r/FruitTree • • Aug 09 '26

Fruiting potato plants..?

So I’ve been growing potatoes this year at our allotment, but a couple of the plants have started to fruit above the soil it seems? They look and smell like tomatoes.. but are growing on my potato plants!

Anyone have any idea of what these are or why it’s happening? Would love to find out more about these.

968 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

21

u/RandomBoxOfCables Aug 10 '26

So everyone already said don’t eat the berries but on another note…. I dig the Casio

10

u/RE3DOR Aug 10 '26

Appreciating the gardening pun there, purposeful or not 🤣 can’t beat a Casio!

57

u/Certain_Connection54 Aug 10 '26

If you grow any of the seeds they will be a whole new variety you can name after you're self.... I tried this a few years ago

17

u/Lenore_Clark_Tarot Aug 10 '26

Yes! OP, there are actually seed projects going where people are deliberately trying to save potato seed to grow new varieties and potentially work on adaptations to new environments. The seeds would be pretty sought after by people in the landrace gardening communities, for example. If you feel so inclined you could let the fruit go and save the seed to send along to some plant breeders.

1

u/RE3DOR Aug 10 '26

That’s so interesting! I’ll definitely save them for seed then!! How do you suggest find local plant breeders ?

2

u/Lenore_Clark_Tarot Aug 10 '26

I know that you can share seed with the folks at this website: https://goingtoseed.org

1

u/RE3DOR Aug 10 '26

Thankyou! I’ll take a look!!

3

u/PoorOnagraphy Aug 10 '26

Was the new variety noticeably different?

7

u/Slayde4 Aug 10 '26

Not OP but I'm in my second year of growing true potato seed. (It takes 2 years to get normal sized harvests). Sometimes the potatoes look the same as the parent (often caused by self-pollination), sometimes they look very different. But there is a trend toward differentness because potatoes aren't bred to be consistent from seed, and they have 4 sets of chromosomes. This means there are more chances for recessive genes to hide in the genome and reappear in a generation. e.g. there could be three gold, red, or white skin alleles in a blue skinned potato that you don't see until you plant the seeds (blue is more or less dominant to all other colors)

3

u/Certain_Connection54 Aug 10 '26

I had red and white growing the year I got fruit, the seeds that produced potatoes the next year were definitely a combination of the two parent varieties

66

u/GenericMelon Aug 09 '26

Potatoes and tomatoes are both solanaceae. These are the berries that potato plants produce if you let them get this far (typically, you want to pinch off the flowers after they're spent). Don't eat these, as they are toxic.

33

u/Nothing_F4ce Aug 10 '26

You can actually graft tomatoes into potato plants.

21

u/Mimosa_13 Aug 10 '26

I had one of these grafted plants one year. It was called ketchup&fries. After the tomatoes were done, a few weeks later it was harvest potatoes time.

2

u/Lopsided-Case1294 Aug 10 '26

Do they look different enough you don’t harvest potato berries thinking they’re tomatoes?

1

u/Mimosa_13 Aug 10 '26

I don't remember ever seeing these potato berries on my plant.

1

u/Few-Secretary-7280 Aug 11 '26

it should never have any potato berries

1

u/Lopsided-Case1294 Aug 10 '26

Do they look different enough you don’t harvest potato berries thinking they’re tomatoes?

1

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

Potato berries never ripen to red/orange/yellow.

9

u/GenericMelon Aug 10 '26

Ha that's crazy. Just for fun or is there a practical reason?

21

u/Hortusana Aug 10 '26

Saves space. 2 for 1 crop. I think novelty and mad scientist vibes too.

4

u/GenericMelon Aug 10 '26

Oh wow, yeah, that makes total sense.

4

u/nilsmm Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26

They actually sell them as plants, look up 'pomato'.

8

u/Ralfarius Aug 10 '26

Not to be confused with tomacco

7

u/Legitimate_Concern_5 Aug 10 '26

Hmmmm tobacco is also solanaceae, can we graft a single potato/tomato/tobacco plant? That’s the real question.

4

u/One_Student9606 Aug 10 '26

You say pomato, I say tomacco

2

u/slim6_4 Aug 10 '26

They taste like grandma

1

u/f0xbunny Aug 10 '26

Tomato and tobacco?

1

u/Woodpusherpro Aug 10 '26

Simpsons episode.

1

u/Subjugatealllife Aug 11 '26

It’s largely a novelty though, as you get lower yield of both since the energy has to be used between the two. Only makes sense if you are very space constrained.

