Over this last week, I attended a live taping for one of their afternoon shows. I just wanted to share my experience as an audience member with others interested in the show.
I had a great overall experience. I arrived an hour before seating began, so I was one of the first few in the line, giving myself and my fiancee two very front-row seats on Teller's side. The stage was a little difficult to see considering I'm fairly tall. Still -- well worth the wait since we felt up front and personal with the magicians and producers. After a host came out to the audience to get us amped up, they pre-recorded some bits for lauging, astonishment, wincing, etc. Then the magic began!
First act was fantastic. I don't want to spoil anything but I am looking forward to the TV version to see which parts of her act are difficult to see from Penn & Teller's POV, since I think I saw some things I wasn't supposed to. As the crew was cleaning up her props, some other producer asked me and two others if our handwriting was good and if we wanted to be a part of the next act. I happily agreed. First time ever seeing Penn & Teller, front row-seats at one of my favorite shows, AND I get to be on stage? Yay!
So we get on stage, and they mic each of us up, warn us about the stairs when we exit, and instruct us to a table with three chairs center stage. We sit down and the curtain drops over us. In front of each of us on the table are two white postcards, a black envelope, and wide, black felt tip marker. One of the producers is at our table making sure our markers are writing, and then leaves. The magician approaches from sidestage to the table. As I can hear through the curtain Alyson's introduction for the magician, he requests to us that we write big and boldly. He does not tell us what to write/draw.
Cameras rolling, the curtain comes up revealing the four of us. The magician was doing his intro, but I can vaguely remember it since it's my first time on stage on national television and focused on Penn & Teller sitting right in front of me, and myself on the big screen. It was just a very new experience for me, so I wasn't quite paying attention to what the magician was saying two feet from my ear. Lol.
He instructs us to think of any word in the English dictionary, write it on the card, and to place the card in the envelope. He turns his back toward us to face Alyson. Mind you, this marker I was holding had a very wide (about 3/4 inch), circular, flat tip. The postcard was about 6"x9", so I did not have a lot of space to write. I doubt I could have sufficiently fit in even a four letter word on it. So I chose a simple, 3-letter word to hopefully make it easier for the magician. I wrote "ELK," the girl next to me wrote "LIES," and the other guy wrote "Family."
We all have our words in our envelopes, and Alyson is instructed to scramble them up. She then chooses an envelope at random, and the magician places it in a box, which is delivered to Teller to hold. Another little speech that I cannot remember too well is delivered, and he says a word is coming to him.
"Did any of you write the word 'Party?'
Silence. I look over at the other two, who look puzzled and do not say anything. We look back at the magician and shake our heads. Weird. Maybe it's part of the trick? The magician pauses briefly, turns towards the audience, and asks Teller to open the box.
Teller opens up the box, pulls out the envelope, takes out the card and faces it toward the camera. I can see it on the big screen read "Family." And yes; not capitalized. The letters "mily" are all crunched up near the side of the postcard. Oh boy -- not big and bold how the magician requested at all. Penn & Teller look at the card confused, as do the rest of the audience. They both wait for the magician to move on. Silence.
I struggle to figure out where this trick is going. I'm used to watching the show on TV where there are punchlines everywhere. Sometimes the magician pretends a trick is not going his way to soon reveal that he had it under control all along one way or another. But where's this gimmick? Is he going to turn the card upside down? Is he going to combine all of our cards somehow? Is a different word going to pop up and gag us? Finally the magician speaks.
"Ladies and gents, sometimes magic just doesn't work out. Looks like no magic is going to happen today."
I'm very confused. I cannot tell if that was the end of the trick, or if it was intentional. Penn & Teller are confused, the whole audience is looking at each other wondering the same thing I am. The magician exits the stage, and I hear the director saying "I have no idea what just happened" and the audience starts mumbling to each other. I can't remember if Alyson commentated again for him or not. The three of us at the table are instructed to go take our seats and I ask the director about the mics. Everything in disarray, the audio crew rushes out from the back and de-mics us asking the director "what happened?"
I go sit back with my fiancee baffled. The crew on stage is already bringing out a watermelon on some cool table for Penn & Teller's trick, which I thought would be last. I am guessing it was because the last magician made such a mess it would take a while to clean up.
Anyway, I feel so bad for this guy. He must have spent months looking forward to come out to Las Vegas to perform for Penn & Teller, booking his trip, spending hours with Mike Close to coordinate his magic trick with the producers, and is at the mercy of some random audience member's poor handwriting. And while it was cool being on stage, I don't see how Fool Us would put the act on air given it was a failed trick. I have seen many bad tricks on their show but none that ended where Penn does not even talk with them after their trick.
It just gave me a whole different perspective of the magic world for me. It does not always work out the way it does at home on the flashy TV. My best wishes to that performer.