FINAL FANTASY IX REVIEW
Final Fantasy IX for me, Storyline-wise is the worst game in the series, yes I said that (FYI, I liked XIII). The gameplay was decent, but that's not the problem here, say what you will about XIII and its flaws but they weren't as frequent and huge as IX's.
I'll explain the reason why the story didn't engage me, it's because it plays nothing like the previous FF games, has a story nothing like them and has characters nothing like them, yet is one of the most overrated games in the series (or just has a really loud vocal minority) and was stated by Hironobu Sakaguchi to be his "favourite FF game" and "represented everything FF should be" which I really don't buy (I'm not saying he has bad taste, but Creators don't always have the best ideas in mind unless given the proper guidance, after all this is the same guy who gave us "The Spirits Within" and almost got Square bankrupt a second time, I'm comparing him as the George Lucas of gaming), the game suffers from really poor pacing and in regards to the Characters, excluding the main ones, they are really generic and underdeveloped, they are either obnoxious, stereotyped, or just completely become irrelevant as the game goes on (the only exception mostly is Vivi), they barely get any significant flashbacks or backstories (the most significant cases being Steiner, Beatrix, Eiko and Amarant)
To sum it up I'm going to list this review in a top ten things wrong with FFIX:
10: The Trance
To start things off, let's talk about the biggest gameplay flaw in IX, Trance, unlike other FF games with a similar mechanic such as VII and VIII's limit breaks and X's overdrives, where you could choose when to use them, the same can't be said about trance, it activates automatically when the bar completely fills, meaning, against your will, it could activate in a battle against weak enemies or in a boss battle where the boss is already almost dead where there would be no point to really use it, and as for the energy bar itself, again in the other FF's, how much the bars would fill depend on your actions in battle and the amount of damage you take, ranging from small to big, or in the case of VIII, when you were low on HP or if you used the Aura spell.
But in IX the whole thing is completely static, regardless of what happens the Trance bar would always fill at the same amount, making it take forever to actually use the form and as mentioned above the moment you Trance at an inconvenient time and waste the whole thing, the bar completely resets and you have to start over, you couldn't strategize with it. But moving along from the gameplay element of this concept, after spending a majority of the game solely being a gameplay mechanic with no references or significance in the actual story and world (aside from one comment by Steiner at the beginning of the game, in battle, that never gets referenced again) and then BAM suddenly late in the game it's comes in as a convoluted plot point that Kuja decides to use, rendering the first 70% of the game a waste of time, but we'll get to that once we get lower on the list.
Basically to sum that part up, an Eidolon (summon) disguised as a moogle reverts back to it's true form and it gets called "Trance" for some reason, there was no implication or statement beforehand that Eidolons could Trance, Trance is a super form that living creatures take on, Eidolons are not living creatures but spiritual guardians (probably once living people) of the world changed by the Crystal, and what the above mentioned eidolon was doing was simply reverting back to its original form, the whole thing falls into lazy and poor execution.
9:Necron
This comes as obvious, but a lot of people don't seem to see the full picture, and some try to "justify" his appearance because SYMBOLISM.
Necron was really just a cheap out of nowhere excuse for Kuja to "redeem himself", the "symbolism" was just a cheap excuse by the writers to try and justify his appearance.
Instead of the thing where the final bosses transform One-Winged Angel style with Kuja following suit, we get this "giant space flea from nowhere" final boss whom is never properly explained what he is or where exactly he came from (with what the Ultimania stating just feels like the writers flat out made it up) and his only purpose is to serve as a lazy plot device for a incredibly unsympathetic character to pull off a forced and contrived "redemption" or more specifically to try and make it seem more sensible, and being a "representation of the games (unclear) themes" is just a lazy excuse and distraction from what he really is and dosen't make his appearance matter, rather they should have actually built up and forshadowed him (there are some theories going around that he is the true form of the Lifa Tree and the Soul Cage itself).
