r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Discussion American Psycho Explanation

640 Upvotes

I've written two papers on this film and figured I could try my best to explain some confusing parts of the film.

Spoliers from here on out

American Psycho is a film about a man who is unsure about his identity. He wants desperately to fit in with the other yuppies, but also wants to be an intelligent free-thinking individual. Eventually his internal conflict becomes so troubling that he finds catharsis by murdering people.

I can offer my view on some common questions people have after viewing the film. #1 What's the deal with the music monologues? Why does everyone call each other the wrong names? Did Patrick really kill all those people, and if he did how come he didn't get caught?

I'll start with the music monologues. Lets look at the musicians he talks about Genesis, Huey Lewis & The News, and Whitney Houston. Not exactly the deepest and most profound stuff out there, considering that the film was set in the late 80s this was the pop music of the time, this would kind of be like breaking down Pitbull or Adele music (bear with me, I don't know many current artists).

Patrick breaks down these musicians because he wants to feel smart, he wants people to know he doesn't just listen to music but that he understands it and wants his opinions heard and validated. He also picks pop music because it is usually just skin deep and its all he understands and has ever known and most of it is just dates, record sales, chart positions and various facts about the artists without any true analysis. He basically recites the albums wikipedia page with a random nugget or two of actual analysis. A good quote for this is during the Genesis speech.

"I've been a big Genesis fan ever since the release of their 1980 album, Duke. Before that, I really didn't understand any of their work. Too artsy, too intellectual."

He admits that he is too dense to understand anything that he finds "too artsy". This is evidenced by his apartment as well. His artwork looks to be all contemporary undoubtedly purchased either for him or recommended based on artist name, he has a Les Miserables poster (The play had just come out in the films timeline), and a bunch of pop music cds. He only likes whats popular, essentially because its popular.

Ironically, no one he speaks to about music every really listens to what he is saying, he is basically talking at the prostitutes and/or Paul. He brings up Whitney Houston and is laughed at by a prostitute, and Paul Allen doesn't listen to a word Patrick says about Huey.

TL;DR: The music monologues represent Patrick's identity crisis because he feels unheard and wants to be something he is not. His problems are reinforced by the fact that the prostitutes and Paul don't listen and that he doesn't even fully understand the music.

Another common question is "Why do they call each other by different names?" This plays into Patrick's identity crisis as well. The point being made here is that in Patrick's Wall Street, yuppie world there really is no significant difference between any of the people and everyone confuses each other for someone else because they all look and act the same anyway. They all fit this cookie-cutter mold of designer suits, expensive haircuts, luxury cars, etc. and all look to one up each other for no apparent reason other than one upping each other. Patrick's internal conflict is that he A: Wants nothing more than to one up his "friends" and B: Wants to be a unique individual. These desires directly conflict each other because to outdo them he needs to not only conform to a yuppie lifestyle, but be the best at conforming.

A great example of this is the famous business card scene, the coworkers get in a dick measuring contest over who's got the best designed business card. The thing is, all of the business cards are pretty much identical. White paper, black text, and similar fonts (they even have the same contact info and job title) but Bateman is crushed when his peers laud a coworkers more than his own card. His jealousy is enhanced when his coworker gets a reservation at the hip restaurant Dorsia to eat sea urchins. Like the pop music Dorsia is something he cares about doing just because its popular. In reality eating sea urchins sounds terrible, and is not something he actually wants to do, but since it is “in” he desperately wants to do just to one up his coworker.

TL;DR They call each other by different names because everyone is so similar, and interchangeable. They are all shallow and void of a personality. Patrick wants to be able to fit the mold to a tee and be a free-thinking individual, which is his internal conflict.

Of course the big question everyone has is “Did Patrick really commit those murders?” And the answer is for the most part yes, with a bit of a wrinkle. I believe Patrick did commit the murders except for the crimes committed during the killing spree initiated by the ATM. Up until the ATM scene everything Patrick had done had been while far-fetched, at least possible. When the ATM commands Patrick to feed him the cat we start to get into some really unrealistic and almost cartoonish territory. He kills the old woman and the police are there instantly. He hits the cop car and it bursts into flames with one shot. Patrick’s improbable reign continues until he gets back to his office, where he leaves a confession voicemail to his lawyer. The voicemail is confirmed as taking place by the lawyer who thinks it is a joke. What I think really happened is that Patrick’s descent into madness spiraled out of control, he stayed in his office all night doing drugs, drinking and becoming more insane by the minute. He envisions himself committing those acts in a haze of inebriation and figures there is no way out so he confesses to the lawyer.

