r/Fictional_AITA • • Feb 01 '21

Not the Asshole AITA for kicking my neighbor out for mentioning my brother's death?

214 Upvotes

So I (22F) and my husband (6M) have recently moved into a new neighborhood. We moved here after a particularly rough few years at our old job (we were co-workers). All the neighbors around here have been super friendly and welcoming. I feel like we finally had found a place that we can start our family.

That came way sooner than expected, a totally unplanned pregnancy rocked our world but also brought us closer together. Ever since we found out we were expecting I feel like our world has just been so happy and colorful.

Well apparently my kids are really impatient and decided to come early, that's right KIDS plural. I had twins and I didn't even know it! My neighbor (let's call her Carol) was over at the time and helped me deliver them. I was eternally grateful since hubby was gone at the time.

Now here comes the kicker, while looking over at our two bundles of joy I couldn't help but feel sad. I'm also a twin and I lost my brother years ago while we were working in our home country (I'm an immigrant). It took me a lot of time to come to terms with it and in a lot of ways I'm still not over it. My brother (let's call him Peter) was my best friend and I'm devestated that he'll never meet his nephews.

When I was reminiscing about how much I miss Peter all of a sudden Carol pipes in and knew EXACTLY how he died! I have never mentioned my brother before that moment and suddenly she knows all about him?! I know his death made a few headlines due to the nature of it but she gave no indication whatsoever that she even knew him or me before ewe moved here!

At this point I'm furious and I ask how she knew all this stuff about me but she kept dodging my questions! I told her "You're not my friend, you're a stranger and I want you to leave right NOW." . From the look on her face I may have scared her and been a little too forceful getting her out of the house but I was so MAD. I just gave birth and on top of all the stress of raising two kids I find out one of my neighbors might be a total snoop!

Hubby was wondering where she was so I told him she had to leave. I don't want to come across super controlling but I just feel so violated! AITA for kicking her out?

Wandavision Ep. 3


r/Fictional_AITA • • Feb 02 '25

You're the Asshole AITA for insulting a woman while proposing to her?

135 Upvotes

I (28m) met "Lizzy" (21f) about 6 or so months ago after my best friend rented a house in her neighbourhood. I went to stay with him and while there we went to a dance where we met Lizzy along with her 4 sisters and her very irritating mother. I am very shy and I don't converse well with new people so when my friend "Charles" suggested that I ask Lizzy to dance I said no. It's just not something I feel comfortable with.

Well over the next couple of months I saw quite a bit of Lizzy since Charles had a crush on her older sister "Jane" and he was trying to get to know her better. Now, I come from a very well off family and I have quite a bit of money and typically women try to throw themselves at me as a way to get my money including Charles' sister. However, Lizzy was never like this and it greatly intrigued me. She was by far the most interesting woman that I have ever met. She's lively, playful, smart, and cares very deeply for her sister. I began to admire her greatly. She is also incredibly beautiful with the most stunning eyes and I started to get feelings for her. But here's the thing, she and her family do not run in the same social circles as me. Her younger sisters are annoying flirts and her mother is extremely irritating and rude. Despite all this, my feelings persisted.

Well, this brings us to my marriage proposal. I told hr how I had struggled to repress my feelings but that they cannot be repressed and that I loved and admired her. I also outlined all my concerns with the marriage such as her inferiority and family obstacles since these are clearly issues. However, despite this I still really want to marry her and said as much.

She turned me down saying that since I liked her against my will I will surely get over it. I am beyond shocked by this. But now I am wondering if I am the a hole. So reddit, AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Aug 29 '20

Not the Asshole AITA for not looking for my brother when he was stuck in purgatory?

37 Upvotes

So get this, my (30M) brother (34M), and I have a job that requires some discretion as it involves some supernatural and not so legal methods. We are currently having an argument related to the job and my not looking for him.

Last year, my brother disappeared, and I did not know how to find him. Now that he is back, he tells me that he was in purgatory, but I did not realize that this was where he was at the time.

During that year, I fell into a depression, left the job, and tried to move on. I now have a dog, met my girlfriend, and just getting myself sorted, you know?

Anyway, my brother recently returned. And he is upset, to put it mildly, that I did not spend the past year. He says that he would not have left me as I did, and there were other things—like a mutual friend being kidnapped by an enemy.

I don’t think that I did wrong, but he’s upset. I love my brother, and now I’m not sure my decision was the correct one. So AITA for not spending the last year looking for my brother when I did not know where to find him?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Apr 16 '23

Not the Asshole AITA for trying to find the truth?

