r/foucault • u/Dopewarg22 • Sep 01 '25
Welcome back Foucault!
The Rock resembles Foucault after losing weight for movie
r/foucault • u/Dopewarg22 • Sep 01 '25
The Rock resembles Foucault after losing weight for movie
r/foucault • u/MBTIstuff • Feb 19 '22
Click here to listen to the audio of this text.
Michel Foucault: Discipline and punishment
Today, we will be discussing Michel Foucault’s work called discipline and punish: the birth of the prison. The motive we got here with ‘discipline and punish’ is that Foucault wants to give a logical narrative for the history and for the practices of punishing crime in the late 1700s through the mid-1800s. He also wants to give us a reason as to why the attitudes towards crime had changed. Now, you see, the reason why Foucault talks about crime, or maybe it is better to say, the reason why he wants to talk about discipline and punishment is that it also gives him a really good chance to also explain how power operates in our society and how people are pushed into these so-called ‘correct’ behaviors. What we are going to do with the help of Foucault is that we are going to analyze punishment in its social context too.
The first two parts of Discipline and punish; shows us how there was a transition from public display of punishments to private detention. In better words, Foucault wants to show us the reasons for the change of punishing criminals in public and how it came to become something private. He claims that up until the 1700s, punishments for crimes were given out by the kings or leaders of the country and usually these punishments were in the form of public executions or torture. They did these things to obviously reestablish power and authority within the society.
Slowly and gradually, in the 1800s, at the beginning of the 1800s to be more precise, there was this transition taking place. These public punishments were replaced with a different method. The reason for the change of method, was not because people cared for these criminals but because the people who wanted to change the method of punishment, wanted power to run more efficiently. This is what gave rise to the birth of the prison. Now criminals were being taken away from social view and torture was pretty much out of the picture. Now, the focus was not to execute or punish the person but to change the person, to reform the person’s personality, so that crime could be prevented later.
This shift from torture to prisons also brought about many other changes. Firstly, there is a change from focusing on the body to focusing on the soul and when we talk about the soul, we are talking about the self, the mind, the immaterial aspect of a human being. Secondly, there is a change in perspective because now we do not think of crime as an injury but as a violation of social norms. We now think like this, that the criminal has violated these social codes, that the criminal went against society, and that the criminal must now be reformed because that criminal has to fit back into society. Also, we think, ok, we should not break these social norms either. There is this control in society, there is this hidden guideline as to how we should act and how we should not. We live with this deeply rooted understanding that if we break the norms, we could be punished.
Now, going back to talking about these criminals, well, it is the norm now that they need to be disciplined. And discipline is a technique in which power can be exercised. Discipline is the manipulation of the individual’s movements, and it is the manipulation of their sense of space and time. Such discipline, for example, is exercised through timetables or military drills.
This is known as disciplinary power, and it is based on three principles.
The first principle is hierarchical observation. Hierarchical observation is an all-knowing presence of power that constantly observes everything, with all knowledge circulating back to its center. In return, we have a constant way of controlling people. For example, let us say that you are a soldier in training in a room in a corridor, and these rooms have windows, very big windows where we can see your head and feet and you are being inspected. Not all the time but because of the window, you feel that you are being inspected and could be inspected at any time. This is hierarchical observation; you feel the presence of a power that is constantly observing everything.
The second principle is normalizing judgment. It consists of very subtle and consistent ways of discipline. These methods could include some form of physical punishment, deprivations, and humiliations. This sort of disciplinary power makes us feel that if we deviate from these so-called norms, these subjective social norms, it will result in us getting punished.
The last one is the examination. It is a combination of the first two principles. Those in power observe, judge, and punish those who are not in power. It is the normalizing gaze, where people fear being judged, observed, and punished.
Such disciplinary power is everywhere! You will find all three principles working everywhere.
Then in the third part of ‘Discipline and punish’, we start analyzing different institutions which act like prisons too. In the 1800s, many institutions were reinvented. They were reinvented with an aim in mind and that aim was to reform people, to train people so that they could correct or develop these certain behaviors. These institutions confined people, it gave them a place, a role, and the members of these institutions were constantly being analyzed and observed and being analyzed and observed also worked fantastically well into making these members of these institutions start acting in the ways that they should.
And you can see this take place in many ways. For example, a school is a fantastic example of this because schools train students by giving everyone a grade and a place in the classroom.
Moving on, let us talk about the panopticon because it became a very important symbol in the process of this whole shift. Now, you might be thinking, what is this panopticon? The panopticon is a concept of discipline brought to life in the form of a central observation tower placed within a circle of prison cells. So you had a tall central tower and you had the cells arranged around this central tower. Because of the way it was built, it made the prisoners feel that they could be watched at any time. So, the prisoners would never disobey, they wouldn’t go astray, they wouldn’t try anything funny because they had a fear of being caught.
What Foucault does, is that he takes this panopticon as a symbol of social organization on a huge scale. Foucault says that this is how people live in western societies now. We observe ourselves through social norms and we adapt ourselves according to them. This power, which is about discipline, is everywhere because social norms do not belong to any individual like they use to belong to the kings in the previous period that we had talked about earlier on.