Another reason people don’t believe that he committed the murders is because when he is talking to his lawyer (after the voicemail) his says that Paul Allen can’t be dead, because he just had dinner with him the other night. This one is explained by the fact that the lawyer much like the other characters, is constantly confusing the names people throughout the entire film he is even calling Patrick “Davis” throughout this encounter. The lawyer was probably having dinner with some other yuppie and confused him for Paul.

The final question people typically have is “If Patrick did commit the murders, why didn't the Realtor turn him in? She would have had to discover the body parts because Paul’s apartment was clean, and she never said a word about it.” The film has put us in an incredibly shallow world where money and status is king, and if the realtor turned in Patrick she would stand to lose thousands on commission money (an apartment like that overlooking the park was probably one of her most valuable properties). The value would nosedive if it was discovered that horrid murders took place there, so she sweeps it under the rug to avoid the commotion. When Patrick shows up and is wondering where the body parts when she sternly ushers him out and gives him a cold stare. She knew exactly what he had done, and didn’t care as long as she got her property back.

TL;DR Patrick committed all the crimes sans the ATM killing spree, the selfishness of the lawyer and realtor helped him get away with it.

And I also believe Patrick would continue to kill, as in the end he narrates about how he wants others to feel his pain, about how he has learned nothing and felt no catharsis, and that his confession meant nothing.

I kind of had to rush this together so if anything doesn't make sense or if I missed something I can clarify.


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 31 '15

Video Drive explained

Thumbnail
youtube.com
61 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Video TOP GUN - as expounded on by Quentin Tarantino

Thumbnail
youtube.com
60 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Jun 07 '19

Video I Am Mother: Ending Explained | Full Breakdown And Spoiler Review Of The Netflix Movie Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
54 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Apr 20 '20

Video I go far too deep into movies. Here's a 1 Hour 20 minute dissertation on Robert Eggers' 'The Lighthouse'

Thumbnail
youtube.com
48 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 31 '15

Request (Request) Spirited Away

47 Upvotes

I don't understand what "No Face" was, if Sen remembered what had happened or not and if the film had a specific message and if so, what was it?


r/FilmsExplained • • Oct 24 '19

Charlie don't surf

40 Upvotes

In the 1979 cult classic 'Apocalypse Now' Robert Duval's character (Luitenant Kilgore) uses the phrase

Charlie don't surf

After googling I noticed it used in a lot of songs and mainstream culture, but I don't understand why that quote has the huge significance it has today. For what I understand it basically means 'Fuck that' but I fail to see how it would be linked in this way.

Can anyone elaborate?


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Video Enemy EXPLAINED - Movie Review (SPOILERS)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
40 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Sep 11 '26

Discussion Butchers Crossing (2022) - Why was this in the movie?

Post image
39 Upvotes

So there is this movie titled Butchers Crossing starring the one and only Nicolas Cage. Pretty much everything was shot on location in Montana, which is why the movie looks absolutely stunning and beautiful. Regardless of the story, it’s just a nice movie to look it, that the scenery alone is worth it.

HOWEVER!

There is this f**** scene I posted the screenshot from. The Green screen is so horrendous that if you look closely you can see the shadow of the actor falling onto the wall.

The scene goes for around 10-20 seconds and is obviously just stock footage with the actors placed infront of it.

It serves no purpose whatsoever, they speak two words and it has no impact on the overall runtime or the plot.

So why the holy f*** is this atrocious shot in the movie that is filmed 99% on location. I understand that budget constraints and reshoots can be a reason but the scene is pointless. Nothing happens, it’s as if it’s only there to show of the green screen effect.

You could cut it out and it wouldn’t impact a damn thing. It would actually make the transition from the previous scene to the next one so much smoother if this piece of s*** would be missing.

I know it’s super far fetched, but maybe somebody here knows someone who had worked on the movie and could explain to my why this was in the film. I just can’t wrap my head around this.

Thank you!


r/FilmsExplained • • Feb 01 '15

Request Borgman (2013 Dutch film)

37 Upvotes

This is one of those movies where I'm watching it on the edge of my seat, fascinated to find out the solution to a taut, suspenseful mystery.

