r/FromsoftGames • • Jul 27 '22

OPINION I hated Elden Ring, but in trying to find something to love I accidentally platinumed it

Thumbnail
vg247.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Oct 01 '22

Elden Ring - The Great, Not So Great, The ‘Meh’??

0 Upvotes

As someone who has played and platinumed all the Souls-esque FromSoftware titles, after 200 hours of Elden Ring, I’ve contemplated quite a lot as to why I don’t love the game as much as I think I should.

The Great

  • The world setting and sense of exploration; A big positive for me, the sense of “wow this just keeps going” was brilliant

  • The depth of the world itself - discovering the underground map was such a treat

  • Stand out bosses; Praetor Rykard, General Radhan, Maliketh, Malenia, Placidusax

  • The visual art direction - the vista seen of Liurnia of the Lakes upon exiting the back of Stormvail Castle is one of the most gorgeous scenes from any FromSoftware game

The Not So Great

  • The spike in difficulty upon entering the Forbidden Lands/Mountaintop region

  • The artificial difficulty in combat encounters which felt more obnoxiously difficult as opposed to being difficult but interesting/engaging (Godskin Duo, Tree Spirits, Crucible Knight and Misbegotten duo in Caelid, the rotting dogs and crows, could keep going at this rate…)

  • The “boss rush” at the end with Gideon > Godfrey/Horaux Lux > Radagon + Elden Beast - Why not space these out?

  • Easily for me the worst final boss battle FromSoftware has ever put out with the Elden Beast, seeing it just reminds me of Dragonite from Pokemon and isn’t alluded to in the game except in the Elden Stars incantation description, feels very lazy and not a fun boss battle to cap off the journey

  • The End game/New Game+; There is very little incentive for replaying the game when you consider the first playthrough consisted of exploring all the catacombs and areas which resulted in obtaining an unique weapon or an unique ash of war, something which having multiple copies of doesn't really add any benefit. The game feels much, much smaller on New Game + when you realise you don’t have any reason to explore those catacombs and dungeons anymore because you already have the catacomb reward (Even Dark Souls 2 included red phantom enemies to remix the enemy placements in New Game +, and having New Game + specific rings to incentivise multiple playthroughs)

  • The performance; why does this not run at a buttery smooth 60FPS on my PS5? I was actually surprised how much this annoyed me as I’m not one who notices what FPS a game is running at but wow did I feel it with Elden Ring

The Meh

  • The lore; I know its controversial but I just wasn’t intrigued by the lore, an example of this is finding out Marika is Radagon and vice versa - it didn’t really impact me as much as the game thought it would

  • The combat; again controversial but it's basically Dark Souls 3 with an expanded tool set in the form of Ashes of Wars and Summon Spirits 

  • Inclusion of Jumping; the only real impact this had was introducing the Jump attacks which are nice but just affects combat. You can’t grab onto ledges or scale walls/enemies as you could in say Dragon’s Dogma, and there’s no bosses which requires the jump mechanic per say. The platforming is still not great (the descent to the 3 Fingers springs to mind, being able to jump don’t really change things here)

  • The soundtrack; some standout pieces but on the whole not quite as impactful compared to Bloodborne, Dark Souls 1 and 3, Demon’s Souls remake

  • The graphical prowess; this really was apparent as I just played the Demon’s Soul Remake before Elden Ring and it was night and day. Elden Ring doesn’t look bad but you know it could look much better on a graphical/technical level

I did enjoy my time with Elden Ring and believe it is a brilliant game, but it’s not a game I love or think about replaying. What are your thoughts? Is any of the above accurate or have I missed something that may change how I view the game? Interested to hear from other fellow Tarnished.


r/FromsoftGames • • Nov 03 '22

OPINION I Don’t Even Want FromSoftware To Make Bloodborne 2

Thumbnail
screenrant.com
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Dec 19 '22

RUMORS Bluepoint Games Teases Bloodborne Remake

Thumbnail
ggrecon.com
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Dec 06 '22

NEWS Elden Ring Gets Free Colosseum DLC After Months Of Fans Begging

Thumbnail
kotaku.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Sep 16 '22

OPINION Elden Ring Proves Dark Souls 2 Was Actually Good

Thumbnail
dualshockers.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Dec 09 '23

OPINION It's not just you: we were sure there'd be an Elden Ring DLC trailer at The Game Awards, so when the heck will we see one?

Thumbnail
pcgamer.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Aug 08 '22

DISCUSSION Elden Ring: A site created to complain about PvP

Thumbnail
oicanadian.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jul 27 '22

RUMORS There is clearly something going on at FromSoftware with Armored Core

Thumbnail
hitechwiki.com
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jul 27 '22

DISCUSSION Found out in Elden Ring greater than 100 unused mysterious icons that recommend the cancellation of a conceivable serve as

Thumbnail
thenewstrace.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Nov 14 '22

LORE An Elden Ring Story ► The Blessing of Despair (Latest VaatiVidya)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Nov 04 '22

NEWS FromSoftware is EVOLVING! New Details and Elden Ring's Future

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Sep 26 '22

hey Guys if you have a similar voice like margit or morgott or sound close to his voice please message me i would love to video some kind of abridge Elden ring videos

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • May 03 '23

OPINION 'Elden Ring' Theory Reveals a Trippy Connection to 'Bloodborne'

Thumbnail
inverse.com
1 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jan 31 '23

RUMORS "Huge" Elden Ring DLC in the works?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Dec 13 '22

OPINION The Horror That FromSoftware Lost Between ‘Demon's Souls’ and ‘Elden Ring’

Thumbnail
vice.com
4 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jan 30 '24

What to do

2 Upvotes

I really want get dark souls because I think it would be interesting however the only souls games I've played are newer ones sekiro and Elden ring so I feel like it'll through me off because off the graphics even the 2018 remastered still looks off than what I'm used to and don't know what to do


r/FromsoftGames • • Feb 28 '24

Elden Ring Player Discovers Boss for the First Time After Playing for Over 1,000 Hours

Thumbnail
gamerant.com
0 Upvotes

I couldn't imagine how they feel I'd be like wow wt


r/FromsoftGames • • Apr 29 '24

OPINION Elden Ring's uber boss Malenia says she has 'never known defeat', but your bank account sure will if you buy this 1:1 scale replica of her blade arm

Thumbnail
pcgamer.com
2 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Sep 25 '22

OPINION FromSoftware's Greatest Game is Still Better Than Elden Ring

Thumbnail
cbr.com
2 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Oct 16 '22

OPINION Bloodborne Will Always Be My Game Of The Year

Thumbnail
kotaku.com
2 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Feb 25 '23

RUMORS Rumor: Bloodborne PC Port Was Canceled After Poor Horizon PC Launch - PlayStation LifeStyle

Thumbnail
playstationlifestyle.net
2 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jul 09 '22

DISCUSSION This Elden Ring mod completely overhauls combat

Thumbnail
pcgamesn.com
2 Upvotes

r/FromsoftGames • • Jul 30 '22

VIDEO Dark Souls is Underrated, no really!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes