r/Firewatch • • Oct 17 '24

Some of the Firewatch devs backpacked into my lookout for the night!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Firewatch • • Mar 24 '18

Discussion | Spoiler Did anyone else not only dislike this game, but actually fucking hate it?

0 Upvotes

I just finished it and wow, what a whimpering finish to a game that started out with a promising beginning; it just meanders and builds mystery until the end when its some half-assed lazy ending that doesn’t add up at all. It seemed like more of a proof of concept than an actual enjoyable game, and I’m frustrated as hell I lost four hours of my life to this. I like games like Journey, this was just a mess. What am I missing? Why does everyone seem to love this exercise in banality? I’m honestly asking - I’m interested to hear what other saw that I didn’t.


r/Firewatch • • Feb 08 '25

Support Firewatch 2 petition

4 Upvotes

i know me aslong as alot of other players wish to have an 2nd firewatch to play since it has left a big impact on us all so heres my petition for the creation of firewatch 2

and please share the petition if you also want a firewatch 2

https://chng.it/HyFZNgG6xh


r/Firewatch • • 20d ago

Just started the game and something I already hate about it

19 Upvotes

Why is this lady yelling " you're a fucking asshole" at me because I don't want to tell her personal relationship issues with my wife first day meeting her?

genuinely threw the whole peaceful vibe off that I had with the game, I felt telling her it's none of her business was the normal response. but instead I get shamed and punished for it like the game actually tries to make me feel bad. don't like that at all


r/Firewatch • • Oct 16 '22

Support I’ve never been more disappointed with a game.

6 Upvotes

r/Firewatch • • Jul 13 '22

Please Help

0 Upvotes

I have an essay that I have to write for school about this game. Because of my lack of time I don’t have the time to play it or watch a 4 hour long video about it. Can anyone help me?


r/Firewatch • • Jul 02 '24

Spoiler I’ve just finished the game, and I’m kinda disappointed.

2 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, it was an amazing game. The story was great, but at the end you don’t even get to meet Delilah? wtf? I was hoping they’d at least meet or something, but nothing?

I had hoped they would meet and continue growing closer, especially after what they had been through together.


r/Firewatch • • Feb 06 '24

Discussion The ending of Firewatch ruined the entire game for me. Spoiler

21 Upvotes

I've always loved the feeling of freedom that indie games give. Despite my bias towards games with walking simulations, I wanted to try Firewatch. It was a game I saw on many "best indie games" lists. I bought the game on sale and downloaded it.

Despite my negative perspective on walking simulations, I was never bored while playing. On the contrary, the atmosphere of the game gave great relief. However, I was annoyed that the mystery created throughout the game did not reach any conclusion. The game's story felt like a poorly written third-rate script. I've never seen anything written so lazily in my life.

Let's look at the clues given to us throughout the game:

  • Henry's wife Julia's disease

  • Delilah forgetting to turn off the radio line and talking to someone else

  • Radio conversations are listened to by a mysterious person

  • Disappearance of camping girls

  • Brian's story

  • Fires occurring in the region

  • Deployment of the shelter by an unknown person

  • Henry is attacked by a mysterious person

So what did all this mystery create end up being? Nothing. I witnessed the laziest story that could ever be written. All the fun I had throughout the game was ruined. I wasn't expecting to end up with Delilah. I just expect everything that happened to be based on a grounded reason.

Finally, I do not accept the defense of the story as "ordinary events happening to an ordinary man" or "Henry's inability to escape the truth". They could reflect these emotions with a well-written story. Firewatch will be one of the worst gaming experiences I've ever had, even if the game itself isn't theoretically bad.

EDIT: I know most of the things I write are made by Ned. I also know Ned and Brian's story. I'm just saying that at the end of the day, these have no bearing on the story. Yes, Brian's story was tragic, but that was not our experience. At the end of the game, nothing we experienced mattered.


r/Firewatch • • Feb 14 '16

Fuck Delilah

0 Upvotes

I don't know why everyone loves her so much. I didn't fall for an ounce of her shit, the writers did a great job at making her a manipulative bitch that men easily fall in love with, because that's exactly what she is. She's a manipulator. Plain as day.

Hashtag fuck Delilah.

Actress did a great job though.


r/Firewatch • • Nov 27 '23

Wtf

0 Upvotes

That’s really the end? Why were we being studied by scientists and rated based on how easily manipulated we are? Did Goodwin really kill his son? Why did Goodwin assault me and stock me?


r/Firewatch • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion How I hate fanciful people (yes, Delilah)

0 Upvotes

I just finished the game and it's about 3 people who are running away from problems, okay.

But Delilah... is the worst kind. Extremely manipulative, creating narratives to keep Henry mentally trapped with her.

This reminded me of 2 people I had to cut out of my life. It's intolerable and harmful behavior.

That's it, cut the "Delilahs" out of your lives.


r/Firewatch • • Feb 11 '25

Discussion My Opinion on the Game

13 Upvotes

I just finished Firewatch and I have to admit that I am really disappointed. I obviously read some reviews before playing and was prepared for an emotionally engaging story, expecting to feel like I had just finished RDR2. But for some reason, Firewatch just didn’t convince me. The story was emotional, sure, but not as groundbreaking as I had hoped it would be.

Can someone share their opinion and maybe explain why I didn’t like it? Usually, I enjoy these kinds of games.

ps: I of course know that Firewatch isn’t an action-packed triple-A studio game, but reading the reviews online made me hope for something with more of an impact.


r/Firewatch • • Mar 02 '21

Review | Spoiler Finished the game and I am disappointed (NO SPOILER) Spoiler

9 Upvotes

I had high hopes for this game because I love mysteries! Yes the art is good and the voice acting’s great. The story just didnt live up to it. It couldve been so much better and deeper. I find the story too simple and short. There wasnt enough fear factor or thrill to make it a good mystery game. A lot of the time was spent on just walking around, you dont actually get to immerse yourself in the game environment because you’re only allowed to touch/interact with a few things. A lot of the time I just became too lazy to finish the game because it lost my interest.

The feeling that I expected from this game is like... hmm... the beginning of The Last Of Us videogame (just the beginning ok,the one when you start at the house of Joel): you’re in Joel’s house and suddenly some weird stuff happens and your fearful, intrigued and curious. That feeling was what I was expecting from Firewatch. A mystery adrenaline. I know that Last Of Us is an even better game ok, I am just referring to the beginning of the Last Of Us game wherein youre in Joel’s house and you dont know what the hell was going on and you have that exciting feeling of the unknow.

My rating would be 5/10.

I know some of you may disagree, and I respect that. But I just expected MORE. Firewatch did not reach its full potential. Hopefully they would realize what this game can bring to the table and do a major upgrade on Firewatch 2 if theres ever gonna be one!

Update: Lol. I just said that I didn’t like the game and everyone’s feelings got hurt and coming at me. Haha.


r/Firewatch • • Jan 14 '23

Discussion | Spoiler Just finished. Totally underwhelmed and disappointed at the ending Spoiler

2 Upvotes

What was with that odd ending? I can’t remember the last time I played a game with an underwhelming ending like that. You never meet Delilah, she’s that selfish she can’t even stay until you get there? And she comes on to you and then at the end acts like you’re strangers?? Am I the only one that felt they played a game just to be manipulated by some rando woman and then go home? Haha… idk


r/Firewatch • • Feb 02 '25

Discussion Disappointing ending

1 Upvotes

I just finished Firewatch after hearing great stuff about it. I'm a big fan of walking simulators so I wanted to give it a try. What I found was sadly more than disappointing. This is completely my opinion and I dont want to attack anyone who enjoyed it!

