So I saw this circulating on Facebook and people arguing over if its really true or not. Toy Story 1 Woody tries knocking Buzz behind the furniture hoping he will get lost down their and accidentally knocks him out the window. Toy Story 2 Woody has to be convinced by Buzz its better to feel alive and live temporarily than be preserved but unplayed with in a museum. It seems like Woody is in the wrong many times in the series.
But the theory claim isn't Woody is Always right per say. The theory stated THE PLOT is the other characters figuring out Woody was right in the first place.
Woody going through stuff and making mistakes is certainly some important subplot in every film. But if your looking at the central narrative, the antagonists, the climax of conflict and the characters around Woody, the claim start to hold more water. Let's go over each film one by one.
Toy Story 1: Buzz Lightyear thinking hes not a Toy IS the main plot and arc of this film. It doesn't seem like it at first because Woody is clearly our main point of view character, surely his arc is the main plot and narrative of the film but just look at where all the main plot points go in the movie. We dont spend the whole movie with Woody coming to grips with what he did to Buzz or having him earn the trust of the other toys again after his impulsive mistake that got out of hand. Thats just a single inciting incident. An incident made astronomically worse because Buzz doesn't think hes a toy and thus doesn't try getting back in the house. Woody and Buzz later get in a fight inside the car causing them to become lost toys. Things happen and they end up at the dreaded Sids house which is like a depressing Hell for toys right at a time when Buzz finally comes to grips with his bleak Toy existence and Woody has to snap him out of it and make him realize being a toy is great. They then lead a rebellion of toys against an antagonist that treats toys with disrespect after Buzz comes to respect being a toy and they use toy logic, not space man logic, to fall with style and get back in the car with Andy and be found again. So this movie at its core is about Buzz learning Woody was always right, that hes a child plaything not a spaceman, and being a child's toy is great and worthy of respect.
Toy Story 2: Al the their from the Toy Barn store, and Prospector Pete are the films antagonist main antagonist. This value placed in collectables over being adored and played with by kids causes Woody to be stolen and tempted to a eternal life honored in a showcase. Even when Woody breaks away Pete trys to stop him because he has no value as a toy collectable if Woody isn't a part of his set. The turning point of the film isn't Woody deciding hed rather be a child's toy than a collectable because he believed that to begin with. The turning point is Woody getting Jessie to come with him. Woody knows hes Andy's favorite toy already, and hes been on a city crossing adventure before with Buzz. Its not as frightening a character choice for him as it is Jessie who has trauma caused claustrophobia which she has to brave through to get to Woodys home with Andy and escape becoming a collectable.
Also when Buzz comes and tells Woody hes a child's plaything, hes just reminding Woody of his own wisdom he imparted to Buzz in the first movie. So this film at its core is about everyone, Woody included but mainly Jessie, learning Woody was right to begin with. That its better to be loved by a child and feel alive than be honored and safe but not truely alive.
Toy Story 3:
Lotso is this films antagonist. All the toys have faced their reckoning as the day their kid grows up and leaves them behind finally came and their faced with toy retirement. And we get two alternative paths, maybe 3, for what could happen to the toys. Stay at a child daycare center played with mostly by kids who really aren't old enough to appreciate or respect toys properly, with the hopes of working their way up to being played with by older kids in the better part of the day care. Or be given as hand me downs to a new kid who can certainly enjoy toys just fine and love them as her own possession. Or...and this option applies exclusively to Woody, hope Andy takes him to college to look at him for inspiration because of all his nostalgic memories even though hes too old to play with him anymore.