But then comes the ending. And I'm not sure what just happened.

  1. Did I miss an important scene or clue? Am I just a little slow on the uptake, here? The first time I watched Frailty, I hated it and felt cheated by the confusing ending. Until I watched the DVD extras and realized what was really going on. Then it became one of my favorite movies, so I am definitely capable of being dense...

  2. Is the movie more complex and subtle than I thought on first viewing? 2001 is one of my favorite movies, but it has this zen-like quality of conveying things that are too big to convey, depicting things that are too vast to see, describing things that are beyond conception. It doesn't have the kind of "Oh, I get it, the guy was a ghost the whole time" type explanation. But there is a there, there, so to speak. There is a plot, with genuine causality and structure, and an actual "payoff", it's just a bigger and more existential kind of payoff than "catching the bad guy" or "returning the stolen necklace"...

  3. Or is this ultimately (as I fear), just a kind of art-house shaggy-dog story, like a music video that just strings together cool imagery and clever gimmicks?

I really, really don't want it to be option 3, because the set-up was so well done in terms of suspense and winding up the spring... if there is no "payoff", if all the mystery is just a bunch of unexplained gimmicks, then I will be really disappointed and annoyed by the cop-out. I understand that you can have movies like 2001 or the Seventh Seal, and that sometimes it's better not to show what's inside Marcellus Wallace's case, and Alien was a better and scarier movie for having the unexplained iconography, giant skeleton, etc. But if you load a gun and put it on the mantlepiece in Act 1, it needs to get fired by Act 3, as they say.

Some of the guns that this movie loaded, and placed on the mantlepiece, very deliberately and conspicuously, include:

  • The scars/surgeries,

  • The dogs,

  • The ritualistic body-disposal,

  • Borgman's influence over dreams,

  • The whole living underground business,

  • The religiosity and origins of Borgman and his entourage,

etc etc. Now, maybe not every one of these has a tidy payoff like "Rose had the necklace the whole time!", but to me it is outright cheating if you load up a movie with all that kind of stuff and then roll credits without solving the riddles. You can have some stuff that is just pure atmospherics, symbolism, or iconography, but in Borgman's case, we're talking about essentially the whole movie. If it's just red herring after red herring, then frankly I think it's just a pretentious waste of time.

So I really, really would love to hear an explanation that brings some of these things together, because the setup in Borgman was so well-done. But if it's just setup with no payoff, then I think the whole thing was basically a cheat.

Give me faith, reddit!


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 31 '15

Discussion The Truman Show

37 Upvotes

Hey guys, I've been wondering what people generally think of this film. It's one of my all-time top favorites, and I've never had a full-fledged discussion about it.

Things like, "We accept the reality with which we are presented" raise all sorts of questions for me. After seeing it a couple times when I was younger, I sort of decided it was a satirical, coming of age story about leaving the church. I may be totally off base with that thought, though.

So what do you think?


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 31 '15

Request I still don't understand how the end on ace ventura pet detective makes sense, anyone?

35 Upvotes

He got a few guesses wrong with that lady but for some reason her terrible hemorrhoids cracks the case? Granted I haven't seen it in a while but that's what I remember and it doesn't make sense.


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Discussion Mullholand Dr. Explained

33 Upvotes

The beautiful thing about David Lynch's Mullholand Dr. is how even as a poetic/ mind bending movie, it does not have a vague interpretation but a very specific one.

Some movies similar to this, are really up to the individual to drawn his very own conclusions, parallelisms, symbolisms etc. But not this movie.

So first a brief explanation of what happens in the movie.

The movie

Movie is introduced, people dancing (Swinging). Rita, a sexy mysterious woman barely escapes an execution attempt only to find shelter in some completely random nice house. Betty, a jolly good ol' innocent girl from rural America arrives at the airport, thanks an old couple for everything and arrives at her aunt's house which hosts the vulnerable and fragile Rita. She is a straggling actress and she wows everyone in her very first audition.

But soon we are introduced to some douchey director who is forced by a superior stronger force to chose a specific girl for his movie instead of Betty. The superior force being the Italian producers, who are so intimidating that everyone starts freaking out when one of them is not pleased with his coffee.

The director disagrees with him and soon his bank account freezes, he gets cheated on by his wife, he gets beaten up by her lover, he gets paint on him and on his amazing supercar and eventually gives in and choses to not hire Betty.

