r/Flute • • Apr 22 '24

General Discussion Which is more expressive, flute, violin or piano?

0 Upvotes

Which do you think is more expressive, flute, violin or piano? Why? How would you rank them in order of expressiveness?

Edit: Why am I getting downvoted? :(

Edit 2: After reading all the comments I've received, I've concluded that all three can be equally as expressive, just in different ways. :) The piano gives you more notes you can be expressive with, while the flute and violin let you do more with each note.


r/Flute • • 11d ago

General Discussion Looking for 20 flute players with an iPhone to test my learning app, with free Plus for life for proper feedback

Post image
0 Upvotes

I've built an iPhone app called Flutio that teaches flute through the phone's microphone. It listens to each note you play and shows how close it was. There are short lessons, a tuner, games and a library of public-domain songs.

I played flute throughout highschool and it was always one of my favourite instruments - I recently saw that there were no gamified flute or woodwind learning apps - so I made Flutio. I plan to expand to other woodwind instruments in the future but for now it is just for flute 🎵

It hasn't been tested by real flute players yet, and that's what I need before it goes on the App Store. I need to know whether it hears real flutes properly in real rooms, and whether the lessons make sense to someone actually holding one.

You'll need:

- Your own flute. Any level is fine, and beginners are very welcome.

- An iPhone on iOS 17 or later. There's no Android version.

What I'm asking for, over two weeks:

- Play on at least 5 different days.

- Send feedback through TestFlight as you go, with screenshots of anything wrong or confusing. Take a screenshot in the app and TestFlight offers to send it to me.

- Tell me whether it heard your notes correctly, and where it got them wrong, could you navigate the app easily ? Any UI bugs ? Anything is useful and very much appreciated! :)

- Send one short write-up at the end: what you liked, what annoyed you, and whether you'd keep using it.

What you get: if you do all of that, you get Flutio Plus free for life once the app is on the App Store. Plus covers unlimited Breath (the lesson energy), every song, song imports, streak repair, extra looks and practice insights. The beta itself is free for everyone.

Worth knowing:

- It's a beta, so expect bugs. Finding them is the point.

- N.B! Settings has a Test tools screen with unlock buttons and xp buttons. Please leave those alone unless I ask, or your results won't tell me anything.

- Your beta progress may be reset when the app launches.

- The sound from your mic stays on your phone.

To join, send me a message with what flute you play, how long you've played, your iPhone model and a quick photo of your flute. I'll send a TestFlight invite to your email. There are 20 places.

Check out the website :)


r/Flute • • Oct 15 '22

Purchasing a better flute?

0 Upvotes

Don’t buy it if there’s no C# trill. It is not optional.

[EDIT: The difference in weight between my heavy-wall, B-foot, offset G Weissman with C# trill and a student-model Bundy is 2.6 oz, which is less than the weight of three standard-size envelopes.]

We can go back and forth regarding the comparative merits of the Split E, offset G, B foot vs C foot, as well as the actual metal used, but this key must be standard on all flutes except those intended for beginners. There is no rational reason to choose not to have one.


r/Flute • • Jun 12 '25

Meme Donald Trump: I used to play the flute

Thumbnail
slippedisc.com
0 Upvotes

r/Flute • • Oct 10 '24

Beginning Flute Questions what is this symbol ? (sorry for blurry picture)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Flute • • Aug 15 '26

General Discussion I’m starting to see less of a purpose for flute in marching bands, should they even be in it?

0 Upvotes

for context, im in high school and i really really have a deep burning passion for the flute, I’ve been called the and best sounding flautist and technical out of everyone so far, directors, even from musicians outside my school, which sounds nice , I guess. but my issue is that do matter how good or loud I play I’m always overshadowed by any other woodwind and brass especially, I’m just failing to see why we should incorporate flutes in marching band when piccolo seems like the only reasonable answer for its inclusion (even then I still can’t hear our piccoloists half the time) and Im just failing to see why we should play these ’show off pieces’ when they always make the brass louder than us. I guess my question is: why should we keep flutes in marching band at all? there are so many reasons as to personally why I think it shouldn’t, I’d love to double instruments but band instruments have wayyy different embouchures and I don’t want to risk losing my tone, I love the instrument too much to do that to it.


r/Flute • • Jan 01 '25

Beginning Flute Questions I’M A PICKLE PLAYER NOW IN MIDDLE SCHOOL

0 Upvotes

Hello my director is letting me play pickle for festival he knew I can do it, since I also march for a High School. I need help audition is soon on honor and I just can’t play no low octave bellow the staff for my life HELP.


r/Flute • • Jun 22 '25

College Advice Hello. I’m a beginner, and I bought this one to learn on it.

