r/Fromis • • Aug 11 '22

Discussion thoughts on Membership-only Weverse lives

3 Upvotes

(firstly, pardon me for my bad english as it is not my main language)

So, after a short but painful drought (like almost 2 week actually) from the news of our Gyuri departure from the group, the girls are finally coming back interacting with us on Weverse - and we love to see it :). Just yesterday, our captain Saerom went live on Weverse but it was made only for flover-only/membership only members. Even after the live ended, the replays were not made public nor there is any intention to.

For me, - a flover who do not sign up or bought the membership - i am a bit disappointed as i too, waited for them to finally coming out from the silence they had to endure and interacting with us flover once again.

I fully understand of the many factors that may or may not be the reason on why she (or the company) chooses to went live only for membership-only flover. One of the reason why i think they choose to went live on flover only is to restrict/reduce the amount of spamming harassment and malicious comments that WEVERSE FAILED TO DETECT/FILTER OUT before it was posted in the comment section during the live. Not only that, Weverse also have a very lousy report system both on its platform public posting feature and live comments. For me, this is very understandable.

However, we must not forget that Weverse company LITERALLY OWNED VLIVE. We never had this kind of problem with vlive before so why is it exist now? Weverse could literally copy and paste all the code or features that exist on vlive THAT COULD DETECT AND FILTER OUT malicious commenters far better. But they didn't. Not to mentioned, HYBE owned Weverse andd they letting this kinda problem to persist (?). Now it had become a platform-wide problem that not only fromis_9 is suffering, but all the other groups that are using the Weverse platform.

Before you guys said that i could have just purchase the membership to solve my disappointment, mind you that not all people and fans have the same privileges as you. I live in one of the SEA countries and the currency here is just sooo bad. The price conversion of the membership which are $20 that valid for 365 days, may seems small to y'all western folks but for me, this is my 3 days food expenses in my uni. Not to mentioned my bucket load of student loans i am in with no real source of income, fromis_9 literally helped me cope with the situation i am right now. So now the content (photos, videos, lives) that i have regularly watched and enjoyed to be suddenly behind a paywall unlike any other gg? this is kinda a bit unfair to me.

Before Weverse it was much simpler, lives are free and subtitle are constantly available and community made. Lives are also much safer and harmonious as there are less if not zero malicious comments present as VLIVE is just fairly a better platform with REAL AND FUNCTIONAL COMMENTS FILTERING SYSTEM.

I do not blame Saerom if she chooses to went live on Weverse for flover-only. She wanted a much safer space and environment for her and also flovers to interact and that's okay. But think about all the fans that were unfortunate to not have the membership, - new fans that were trying to getting to know the girls or even underaged fans - they do not have the ability nor the privilege to buy it.

So what are guys thoughts on this problem? As for me, i think Weverse needs a heavy overhaul in their chat and comments safety features to curb the malicious comments. I also felt that Weverse lives SHOULD ONLY BE MADE PUBLIC WITH NO OPTION FOR MEMBERSHIP ONLY/flover only after Weverse solved its chat and comments safety problem.

Or it just me being dramatic and i should just purchase the membership and move on?

Thank you for reading <3


r/Fromis • • Nov 22 '22

Discussion moving on

11 Upvotes

hello, so this is sort of a solemn post, sorry i didnt know where else to post this.... ive been a really dedicated flover for about 2 years. i would really follow their every move and be quite active posting about them on instagram and twitter.

when they announced that gyuri was leaving i was crushed like many flovers so i took a sort of break from kpop/social media to collect myself. gyuri wasnt even in my bias line btw. but yeah after a few days i felt better and i was back to being active within kpop spaces (i like/stan other groups) but i didnt interact with fromis/flovers at all

since then ive been completely distancing myself from the group and it feels very frustrating because i considered them my absolute ult group for a very long time and now i feel nothing. it's like something was switched off. i used to be the person who would drop everything on thursday 9pm kst to watch channel_9 the minute it dropped and now im realising i havent watched channel_9 at all since july, or any fromis video really

i kinda need to get this off my chest because i haven't seen any flover with similar reactions. most flovers seemed to have moved on and post about fromis as usual with the occasional tweet about actress gyuri

i know it happens to feel less strongly about a group/unstan over time as it's happened to me before but this was so sudden im still not sure how to feel. anyone has been through this with fromis aswell or other groups?


r/Fromis • • Jan 17 '26

From

12 Upvotes

I am curios as I am new to kpop (my favs are are metal and country music) and I am curios to know what "from" is about? I personally believe it's a thank u song, but that's just my feeling about it. What are your opinions regarding that one song?

