RAD is a word whose shark-like fin we see popping up on many comment sections and posts. In the 90s, RAD hit its popularity peak, and it quickly became a catch-all word for any child with trauma issues. However, as anyone can tell you during this time, trainings called it "the kiss of death." The whole idea of RAD is that it is incurable and the child is essentially doomed to be a chaotic maelstrom of hate for their whole life until they eventually become a serial killer.
It is UNTRUE and MISUSED. There is a reason why trauma-specialist shun the word. RAD is no longer recognized by most specialists and is expected to eventually be removed from the DSM.
However, I want to share a write-up that really nails it on the head. I think it is very important it is shared, because it puts into clear terms and can help others avoid this trap. If someone mentions the word RAD to you, particularly a specialist, then run the other way! If it is someone who is just a parent, educate them and show them to better resources.
People who use this diagnosis or jump to this diagnosis also use dangerous, out-dated practices that will promise a life of no answers for your kiddo. RAD was initially intended for kids who are unimaginably feral and are 1 out of a million, like this poor abuse case here: https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/girl-in-the-window/neglect-feral-child-ten-years-later/ Even in this situation, they are avoiding RAD as it is better understood to be closer to something like an "environmentally caused autism."
REACTIVE ATTACHMENT DISORDER
Parents and caregivers who have children who receive a diagnosis of Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) often feel relieved, because their struggles with their children are being recognized, and they can go online and see a list of behaviors that mirrors their experience. It is important to know, however, that RAD is a problematic diagnosis from a standpoint of Connected Parenting.
RAD has been a problematic diagnosis since it was first included in the “bible” for diagnosis, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), in 1980. This is the case for many reasons, including the fact that it had poor evidentiary support then for how its symptoms hang together to form a recognizable syndrome and it has been continually criticized by giants in the field such as Bessel van der Kolk for its poor validity.
Not only is RAD problematic as a diagnosis as written, but it is often misdiagnosed, sometimes by clinicians and often by parents who self-diagnose their children when they fall victim to the huge amount of disinformation out there online about RAD. For example, here is a list from one website labeled, "Symptoms of Reactive Attachment Disorder in a child":
--Does not trust adults in authority
--Extreme need for control
--Manipulative and hostile
--Trouble showing empathy, remorse, or compassion for others
--No ability to receive or give genuine affection or love
--Resists guidance and nurturing
--Lacks cause and effect thinking
--Provokes anger in others
--Lies, steals, and cheats
--Destructive and cruel
--Argues excessively
--Impulsive
--Superficially charming
There are two major problems with this list. First, not one of those things is part of the actual diagnostic criteria for RAD. Second, every one of those things can be present for reasons that have nothing to do with RAD. As a result, there are many parents out there thinking their child has RAD when they do not have RAD at all.
What does a diagnosis of RAD mean, anyway? To be clear, RAD is a “real” diagnosis, and if it were given and received solely as a way to express how a child has been impacted by trauma, it would not be problematic. It attempts to capture the psychological harm that can befall a child when there have been disruptions in caregiving. The only behaviors associated with RAD in the DSM have to do with difficulty seeking and accepting comfort, minimal social and emotional responsiveness, limited positive affect, and episodes of unexplained irritability, sadness, or fearfulness, even during non-threatening interactions with caregivers. Those are all trauma behaviors that are the result of inadequate, interrupted, or inconsistent early caregiving. The fact that RAD points to the causality of inadequate care in early life is actually a good thing, because it shows that the child’s behaviors express an adaptation to an unsafe environment. Essentially, what RAD is referencing is an extremely severe form of disrupted attachment and resulting traumatic reactions to it.
However, RAD is a stigmatized diagnosis within the field of mental health. Any diagnosis communicates a lot more than what is written on the page in the DSM. Technically, the RAD symptoms fit many kids with a trauma background, but the “message” accompanying the diagnosis is often very pessimistic about the possibility for change. As it plays out in reality, it communicates that the child is immutably flawed or broken. Many clinicians will see a diagnosis of RAD given by another provider and assume that the child is beyond help. It can be given by clinicians who want to communicate that the child is “manipulative” or “controlling.” By definition, a diagnosis of RAD communicates to parents and caregivers that the child is unable of making healthy attachments, and that message is a very damaging one to believe and internalize about your child.
Thus, many of the most up-to-date and trauma-informed professionals avoid using the RAD label altogether. For example, you won't find the RAD label mentioned anywhere in the TBRI Caregiver Training materials. Trauma-informed clinicians are much more likely to give a diagnosis of PTSD or anxiety. Or they may be forced to enter a RAD diagnosis in the chart for reimbursement purposes but will use trauma as a way to talk about the child’s struggles and will be sure to explain to parents why they should take a RAD diagnosis with a hefty grain of salt.
Historically, many dangerous and abusive therapies were created to address this diagnosis which have caused irreparable harm, some of which are still in use today. There were a number of seriously bad therapies created to treat RAD. Most of what has been suggested by professionals as a way to treat a child with a RAD diagnosis is authoritarian, consequence-based, behavior modification-based, and even sometimes quite mean, exactly the opposite of what actually helps heal trauma. Sadly, many parents who go online looking for help for their adopted child or child with attachment trauma will stumble upon the treatment model of Nancy Thomas, elements of which are anti-connected and not trauma-informed. One now-discredited RAD treatment was the infamous “rebirthing” therapy that led to the suffocation of a child in Evergreen, Colorado. A RAD diagnosis can actually impede getting good help.