9

u/Happy_Scrotum Aug 10 '26

Just for fun.

Some youtuber made a video a while ago, he got half the yield of both compared whith the same non grafted tomato and potato plants.

9

u/Glad-Barracuda2243 Aug 10 '26

Wait, what?!!! Off to research this new rabbit hole!!!

1

u/longcreepyhug Aug 10 '26

Even more than being in the same family. They are actually in the same genus.

1

u/Googulator Aug 11 '26

More than that even. The modern potato is a natural cross between the tomato and a wild potato species 'Solanum etuberosum'.

35

u/surlyburlygirl Aug 09 '26

That is potato fruit and they show up after some rather pretty flowers. They are toxic to eat, and some say they should be pinched off to redirect energy back to your potatoes.

5

u/mitolit Aug 10 '26

I live in Idaho. Potato farmers do not spend their days worrying about the flowers on their crops…

13

u/forkonce Aug 10 '26

What do they spend their days worrying about?

12

u/ohiobluetipmatches Aug 10 '26

Martial Arts, Dancing and Elections.

3

u/Crazy_Ad_91 Aug 10 '26

Coming up with new ways to eat them

34

u/longcreepyhug Aug 10 '26

Potatoes and tomatoes are in the same genus. That's why their fruit looks very similar. However the potato fruit is very poisonous.

However, it does contain seeds that have genetic material that is wildly different from the parent plant. So if you plant the seeds, each one will be a completely new type of potato. Most will not be good, but some might be great!

7

u/bluething79 Aug 10 '26

Just like apples!!

4

u/Unusualshrub003 Aug 10 '26

And avocados, right?

3

u/Paramaniacc Aug 10 '26

This is by far the coolest fact I have learnt this year!

When you say a new type of potato, are you on about from the same family or like completely brand new?

1

u/longcreepyhug Aug 10 '26

Quite often they won't resemble the parent potato very much at all.

23

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Don't eat them you'll die

1

u/ChristinaBeck2649 Aug 10 '26

That’s deadly

45

u/Low-Crow5719 Aug 10 '26

Potatoes will bolt and fruit if they like the conditions. Don't eat the fruit.

Experimenting with the seeds is possible but may not be a good idea. Potatoes are selectively bred for low alkaloid content, potatoes from seed will not come true to type, and they may turn out toxic. Without a lab facility on hand, I can't recommend it.

13

u/Slayde4 Aug 10 '26

 potatoes from seed will not come true to type, and they may turn out toxic

This is very unlikely in regular potatoes. And, even so, the toxic compounds in potatoes have a bitter taste, or in my case, burn my mouth and throat. So it's not like you wouldn't know if you paid attention.

18

u/DJHickman Aug 10 '26

Topatoshade

18

u/FunNectarine6906 Aug 10 '26

1 it's a highly poisonous so don't eat.

2 this is how you make new varieties of potatoes. Start them like you would a tomato plant.

They are also great to keep with emergency seats. If tshtf, and you have to eat all your potatoes. These potato seeds can be planted to grow new potatoes.

1

u/No-Self8780 Aug 13 '26

Yes! OP, In the Andes, where potatoes as a land race first originated, there’s a huge degree of diversity among potatoes because they used the seeds, which is a type of sexual reproduction that recombines the genes of both parents. The way we generally reproduce potatoes from pieces of the tuber is asexual reproduction, and produces plants that are clones of the parent plant.

16

u/BootyGarb Aug 10 '26

Normal. Potatoes have berries, we don’t eat them. They’re used in breeding plants tho!

15

u/kunino_sagiri Aug 10 '26

To add to what other people have said, some varieties of potato are a lot more likely to produce fruit than others.

Some varieties rarely even flower. Others flower well but rarely pollinate in any great number. And some produce masses of fruit. You were probably growing the former varieties before now, so never saw fruit.

I grow Vitolette, a purple variety, every year. They always produce loads of fairly large (inch across) fruit.

15

u/heyseed88 Aug 10 '26

Dad said if there's berries that means lots of potatoes. He was a potato farmer.

3

u/Odd_Bodybuilder5456 Aug 10 '26

strange i was always told to pick the flowers off for more potatoes so they focus the energy into the roots to try again with flowers next season

14

u/Ramsescat1968 Aug 10 '26

Pa called them potato berries. Really poisonous.