Also, I don't care about how they look, they're idols, enough said.


r/Fromis • • May 05 '18

Misc Fromis V-live streams ,subscribe to my youtube account for regular updates on Fromis_9

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Jun 26 '25

Fan Content Like You Better x I Really Like You (fromis_9/Carly Rae Jepsen Mashup)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Aug 21 '24

Video Short Reaction vid from “Beat the Heat” songwriter

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

reaction vids are a bit overplayed but i thought this one was short and interesting enough to recommend. was looking at the writing credits on the album and saw that “beat the heat” was composed by a couple of the LYRE songwriters (in this video, Gisselle, the one in braids, is one of the writers, the other is not in the video) and she says a couple of things about making the song for the group. LYRE seem to be pretty popular among the english-speaking Kpop community and theyve also written some pretty big songs like ITZY’s “Mafia in the Morning”, Kep1er’s “Giddy”, Purple Kiss’s “Sweet Juice”, and Blackswan’s “Karma”


r/Fromis • • Jul 14 '24

Video 240713 [GQ KOREA] Jang Gyuri 'My Essentials'

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Jan 11 '25

Discussion Predictions for fromis post-HYBE?

26 Upvotes

I just thought this would be a fun post to make since the girls are starting to interact with flovers again. Personally, I want Jiwon and Seoyeon to debut solo and make some fire music. (No ballads please.)

Jiheon and some other fromis members (Hayoung, Nagyung and Chaeyoung?) should redebut in a subunit like Viviz or BB Girls, I think they’ll be able to reestablish themselves with new kpop fans and gain more popularity.

Saerom and Jisun… well, I’m not even sure if they’re continuing in the idol industry. But I can picture them being influencers, I do hope they’ll continue singing.

What does everyone hope for?


r/Fromis • • Sep 10 '24

Fan Content Song Review:: fromis_9: Supersonic- Supersonic

Thumbnail
justalittlefangirllove.blogspot.com
21 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Dec 18 '18

Chaeyoung issues...

7 Upvotes

im still suprised that people are still having issues about chaeyoung saying she's the reason the group is not popular in korea. like her initial issue is already disproven by her agency and her actions on her members that was interpreted as bullying is really sad because she is probably the most close to each members aside from hayoung and her playfulness is interpreted as bullying. fromis_9 reached top 2 in mcountdown and top 10 in other music shows, i doubt that there is still issue around her, mostly just netizens that are really antis which is the norm in korea if your a star.


r/Fromis • • Apr 29 '26

Misc Gender Demographic of this Sub/Flovers?

17 Upvotes

Made this after seeing a similar poll on Ive sub.

386 votes, May 06 '26
319 Male
50 Female
9 NB
2 Genderfluid
6 Other

r/Fromis • • Aug 18 '25

Halo!

12 Upvotes

So, saerom mentioned about doing bubble lives in the future. Does anyone know a way to download bubble live replay beside screenrecord it? I want to archive her bubble live because bubble live replay only available for 24 hours... :(


r/Fromis • • Jul 03 '25

Discussion Old OLD fromis music

8 Upvotes

(the title is like that because all I could find was someone asking about their "old" music in reference to their Pledis releases)

I've been wondering about the state of fromis' pre-Pledis music and where the rights for those actually lie. If you go on Spotify the publisher/rights holder is listed as Stone Music/Off The Record or CJ E&M Music. I've been boycotting Hybe for years with fromis as the one exceptions and Hybe as a whole for almost 2 years now because of their associations with Zionists so I avoided even To.Heart-9 Way Ticket just to be safe but now that the rights to fromis are almost completely out of Hybe I'm wondering if at least those releases are safe? Do you know if Pledis handles the royalties for those or if it still goes through CJ/Stone Music/Wake One? I really miss Weather, Clover, and To Heart but I will keep missing them if those releases in any way go through Pledis.


r/Fromis • • Mar 15 '25

Misc Hypotheticals

13 Upvotes

Was feeling bored and wanted to cheer the mood up so y’all can post your hypothetical questions related to Fromis here, anyone is welcomed to answer any questions

My question to y’all are: If you had the chance to hang out with any member for a day, who and what would you do


r/Fromis • • Aug 31 '22

Who do you think are the closes members in fromis_9

25 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Nov 09 '18

Discussion I just found out some of the girls have their own insta account..

4 Upvotes

do you think they will accept my request to follow them? cos i would be pretty depressed if they didn't lmao. my profile pic is of my face, my insta handle is a combination of momo (twice) and lisa (bp), my bio is a lyric by halsey.

am i thinking too much..? whats your experience in following the girls with private account? especially romsae and hayoung because they are the only ones with posts


r/Fromis • • Jun 26 '25

Are they officially ditching the "_"? fromis9 vs fromis_9

9 Upvotes

From the shirts in the MV to the stickers in the album to the back of the MC prompt cards that Hayoung was using in the countdown live, they all don't have the underscore "_" between the fromis and the 9. They all say "fromis9".

