r/GIDLE • • Jun 27 '24

Discussion Please stop with the misconception of G-IDLE Minnie being Thai royalty or having royal blood

Thumbnail self.kpoprants
2 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Aug 29 '22

Discussion Why is Shuhua the first visual of (G)-Idle but not Miyeon?

0 Upvotes

(No hate to both of them, I'm just curious)

Miyeon and Yuqi fit Korean beauty standards more than Shuhua but Shuhua is the one who first got the visual position. To get the visual position, you need to fit the Korean beauty standards.


r/GIDLE • • Aug 16 '20

Discussion Cube really need to boost G-idle management team, producers, song writers as well as creative productions

0 Upvotes

Even though we all admire the fact that they do it all on their own their talent which is very musically inclined if they are provided all these since how will they be able to compete with people who have amazing teams. Take for example BTS they take part in all the stuff but also leave some of it for their teams and this is what makes them the best management + talent. If this doesn't happen I don't see how G-idle will blow up with so many antis already.

Their talent will be wasted

I am not questioning the girls talent but I am saying that cube should invest more on them.


r/GIDLE • • Jun 18 '22

Discussion Am I the only one that was slightly disappointed with the setlist at the concert?

0 Upvotes

Now don’t get me wrong, I loved the stages and loved all the work the girls put into the concert but after looking at the setlist I was confused.

First off I wished they had not performed Pop/stars, i feel like we have gotten enough stages of that song and we could have gotten a performance of a different bside instead

Second off I wish they had performed Dahlia and Escape instead of Moon and Already, I feel like Escape tells such a nice story and really resonates with idle themselves and neverlands, and then for Dahlia I just personally like it more than Moon

And I wish Blow Your Mind was replaced by Put It Straight, i feel like it fits performances more as they can either go really theatrical or go heavy on the ballad and go raw with the vocals

Third of all what happened to the solo stages, 3 members have already released solos yet none of them got to perform atleast on of their songs?

But yeah overall I did love majority of the concert but these are just some thoughts I had after seeing the setlist

Update: It seems like for Day 2 they performed slightly different songs so I guess they planned on performing different bsides for different dates


r/GIDLE • • 16d ago

Discussion As much as I love I-dle I don't like that their lastest albums are a remix of their other album names

0 Upvotes

I liked We are because I thought it was very fitting for the first EP name after their rebrand but I was really disappointed when I found out that We made was the name for the next one even though it's absolutely amazing I don't really like that it doesn't have its own original name. Apparently the next mini album will be called We Trust because they changed their YouTube and music streaming platform banner to one of the I Trust promo images which kind of disapoints me because I want original names guys 😭💔


r/GIDLE • • Feb 02 '20

Discussion Does (G)I-DLE use autotune?

0 Upvotes

Pls can anyone answer this question because I have no idea what's the difference with autotune and with no autotune.


r/GIDLE • • May 05 '24

Discussion K-neverland After years of silence, they opened their mouths and it smelled like sh**t

66 Upvotes

I wasn’t going to talk about the drama because it’s mentally ill people talking, but after Miyeon and Minnie went live, (G)I-DLE definitely saw the complaint.

If you don’t know, after (G)I-DLE’s 6th anniversary, some K-neverlands decided to go on Twitter and talk about how little (G)I-DLE communicates with the fans, undermining the fact that (G)I-DLE is not like other groups. (G)I-DLE is self-producing and has the pressure to make a number one song every time they come back, but apparently, to some fans, it doesn’t matter as much as the feeling they have of a parasocial relationship and going to Bubble to talk with them.

And some complaints turn into hate comments that affect the group, and news media picks them up saying (G)I-DLE is ungrateful. Some of them are mad about Soyeon because she talked about her exes and doesn’t do much in i-talk. Are you actually a fan of Soyeon? Because that’s the Soyeon from the beginning she’s always have been straight forward about her relationship,and for i-talk she’s working 24/7. Of course, she doesn’t have the energy for i-talk. She literally stayed in the hotel in Vietnam to work on her new song instead of going out with the girls and having fun.