In the fourth part, Foucault talks about how prisons haven’t really done much. They have not done what they were intended to do because criminals still commit crimes, and they get released without being reformed too. However, prisons still exist, not because it works or anything but because of the symbolic power, it has in organizing a society. One example of how it organizes a society is that it gives people classes. So now we have the ‘offenders’, the ‘murderers’, the ‘thieves’, and so on and so forth and these classes are separated from the rest of society.
r/foucault • u/Greaserpirate • Jun 29 '19
r/foucault • u/HairyBiscotti9444 • May 24 '25
r/foucault • u/ForeignChance6890 • Oct 09 '26
I think Foucault would understand what Trump and Hegseth are doing with a performative execution.
r/foucault • u/Illustrious_End_4952 • Sep 15 '23
Sitting in our camper, preparing some notes on Foucault. I thought the intensity in the second image was hilarious. I am pretty sure my face always looks like this when reading Foucault too.
r/foucault • u/Herclinze • Apr 10 '21
r/foucault • u/[deleted] • Mar 29 '21
r/foucault • u/juanperezjolote • Jan 03 '21
r/foucault • u/BoxLanky8541 • Aug 09 '26
I’ve started to read Paul Rabinow’s The Foucault Reader recently. I tought the concepts Foucault was writing about was interesting so i just picked up an introduction book about him. I have no experience of philosophy except several easy-reading books. I was reading the introduction part of this book and man, even the trailer is hard to deal with. It seems like he is using regular vocabulary with specific meanings he linked to them like many other philosopher. But it is hard to get them without an explicit explanation and not knowing what the actual fuck he is talking about and who he has beef with and why. Isn’t there a way to understand him without having detailed knowledge about what was going on in the philosophy scene and direct meaning of the terms he is talking about? Also english is not my mother tounge and i guess it makes things even harder.
r/foucault • u/Agoodusern4me • Jun 11 '25
It seems Foucault is critical of any "constructions of the soul" (e.g. gender, class, race, etc) that divide people and confer some amount of knowledge on their dispositions, attitudes, character, etc. In a debate with Chomsky, Foucault says even justice is a construct, to which Chomsky disagrees. If something as fundamental to our view of human nature, that being justice, is a construct and medium for power to move through, is there any escaping power? And, in this case, is there any society that can mitigate the dissemination of invisible, productive power?
Considering Foucault's focus on the knowledge/power dyad, it would seem that his ideal is a society with no identifiers – this way, people are not divided into ranks (as he says in Discipline and Punish; ranks being different classifications of people) and knowledge cannot be extracted from them. For the same reason, Foucault criticizes psychiatry, saying it discriminates between the insane and sane in a way that allows people to be more thoroughly examined and coerced/disciplined. However, a society with no identifiers sounds ridiculous; not only that, but it also seems impossible. Given how much Foucault criticized modern-day society, is there a better alternative?
r/foucault • u/stranglethebars • May 03 '24
What's the most interesting material on psychology by/about Foucault that you've come across?
I've found some interesting stuff already, like Foucault’s Change of Attitude Toward Psychology in 1953, and the following excerpt from Wikipedia:
Sciences such as psychiatry, biology, medicine, economics, psychoanalysis, psychology, sociology, ethnology, pedagogy and criminology have all categorized behaviors as rational, irrational, normal, abnormal, human, inhuman, etc. By doing so, they have all created various types of subjectivity and norms,[199] which are then internalized by people as "truths". People have then adapted their behavior to get closer to what these sciences has labeled as "normal".[200] For example, Foucault claims that psychological observation/surveillance and psychological discourses have created a type of psychology-centered subjectivity, which has led to people considering unhappiness a fault in their psychology rather than in society. This has also, according to Foucault, been a way for society to resist criticism—criticism against society has been turned against the individual and their psychological health.
r/foucault • u/cronenber9 • Dec 08 '25
"Speaking of sex primarily in terms of aberrations-> makes it aberrational.
r/foucault • u/posijumps • Feb 13 '21
The only Foucauldians I've known I met in college. They tended to be very privileged, usually queer or trans identified, usually pretty heady and almost always very depressed. They treated Discipline and Punish like it was the gospel, and are completely afraid to wed themselves to any concrete material positions out of a fear of appearing wrong-headed. It comes across to me as a very weak, gelatinous, clammy-handed intellectual tradition.
When you have white queer kids going to private school saying that "life is carceral" or "life is like prison" when (by virtue of their class status) they've been afforded every avenue into elite society, it's hard to take it seriously. I'm queer, and I know what it's like to be discriminated against or treated in a bigoted manner. That's not prison. I've also been to prison. I wonder if there has been a study done on incarcerated persons' reactions to Foucault's work. I'm not big into standpoint epistemology but it's hard to take some midwestern white gay Sarah Lawrence grad seriously when you come from the land of meth labs and heroin dens.
Do I have it wrong? What can be done to bridge the gap between rich, white, queer, "marginalized" academics and actually marginalized cis white straight meth heads?