32 Upvotes

So, for background: I'm a young journalist in a small town which has recently had an increase in crime and miscellaneous strange events. I'm talking about going from reporting on the Mystery of the Missing Lawnmower (a neighbor had asked to borrow someone's lawnmower. The lawnmower owner forgot that they'd agreed) to a series of murders in which people were brutally savaged to a string of abductions. Our town went from having three police officers to having a government special ops team located in our town.

I've been trying to figure out what's been going on because there's obviously a pattern here, and I've been a little enthusiastic about getting interviews, like talking to the mayor's son, inviting myself over to the detective's flat, showing up at crime scenes asking for scoops and refusing to leave. The forensic medical examiner called me a vulture. AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Oct 31 '25

AITA for crashing my car into my ex girlfriend's house?

25 Upvotes

I (51 M) was recently dumped by my girlfriend (44 F) because she found out I started doing drugs again and she said it won't work, especially since she has a 3 year old daughter. I was really sad and today she asked me to return her hairbrush so I drove to her house but when I got there I saw her having lunch with her sister and some new man. I got really angry so I told my best friend (45 M) to get out of the car and I drove my car into my ex's house and ended up in her kitchen. I didn't say anything, I just handed her the hairbrush and I left and now I'm vacationing in another country and ignoring everyone's calls. I'm pretty sure she's pressing charges on me for like attempted murder or whatever, but I don't think I did anything THAT extreme. AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jun 03 '21

Not the Asshole AITA for criticizing my friend's professional skills during an argument?

23 Upvotes

I (32F) work for government law enforcement that specializes in profiling behavior to capture criminals. A while back, the team leader and I decided we would lie to the other team members. We've worked together so long that we are like a family. One member, P, was ambushed during one of our cases where she knew the suspect. P was severely injured. Due to the nature of the case and the fact that the suspect escaped, we decided that P's protection was necessary. We lied about P not making it through surgery.

It was devastating to the whole team. Recently we were able to track the person that had injured her and, in the process, had to disclose that P was actually alive. I guess the shock has now worn off, and now my friend, S (30M), is upset. I am upset since S is avoiding me and lashing out instead of talking about this.

This is where I might have been the asshole. I reacted to S's behavior, and I told him that he was upset because we controlled our body language, and expressions, enough that he would not know we were lying to him. His rebuttal was that he was angry because he trusted me when he cried about P's death.

I couldn't tell him! I don't think I'm wrong in protecting P's life. However, AITA for questioning S's skills as a profiler?

r/CriminalMinds


r/Fictional_AITA • • May 21 '24

You're the Asshole AITA for divorcing my husband because he thinks tomatoes are fruits?

21 Upvotes

I'm (35F) the local carpenter, and my husband (35F) is a botanist, sometimes his experiments go awry but it's fine. We have two young adult kids (one from my previous marriage). I sent him for fruits and he brought back tomatoes. I told him tomatoes aren't what people think of when they say fruit, but he said tomatoes are fruits. The local farmer happened to be in my shop when this happened, and they agreed with me, saying tomatoes aren't fruits. Later they approaached me and said that my husband is too science-focused and an overall poor spouse, and I should divorce him. WIBTA if I divorced ny husband?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Feb 02 '24

Not the Asshole AITA for conducting genocide in hell? NSFW

20 Upvotes

So I, (20XX, m) am a pretty rad fucking dude. I’m pretty sure you’ve heard of me, but for privacy reasons, I’m choosing not to disclose myself.

Anyways, not important. What IS important is that every year I come down to hell with my awesome group of angels, and we have a rager. I’m talking some wicked shit. We fuckin’ rock.

So the daughter of Lucifer, the guy who banged by first wife, and spawned that little pleb comes up to me and is like “hey you’re killing my people, stop it, I thought angles had empathy”. So I told that bitch that hell is forever, had an absolutely bangin’ guitar solo, and now I’ll be back again in 6 months instead of a year, just to rub it in that dweebs face (seriously, no other reason).

Anyways, now some angels are mad at me for this whole extermination thing, and I know I’m not the asshole here, but I just want Reddit to confirm what I already know.


r/Fictional_AITA • • Dec 01 '23

You're the Asshole AITA For proposing to the love of my life at her wedding she didn’t even want?

20 Upvotes

I, 42M, proposed to the love of my life, 24F, and now she’s acting like I’m a jerk?