The "plot twist" felt really weak, I didnt expect it to be some crazy CIA stalking but it still felt very off, especially after he randomly tried to kill you twice and planting traps. I liked the characters, they were rly good written and I get the story focuses on these two especially, despite this I thought the ending was cheap. Did I miss something or do you agree?


r/Firewatch • • Nov 30 '23

Discussion Do it.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Firewatch • • Jan 12 '24

Review Just found the time to finish the game and... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

As i said in the title i finished th game and now i'm kinda disappointed. I've already had bad experiences with endings in films or tv series but this one is one of the worst. I really enjoied the graphics, the dialogues and the enviroment of the game but the ending kinda ruined everything. I mean it is a happy ending wich can be considered a good thing (because usually it's fulfilling to see the main character win against the bad ones but in this case it maybe was better to make him lose, and i said that because after seeing a lot of post on reddit with "delusional ending" as a title I thought Henry would die towards the end of the story. I really don't know what to think about the game in general now, i also read somewhere thet they where thinking about making a film about it but now i'm not sure if it would be a good idea to do so. Let me know what y'all think about it.


r/Firewatch • • Aug 05 '22

What I would have liked Firewatch to be

1 Upvotes

I played through Firewatch some weeks ago and enjoyed it. Like most of you, I found the ending to be disappointing, and the game altogether too short.

The top post of this sub is a discussion about the ending, but since the sub seems not to suffer from spam these days I figured a new post wouldn't hurt.

And I want to talk about what I would have liked Firewatch to be, in contrast to what it was.

First, there is obviously the way the game itself seemed to be taking, with the conspiracy: A real conspiracy, an attempt to study a male and female human, both isolated and suffering from loneliness, introducing stimuli via ranger, would be an interesting plot. I was not really looking for this plot line, but I was intrigued, as I assume most other players were.

But the other way the game could have gone was the reason I initially bought it: A continuation of the day-to-day work in a National Park we do at the start of the game. I think this was catered to so little that a second game, Firewatch 2 or maybe a game by Hinterland Studios (The Long Fire? lol) could capitalise on that idea and be successful independent of Firewatch.

The idea would be a relaxing game centred around navigating the park, just being in nature, and talking to Delilah occasionally. Fixing stuff, taking notes.

  • Get rid of all tension in the storyline. I hated how I felt about the conspiracy and the wildfire at the end. I never wanted to run, I wanted to walk, but walking felt unfit for the situation. Of course, I'm going to run/jog if I think there is someone out there who wants to hurt me or Delilah. Or if there's a forest fire or if a backpack is beeping a few feet from me. Adding suspense was the worst thing this game ever did imho.

  • Get rid of the initial storyline about Henry's wife altogether. I don't think it was sufficiently explored, it's not integral to the experience, and the moral of Firewatch seems to be that running away and hiding from your problems doesn't solve them. The story is a downer, and while the moral is correct, I want to play this game specifically for the escapism and relaxation it offers. I don't want it to preach hypocritically that that's wrong. Just like I believe Alcohol can be enjoyed responsibly, I think games can be enjoyed and used as escapism without it becoming a problem.

  • Don't ever jump days. I want to wake up, get my tasks from Delilah, and then spend the day walking around and doing these tasks. Maybe there'd be a way where I can look at the sunset, tell Delilah good night, and then "end the day" manually. Or maybe I click on my bed or something.

  • Add more tasks.

    • Checking if phone lines / signposts / fences are in order.

    • Maybe use the tracking device to track down an injured animal?

    • Clear the ways of overgrowth with my axe

    • Refill supply boxes

    • Make repairs to the tower.

  • Maybe add a (stronger) conservation theme. Maybe Henry needs to check on some beavers, or he finds a GPS collar, or some park visitors left food that needs to be cleaned up so animals remain wild. Maybe Henry takes the poop shovel to clean up some park visitor's poop, lol. There are options to inject some discussion between H&D, with him being a newbie to all this and her already having formulated opinions on conservation.