There is also a toxic subculture that has arisen around the RAD label. This subculture, fueled by poorly informed online resources and toxic online parenting groups, consistently blames the child, portrays the children as abusive monsters, and insulates parents from hope and help by portraying all contrary perspectives (like our group, Parenting with Connection) as clueless, ignorant, and deceived. Anyone who attempts to suggest hope or that the parents may need to change is shouted down as obviously not understanding.
This toxic subculture often portrays the following inaccurate information about children who have been given a label of RAD:
--The child is identified as flawed and broken. The child is often labeled as incapable of attaching.
--Behaviors are seen as intentional and willful. The child is choosing to do these behaviors because they want to hurt others and make everyone miserable.
--Conflict between adults and the child is blamed on the child. Adults are the victims of the child. The child is often attributed with the power in the relationship and is often shamed and vilified.
--Extreme responses to misbehavior, including shaming and harsh punishments, are justified as the only way to manage these children.
--The child is identified as determined to seize control from adults, and the remedy is for adults to control every aspect of the child's life. Controlling the child in this way is supposed to create attachment.
--Any criticism of the adults is used as proof that the critic is ignorant of RAD and has no clue what it is like to have a child like this. Adults do not take responsibility for how their parenting practices, including harsh discipline and lack of warmth, cause the child pain.
--Children are depicted as so damaged that connected parenting can't work with their child, despite the evidence to the contrary.
Note that this mindset is very affirming to parents that have struggled with a child’s incredibly challenging behavior and who have never found good help. They often feel understood for the first time, and eagerly join the sub-culture despite the lack of much hope for a better future.
However, many online RAD parenting groups are anti-connected and toxic. Children are described as “my RAD,” with their basic humanity overshadowed by their diagnosis. Many groups are not oriented toward seeing children’s pain or extending compassion for their struggles, and in the worst of these groups, the children are outright insulted, mocked, and treated like the enemy. The culture of such groups encourages parents to describe their child with terms such as “disrespectful,” “manipulative,” “disobedient,” and “a liar.” Parents in these groups seem to feed off of each other’s negativity.
Unfortunately, while parents feel supported and understood in these groups, the negative messages they receive about their children often create a self-fulfilling prophecy. Sadly, the advice offered in many of those groups can damage the relationships with these very vulnerable children, whose attachment histories are so bleak that they need Connection more than any other children do. It is understandable that caregivers feel relieved when finding a place where they feel understood, hear stories that they live every day, and feel like they found a place where they can belong. If you first landed in a RAD group and found solace there, don't feel bad--many of us came to connected parenting after taking some detours first. But be aware that we soak up attitudes from those around us, which is why here we strongly recommend avoiding those spaces that promote harsh messages about our traumatized children.
So, if I’m a parent whose child has just received a diagnosis of RAD, what should I do?
--First, evaluate whether your clinician is trauma-informed and is aware of this information about the baggage associated with the RAD diagnosis. If so, consider advocating for a diagnosis of PTSD or anxiety. If not, consider seeking a new clinician.
--Seek comfort in the fact that Connected Parenting does work with children who have been given a diagnosis of RAD. In fact, children with serious attachment challenges are more in need of Connected interventions than other children.
--Get familiar with Connected Parenting. Read up on the Connected resources we promote in this group. Read in the group, ask questions, and take advantage of the vast pool of personal experiences represented here--thousands of parents and caregivers of attachment-challenged children who are successfully implementing this way of being in relationship and seeing positive results. You will learn the tools here to connect with your child and build your relationship. It is possible that Connected Parenting is the most powerful intervention to heal attachment trauma—even more important than any therapy.
--Notice how you think and speak about your child. If you’ve been exposed to online parenting forums that vilify children who have been given a label of RAD, notice how you may easily slip into thinking about your child as manipulative or controlling. Remember that underneath the negative behavior, there is a child in pain. Access your compassion, look for the cause of the behavior, and be aware of the hurt that is under the anger. Remind yourself, “She isn’t giving me a hard time, she’s having a hard time.” Remember that for as hard as this is for you as the parent, it’s even harder and feels even scarier and more out of control for your child. Find ways to “catch your child doing something right” and to remember the positive attributes your child has. Develop a safety plan, if needed, with a clinician who is skilled in coping with challenging behavior.
--Avoid thinking about the future. Don’t get seduced into looking at videos about RAD that prophesize a catastrophic outcome. If you’ve met one child with trauma, you’ve met one child. Every child’s outcome will be different. Early intervention is an important predictive factor, and members of this group are intervening powerfully with Connected Parenting. So, stay in the moment, don’t go down the rabbit hole about the future, and if you hear or read something that seems overly negative or off-putting, listen to your gut and set it aside.
--Keep filling your own cup (this is CRUCIAL!) through getting your own therapy, seeking respite, and engaging in self-care. Be proud of your own instincts to get your family the support it needs!
Many parents ask if healing is possible for a child who has been given a label of RAD. The answer is, emphatically, yes. Dr. Karyn Purvis once said, "I've never once met a child who can't come to deep levels of healing if you understand what they need."