Meanwhile Betty is stuggling to uncover the mystery of Rita's origin. So they go to Mullholand Dr. where they discover a dead body. At this point it is also important to note that an incompetent serial killer has been introduced, that completely messes up one of his jobs and of course the infamous restaurant scene where a man describes one of his dreams about a scary character, and eventually indeed meets the character behind the restaurant and dies.

One night Rita wakes up repeating Silencio and introduces a tiny little box.We never see what is in it. Soon they go to Silencio where "there is no band, everything is just a recording". As a girl is singing a Spanish translation of Roy Orbison's Crying the girls look inside the tiny little box and start violently shaking.

Second Phase

Then the second phase of the movie starts were Betty is now introduced as Diane and really...she is not all that jolly after all. The sparkle is gone, she looks tired and long story short

she is a struggling actress

Rita is getting married to the director,

it is assumed that they had a relationship but it is over now,

Diane lives in a small less prestigious house in Mullholand Dr.,

goes to Rita's party,

gets asked how she ended up in this town and says how she won a dancing competition,

hires a killer to kill Rita over jealousy and

eventually kills herself whilst a tiny old couple walks around her floor.

Explanation

Everyone can easily understand how the first part is a dream sequence. The paranormal is completely absent from the second phase of the movie and the whole direction of the movie changes.

It's Diane's fantasy and how she justifies her surroundings, views her environment.

She didn't get the job not because she is not a good actress but because of the Italian guys. Rita is a vulnerable girl in dire need of her help. They live in an amazing house. The director, who in reality stole Rita from her, is punished, ridiculed and laughed at. In her mind, Diane wants to be an innocent girl from Kansas or whatever. The whole dream sequence ended as they opened the tiny box and started shaking. "it is all a recording" translates to it is all just a memory.

its done. it is over. it will never be again.

I am ashamed for how long it took me to realize what the tiny box contained. It contains the director's wedding ring. which grounds Diane back to reality.

As for the incompetent killer, it refers to Diane's fear that he is going to mess up and she will end up getting busted.

As for the restaurant scene, it is heavily linked with the scene where they discover the dead body in Mullholand Dr. and pretty much it explains the whole movie.

It is a self fulfilling prophecy. Simply because he pursued it, it happened. He visualized it first. As Diane visualized her very own suicide.

Lastly it is important to make the connection between the old couple in the beginning, their tiny versions in the end, the opening credits with the dancers and the party scene where she explains how she ended up there by winning a dancing competition. These are the people responsible for sending her there IF she is not lying which is not important at this moment.

Pretty much the only thing I haven't figured out yet is the cowboy man and what his purpose is.


r/FilmsExplained • • Jun 08 '26

Can anyone explain me this movie Mulholland Drive (2001) by David Lynch?

Post image
32 Upvotes

I just finished watching this film and ive been so curious about it all. Ive been reading about it on reddit and im so confused by all the clues and perspectives. Did david lynch really gave a meaning to this film or do we have to keep guessing? But honestly we got major clues by the film itself im just confused by some parts especially the black man and club silincio


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 31 '15

Request [Request] Birdman or The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance

32 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Discussion Shyamalan's Signs (2002) has the biggest twist ever.

30 Upvotes

It is not spoonfed to the people.

The characters in the movie misguide you well in reality they are just trying to make sense of what is going on and each give their own explanation.

Shyamalan took a big hit for the deus ex machina that saved the day...which was essentialy tap water.

Twist and Spoilers: It was not tap water.

It was Holy Water


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Video An incredible interpretation of Inception. "Inception and Philosophy".

Thumbnail
youtube.com
29 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Feb 17 '15

Request [Request] Oldboy (2003)

27 Upvotes

Anyone want to explain what the hell happened at the end of that film?


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Image Pulp Fiction explained

Thumbnail
static1.squarespace.com
27 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Mar 22 '19

Discussion Why is the intermission in 2001: A Space Odyssey where it is?

26 Upvotes

2001 is an absolute favorite and I've watched it many times, but I've always wondered why the intermission comes so late in the film.

Story-wise, it seems like the perfect place for a break would be after the radio signal on the Moon, so that we return from the intermission and interlude to "JUPITER MISSION, 18 MONTHS LATER" and spend the rest of the film on board Discovery.

I suppose it could be argued that Kubrick wanted to show us life aboard the ship, have us meet the characters we'd be watching from then on.

