Recently, somebody made a really awesome post talking about how they’re doing all this world building based on African culture. They had artwork they had a link that posted everything about the world building and they ask people to make comments on it.
And many of the first comments were awesome just general well wishes and how awesome everything looks and stuff like that.
Now I am not a native born African, but I am black and I have been to Africa, specifically when I was working different animal, rehabilitation groups, most notably, focusing on the cheetah.
I’ve been in and around small isolated villages in Africa and experienced some authentic African culture. I love African culture. So seeing this I was ecstatic. Especially so because OP seemed to be trying to cast a pretty wide net, and desire to represent as many different cultures as possible.
But some of y’all thought that you should educate a native born African on how to be sensitive and respectful to African culture. The purity testing I saw in the comments, blew my mind. And almost every single one of these comments were made by people who absolutely did not click the link and read through the material.
Well, there was one person who did seem read through the material at least a little bit was this fucking British person, I’m fairly certain is white. But you know just because they’re British doesn’t mean they’re white but looking at their post history and the subreddits they are involved in my guess is they are white. Anyway, they had the audacity to tell this native born African “ask yourself why you specifically are a good choice for representing African culture.”
Now, besides the audacity, I do want to answer this question in a way I think it should be answered. Anything like “because I thought it’s cool” and beyond, is an appropriate response to this. I don’t care if you’re white black Asian Hispanic Native American, Pacific Islander, hell your ass could be Kandorian for all I care, if you think African culture is awesome, and you put in the effort in the research and the time in the energy that this person very clearly did, I’d love for you to write a story and I hope it becomes super famous and super popular. I hope it becomes a movie. I hope that it means 50 million people become interested in African culture because of it. Now, in a perfect world, would I prefer the author to be black? Sure. I would also prefer the person to be from Africa, or at least have lived there. But I’m not going to begrudge someone their desire to include some of the coolest mythology on the planet into their fantasy series.
I also saw quite a few comments talking about how diverse Africa is and how it would be better for them to focus on a small region so they can give it “the respect it’s due”
I wanna start by saying that it is totally fine to focus on a smaller region of Africa. But it’s also fine to pull from all over the place. In fact, one could argue by pulling from all over the place it forces the author to do more research and really get a better picture of Africa as a continent as a whole. They’ll probably learn more about many different tribes and learn how those tribes interacted with each other. They’ll learn more about the different languages and how they are different and how they are. Another day made of Africa are gonna just think it’s cool part of their culture against embedded in the tapestry, and everyone else is not gonna know enough to care that a someone is going sting a traditional San dish made with the meat of a Maasai monster.
I wanted to add some nuance about the cultural diversity in Africa and compare it to cultural diversity and other parts of the world as well as point out some details but when I wrote it out, I just realized it was me rambling and most people aren’t gonna care.
Anyway, I’m getting carried away. Point is, I’m disappointed, and was hoping people would be more supportive and not act like piranhas tryna one drop rule someone for wanting to make something awesome.