12

u/portabuddy2 Aug 10 '26

I tried a bit of one so you don't have to. Tastes like a nightshade. The ripe ones are not super bitter. Sates more like a cherry tomato with a slightly fruity quality. Shaded by the flavor of death.

Don't eat these.

2

u/theholyirishman Aug 10 '26

Wow, thanks for coming back from the grave to share that

1

u/portabuddy2 Aug 10 '26

Most items you can try but spit out. You can pretty much taste if it's poison or not. Just don't swallow and rinse your mouth.

Or course it's not recommended to even try. Esp with things like mushrooms. But fruits are usually not too bad. Just make sure not to eat any seeds esp.

Yes their are outlyers that are truly bad for you.

1

u/dadofadisaster Aug 10 '26

Luckily for mushrooms there are very few that are completely deadly like the death angel. Most will just make you regret being adventurous like the green sickener. Some cultures ferment mildly poisonous mushrooms like milky caps to make them edible after a year or two but that’s mostly in the balkans

1

u/portabuddy2 Aug 10 '26

Or blanche and wash. Or soak with various liquids. Yes. True.

But same with acorns. Other than one variety you have to leach out the tannins. Eating them as is would harm you pretty badly.

1

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

Domesticated potatoes have been bred to have minimal solanine for a very long time. The fruit aren't edible, but they also aren't deadly poisonous as some people here seem to think.

12

u/Ok-Artichoke6703 Aug 10 '26

I learned recently that yes, potatoes do grow fruit, what we eat are the tubers not the fruit. The berries are very toxic, seeing that they are part of the nightshade family, but unlike peppers, tomatoes, and eggplants the fruit is not for consumption. Nightshades are very interesting in that they can give us our staple food crops as well as make us sick or kill us if we eat the wrong type

3

u/Poopinabag Aug 10 '26

Like one of the scariest nightshades: Datura.

1

u/Left-Pineapple-6084 Aug 10 '26

lol not Brugmansia? Henbane? Mandrake?

23

u/GlackBang Aug 10 '26

DO NOT EAT THESE!!! Highly poisonous / toxic

11

u/cowbirdmilk Aug 10 '26

Don’t eat the potato berries

10

u/GeneralQuailly Aug 10 '26

That is not edible man…..

7

u/ZafakD Aug 10 '26

The cultivariable website might be of interest to you.  Lots of information about growing potatoes from seeds harvested from potato fruits.

6

u/yozoms Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26

Those are true potato seeds. They will grow a random type of potato. Some are tiny and not worth the effort. Or you may grow an entirely new type of edible and neat potato. Or just a type that already exists. If you have the space and time/patience. It could be a fun experiment.

Edit: autocorrect wanted the first spelling of potato to be plural for some reason.

2

u/kaptaincorn Aug 11 '26

Neat so some sort of potato wheel of fortune?

2

u/yozoms Aug 11 '26

Yeah essentially. The seeds do not grow true to type. So the genetics are different for each seed. It is possible to create a new type of potato. You could technically name a variety and grow them out to have seed potatoes after a couple plantings from the original crop.

2

u/Mr_McGuy Aug 11 '26

This is interesting. Is it possible to get a poisonous variety of potato from your potato berries?

2

u/vanguardJesse Aug 11 '26

you just can't let the potatoes see the sun, when they take in sunlight they become unsafe

2

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

That has happened before. Commercial potato breeders now lab test their plants to ensure low solanine.

As a home gardener, you can just taste some of the spuds from each seed-grown plant. If they don't taste good, discard that plant.

The worst I've had was one that tasted if fresh cut green grass. In retrospect, I should have kept that variety around for its prank value.

6

u/Kitchen-College4176 Aug 10 '26

Same thing happened to me a year ago. Tossed some "bad" potatoes onto the raised bed, they grew and then flowered and then made these potato berries. Mine were smaller. Took a picture of them and used Google photo search and it immediately brought up potato berries. DO NOT EAT!

6

u/historygal75 Aug 11 '26

Tomatoes birthed potatoes so says their genes awesome isn’t it

10

u/TallOrange Aug 09 '26

They are potato fruits but not for eating. You could experiment and try growing new potatoes from those seeds, and someone usually has a good potato seed site recommendation since they’re pretty unusual to do.

5

u/Technician-timer Aug 10 '26

If plucked before they get that big you'll get more tators instead

4

u/PointyHatJoe Aug 10 '26

Are the surprise potato's grown from the potato Berry seeds always safe to eat? Or should you try with caution?