Anyone have any other ideas?


r/FilmsExplained • • Jul 25 '26

Which scene is more epic? Agamemnon entering Troy Odysseus stringing the bow

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Which one do you like best?


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

An interactive animation explaining Inception

Thumbnail
inception-explained.com
23 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Sep 01 '15

Lars Von Trier's - Melancholia

21 Upvotes

Copy paste from another post.

Yes there has.

Spoilers and analysis for Lars Von Trier's Melancholia.

This is a disaster movie. What makes it so unique is that it has absolutely zero cliches. There is no technology. There is no internet, no news, no imagery of the Acropolis/Aiffel tower/ Lady Liberty/ China Wall get bombarded by meteors.

There is only Kirsten Dunst, her family and a large number of people attending her wedding in some vineyard, castle chatteu.

Kirsten is a cunt. She cheats on her husband during her wedding with some stupid nobody she doesn't even like. Notably she is also exceptionally rude to her former boss which eventually causes him to leave the place. She is emotionally detouched at all times except from the time where her father tells her how he has to leave. This is the only time we see her re - act.

Why?

Because she knows. She just knows.

There is a jar of beans or lentils in the wedding. And the person that guesses closer to the number of beans/lentils that it contains wins some kind of prize. Kirsten guesses the exact number and the butler asks her how does she know. She replies, I just know.

Enter the second half of the movie.

Apparently an asteroid is coming close to the Earth. Kirsten's sister is worried, but her husband, Kiefer Sutherland is the reasonable one. He makes everyone feel safe by reassuring them that the asteroid will not crush but leave. He even goes as far to create a small mechanism that people can use as a tool to measure how much closer it comes, a circle the size of the asteroid. As it comes closer, the asteroid does not fit in the circle, as the asteroid leaves, it grows smaller and fits again.

They all get together to witness the moment the asteroid gets the closest and suddenly people cant breath. Because the asteroid's gravitational force pulls the atmosphere away from the ground temporarily. Soon later things return back to normal as the asteroid leaves.

A few days later, as Kirsten's sister seats with the mechanism in her hand, she decides to check it one more time, only to find out that....the asteroid is coming back. Sutherland, the voice of reason, the pillar of safety in that movie...kills himself! Kirsten is unresponsive again.

Because she just knew. She never cared about the wedding. She knew everything is pointless. She is a nihilist.

But, and that is the important thing here. She said she just knew the number of the beans in the jar. She showed she knew about the disaster that was comming, when she cheated on her idiot husband with an dumb nobody and when she cried for her father as she begged him to stay.

But she also said it one more time.

"Claire (Her sister):Then maybe life somewhere else.

Justine (Kirsten): But there isn't.

Claire: How do you know?

Justine: Because I know things.

Claire: Oh yes, you always imagined you did.

Justine: I know we're alone."

She just knows we are alone.

According to the "Rare Earth Hypothesis" the chances of life existing elsewhere... are NIL.

If our Sun was too close to the center of the galaxy, everything would get melted by supernova radiation

Too far along the edge of the galaxy and it wouldn't be able to support life.

If the Sun was too old, too bright, or too big, complex life wouldn't develop.

Earth needs to be in a perfect orbit. If it was 5 percent smaller or 15 percent larger we would all freeze or burn to death, respectively.

If the moon was of a different size and a different axis, the Earth would be in a constant state of tremor, earthquakes and tsunamis

SPOILER FOR INTERSTELLAR: This also explains the event in the water planet.

If the sequence of geologic eras was different, if the Mesozoic had occurred after the Cenozoic, for example, the exact conditions needed for human life to develop might never have been met, upsetting the evolutionary order and resulting in a race of dinosaur humans.

Jupiter protects the Earth from cosmic debris and world-ending asteroids would be more frequent thus life would not have evolved.

The chances of life existing elsewhere are not only ridiculously low, but really...non existant.

But really, that is where things escape the field of science and enter the field of philosophy and even religion.

Are we really nothing but a happy accident?

According to Kirsten yes. Nothing but an accident. A pointless anomaly in energy/matter and time that will fix itself before the Big Freeze, the end of the universe.


r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Video PROMETHEUS EXPLAINED

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes

r/FilmsExplained • • Jan 30 '15

Discussion Donnie Darko

20 Upvotes

Some please explain this movie to me, or I will always think of it as a piece of shit Hipsters choose to like thinking they're super cool.