Here is a take on what Necron should have been, Necron should have been Terra's former king whom was corrupted and was responsible for Terra's tragic decline, and he assimilated with a large amount of the lifestream of Terra (what Sephiroth attempted to do VII) and became the form he is now and later on became the Lifa Tree, and Zidane was also supposed to be his host, and part of his power was hoisted in Kuja.
8: The Eidolons and the Summoner Tribe
The Eidolons honestly felt interesting here but then became wasted potential, they start to get completely shafted in the second half of the game, in FFs like IV, VI and X the summons have actual personalities, lore and mythos surrounding them, everything is intertwined into the plot, but in IX it seems like it's going to have this too, but other than that one interaction with Ramuh, the Eidolons pretty much get reduced to mindless destructive beasts with no personality, no lore and past surrounding them and start dropping out of the plot in the second half, the Eidolons are supposed to be the guardians of the world and crystal, yet it never properly gets explained how the whole "Extracting Eidolons ritual" works and how it turns these powerful entities against what they're protecting, and we haven't even got to the part with the most powerful Eidolon Alexander being completely wasted.
The Summoner Tribe, I felt, compared to the Cetra Tribe from FFVII, was really underwhelming, their only purpose in the story was to be a random tribe that was nearly wiped out and served as nothing more as quick backstory exposition for Garnet and Eiko, yet got really overhyped, when the game starts you're given Garnet's dream sequence which involved Garnet/Sarah's biological mother, which leads you to believe that will be one of the major plot points, but as stated above, gets shafted and serves as nothing more than cheap backstory exposition. With the Cetra from FFVII, they've always had a presence throughout the story, almost all of the major plot elements could be traced back to them, they actually had impact and importance to the plot, while the summoners in IX just feel like poorly written and undeveloped copies of them.
7: Brahne, Alexander, the Mist and the Black Mages
Brahne, she has got to be one of the most generic, cliché and unrealistic characters in the FF series, not only does she embody the negative stereotype that ugly and/or overweight people are evil, but her motivation is extremely unrealistic, she is just "Greedy", I'm sorry, but that is not how real greed works, Final Fantasy Whatever's review pretty much summed it up best: "Well, then I just exploded. Nooo, no, no. So do not be easy, she left behind a moral event horizon has already bombed when Claire robbed and ordered to chop off the head of Garnet. It is not greed, it is excessive and does not motivated violence, which is no excuse and can not be - and this pathetic attempt to beat the drop of compassion for this dolboslonihe looks shabby."
(I apologize for the bad English, this was originally Russian that I translated from Google Translate) Real Life dictators did not do the things they did because of simple greed, it had to do with screwed up philosophy and bad up-bringing, none of this which Brahne had, as was described in the game, Brahne had a really good and productive life and was kind, good ruler, the loss of her husband and biological daughter were recent things but not enough to turn you into a war mongering sociopath that wants to murder her family members and friends (and that has nothing to do with "greed"), especially when you still have your identical adoptive daughter, there is nothing Kuja could have said to have instigated that, she's just another Emperor Gestahl/Shinra/ clone whose only purpose in the story is to serve as a generic one dimensional antagonist who you know is just going to get stabbed in the back and die, and after all she did, that is really unsatisfying.
Plus we never really find out what she wanted with Alexander, yeah, she was collecting the jewels and everything but that was never explained, it was pretty much an aborted arc.
What should have happened, was that Beatrix should have been the Queen (we'll get to her in a second) and Garnet's adoptive mother (she used to be one of the Alexandrian Knights along with Steiner who had feelings for her, but later became Queen after marrying the King, Steiner of course still loved Beatrix, but still watched over as a knight, which also explains why he was so overprotective of Garnet, she's the child of the woman he loves, so he sees her as a daughter, which makes it all the more tragic that the girl he thought was the princess was adopted, and the real Garnet he knew died all those years ago) and she would be a deconstruction of previous "Disk 1 Final Bosses" (Gestahl, P. Shinra and the galbadan President), the whole reason she was waging war is because she was convinced by Kuja that Alexander could bring back the dead, such as her husband and biological daughter and the desire to bring them back got the better of her, which lead to some actual interesting conflict between her and Steiner, and instead of getting killed off, she tries to make up and attone for what happened and gives up the throne to Dagger (and Zidane). Brahne could have still been a character but as a nice if eccentric noble who helps the players.