  • Tone back the things you can talk to Delilah about in the middle of the game. Start by letting us call in every little thing as usual, then as Henry gets more used to his role, tone it down a bit, then pick up again with details about the two of them when the relationship deepens. Obviously, you can't do that in a 4h game, but maybe a reduction in voice line frequency would allow for the game to be stretched out.

I know that it's problematic to simply ask for more content. Development is expensive, and "more, please" is not constructive criticism. But yes, please just more. A bigger area to explore and get used to, a longer play time (at least 10 hours), more tasks to do. With how tightly FW is written right now, that's hard to do, VA is expensive, but it would be just the thing to improve this game. Not a new storyline, just more being in the woods.

One final (expensive) idea would be to add localisation. Yes, the VA takes a lot of the game's budget, but for learning other languages, this game would be great. You have a relaxed atmosphere, and then you get to have organic talks about things you see. You see a shovel. Henry comments on it, Delilah comments on it. Now you know what a shovel is called in another language, how you use it in a sentence, and it's easy to follow because you got to start the conversation when you were ready and you know exactly what it is about.

Finally, please let me use the Osborne Fire Finder. It's right there, there's Firewatch in the title, and I never get to use it? Come on.

Let me know what you think. I mainly just want to talk more about this game that was way too short and still captures my longing and imagination weeks later.


r/Firewatch • • Aug 31 '23

Discussion More features

0 Upvotes

I wish we got to have more features like online multiplayer mainly. Or even something where we could look for clues for those missing people ( which were mentioned barely once )


r/Firewatch • • Jan 18 '23

Review Just finished the game

7 Upvotes

Played the game based on recommendations and while I enjoyed it, I didn’t think it was great and I certainly wouldn’t replay it.

I get to some people that observing the atmosphere is relaxing but to me I felt bored while moving. I got lost a bit and there really wasn’t much gameplay at all. Just move from point a to point b. Next day, do the same.

Don’t get me wrong I enjoyed the story but I didn’t enjoy playing

I think I read somewhere that Firewatch is a walking simulator and this is my first time playing one. Don’t think it’s my cup of tea.

Know this is the sub for Firewatch so will mainly get people disagreeing with me. but, anyone else have the same experience?


r/Firewatch • • Jun 27 '24

There's still one thing I don't understand, and it seems DUMB. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Maybe the writers didn't hink it all the way through or they simply didn't explain but:

  1. WHY THE HELL did Ned choose to stay at the park? ESPECIALLY after his son died there??

  2. After he gets found out by Henry and Delilah and the forest starts burning down, He just finds a new spot in the SAME PARK instead of leaving like what??? Bro GO HOME???????


r/Firewatch • • Mar 04 '16

Campo Santo, Firewatch, and the Death of Gamers

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Firewatch • • Jun 20 '24

What happened after ending?

1 Upvotes

Is there some info about what Henry and Delilah did after the ending? Like have they met and live together?


r/Firewatch • • May 16 '24

Discussion | Spoiler fire watch two(won’t be like one)

4 Upvotes

i know this is probably gonna get a lot of backlash but i honestly think having a second fire watch would be pretty cool.

characters should be different and maybe a different story line. a lot of people when they here fire watch two think we get to see Delilah and all that but i don’t think the second game would do any good if that were to happen.

instead of a dead boy we find out some people go missing and as a look out we help search our grounds because we know our area better than the search teams that are going to come out however we start to run out of time because of a wildfire broke out.

we could even have references from the first game. talk about the June fire. maybe how fire teams recused the boys remains and the dad being air lifted out because they found the dad in the cave. endless amounts of references.

the game should have a Delilah and Hank dynamic with the other lookout helping keep track of were the player has been for searching with the added company as well.

in theory it sounds like a 2nd game could be made it just wouldn’t follow the story line of 1. it would be a stand alone game but following ideas from the first game. the game would still be a sequel considering it would have references to the first game just the second game would be up the timeline a bit.