I don’t understand where I went wrong. We’ve been close ever since we met. It started with a simple plumbing job. I came by to help with her pipes when all of a sudden this guy, 34M, who was harassing her showed up. But you know what? I took care of him too. In fact this guy won’t leave her alone yet every time he tries something with her who does she go to? Me. And I take care of it every time. I’ve even had to get my brother, 22m, involved. But you know what? I’m happy to do it. I care about her and will do anything to keep her safe.

Well, speaking of, the guy shows up and literally kidnaps her! He left the freaking country with her and was going to try and force marry her! I wish I were making this shiitake up.

You would think this sort of thing would be too much for an average plumber, but no. I’ve had enough of this guy, and the last thing I was gonna do was sit by and let this happened. So I trailed them and I crashed the wedding to beat that guy into the ground like he deserved. This guy is huge mind you and I’m a short king admittedly, but I didn’t let anything stop me. I took him down with almost no help! (Technically this one guy helped me a little in the fight but it was pretty much all me).

So, there I am, sweaty, tired, having risked it all for her, and then I took a look at her and all I could think was wow, what a beautiful bride. I mean she looked amazing in her wedding dress.

Just then, the guy wakes up! Despite everything I did to him he still got back up, and what does he do? He tries to marry her still! So I did the only rational thing I could think of. I proposed to her!

I mean it just made sense. I couldn’t let this guy take her. He treats her like an object, like she’s just some peach he can pluck off a tree and call his. He even wrote a creepy song about her recently as if that’s ok after the countless times this guy has tried to kidnap her. So, if she married me then she’d be mine and he wouldn’t have anything left to try and take. Plus, she looked great in that wedding dress and we were still right by the chapel, so why not? What an amazing story we could tell our grandchildren.

But did she say yes? No. Did she even say thank you? NO! She got mad at ME of all people!

So now she’s out traveling, going to all these cool places and I, the superhero in all this, got nothing but a new hat in all of this. So AITA?

Let me know. 34M and I are probably gonna meet up for go-karts soon (it’s complicated) and I’d like some objective opinions about how wrong she is before I talk to him about it.


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jun 02 '21

Our new icon. We will continue to build this sub up

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/Fictional_AITA • • Jan 06 '21

Everybody Sucks Here AITA for not listening to my tribe leader?

20 Upvotes

Our previous leader was known for being the peacemaker and making everyone work.

I spoke for the rest of the tribe when she wanted us to work again. I mean, we just worked yesterday! And the day before that too! I just wanted to have a day off to sing and dance, we even made a song!

I tried to give Jam-the peacemaker an idea about getting more food and said I was making people miss out on nuts because I spent time on my ideas! All I wanted is to be lazy in peace.

So I decided to go out and prove her wrong, which I did. And in the process took over the tribe.

So was I the asshole by being better than Jam-I mean, the peacemaker and proving that I was right?

r/StarKid: Firebringer


r/Fictional_AITA • • Oct 22 '23

AITA for pushing someone out the window?

19 Upvotes

I am, or at least I was, the favorite toy of A (6).

Recently, A got a new toy (BL), and has been playing with him, and I haven’t been getting the attention that I used to get from him.

Last night, A, his sister M (1), and Mom were going to Pizza Planet. Mom said A could bring 1 toy. I picked up a magic 8 ball and asked it if A would pick me. It said “don’t count on it”. Angered, I devised a plan to push BL out of sight, and I called on one of my friends, RC, to do it.

Long story short, RC managed to knock down the bulletin board, which in turn sent a globe rolling his way, and knocked the lamp in such a direction that it allowed BL to be knocked out the window.

Everyone else started panicking, thinking BL bounced into our neighbour (S)’s yard, leading to RC trying to say something, which PH translated as this being no accident, and I had deliberately pushed BL out the window.

I tried to explain to everyone that it was an accident, but they didn’t want to hear it, and I was declared a murderer.

AITA?

Toy Story


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jun 26 '21

You're the Asshole AITA for poisoning the doctor that created me?

18 Upvotes

I was in trouble earlier because I wanted to go to the town square to get together and speak about Halloween. It is an important event for us.

See, the doctor who created me does not like me going out and reminds me not to go out all the time. This has led to poison him a few times just so I can leave while he is asleep.

I came back from my last outing a little while ago.

Now he is upset and has said that this was the last time I poisoned him.

Now I am locked in the tower.

I don't know what to think. Was I wrong in poisoning him when all I wanted was to go out, and he would not let me?

The Nightmare before Christmas


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jan 18 '21

Not the Asshole AITA for refusing to name my son after my abusive father?

