This might just be me overthinking, and maybe I do need to hear more singles as time goes on, but I’ve been reflecting on Florence’s upcoming album and wondering if anyone else has the same slight concern: that it could feel a little too close to Dance Fever, almost like a continuation rather than a new chapter.
I had a similar feeling when High as Hope followed How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful. HBHBHB was sweeping and cinematic, and while High as Hope is beautiful in its own right, it carried over some of that DNA — which made the shift feel subtler compared to the sharper turns of all the other sequences (L to C, C to HB3, HAH to DF).
For context: How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful and Dance Fever are actually my #1 and #2 favorite Florence albums (with only the slightest gap between them). I love them both for the same reasons — they’re reflective, euphoric, and completely immersive. That’s why part of me wonders whether a new album in Dance Fever’s shadow might feel too much like a “Part II” instead of its own distinct world.
Here's how I interpret each album:
Lungs → whimsical, primal and searching.
Ceremonials → gothic, glitzy maximalism.
How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful → expansive and cinematic, LA sun soaked.
High as Hope → pared-back and intimate (but still linked to HBHBHB).
Dance Fever → ecstatic, euphoric, mythic fairytale.
On a personal note — if you saw me walking down the street, you probably wouldn’t peg me as a Florence fan. But the thing I admire most about her is how unashamed she is of existing in contradiction: her voice is both demure and grand, fragile and enormous. At her concerts, she creates space for everyone to live in their own dichotomies too. That’s why I trust that even if this new album does carry over Dance Fever’s palette, she’ll transform it into something unexpected.
Maybe it’s just me, but does anyone else feel this? I will still love the album nonetheless because Florence explores things in such a healthy way, and she's not afraid to call anything out, and bring her own renaissance into it. I'd hate to feel like a fan that has too high of unnecessary expectations.