Post image
2 Upvotes

My main purpose for choosing this instrument is to play spiritual music using it, so I just need like a source who can teach me notes that is spiritual Please advice


r/Flute • • Jul 20 '25

Beginning Flute Questions Is any of this right?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I can’t get it to sound right, I can’t get it to work, I don’t know if I’m holding it right. My mom bought me this, offered no lessons, and just gave me a book to go with it when I’m at my lowest in creativity. How do I do any of this?


r/Flute • • May 07 '24

Audition Advice How the hell do I play most of these high notes there’s an f flat

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Flute • • Apr 15 '18

Inspiration Flute Quote

Thumbnail
5bucksworld.com
1 Upvotes

r/Flute • • Mar 30 '26

Compositions & Composers asking for help in composing a exercise book for flute

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I’d like to write an exercise book for flute, but I’m not sure where to start.

Do you have any advice or resources that could help me?

Thanks!!


r/Flute • • Jan 28 '25

Repair/Broken Flute questions I DROPPED MY FLUTE ONTO CONCRETE HELP!

0 Upvotes

IT’S NOT EVEN MY FLUTE IT’S RENTED BY MY BAND TEACHER IF IT’S BROKEN HE’S GONNA KILL ME HELPPPPPP

edit: yay I did not get annihilated ^^


r/Flute • • Dec 02 '24

Beginning Flute Questions found a flute for about $100....... are they any good?

0 Upvotes

like..... i wanna start playing but they're pretty expensive but i also don't want a flute that sounds bad or anything... so is the $100-150 range any good or should i blow my savings just a little more💀


r/Flute • • Feb 15 '14

Which flute are you?

Thumbnail
playbuzz.com
0 Upvotes

r/Flute • • Jun 01 '22

School Band System is Wrong. Fight Me!

0 Upvotes

No offence to anyone here, but I just wanted to say this for a long time. Feel free to challenge my argument. (all criticism accepted here)

Ok, where shall I start?

  1. School band does not serve the purpose of educating children to truly appreciate classical music and what it means to play an instrument. By attending the school band, you don't learn about the history, the theory, and appreciate classical music in general. all the school does is just exploit you for the gains of the band. In a youth orchestra, I had the opportunity play masterpieces of music that is highly regarded for centuries. If you ask most band kids to name a piece by Stravinsky, Bartok, or Mahler, they will be surprised 90% of the time. Band teaches kids that band is all playing an instrument is, nothing more. In fact, playing an instrument means so much more than just band itself. It opens you to the wonderful world of classical music, it teaches you to appreciate it by learning it hands on. You get the chance to play a whole wide variety of music.

  2. It sacrifices individuality and ambition for collectivistic gains. Before I was in university, playing in band seemed like a chore. Playing in a youth orchestra, I get a sense of engagement and fulfillment. I felt important, as nobody is playing the same parts as me, and I become a crucial part of what makes the music performance successful. When playing solo pieces, or with pianos, I get to express myself fully through the music using my own interpretation and interact with the audience. I do not get that playing in a band. I felt as if I was not needed for it to be a good performance. It's as if the whole point of it is to teach obedience and "fall in line". 5 other people play the same part as I do, after a performance, I felt it as a complete waste of time.

  3. Does not teach correct techniques. Many children that started on their instruments in school, were taught incorrect techniques by band directors who don't play their instrument well, much less know how to correctly teach them. I was very fortunate to have started flute with a private teacher, and I think that is the greatest choice I made while learning the flute

Like I said, Any counter arguments are welcome. Peace out.

EDIT: I think I have a misconception of what the purpose of school band is. Thank you guys for giving me some context to this issue.


r/Flute • • Jun 23 '26

Beginning Flute Questions Help ._.