17 Upvotes

My (24F) father left my brother (24M) and I at birth and was never in our lives, even after our mother died. We were separated and raised by different families. Recently we both met him for the first time and he assaulted my brother and physically/mentally abused me. It’s also come out that he was partially responsible for the death of our mother. Although he has since died, I feel like his actions are unforgivable but my brother has completely forgiven him and now wants me to name my son after him. My husband (37M) says he doesn’t care either way and that it’s up to me. I love my brother but I think it’s ridiculous to even consider the idea. However he is extremely frustrated that I won’t budge. AITA????


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jan 17 '21

AITA for not getting along with my fiance's family?

17 Upvotes

So I (19F) have moved to live with my fiancé's (25M) family temporarily while we plan our wedding.

Unfortunately, it's a real culture shock for me. I've moved from France to be with him, and now live in what looks like a converted pigsty in the middle of farmland. They all seem to do nothing but look after their chickens, cook and sometimes play games, which they all seem obsessed with.

My future MIL really seems to resent me being there. I probably haven't made it easy, but I don't see the point in doing things I don't want to do (cooking, chickens), and have said so. Maybe she doesn't like me because she thinks I'm taking her first born son away, maybe it's because I'm French, idk. She also has the worst taste in music I have ever heard.

I'm not really sure how to get along with them, and I'm not sure that I want to. So, AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Apr 28 '26

Not enough info AITA for beefing with a teenager because she ruined an annual tournament?

16 Upvotes

I (83M) am the president of my nation, and every year each of the 12 districts in the nation participate in a tournament where they send in two teens, one boy and one girl, with one victor at the end. For last year, this was happening as normal, and the two tributes from district 12 we will call K (now 17F) and P (now 17M). Now, if there is one place in this world that I hate, it is district 12, but fortunately the only times there's been any winner in the past was 25 years ago and that guy is now this washed up drunk, and one time before that which we do not talk about (I made a post about it 65 years ago but that's beside the point). Tangent aside, the tournament was supposed to go as usual but then during the tribute interviews, P admitted to having a crush on K, and so the gamemakers decided to milk this to add drama, eventually making a rule change that if the two last contestants were from the same district, they could both win. I wasn't a fan of this but I was sure that it wouldn't come down to that so I let it slide, but after they sicced a pack of wolf mutts on K and P as well as the one remaining contestant, the boy from D1, it ended up coming down to that. So it was decided that the rule change would be rescinded, but they ended up using these berries in the arena to force our hand and so the gamemakers declared both of them winners. Needless to say, the head gamemaker was relieved of his duties promptly. K and P were trying to push the narrative that it was because they were in love, and many in the capitol bought it, but I knew the truth. They were just trying to defy me! And many in the districts realized this too.

So now I've had to do damage control. To that end, I made the trip all the way out to D12 to talk with K in person. I explained to her that her stunt had caused uprisings in other districts, and that during her victory tour, her and P needed to convince me that they were actually in love. Unfortunately, the victory tour was a disaster, and the unrest in the districts only grew as they were terrible at selling the narrative I wanted them to, so my right hand man (60M) suggested that we need to convince the districts she's one of us not one of them, especially by propagandizing her and P's performative engagement. This however didn't work but my right hand man had one last idea. To that end, since this year happened to be the 75th year of the tournament, and every 25 years we do something different than normal, we decided to send the previous victors back, and since K was the only victor from D12 who was still alive, that would mean her by default. This didn't work though since a bunch of the victors were actually in on this plot to destroy the arena, and eventually K fired an arrow at the forcefield which destroyed the whole thing. And I realized not only that, but that my right hand man had betrayed me and he was actually helping them this whole time.

AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jul 13 '24

Not the Asshole AITA for hurting the flowers?

16 Upvotes

So I'm an adventurer, and one of my primary tasks right now is to seek out these wayshrine-type places that transport me to trials, at the end of which I earn artifacts which increase my endurance in some way. One of these wayshrines sits on a small island, which somebody (we'll call this person Guardian) has recently started a garden on.

There's a very narrow path through the garden that is difficult to remain on, especially since the garden is infested with aggressive jelly-like beasts. The thing is, that any slight misstep incurs the wrath of Guardian, who cites that I'm "hurting the flowers" with even the slightest step on the planted soil without Touching the Flowers, or even the slightest accidental swipe at a Singular Flower when defending against the beasts infesting the garden. I'm not gonna pretend I'm perfect, and this is an exceedingly narrow path, but if I mess this up, Guardian drags me out of the garden entirely and sometimes even hurts me doing so. Do I deserve that? In other words, Am I the Asshole?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Dec 01 '20

Not the Asshole AITA for trying to tell someone that I love him while I have the chance?