Speaking of Alexander, also regarding what was stated above, don't you just love how after spending the first half of the game building up to Alexander, he appears for one scene, then gets nuked by the Invincible and never shows up again or plays no role in the second half, wasting a perfectly good plot and rendering the first half pointless (and pretty much Kuja's whole Eidolon hunt, but again we'll get to that), we never get any elaboration on this interesting character's lore, connection to Alexandria or heck, that whole eclipse of Gaia and Terra's moons when the summoning happens, yes Garland wanted to get rid of Alexander so it wouldn't get in the way (despite it standing no chance against the Invincible), but my point is that Alexander should have still showed up and played a role in the second half, albeit in a weaker form that you could summon during gameplay, he would have contributed and gave revaluations and actually served a purpose and the first half of the story was simply leading up to the seal on Alexander being broken after reassembling all the jewel shards, and establish Alexander's past as the founder of Alexandria and knowledge of the whole Gaia Terra thing.
The Mist, as this one commenter sums it: "-~The Dumbness and Restrictions of Mist~
In the world of Final Fantasy IX, you have what is known as the Ilfa Tree. From it, comes this mysterious mist which, even more mysteriously, is able to be utilized as a power source. Think of it as steam, if you will. Now, let me first say that the mist is a nice idea as it covers our main continent. It is used as a sort of âfuelâ due to its properties that we never fully explained on, but adds an element to the world's own mythology.
That is until you realize it's entirely there for plot convenience, not really to evolve the game's world. You see, it powers things like airships and buildings on our main continent, but outside of that the world is bland and uninteresting. It's used more as an excuse than anything of any relevance. Then when you come to be told it's also actually Gaia's souls expelled from the crystal cycle by the Lifa Tree.
What's worse is that the convenience of it reveals itself even more when you realize this world has boats...and boats have sails...and sails don't need mist. So you start scratching your head and realize that the entire world outside of this main continent should not only be charted (because apparently it's not) but are perfectly habitable areas for people to live in. The world is old, and these people haven't ever got to a boat and looked out upon the world? Seeing as how there's a history of power hungry leaders in Gaia, it's surprising there's not a ton of outer-mist-continent colonies about refining minerals and staking claims."
As stated above, the Mist is a large amount of wasted opportunity, reduced to a cheap plot device, the Mist is actually the spirits of the people of Gaia left on the surface by the Lifa Tree, so then, what state are they in? What's it like? Are they suffering? What about the monsters spawned from the Mist? Does this mean that the monsters are actually the tormented spirits of Gaia, are they like the Unsent and the Fiends from FFX, spectres driven mad and envious of the living and take the form of beasts, or posses the flora and fauna and mutate and control them? What happens when they get used as fuel and to power machinery, is it like the mako reactors from VII? Imagine all the things you can do with this, so much creativity and details to expand upon, and it all gets wasted by being reduced to a simple cheap plot device and poor world building (we'll get to that in the dishonourable mentions) which lastly brings us to what said Mist is also involved with.
The Black Mages I felt could have been way more interesting had they actually went into the fact that they were made from the mist (the expelled souls of Gaia), dosen't that mean that the black mages are dead people brought back to life in artificial bodies? What was Vivi originally? Why would they fear death if they technically already died before? (they are basically ghosts placed into artificial bodies) What about their memories of their past lives? Again another interesting concept that gets completely shafted.
6: Freya & Fratley and Amarant
Freya I felt, was hijacking love story focus from Zidane/Garnet (although that's really only because of Garnet's stupidity and selfishness, and Zidane being somewhere he shouldn't be) and her storyline just gets booted to the side and never goes anywhere, we never find out why Fratley had amnesia or what happened with him and that love story pretty much gets shafted (honestly one of the game's biggest problems is it's poorly written love stories).