8

u/FunNectarine6906 Aug 10 '26

The potato fruit is poison, but the potatoes that it will grow are safe .

1

u/PointyHatJoe Aug 10 '26

Ok. This is what I was wondering, its sounds like it could be an interesting experiment but I would hate too poison anybody.

1

u/name__0 Aug 11 '26

Some varieties of heirloom potatoes are poisonous to eat the root with out special prep. It's unlikely if both parents were safe to eat, but there is always a chance something could revert in a propagated potato. I would eat the first bite gingerly and wait a while.

While regular store-bought potatoes are safe, they naturally produce a toxic chemical called solanine (a glycoalkaloid). Eating potatoes with high solanine levels can make you very sick. Solanine causes a sharp, bitter taste.Symptoms are PoisoningNausea and vomitingStomach cramps and diarrheaHeadaches and confusion.

1

u/miserablenovel Aug 11 '26

Isn't the solanine green? Do you know if it is possible for a potato to grow dangerous levels and not be green?

1

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

Solanine isn't green. The green color is chlorophyll. A spud being green is a marker fir light exposure, which also can induce Solanine production.

2

u/PointyHatJoe Aug 11 '26

Ok. So this is sounding like common sense. Don't eat them raw, don't eat them if they are green, don't keep eating them if they taste like poison.

I would apply these rules to any potato anyway, so I should be ok

2

u/dadydaycare Aug 10 '26

Usually, the berries are no bueno.

1

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

The toxin in potatoes is called solanine, which most people find distasteful. If your seed-grown potatoes don't taste good, stop eating them.

4

u/Jumpy_Insurance_581 Aug 11 '26

DO NOT EAT IT IT'S MORE LIKELY POISONOUS THAN NOT

4

u/doanotherextraction Aug 13 '26

Don’t eat the “tomatoes” off the potato plant and also don’t eat the “potatoes” from a tomato plant!!

3

u/Opheliattack Aug 10 '26

Ours did the same i had to double check our patch to check if a tomatoe didn't sneak it smell the same to me!

3

u/Left-Pineapple-6084 Aug 10 '26

Potatoes from seed are always fascinating!

3

u/Ceeeceeeceee Aug 11 '26

I wish someone would tell me if you can eat them, though /s

2

u/Significant_Win_216 Aug 11 '26

You cant sadly, they contain solanine which is also found in deadly night shades…

1

u/Ceeeceeeceee Aug 11 '26

I know lol, the /s stands for sarcasm because it’s in every comment

1

u/Significant_Win_216 Aug 12 '26

Dang mb i didn’t know that💔

1

u/thebiologistisn Aug 11 '26

The toxin in deadly nightshade (Atropa beladona) is atropine, which is far more active in the heart than solanine.

3

u/Savings-Base-1908 Aug 11 '26

It’s because potatoes are in the nightshade family alongside tomatoes. Don’t eat those, but you can graft a tomato onto a potato and then eat the tomatoes 🙂

2

u/ag2575 Aug 11 '26

Whaaaat

2

u/Distinct_Ride_6199 Aug 11 '26

‘‘tis true.

1

u/w8_wuht Aug 11 '26

Can confirm. Very true, but your yield for both will be a good bit less from what I understand.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SmallTitBigClit Aug 13 '26

It's technically possible, just practically not efficient. If it were, every single farm out there would be planting with to get twice the yeild.

3

u/TheLowestHungarian Aug 11 '26

Potato, tomatNO

2

u/Ill-Driver2645 Aug 13 '26

Underrated comment!

3

u/clownfacedbozo Aug 12 '26 • Bravo

Tomacco!

3

u/Just-another-weapon Aug 12 '26

Tastes like burning

2

u/1Negative_Person Aug 12 '26

No, it tastes like grandma.

2

u/clownfacedbozo Aug 12 '26

Here, gimme one of those. Ugh, it does taste like grandma!

2

u/OceanStateRI401 Aug 13 '26

Hahaha I was only here for this comment.

3

u/TheThreeNippledJerry Aug 12 '26

Do NOT eat them, they are toxic, even if cooked. Idk why there is a debate here, I've grown potatoes for YEARS and have always known they're no good.

3

u/blurfgh Aug 12 '26

Topato :)

3

u/vendetta4200 Aug 12 '26 • This

You can’t eat the top fruits of a potato plant. They are poisonous and contain high levels of a compound called solanine, which can cause severe illness, including severe stomach cramps, headache, and diarrhea. Jeez, why is this not common knowledge?