I’m fed up with K-neverlands. Many times when they were needed, they stayed silent. I still don’t forget when they immediately left Soojin to defend herself alone. So most of the defending came from international fans. I think if the international fans follow suit of the Korean fans, Soojin wouldn’t have come back. But now they’ve turned into antis because the busiest group decided to use the little time they have to rest instead of feeding the parasocial relationship.


r/GIDLE • • Dec 31 '19

Discussion I’m tired of miyeon not getting enough attention

4 Upvotes

ok i know that soyeon is extremely talented writing all the songs for the group and soojin is a very charismatic dancer and minnie is a great performer and yuqi is cute and friendly and variety show material but miyeon and shuhua, miyeon especially, seriously deserves a chance to shine. i’m tired of seeing her dancing behind the other members and not getting enough screen time and not getting to talk during variety shows etc. now i know miyeon is not the best dancer, or the most charismatic one among them, but her VISUALS man, as a reveluv who just got into g-idle i am shocked that someone with the visuals as great as irene’s never got the chance to stand in the center, in fact she’s always at the far end. i’m shocked again to find out her and shuhua are actually the least popular ones when they were the ones that caught my attention when i first fell in love with g-idle. cube should really be making use of her visuals by letting her star in cf or something cuz it’s such a waste to let her beauty be undiscovered. visuals aside, her voice is just as beautiful. her feminine voice balances out the husky and masculine voices of the most popular members but her vocals never got shown off. i’m so sad that she’s so underrated guys :(


r/GIDLE • • May 01 '20

Discussion T&J: Appropriate behavior against an "Unnie"?

4 Upvotes

Recently I've started to see some videos of Shuhua interactions with the other members and I kept thinking if the way she says or does something would be considered rude in korean culture.

For example, she's always pushing away Miyeon(her unnie) whenever she tries to hug or kiss her(which I don't know why she keeps doing this as Shuhua seems kind of irritated by that).Considering that she seems to have no problem of being really loud or blunt(the most savage maknae I've ever seen) it's weird to see the other members(or at least the korean ones)accept this kind of behavior.

No, this is not a hate post, I am just really curious.


r/GIDLE • • Jul 01 '22

Discussion I don't really think that Soyeon and other members will leave Cube and if they do they won't be a group anymore. They will probably disband.

6 Upvotes

Not only would they need to get the rights to their music from Cube (which I don't think they would get), but they would also need to change their name. I also don't think that Soojin could join the group again in another company, because of her scandal. Companies wouldn't want to take a risk. I could imagine Soyeon under PNATION, but I can't say the same thing about the rest of the group. I think Minnie could go solo in Korea and also promote in Thailand. Yuqi will probably promote mainly in China. I think Miyeon will go solo. I don't know about Shuhua. Soyeon will probably make songs for another artists. She also said that she wants to have family in her 30s. In 2025 she will be 28/29. I could imagine her working more as composer than a soloist or a member of group.

In Dazed Korea she responded Q: This year you are 26. You first appeared on TV at the age of 19, and rose to the position of a judge after 6 years. What will you be like 6 years later.
A: 6 years later, I want to achieve so much that I have nothing more I want to achieve. After that if I have a chance, I want to be in charge of producing for junior singers.

Even though they said they want to be together forever I wonder how long will the group last

What do you guys think?


r/GIDLE • • Aug 04 '20

Discussion Does anyone else feel like Dumdi Dumdi was a miss?

7 Upvotes

I went into this song fully expecting to love it as much as I've loved the rest of their discography but I left feeling disappointed and I can't pinpoint why.

Maybe it'll grow on me later, idk.


r/GIDLE • • Jun 19 '20

Discussion How come Cube doesn't help make more songs?

0 Upvotes

If it was a normal group Companies would have to find songs for their idol groups..