Amarant barely had any significance at all and had a really generic and clichĂ© (not to mention implausible) backstory, "oh my gosh that blonde haired tailed thief is trying to frame me for his own theft, even though the other guards have no reason to immediately buy into this complete strangers story, also instead of simply staying put and proving that I'm innocent, especially with how I DON'T have the stolen item, I'm just going to stupidly go away incriminating myself, I'M SO SMART, the writers weren't even trying to make him interesting. Here is a suggestion for a fanfic called "The Thief and his Princess", it shows a much better story arc for him: www.fanfiction.net/s/6925384/1âŠ
5: Steiner and Beatrix
Steiner's whole schtick got old real fast and he was just a stereotypical Flanderization of previous knight characters such as FFVI's Cyan and Chrono Trigger's Frog/Glenn who were way more subtle. Steiner and Beatrix's whole relationship was really forced, they've never really had any real chemistry (especially in disk 1 and 2 where during the kidnapping they barely gave each other a second thought, and Beatrix didn't show much concern that Steiner was gone and during the fight with her in disk 2 she treats him like dirt and a traitor up until her spontaneous and forced heel face turn, but I'll get to that), he would have been better developed if he was the one that went with Freya to Burmecia and, you know, actually witness for himself the atrocities that the Queen was committing (who should have been Beatrix mind you) and actually have some interaction and relation to fellow Burmecian knight Freya (and since she actually knew Zidane a bit, she would try to make Steiner better understand Zidane), and when encountering Beatrix, have actual drama and conflict and delve into their relationship, instead of having to pull us through a really long and pointless subquest that had a extremely obvious conclusion and drag out his painfully oblivious, unlikable and obnoxious, cliché personality that nobody wanted.
Beatrix, she's just an annoying God Modder, she's far more powerful than she should be, and NEVER loses a fight (which is really annoying when one of the people fighting her is supposed to be the ANGEL OF DEATH, Zidane, the ultimate life form.) and is just a straight up Karma Houdini, she's basically a poorly written version of Cecil Harvey, with Cecil at the beginning of the game you were shown the conflict with him and the red wings with them debating if they should really do those actions, and when actually attacking Mysidia, actually showed hesitation and afterwards immediate remorse, there was actual build up, and unlike Beatrix, didn't act like a total jerk wad or brainwashed tool when doing it (I don't judge a person based solely on their actions but also largely on their attitude and motives, which is what I think all people should do), with Beatrix there is no build up, the scene on the Red Rose with her post-Cleyra I felt was a complete ass pull, then bam! Suddenly when you're back in Alexandria, she's her jerkwad self again, then afterwards as this one person put it "through the span of three dialogue boxes, changes from a cold blooded war mongerer to a loyal companion"? Yeah, no, that's not how it works, it's really cliché.
Plus as Garnet's "protector" she's really bad at it, she didn't show any concern when Garnet was shot down on the Prima Vista, nor did she question why Brahne wasn't sending her to "rescue" Garnet (which you would think she would try to do ASAP) but rather seemed more interested in waging war and instead sending murderous creatures after her that would do more harm than good and cause a lot of collateral damage, Beatrix didn't mention or ask about Garnet's safety or whereabouts when encountered in Burmecia, even though she should clearly be able to recognize some of the party as the people from Tantalas that "Kidnapped" Garnet. Only after Cleyra does she ask about Garnet, even though you think she would immediately return to Alexandria to check up on Garnet's welfare rather than be focusing on waging war with innocent Burmecians and Cleyrians, even back in Alexandria she didn't notice that Garnet was in the room until she was literally pointed out to Beatrix (after forcing you into a pointless battle that did nothing but flaunt her god mode status), not only that, but apparently she was amongst the people who didn't believe Garnet when she said her mom was going crazy and starting a war, even though Beatrix was clearly taking part in this and no doubt had briefings from Brahne on said subject, so she had to know that Garnet was on to something, all this makes it REALLY hard to sympathize with Beatrix, what would have been better is if she instead took the place of a certain other irratating character (Brahne).