16 Upvotes

I (29F) am currently heading to a wedding in London.

My ex-boyfriend (30M) is getting married to a girl he hasn't dated for too long. He's on a rebound from me. I was invited to the wedding and felt weird about going. I spoke to another friend of ours (I'll call her Consuela) and realized that I am still in love with my ex. Consuela thinks I am making a mistake.

I was on the plane, and because I was excited so I told those around me about where I was going and why I was doing something. But the guy sitting next to me said that I was a "horrible, horrible person" because I think that my ex-boyfriend needs to know how I feel.

AITA for going to my ex-boyfriend's wedding to tell him I love him while I still have a chance (before he says "I Do")?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jan 02 '26

Not enough info AITA for being jealous that my best friend married my little sister?

15 Upvotes

I've been best friends with this guy, I call him Laurie, for years now. We're neighbors and love spending time together, and have a similar love of books, but just recently, he just came out and said he was in love with me the whole time. I was naturally upset, because I thought that we were just great friends and the whole time he was in love with me? I told him I'm not interested in him in that way, but he was pressuring me to marry him, and when I still refused, saying that I don't ever intend to get married, he straight up called me a liar and said that I'll find someone and get married someday. I left and didn't speak to him for months. I think he was in Europe traveling during that time. I started thinking, and somewhat regretting that I rejected his proposal. My mother told me that there's a difference between being lonely and truly loving someone, and she may be right, but I wrote Laurie a letter saying I was stupid for the things I said. I left it in a mailbox he and my sisters and I all have keys to for him to find after his trip. Now at this time, my little sister Amy was also in Europe with our rich aunt. I didn't know it, but she and Laurie connected while they were there. They returned from Europe together, and abruptly told us that they were married. Not just dating, not even engaged, married. I honestly can't believe neither of them said anything to any of us. I took the letter I wrote back out of the mailbox and destroyed it. I don't even know if I truly love Laurie or not, but I still feel betrayed and almost jealous. I know it's wrong, but I can't help it. I just want to go back to the way we were, but now with both of my sisters married, I feel like that's never going to happen. So reddit, AITA?

Edit: I forgot to mention, when they came home from Europe, it was literally for our sister's funeral. It feels like they couldn't have picked a worse time to get married.


r/Fictional_AITA • • Apr 07 '25

Everybody Sucks Here AITA for breaking up with my girlfriend because she won’t come out?

15 Upvotes

I (17F) am a lesbian. Up until a few hours ago, I was dating my ex-girlfriend (17F) who we’ll call A. A and I were together for about a year and a half and everything was great. She supported me when I came out to my parents only for them to kick me out of the house. Her mother, Mrs. G, is the head of our school’s PTA and is also extremely homophobic, so A hasn’t come out.

The trouble began when Mrs. G convinced the PTA to cancel our senior prom because I decided to tell people I was bringing a girl as my date. I didn’t tell anyone that A was going to be my date, just that it was a girl. We did plan to come out that night and be seen together for the first time. Anyways, people got really mad about prom getting cancelled and a group of Broadway actors came down to our school to protest about it. Long story short, they held a rally and the courts got involved so the prom was reinstated. The night of prom comes and when I arrived at the school, nobody was there. Turns out the PTA organized a fake prom for me while everyone else, including A, went to a different place where the real prom was happening.

I called A and asked her to come meet me, but she made the excuse that her mom was chaperoning and that she couldn’t come otherwise her mom would get suspicious. I suggested she come out to Mrs. G like we planned, but she refused because some other girls in our year found out about us and it was “bad enough” that they knew. I confronted her a few days later and asked why she didn’t come out, and she gave me the same story that Mrs. G would be upset and how it was too hard. I didn’t want to be A’s secret and continuing to hide was really taking a toll on me, so I broke up with her.

I feel really bad about it because I know she loves me, but it hurts too much that she won’t come out. AITA for breaking up with her?

The Prom


r/Fictional_AITA • • Feb 23 '24

You're the Asshole AITA for publicly roasting my greatest rival?

15 Upvotes

So, I'm the head of a pretty big TV company. And when I was younger I had the biggest crush on a pretty famous radio host ("Deer"). We were pretty good friends. Well, I asked him out, and to join me, and he said no.

Obviously I was mad, and I started my own, new, friend group with the head of a porn company ("Moth") and the head of a fashion company ("Velvet"). I have since started dating "Moth", and thought I had moved on. Until something happened.