Isn't cube obligated to also give Idle some songs and pay for them? they would have more songs on their album if they didn't solely rely on Idle to make songs.. which is unfair..

Did cube just completely abandon that part of being a company or what.. they should have a list of songs for idle to pick out from or test out if they want it also.. which takes some pressure off the group ...


r/GIDLE • • Feb 17 '24

Discussion Why are their newer title tracks more popular than their older ones?

29 Upvotes

All besides Super Lady, which is apparently one of their most hated songs thus far. Not a hate post, they are definitely one of my favorite groups and I’m not disappointed with any comebacks, it’s just an honest question.

Actually though, why was the old stuff less successful even though it sounds so much more (G)I-DLE-ey? It’s so much more fitting to them and more inspired. Now it sounds less unique and it confuses me, do people like the more mainstream-style music they’re putting out even though it’s not a great fit on them (not a bad fit, but there are other concepts that they do much much better)?

Queencard took off even though Oh my god is stronger and deeper, has about ten times the quality, and was a different (in a good way) style that you wouldn’t see with most girl groups and it set them apart. I just don’t get it. I mean yeah you could go for Queencard’s lyricism but I mean in the delivery, the emotion, the stylistic elements of the song that make them amazing and different from others. So what makes people like the new stuff more?


r/GIDLE • • Aug 06 '20

Fan Content hi! im just starting but please support me! thanks!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Aug 17 '23

Discussion If you were to give one piece of advice to your bias to improve their performance, what would it be?

5 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • May 18 '23

Discussion 230517 (G)I-DLE I feel - Album Review

6 Upvotes

Kpop girl group (G)I-DLE is known for many things, one of which being that member Soyeon, pictured in the center above, writes the majority of their songs independently, something not often seen in the world of kpop. This mini album, the 6th in the series of “I _” ones, was also produced by Soyeon. All of the members are bringing a fun girly concept to this comeback, so I’m excited to see how this change is reflected in the music. In the past, I’ve only enjoyed I Trust, so I’m hoping I can find more I enjoy in this comeback.

I’ll listen to each song 3 times and rate them afterward. Each song will be rated on a scale of 1-10 with 5 being completely neutral, 1 being my least favorite song, and 10 being the best songs ever. Please take my rating with a grain of salt, my goal is to be honest, no hate :)

Queencard - 5.5

I love the beat in this song, the production of these summer specials have been incredible so far. The Minnie intro of verse 1 is absolutely golden, I love her husky tone here. There is a high amount of excitement and energy despite the fairly soft sound of the track. Unfortunately though, this track goes downhill the longer the tape rolls. The chorus is somewhat disappointing, and the lyrics are just…cringe. I think this song has a lot of potential in verse 1, but after that the chord progression and instrumentals become boring as they don’t really change in any meaningful way. That said, the song keeps its fun bounce throughout, and verse 1 is one of my favorite verse 1s in kpop. As usual for (G)I-DLE, the vocals sound great, particularly Minnie and Miyeon.

Allergy - 5

(G)I-DLE has really been going for a sort of 2000s teen pop vibe lately. I don’t like or dislike that, but it is certainly noticeable. This song feels like a classic boy band song from the 2000s. I don’t really love this style, but I think this track pulls it off fairly well, and no part of it feels forced or awkward. That said, it may pull off the style a little too well. You could replace the vocals with any other group, and it would fit right in. I think that the message of this song is very thoughtful and nice, and actually reminds me of a lot of the themes from 2000s music, unsurprisingly.

Lucid - 8

This feels more like old (G)I-DLE, or at least pre-Nxde. It feels almost creepy. The verses are dry and gritty, and when the heavy bass in the pre-chorus kicks in it feels nothing less than magical. Minnie is the queen of (G)I-DLE this comeback, according to me. Her voice is so smooth and addictive. The slowed part before the chorus is really unique and cool, especially as it launches into a simultaneously dark and fun chorus. This song actually reminds me a lot of Tainted Love, a massive throwback! They both share the same blend of styles. I really like this song!