4: Zidane, Garland, Terra and the Genomes
The most interesting parts, such as Garland, the Genomes, Terra and Zidane being an Angel of Death were all thrown so forcefully into the plot, and then gets immediately wasted by more of Kuja's nonsense. Garland had to play second fiddle to Kuja and Brahne, a pair of far more typical and uninteresting characters. There is also the major plot hole of why does he even need an Angel of Death to speed up his plans, when he can just use the Invincible, (the warship that not even the most powerful Eidolon Alexander could stand up to) to nuke every city on Gaia to speed up the Lifa Tree's soul swapping process. Then there is Mikoto, Zidane's sister, apparently another Angel of Death, but that dosen't go anywhere.
To sum up Zidane, here is how a meta critic reviewer put it: "The game's supposed protagonist run around observing events but really doing nothing to change them while the plot becomes increasingly obtuse and contorted. It is a failure in storytelling on virtually every level."
Basically, he's a useless protagonist, you can take him out and the exact same events will happen regardless, in almost every significant cutscene he just stands around like an idiot and dosen't even try to do something or make an impact (despite in battle being able to cause massive explosions in trance and has "Grand Lethal"), he's supposed to be the Angel of Death, Garland's ultimate creation, basically the Shadow the Hedgehog/Mewtwo of Final Fantasy IX, yet he never beats Beatrix (a regular human) dosen't have any big impact on major events, he didn't even completely defeat Kuja, his brother whom Zidane is supposed to be supperior to, even the revelation is underwhelming, this kind of thing worked great in FFVII because the entire game built up to that one climatic moment and had lots of payoff, but here, it's completely tacked on and forced and then gets dropped almost as soon as it's revealed, Garland literally rips out his soul (yet somehow gets it back later for no explained reason, since, you know, Garland was the one who supposedly had it.) and this just leads to a really cliché power of friendship scenario, and ultimately had no major effect on the plot.
3: Kuja
For Kuja, he is just an unintentionally unsympathetic character, the game makes him out to be sympathetic when really he isn't, there's no build up, no hesitation or remorse in his actions (he just spouts pointless poetry which just makes him more unsympathetic), up until the last minute, and it's really only for incredibly shallow reasons like finding out he was going die soon and made a desperate attempt at amends (speaking of that, that made no sense, why the heck did Kuja think he was immortal? It was stated in the Ultimania's that he was just a regular Genome that accidentally got a soul, there was no reason for him to think he was immortal.), the writers even pulled a random entity out of nowhere (Necron) to try and make his incredibly forced heel face turn more credible, plus his whole hunt for the Eidolons (which took up roughly 70% of the game) was completely pointless as he could have simply read some books (he literally has a library in his own desert palace plus he also had access to the Alexandria library) and did research on Trance, and focused on achieving a power that was even greater than the most powerful Eidolon, Alexander, from the start, instead of wasting most of the game on the Eidolons.
2: Garnet
With Garnet, she has got to be one of the most obnoxious, horribly written characters in the Final Fantasy series, to put things simply she started off as a intelligent and interesting likeable character, but post kidnapping she devolves into a extremely cliché naïve princess sterotype, who cares more about her psychotic murderous mother than Zidane or her friends, to the point where she perfectly willing to ABANDON them and risk their lives, by running ALL THE WAY back home to mommy to "talk with her" (something you'd assume someone who had an otherwise perfect relationship with her mother [which that in itself is hard to buy, after what happened to her biological daughter you would think the Queen would be overprotective and overbearing] would do FIRST before the whole running away thing) after going through all the effort of running AWAY from Alexandria because she knew her mother was going crazy which renders the entire beginning of the game completely pointless, the next few hours a waste of time, caused the devastation of entire cities and seriously messed up Zidane and Garnet's love story a bit and to make matters worse, she NEVER gets called out on it, but we're going to save the Zidane/Garnet love story for last.
