is the best possible counter-argument for GMOs. And I have no idea why so many people use him to defend GMOs?
8. But GMO could help the developing world! Yes, they could help a little But the primary reason for hunger in the developing world is not lack of food, but lack of infrastructure. Source: http://www.wfp.org/hunger/causes Still, I am not against GMOs in places where they actual can help. Which is not in the developed world. I especially like this research: http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health/genetics/turbo-tobacco-faster-photosynthesis-17217730 Even if it still missing half the way bacteria photosynthesis works, it is a great start. And a 35-60% increase of crop production could make a major difference even without improvements in transportation.
9. But Golden Rice!!!!
The "Golden Rice is an effective source of vitamin A" paper: http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/89/6/1776.full.pdf Includes the following experimental design:
Golden Rice plants were grown hydroponically with heavy water (deuterium oxide) to generate deuterium-labeled [2H] b-carotene in the rice grains. Golden Rice servings of 65–98 g (130–200 g cooked rice) containing 0.99–1.53 mg b-carotene were fed to 5 healthy adult volunteers (3 women and 2 men) with 10 g butter.
I guess the butter was necessary since carotenes are hydrophobic, and there needs to be a sufficient amount of fat present in the diet for golden rice (or most other vitamin A supplements) to be able to alleviate vitamin A deficiency.
Sadly the people in the developing world who suffer from vitamin A deficiency, lack food, especially high caloric food like fatty foods. Thus Golden Rice does not seem like it could help much without more fat in the diet. But fat itself can contain vitamin A, butter has vitamin A. Golden Rice by itself seems insufficient to cure vitamin A deficiency. A varied diet containing foods rich in beta carotene such as sweet potato, leafy green vegetables and fruits could prove just as effective.
The bottom line is that GMOs might be of some help in the developing world, but in the developed world they are at best utterly useless to consumers.
Thoughts?