2

u/hehedud9927 Aug 13 '26

I've been eating them for years I had no idea they make you sick

2

u/thebiologistisn Aug 13 '26 edited Aug 13 '26

How have you gotten past the taste of bitterness and death?

2

u/VDechS Aug 13 '26 • This Bravo

Everybody who tries them dies, so there is no one left to tell the story.

3

u/AstronomerNo912 Aug 13 '26

I can smell the tomato leaves from here

3

u/Substantial_Win_1866 Aug 13 '26

I believe the saying is Potato, Tomato.

... or was it....

1

u/Dear-Adversary Aug 28 '26

Ur hilarious 😆

6

u/LvBorzoi Aug 10 '26

I would say some volunteer tomato seeds sprouted. Probably in your compost or a rotten tomato from a neighboring plot had seeds come up.

6

u/Michaelalayla Aug 10 '26

It is a potato plant. Potatoes, as member of the nightshade family, grow berries (pictured in OP's post) full of seeds that look like little tomatoes. They are never edible, but if allowed to mature you can plant them and grow potatoes from the seeds. They will not be like the tubers of the mother plant, as potatoes don't come true to seed; they might be bitter or have a poor texture, but sometimes delicious new varieties result. 

4

u/Royal_Cryptographer7 Aug 10 '26

Those aren't tomato leaves. I wouldn't eat these unless I knew 200% what the plant was. Tomatoes and potatoes are both nightshades and can be mistaken for other very toxic members of that family.

1

u/carlitospig Aug 10 '26

Some sort of nightshade?

Edit: oops, hit submit too soon. They look like black nightshade but with a messier truss.

1

u/Michaelalayla Aug 10 '26

They're potato that has fruited.

So, yes, nightshade.

2

u/sumosam121 Aug 11 '26

I’ve never seen this before. This is so cool

2

u/generalAbaddon Aug 12 '26

Tomatos & potato are technically members of the nightshade family so it is possible to somehow graft/grow a tomato & potato together

2

u/Turd_bird420 Aug 13 '26

They did it in sandrock anyone can do it

2

u/ohhhtartarsauce Aug 13 '26

Ketchup and fries plant.

2

u/yumeryuu Aug 12 '26

Potato is a member is the Nightshade family.

Do not eat the fruit.

3

u/catastropheelingood Aug 12 '26

Lots of nightshades have edible fruits. Like tomatoes, eggplants, goldenberries, etc. You can’t just say that it’s a nightshade without further explanation and justification. You could say it’s a nightshade that wasn’t selectively bred for delectable fruits and to be wary.

2

u/enormous_schnozz Aug 13 '26

Yes they can. They did.

2

u/Mitologist Aug 12 '26

Yes. And why wouldn't they?

2

u/Ginny-Sacks-Mole Aug 12 '26

Nightshade tripping. No fun.

2

u/neo_nmik Aug 14 '26

The potato plant does this in drought conditions incase it can’t grow actual potatoes. They’re not edible, as you’ve seen from the comments, but you CAN get potato seeds from them… 

1

u/YOLOBIGSKY Aug 11 '26

Not potatoes

1

u/Plasterofmuppets Aug 11 '26

Why not?  Potatoes are tomato relatives but their fruit aren’t safe to eat.

1

u/MossyMinnows Aug 11 '26

Most night shades aren’t safe to eat or have parts that aren’t safe to eat. Like tomatoes and potatoes, which are safe to eat but have not safe parts and potentially poisonous unripe parts.

1

u/LeadingScheduler Aug 26 '26

Love potatoes they grow on the tree.

1

u/Prudent-Twofacts Aug 30 '26

Cherry tomatoes…?

30

u/Crazyblazy395 Aug 10 '26

Yup. Those will kill you. 

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Anxious-Drive9859 Aug 12 '26

This is not the same. Don't eat potato fruits. They will not agree with you. 

2

u/LunaTehNox Aug 12 '26

I wish I could downvote this 10 times. This comment is entirely incorrect. OP DO NOT EAT

2

u/Signal-Struggle-1069 Aug 13 '26

No this is a potato fruit it will make you very very ill and may cause death

2

u/Wild_Light9358 Aug 13 '26

Bro delete this

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26

[deleted]

2

u/shadowdog21 Aug 12 '26

Tomatoes are nightshade too.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/moist__owlet Aug 21 '26

I've grown potatoes several times in two very different climates and have never had this happen!