People CONSTANTLY try to justify this unjustifiable and unsympathetic action with the excuse of "oh, she's just "sheltered and naĂŻve"", okay there's a line between realistic, plausible naĂŻvety and completely brain dead, lacking in any common sense, no fore thought idiocy, also people don't really get what qualifies as "sheltered", being around a castle for 10 years doesn't automatically qualify as this (especially considering that before hand Garnet was in the summoner village on the outer continent and having amnesia dosen't completely surpress it), she is supposed to be highly educated and intelligent, professors and scholars taught her (specifically Dr. Tot), in fact, let's talk about another princess from another Square game called Chrono Trigger, whom was also couped up in a castle, Marle: she had weapon training, knowledge of blending in in public, and even managed to wing her way through getting thrown back in time until the paradox caught up to her and like Garnet she had tutors.
They also seriously expect us to buy that Garnet has not once ever been out of the castle, seriously, like not even on visits to other kingdoms or villages? If anyone is sheltered it would be Vivi, the guy is only six MONTHS old (while physically being a adolescent) and spending that time in a cave with the only company being a Qu as his adoptive father, another example would be Vera Misham from Apollo Justice, being couped up in her house never being outside and her father using her drawing skills to make forgeries (although for sympathetic reasons), and is socially inept.
Moving on, they expect us to buy that she only ran away from home and traveled accross the entire continent to Lindblum JUST to talk to Cid about vague details (that he already knew about, and Garnet could have told him through a letter and Mognet), and nothing else, that's a really weak reason.
What should have been the reason was that Garnet was trying to figure out who that "strange man" prowling the castle was (Kuja), it was incredibly obvious that Kuja was the source of the problem, and that the characters should have been focusing on him straight from the get go, instead of wasting time with the whole pointless Brahne and Burmecia thing (don't fight the symptoms, fight the disease), if a "suspicious person" (which is an understatement for Kuja, just look at his fashion sense) shows up at your home, starts meeting with your mom, and said mom starts acting crazy, it should be REEEALLLLY obvious that the person responsible is said suspicious stranger and you should find out who he is, where he operates and go after HIM, yet in the game Garnet dosen't even remotely come to this obvious conclusion up until after running home like a complete idiot, getting captured, and in her room suddenly proclaimed "gasp the incredibly suspicious person whom my mother meets with after which my mother suddenly started acting crazy was the REASON for said mother going crazy, I am TOTALLY SURPRISED by this not-at-all obvious answer that I'm just realizing now and should have seen from the very beginning", I'm just going to say this is one of the biggest face palm moments in the entire game, it's just another cheap rehash of the "man behind the man" plotline from the previous games, twice with FFIV's King of Baron (fiend of water in disguise) and Golbez (manipulated by Zemus), FFV with multiple people (controlled by Exdeath), FFVIII with Edea (controlled by Ultimecia), those were all less obvious and more vague from the start.
Also I'm just going to put out another massive face palm moment in the entire game involved with this, Cid being aware of the enemy being after the Eidolons, I'm not even kidding here is the line directly from the game: "Brahne was after the <gwok> eidolons. That much, I knew." Sigh So let me get this straight Cid Fabool, you knew that the queen was after the Eidolons yet before all the events that transpired you never bothered to share this INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT information with the cast, ESPECIALLY to the daughter of said queen who has said Eidolons WITHIN HER (that you should be well aware of) so that they would be more cautious?
Okay I'm wrapping this up, but before we get to number 1, let's go over some dishonourable mentions.
Eiko
Eiko while nowhere near as annoying, never got a flashback, we never see her late Grandfather nor get an explaination of who he is. Heck, even her and Amarant's last names are really lazy as they are just the same word but with the a and o switched. Also the whole being adopted by Cid and Hilda came right out of nowhere, I'm sorry but did they even meet? There was no build up or character interaction with them whatsoever.
The Music
Compared to other Final Fantasy games or heck other games franchises in general, FFIX's soundtrack is really disappointing, aside from "Melodies of Life" most of the music is bland, generic and uninspired, it feels like Nobuo Uematsu wasn't really using his A-game, ironically the man himself calls this his favourite soundtrack, I honestly believe it's only his favourite because it was the easiest to do, after the hard and tiring work done on the complex music of the previous FFs, this was basically a holiday break for him. Maybe this is why Square started using him less and less for the games afterward.