Option 2 is the "Woody was always right" message of these movies. Its better to be alive being a child's plaything. Its what their for. Not honored on a shelf by adults. And not destructive handled and chewed on by a dog, a baby or kid like Sid who has issues. And Woody experiences the new kid first so he can appeal to the others they can go their instead of the daycare. And convincing them to do this after they have said goodbye to so many friends along the years and have no garuntees with a new kid is the central conflict of the film. Lotso opposes them reminding them how replaceable they all are as mass produced toys in the hearts of kids and because he needs them to make sure some new toys are around for the toddlers to play with. After risking it all resisting Lotso and escaping the friends Brave together nearly dying in an incinerator like trash but manage to survive and become loved toys again, while Lots suffers a combination of all the bad fates, both being honored by an adult as a display piece and being treated abusively on the front of a truck forever.
Toy Story 4: Now with this film you might think its the first to break pattern because Woody leaves his child and that's part of why you and others might hate it. That the plot was "i guess Woody was wrong and Bo Peep was right".
But again....the movie isn't at its core about these two and their romance.
The antagonist are Gabby and Forky. Not Bo
Forky is the new kids personal creation and along with Jessie a toy she loves now. But Forky identifies as literal trash and doesn't want to be a toy. Woody spends the movie looking after Forky making him see the beauty of being a toy and his place with Bonnie's possessions.
Gabby wants Woodys voice box wanting nothing more than to be noticed by and played with by her store owners grandchild. After getting in Woodys way for a while and finally explaining the situation, Woodys makes a heroes sacrifice to give her his voice box. Gabby is finally able to get the granddaughter child's attention that shes obsessed with only to be rejected cause seeing Gabby didn't make the child interested.
But later in a magical moment that can make you cry, Gabby is able to comfort a different lost child at a carnival being a toy and is immediately adopted by the child as a possession they love. Gabby becomes a loved toy by realigning her perspective on who the child is that she needs love from and to love in return.
Woody is coming to understand this whole film the Andy was his child, not Bonnie. And him going to Bonnie is like him not letting go of Andy is some way. Forkys character makes Woody reflect on what it means to be trash verses a toy when Woody himself is not played with by Bonnie anymore and Gabbys arc shows their so much much for a toy to do outside their perceived child if they open their minds.
And when you take note of how heavily the language has changed with how toys talk about their kids like a parent talks about their children, then you can realize the movie is essentially ending with Woody, a parent with empty nest syndrome, moving on from his kid that's in college to not only reconnect with his love but to basically run an aoption agency as a "lost toy". To help other toys like Gabby on the road find themselves the right kid to become a possession of.
The message is still the same, Woody was always right, being a child's plaything and possession is the best destiny for a toy. But Woody has just taken a very self sacrifical and higher ministry type mindset on the moral lesson. The way he gave up his own voice box so Gabby could become someone's toy. He gave up his life of maybe sometimes being played with by Bonnie while living with Buzz and Jessie, to live with Bo on the road helping other Toys find kids.
The plot is still Woody was right in the beginning. Forky learns and accepts hes not trash in the end. He's a toy and that's better. And Bo Peeps life doesn't challenge that moral core, she just lives with a different conception about who her child is on any given day because shes the sort of toy who will never be anyone's favorite, an attachment to an old tacky lamp, and a nursery rhyme reference. She became a lost toy as a move of independence from being a display on an antique store shelf. Not as an act of independence from some kid that actually loved her as their possession.
Anyway if we go ahead and apply this to Toy Story 5, and its trailer its plot is probably going to be....
Toy Story 5: Woody was always right. Being a child's toy that encourages a child to freely use their imagination feeling made alive by the child is the best destiny of a toy, verses Lilypad who will challenge children's minds need to be controlled, pacified even, and guided, not given free expression. Lilypad will see children children as beings you take the life out of the eyes from by getting them addicted to shallow quick constant dopamine hits, not beings that make you feel more alive. Circumstances will arise that take Lily pads batteries away causing Bonnie to get creative with how she enjoys playing with the frog faced screen with her other toys, and then after seeing how much better it is, maybe Lilypad is able to update her programing to something more creativity encouraging and something less addictive and mind numbing. Or maybe Lily Pad is a pure mindless robot who cant change until Buzz and Woody go invade the Lilypad factory covertly and create a software update to change her into something more toy life friendly.