Post image
1 Upvotes

I wanna play this but I can't read tabs, where can I get some help?


r/Flute • • Oct 18 '25

Buying an Instrument Reliability?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Reliable? I'm not looking for anything high quality, I just really want to own and try an alto flute since it's sound is so nice, yet ones from reputable stores are all $3000+ which is wayyy out of my budget ;-;


r/Flute • • Nov 26 '25

Buying an Instrument Cheapest "usable" irish flute for an "interested" person

0 Upvotes

Ok i am going to say something controversial here: I want the cheapest irish flute that allows me to try and see if i want to get into the instrument. Or transverse flutes in general.

I keep seeing threads that ask for beginners flutes and suggestions range from 200 to 1000 bucks...

Like wtf people? I am NOT going to throw out half a months pay just to see if i find the instrument worth pursuing!

I got started with a tin whistle BECAUSE it is true to its other name "penny whistle". really cheap to pick one up and just try. And i gotta say i like it and now i wouldnt mind paying a bit more for a proper instrument.

And now i am looking for a similar entry to transverse flutes.

So are there some people willing to give me proper suggestions that stay under 100 or even 50 bucks?

Like i've seen the flutes on alibaba but they are mostly chinese style and i would like to focus on irish in the key of d.

Edit:

A couple of background infos I am from germany, schoolkids here usually get their first instrument as a loaner from their schools, so the rental market for instruments for adults doesnt seem to be as strong as elsewhere.

Sessions thus are also rare/non-existent in my area. Craigslist is not a thing here. I dont use facebook. Also the thought of putting something used to my mouth someone else slobbered into isnt exactly appealing.

I am a proficient mouth whistler and can get nearly anything with a hole to make a sound, so i have no concerns here that a cheaper flute could be hard to play.

I am specifically looking for a keyless flute in D i have no interest in keyed flutes and would prefer a simple wood construction.

I have no intention to learn it to any level of professionalism. So no use trying to argue for "concert grade" stuff. Ideally i want a stick i can play a little tune o when i am bored.


r/Flute • • Mar 11 '25

Beginning Flute Questions Flute Notes?!

Post image
0 Upvotes

Trying to identify these notes from Kingstree Overture sheet music for my daughter!


r/Flute • • Feb 26 '24

Repertoire Discussion How can I get my alto saxophone to sound like a flute?

0 Upvotes

I play alto sax but I hate the way it sounds and I really love the way flutes sound so how do I get my saxophone to sound like a flute?


r/Flute • • Feb 09 '26

General Discussion Beginner here. Why is flute considered to be so gay?

0 Upvotes

I, male, play sax, violin, piano, and clarinet. I went to my band teacher and asked if i could try flute. he said sure, so I got one. then later when I was at my locker with my friend he noticed i had another bag tht wasnt there b4. I told him i got flute, and he was like bro, whyd u take the gayest instrument? Then he went around asking ppl and most of them said flute. Can someone please explain why everyone thinks this? Thanks


r/Flute • • Sep 10 '26

Flute & Health Flauta con pirsing de labio, se puede?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Me hice un pirsing sin pensar en que soy flautista "flauta traversa" y no se si puedo tocar con el pirsing, necesito que alguien me de opinión para saber si me lo dejo o definitivamente me lo quito… que hago ?


r/Flute • • Aug 09 '20

Nonsense prices

0 Upvotes

Why does a new flute manufacturer not simply take the dimensions of a flute that costs $100,000 and reproduce those parts and sell the flute for $500 and capture the entire market? There is no reason why one shape of key should really cost significantly more than another slightly different shape of key. It is a question of simply choosing shapes. And metal is metal. Silver is silver. And a hole is a HOLE. It can’t cost much more to machine a tool that cuts one shape rather then another shape that’s almost identical. I can see no justification for charging anyone $5000 $10,000 $20,000 or $50,000 for a metal tube with a few buttons on it. Plus flutes that were built 100 years ago go for high prices and are considered great. So is there not really much technology here to advance? What have they been doing for 100 years if a flute from 1900 costs 5k and is better than a flute at 2k today. And if so, what’s this market for flutes and its pricing all about?