Cid being an Oglop and Hilda
Okay, so Cid's wife Queen Hilda turns her husband into a Oglop because he had an affair with a waitress, then she TAKES the first Gaian Airship to run without Mist, the Hilda Guarde, and flys off to "blow off steam", leaving their whole kingdom in turmoil with one of their leaders being weaker both physically and mentally. Look I get being angry at your husband for not keeping his loins loyal to you, but what's not justified however is the incredibly selfish actions of STEALING an important revolutionary airship that would be especially helpful during a dire situation and risking something happing to prevent you from coming back (which big shock, does) just because you were frustrated and abandoned your own leadership while worsening the other leadership by turning him into a easily squashible bug with a weaker mindset to the point where he couldn't design airships (speaking of which, it makes no sense that they couldn't properly construct another Hilda Guarde just because Cid was an Ooglop, yes his mind wasn't the same as an Ooglop, but they could have simply reused the blue prints for the first Hilda Guarde and construct an exact copy), if she really wanted to blow off steam she simply could have went out of the castle for a bit and hang around town waiting for Cid to seriously make an apology.
Let's talk about the actual condition itself, the Ooglop status spell on Cid apparently can't be removed by a remedy or a esuna spell apparently Hilda herself has to remove the spell, how ridiculously broken is this spell? Is Hilda like the most powerful Mage ever? Why don't they just use Hilda to turn all the antagonists into Ooglops? This whole thing is just another cheap plot device and massive story breaker power and the game even drags you on a pointless fetch quest over this whole thing to make more filler.
The World Building
Again, the above mentioned commenter summed it up best:
"Remember that whole "Mist" thing? Well, guess what. Mist is not only a pretty pointless plot device, but it's also used as an excuse for a lackluster world for it all to take place in. Let first say that the way the game is structured, you don't really notice it at first. The main continent, the one covered in Mist, is masterfully realized. It's interesting, feels intelligently connected and well thought out and is used as a solid central area to take our adventure on. The place is varied, green, sometimes strikingly beautiful. The main continent is one of the finest examples of a "fantasy land" the series has ever done.
Then you venture outside it. The world is brown, lifeless, dull. Sure, the story might say "it's because there's no mist" but Mist really only is there to be used as a power source, ala steam. Are you to tell me the world would be brown and dull and uninteresting because there's no Mist at all? Is it some sort of pollination the Mist causes? The fact is this: outside the main continent, the world of Final Fantasy IX is just a bland dull rock of uselessness. Oh, there's some interesting indvidual spots here and there, and like the mian continent there's a "history" or sense of purpose to the locations - something Final Fantasy IX is good in, but it's sure boring as hell to get to those and really not even worth the effort because, if you recall, you'll be getting into a boring battle every three steps.
As a result, the entire world is much smaller than you even realize. There's simply nothing to do or go on with the other two larger masses the world has, and you can't help but think if the budget was cut and they just made do with it all. To this, it makes me wonder - why bother? Why not have the main countries of this world be a part of a larger landmass (such as fantasy often does, Lord of the Rings a perfect example) and not try to shoe-horn in an entire world. That's just unbelievable and nonsensical. I'd be much more inclined to believe that there's a boundary that nobody has crossed and there lies places like Kuja's desert palace than I am to believe that nobody got in a boat and sailed to explore.
Perhaps this comes from the lack of establishing a history of the world. In reality, all the Final Fantasy games rarely go into the story of what happened before the events of the game. It touches here and there, maybe past wars and leaders, but is overall really shallow. I don't think Final Fantasy IX ever attempts to explain why the rest of the world just sucks other than "there's no mist there" as if Mist is the end all, be all of everything. I think the story wanted to have a slight environmental message here, Mist being a commodity to the world of Gaia as oil is here (or Mako in Final Fantasy VII, far more blunt) but it's never really delved into.
And that's the thing - it shouldn't be. It shouldn't be an issue. So instead of trying to use it to explain why the world is so uninteresting outside our main land, just don't bother with the world at all. Expand that main land, and you might have yourself quite the setting. As it is...it's just a wasted effort."