All Night - 6

Wow, the first few seconds of piano here are beautiful and ominous. The beat kicks in in a massive switch-up to another dark and fun verse. The use of guitars and electric bass continues in this song, continually building throughout the track. The two-chord progression in the chorus feels pretty repetitive, though the bass and guitars make it more entertaining. It feels like a b-side if I’m being honest, and not a power b-side like others on this comeback. I don’t particularly dislike anything, I just don’t find it to be that interesting.

Paradise - 8

Holy intro bass! I swear, every intro is so good these days. The verses make this feel like a Basic Ballad™, but the chorus pushes it into power ballad land. The combination of the bass, synth, and percussion create a beautiful bed for the soft vocals to lie on, if that analogy makes any sense. The percussion and harmonic chords in the verses are also unique and tastefully placed. It really feels like CHVRCHES to me! I would recommend CHVRCHES to basically any kpop girl-group fan, particularly LOONA and (G)I-DLE fans. Honestly this is the first Soyeon rap since I Trust that I’ve enjoyed. This is how a cheesy ballad should be done, and I mean that in the best way.

Peter Pan - 4

The crowd noise, claps, and acoustic guitar further cement this mini-album’s summer vibe. This song feels like an end credit scene, or something someone would play over a campfire. Similar to Allergy, I don’t like this style, but I think (G)I-DLE pulls it off decently well. I don’t think it’s quite as solid of a track as Allergy, but nonetheless it fulfills its role as a carefree teen movie end song. It’s just nothing impressive from them, and I don’t love it personally. Certainly a different way of ending a kpop album than I’m used to seeing.

Final Thoughts

(G)I-DLE has cultivated an experience with this mini-album. Despite my opinions on any of the songs individually, everything is cohesive in a soundtrack-like way. Summer nights, parties, and 2000s teen movies. As I said previously, I don’t love much new (G)I-DLE, so I didn’t enjoy the style of some of these songs. This has been very challenging to review because so many of the songs are quality but not to my taste. Lucid and Paradise, however, I found to be very good! I would have to say that overall this album continues the streak of great spring/summer specials this year. I give this album an overall score of 6, with my favorite song being Paradise, just barely over Lucid. Thank you for reading, let me know what your thoughts are on any of this!

- Maya


r/GIDLE • • Jul 21 '19

Discussion Anyone else ready for them to change up their hair?

0 Upvotes

Straight male perspective here. I feel like their stylists went with the exact opposite of what looks good on half of them for this comeback. Not feeling Minnie with bangs or Soyeon with short hair *at all.*

Their Fake Love styling was amazing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaSlTs6ZahY

Minnie with no bangs, Soyeon with long hair, Yuqi and Miyeon with bangs. Major heart eyes emojis.


r/GIDLE • • Jul 22 '22

Fan Content I made a Yuqi/Shuhua combo on Artbreeder. Came out really well IMO

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Apr 25 '24

Fan Content I made NXDE metal

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Apr 13 '20

Video (G)I-DLE - OH MY GOD (MALE COVER) by Johnny

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Jan 11 '21

Discussion i did not love the album

0 Upvotes

its not that i dislike it, its just that i didnt love it.

first off i would like to say that im a pretty big fan of the group, bought the earlier albums, and made the photoshoped version of "i burn" in the style of "i am" and "i made" in this sub

i think the sad vibes direction was not that great of a choice, we heard that on "i trust"

maybe following the dumdi dumdi style would have fit better

hwaa and dahlia were good i guess

the video clip was also not that good, soyeon was shinning tho

idk the album felt bland


r/GIDLE • • Mar 19 '22

Fan Content 220319 Made a Mixed Mashup between Tomboy and Itzy's Wannabe

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • May 26 '18

Anybody think that this performance was throwing shade because Miyeon was wearing all Black and Pink? ☕️☕️

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/GIDLE • • Jan 04 '21

Fan Content Soyeon fanart

12 Upvotes