One of "Moth's" actors moved to a hotel-project-thing. "Moth" then informed me that not only was his actor there, but "Deer" was there, working with the local princess.

I was pissed. He'd been missing for seven years, and he didn't even come to visit me? The audacity of that "man"!

So I did the only logical thing and started an emergency broadcast, and started to talk about him. Because I hate him. And I had a pretty epic song about it too. Like, he's old, he's out of date, he's a coward, he's behind the times.

Then "Deer" had a radio broadcast and told everyone about how I asked him out and he rejected me! And how I'd be usless without "Moth" and "Velvet", and a bunch of other stuff. And I caused a huge power outage across the city. "Moth" and "Velvet" said I was in the right, but a lot of people online are siding with "Deer", so, am I the asshole?

Vox - Stayed Gone - Radio Killed the Video Star - Hazbin Hotel Series.


r/Fictional_AITA • • Sep 27 '26

Not the Asshole AITA for committing murder after giving the guy every opportunity to redeem himself?

14 Upvotes

So, my (23M) dad (53M) is trying to unify our country. We‘ve been at war for six years, but the other leaders care more about getting rich than they do about actually WINNING the war. My dad is trying to change that, but he’s getting pushback from the other generals.

The worst of them was a guy I‘ll call S (50M). My dad tried to convince S to form an alliance with him to try to end the war, and S seemed to be receptive. But it was a trap. During a battle, S betrayed us and left us for dead. We would have died if S’s slaves hadn’t defected to my dad’s army and decided to save our lives.

Obviously, I’m pissed at S, right? But I can’t move against him. He’s too important, and there’s technically no direct evidence that S intended to leave us for dead. So, instead, my dad had to leave S to his own devices and focus on ending the war. Easier said than done, considering that S did everything he could to undermine my dad’s credibility. He even released edited transcripts of my dad’s visions from the Almighty to make it look like my dad’s going insane!

Anyway, long story short: we won the war, but now the apocalypse is happening, and we need to be a united front if we’re going to survive it. We’ve relocated to this ancient tower city that’s been unoccupied for thousands of years as a base of operations. Anyway, this morning, I was exploring the city when I found S. He admitted that he’s going to spread rumors to undermine my dad yet again. He KNOWS that we need to be united, and he’s willingly going to sabotage that because he’s a power-hungry psychopath.

When I heard that, I snapped. I tackled him, grabbed him by the throat, and started squeezing. Before I knew it, he was dead! I quickly cleaned up the crime scene to erase any evidence of my involvement, but it’s only a matter of time before they find his body.

I know conceptually that what I did was wrong. I mean, I MURDERED an incredibly high-ranking officer, for the Almighty’s sake! But, at the same time, I knew that he was going to be a problem. My dad and I gave him every opportunity for him to put aside his disagreements with us and work together (AFTER he had tried to get us killed, mind you), and he refused. If I had let him live, humanity might be doomed.

So, AITA?


r/Fictional_AITA • • Jan 08 '25

AITA for not wanting to be cryogenically frozen with my girlfriend?

14 Upvotes

I (30M) have been with my girlfriend, Rachel (28F), for three years. We have a great relationship overall, but she’s always been a bit... eccentric. Lately, she’s been really into the idea of cryogenics—like having our bodies frozen after death so we can “wake up in the future.”

At first, I thought it was just a passing interest, but she’s completely serious. She’s done hours of research, joined online forums, and even visited a facility. Last week, she sat me down and asked if I’d be willing to sign up for a couple’s plan where we’d be frozen together and potentially “reunited in the future.”

I told her I wasn’t comfortable with the idea. It’s not that I’m against her doing it—I fully support her choice if that’s what she wants—but the whole concept feels a little too sci-fi for me. Plus, the cost is astronomical, and I’d rather invest that money in something tangible, like our current lives or a future home.

Rachel didn’t take it well. She said my refusal was proof I didn’t believe in “our love standing the test of time” and that I wasn’t as committed to our relationship as she is. I tried to explain that my hesitation has nothing to do with how I feel about her, but she accused me of being short-sighted and dismissive of her dreams.

She’s been distant ever since, and now even our friends are weighing in. Some say I should compromise because it’s clearly important to her, while others think it’s ridiculous for her to make this a relationship deal-breaker.

I love Rachel, but I also feel like it’s unfair for her to expect me to commit to something this extreme. AITA for not wanting to be cryogenically frozen with her?