I just got done trying Fenyx Rising on Stadia (which was actually an incredible experience with Stadia) and I have to vent my utter frustration and bafflement at the beginning of the demo.
I'm someone with a long attention span and I'm someone who appreciates good stories. I DON'T, however, tend to like stories in videogames because they are usually absolutely atrocious. As such, I have VERY LITTLE patience for storytelling in video games. If I have an hour to play a game... I want to PLAY a game. I don't want to sit around watching ugly cutscenes of characters talking about things I do not care about. And... BOY. The beginning of Fenyx Rising justifies every inch of my hatred for video game storytelling.
The demo begins, as these things tend to do, with an old man speaking... very... slowly.. about... WHO CARES. The standard rule in storytelling is to "start at the most interesting point" in order to involve the audience. Instead, FR starts with an old man that we do not know or care about droning on about things that do not involve us and that we can't possibly care about. Just when I am thinking, "THIS IS BORING." Zeus, in the game, shouts out "BORING!!".
Like... what? I'm not sure what meta-commentary this is supposed to be making, but I'm sure it has the complete OPPOSITE effect of what was intended. We then have to watch these two old men bicker for what feels like ages. I kept thinking... "Who is this supposed to be FOR?!?"
It's NOT funny. I don't even know what about it is SUPPOSED to be funny. The characters wind up making snarky comments related to Mythology, but we haven't met any of these characters, so they are talking about people we don't know.
And if it's not supposed to be funny... what then? It's not charming. I don't LIKE these characters. There's nothing TO like. They are just standing there monologging.
I could see someone saying that he humor is for "younger players", but I can't imagine ANY younger kids having the attention span to sit there watching two old men do painful verbal comedy like a vaudeville act for an eternity.
I kept asking myself, "what about what is happening on screen right now am I supposed to be LIKING. It's not funny. We can firmly say that. These characters aren't charming. There is no "saves the cat" moment to endear us to either of them. We have no reason to care about anything they are talking about. The art and animation isn't good (for what's being presented. This isn't a performance captured game where we can be interested in the acting or emoting of characters). So.. what? Who is this FOR?
My jaw was open in bafflement and frustration as I sat through the intro. It was PAINFUL. But I did it because I wanted to try the game. And, I think, that's my biggest problem with this garbage. I don't even know if I LIKE the game yet. I shouldn't have to put in WORK in order to try a game. And even if this was the retail version, you shouldn't front load exposition onto the player that they have NO REASON TO CARE ABOUT YET.
The only storytelling that should happen BEFORE a game starts, is the bare minimum necessary to connect the player to their avatar. Once the player is firmly attached to their avatar in their world, through GAMEPLAY, THEN is a perfect time to explain more about the story. Why then? Because THEN the player has a reason to care. They should have formed these questions about the world organically and then the game is going to ANSWER them.
The utter failure of the intro to Fenyx Rising made me go look up the intro to Herc's Adventures, and old Lucasarts game that was seemingly attempting some of the same tone. It's astounding how much better they do it with a game that's 25 years old. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0AP8vYV6qDU
Game reviewers need to do a better job of holding Developers feet to the fire about games that actively BORE the player. I can't tell you the number of reviews I've seen where the writer casually throws out, "I was sometimes bored" or "I was bored at the beginning" as though that's only a minor flaw in a something you paid money for in the sole purpose of ENTERTAINMENT. You have one job. NOT BE BORING.
Thankfully once the intro was over, I liked running around in the game world. But trying new games shouldn't be a test of patience. It's unnecessary and the industry needs to move beyond it. It's just bad design.