I am desperately, DESPERATELY trying to like Fantasy Grounds. The big selling points being that I own the software and (in theory) it automates healing, damage etc.
All I want to do is to run a game for my friends. I have run a few sessions through Roll20 and it was so easy to set up and run... but EVERYTHING in FGC is just taking so much longer and is SUCH A MESS ALL OF THE TIME!
Same campaign - 2 User Interfaces
I am running an expanded, home brew variant on a one shot created by u/CatLadyHM. I imported it all into Roll20, made my amendments, created my characters, added line dynamic lighting to the maps, set up my encounters with enemies, created my npcs, created custom macros and all the rest in less than a day...
I'm on day 2 for FG just moving the same information across from Roll20 to FG (I don't even have to alter it for my setting like I did when moving to Roll20) and it is barely even half way done. Not only that, it is so much harder to just make something simple like an basic friendly NPC for the characters to interact with, a custom monster for them to fight or a unique item.
Scratch that, I'll go even more basic.
Want to copy and paste a list from word? Tough. How about we make you go through every line individually and then right click, left click, left click.... for EVERY ITEM OF TEXT. Maybe you put that text in the wrong section? Maybe it should have been a story entry rather than a note? Surely it would allow you to move it across with the formatting intact? It's in the same program after all? NOPE! GO THROUGH EVERY LINE AGAIN AND FORMAT EVERYTHING INDIVIDUALLY!
Macro's aren't the easiest to get to grips with for Roll20, but they are absolutely optional. You can pretty much get away with /roll 1d20 or /w gm roll 1d20 as it doesn't automate the damage or heal directly on to the sheet regardless. It's the same chat text code that is on multiple forums and even discord bots. Can even get the Beyond20 extension and just roll straight off D&D Beyond if you're feeling fancy.
Now let's say I want to make something in FG. I have to learn a monstrous effect language and placement that is SOOOOOO unhelpful it is physically making me angry. God forbid you get a bracket in the wrong place or forget a semi-colon. That's if you can figure out where to add the effect in the first place (character, item, npc, generic effect tab?) and then have to go back into it every time each character levels up and hope you remember which bit needs updating. The worst bit is, if you don't do it, you are taking away the one benefit that FG has over Roll20, the automation.
I wanted to make a basic healing potion (possibly THE most common magic item in D&D) to hand out as an item for my players to use.
Can I figure out the correct language to make it work, or even the best way to set it up on their sheets etc. to make the automation useful...? Can I hell!
I can give them the link from the rulebook... but what I've actually given them is a text box. Not a usable item. How about me amending the Potion of Healing in the items list? Nope, can't do that. Locked. So even if I can make it, I have to create a duplicate entry and remember which to give out.
As for a unique item such as an incense that granted necrotic resistance for 2 hours for all characters, I've just taken it out of my game entirely because it p**sed me off so much trying to figure it out.
I may as well just manually adjust the sheets myself for everything and wonder why I moved from Roll20 at all.
I wanted to make an NPC for my players to interact with. Didn't want a stat block or anything, just a quick NPC that may have a few quests he can give out. Nope, it's stat block, 3 separate story entries for his quests, an image link, and god knows what else, all opening in new windows.
...There is quite literally nothing that the maps section of the program that is better than Roll20. Nothing. You can pin a story entry or encounter to a map? Wonderful... I'll just go into the story entry I'm already using to run the game, to find the map I've used to open the story entry for the encounter... that's handy.
The negatives outweigh the few positives by a staggering margin. Maybe Unity will be better, but I'll never know because it is so slow to boot on my laptop at the moment that I can't event test it (2 hours to update and load yesterday).
It would be unfair to focus only on the negatives. The ONLY good thing FG really has over anything else at this point is the Party Sheet. That's nice. It's useful and it works. The rest is like trying to figure out whether a train is coming from your left or right while blindfolded in a cave.
Everything else that is good about FG is in the user created extensions (effects, sounds, visuals etc.) which (for the literally HUNDREDS of pounds I've spent on it) is frankly scandalous. Some of the user extensions are fantastic, and the players who design them should be commended, but to rely on 3rd party content just to make your own program usable (not even enjoyable, just usable) is unbelievable. Just buy the code, pay the programmer and add it in as a standard feature instead of us having to jump across a forum, a wiki, a discord, a DEDICATED COLLEGE BECAUSE IT'S SO F**KING DIFFICULT TO USE and then still end up looking at YouTube videos just to make something work because everyone that knows how to do something, assumes you know all the jargon as well!
...I just wanted to play D&D 😢
EDIT: Tell a lie, there is something else good in FG. The language box. That's really fun and works great.
EDIT 2: I'm going to leave the rant up, as I think it is how a lot of people probably feel when they join FG, but I need to say a big thank you to Laerun and Walkin Dude from the the FG College who have just helped me out with some key tips to make things a bit easier via discord.
Need to add another PRO to the list that I missed off as well. The FG community. They are far more helpful than any of the other VTT's.
Some bits of FG are still extremely frustrating (every click opening a new window etc.), but I'm going to persevere.