Edit: I just saw on the countdown live where at the bottom of the photobook it says "fromis_9". Maybe just a temp styling choice?


r/Fromis • • Aug 24 '24

Discussion Is fromis preparing for another comeback/a tour?

10 Upvotes

To recap, Jiheon dyed her hair blonde, Jiwon went back to black, Saerom dyed her hair the same shade as her Stay this Way era, Seoyeon got bangs and Nagyung seemingly dyed her hair too. Supersonic’s promos/final stage seems to end this week.

I also saw a funny clip of Nagyung glaring at Jiheon when she danced to Beat The Heat….. and Saerom and Hayoung seemingly made up a choreo. Are we perhaps getting a second title track? Or are we just delusional?

Cause I don’t think they would just randomly dye their hair for fun, would they. Hm.


r/Fromis • • Jun 01 '24

Twitter 240531 Gyuri Twitter Update with Player 2 Cast via CJnDrama

21 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Mar 23 '25

Discussion how big could fromis have been if they debuted with the proper management support?

42 Upvotes
  • + if they did not got dragged down by the idol school curse

  • + if they did not have a competing sister group(iz*one)

  • + if hybe prioritized them instead of just using them as "sample girl group F"

  • + if seoyen, hanyang, jiwon, jiheon were given more freedom to produce more songs for the group

  • + if channel_9 was maintained

  • + if individual talents and projects were supported

  • + if they had continuous comebacks instead of long pauses in-between comebacks

  • + if they got proper management support all through out their career

  • + if the japanese debut happened properly

add: this topic, if people do decide to join in, would be one of those topics that would have people clashing against or agreeing with each other. please keep the comments civil and non-toxic for the most part.

add: since there might be people here that are multi-stan, or fromis is not their main ult group, please state your ult group and the groups you support, so people can weight were your perspective is coming from. ie, fans of bigger groups do have a different perspective. i myself started my kpop journey as a once(twice fandom) so i do get why fans from other groups could have a different perspective on things.

add: as long as its for the sake of the conversation, dont be afraid to name groups. just reminding everyone to be civil about things and not go oogah-boogah

add: but please remember that ultimately, this is a fromis post in a fromis sub, people here do prefer if you would talk brightly about fromis.

add: i do consider people here more knowledgeable than me in certain topics. i have learnt a lot from this sub. so i do tend to make posts that net in varied opinions from people with different perspectives. if this post becomes toxic, i would like the mods to decide what to do with this thread. whether to delete it or keep it open.

add: i would be playing two roles on this post. 1) as a host that would try to be as neutral as possible to keep the ball rolling. 2) as me that would give my personal opinions. so if some of my comments would sound like im being two-faced, this is the reason

add: for people getting dragged down, sorry. and also, thankyou for the ones participating, im learning a lot through this post. i myself am neither on the camps, im more on the neutral side since keeping a neutral side would help you learn from different perspectives.

add: for people downvoting the comments, can you at least make an effort to explain your thoughts? just downvoting them wouldnt make any sense cause on the first place we dont know the reason why you downvoted the comments. at the least people discussing here are making an effort to communicate with each other. those comments add in on the topic as a whole, just a downvote and nothing else doesnt

add: people who would defend the light side of the what ifs, where you at???????? when i first opened this post i initially thought that we would get a lot of more positively bright answers like "we would definitely have some banger japanese songs" or something like that, but where you at????????????? of course the whole post/thread would sound dry and too realistic cause, where are the bright happy comments at??????? i want those too.......

(this sprung from a topic from the weekly discussions. i thought it might be interesting to see what people think, specially in retrospect of what already is considered the past and we are now transitioning to asnd era. hopefully, springing some creative ideas that ot5 can use along the way)


r/Fromis • • Jun 19 '24

Video 240619 Gyuri - [tvN drama] The Player 2 Episodes 5-6 Making

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Jun 28 '19

Discussion I've made some alternative covers for FUN FACTORY, because the original looks cheap to me unfortunately. Tell me what you think and feel free to use them!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
10 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Mar 19 '25

Discussion So, is Saerom, Jisun and Seoyeon ex-members or just on hiatus?

77 Upvotes

Even though I kind of(?) consider them ex-members, I also don’t think anything’s really official until they explicitly say we’re no longer in fromis_9. Call it copium but you can’t really say they left the group just because they removed fromis_9 from their bios.

I also don’t think I’ve seen a group situation like fromis’, where some of the members carries the name into a new agency while also writing goodbye letters towards their fans.

For me, I’m inclined to believe that they’re just on hiatus for now and they’ll reunite as eight for the anniversary. I mean, come on, right guys… they still celebrated the seventh anniversary!

What does everyone think?


r/Fromis • • Dec 01 '24

Video 241127 Gyuri - 'When the Phone Rings' Episodes 1-2 Special Making

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/Fromis • • Aug 20 '24

Instagram 240820 Gyuri Instagram Update

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes