EDIT: UPDATE AT THE BOTTOM
Context: I'm in my 30s being treated by a trans-specialist family practitioner (not an endo) at a trans-specialist clinic in Canada, and I'm sharing my side effects with & operating under the guidance of the doc. It is common for me to have unusual or extreme reactions to medications and substances, especially stimulants and psychiatric medications, but my reaction to T was the worst reaction I've ever had. I'm just wondering if anyone has had similar experiences to what I've had, or has any idea what might be causing this. There's a narrative that feel good on hrt = you are trans, feel bad on hrt = not trans, but I still want to experience physical masculinization so I feel like I must still be trans... could I really be that wrong?
I have been on and off low-dose T for a little over a month. I was prescribed to apply a 2.5g sachet of Androgel (1% testosterone gel) daily. The first time I did this I expected to feel nothing, instead I felt like I got hit by a bus: I was almost immediately feeling hyper-excited, lightheaded, pupils dilated, distracted and jittery, racing heart, and within a few hours I was sweating, nauseous, non-functional, with blurred vision and the worst headache I've ever had (worse than migraines or a severe concussion). The headache persisted long after 24h. I probably should've gone to the ER but waited 2 days to see my usual doctor. The doctor tested my blood pressure (normal - she said that blood pressure would not be a cause of the headache because if so the headache would have subsided once the blood pressure was normal) and sent me immediately to the ER. The ER found nothing wrong with me, gave me the big-guns stuff for pain, and sent me home. From that single application of gel I had an immobilizing headache for a little over a week.
I remained determined to go on T and with the support of my doctor tried applying a much lover dose- really just dipping a pinkie in the gel and applying that much. Under 0.25g of gel. I had a lot of the same symptoms but less, and tolerable, and persisted with about that dosage and a constant low-grade headache for about two weeks. I started having wicked mood swings, from incredibly elated and hyper-energized, to despondent on the floor. My dysphoria, dissociation, and brain fog got worse x1000. I felt dysphoric that my body wasn't masculine enough, but ALSO started for the first time that I can ever remember having really dark episodes where I longed for my body to be *more feminine* which totally shocked me. When I looked at myself in the mirror, instead of just being surprised to see "oh no, that's what I look like?" (my normal, pre-T level of dysphoria) I started to have this sensation that there was a huge vast expanse between my reflection and myself and that my reflection was disappearing into the distance.
But, there were also moments when I felt so cheerful, outgoing, energized, when I felt "masculine" on the inside in an exciting way and felt like I could see my internal picture of myself as more masculine, which I was excited by. So I kept on. I noticed that the dark mood swings and "feminine" swings seemed to be worst right before applying my next dose, so went up to <0.25g twice a day, once in the morning and once before bed. That alleviated the worst of the mood swings and for a couple days I felt pretty good, but then for a couple of days after that I felt so tired and the brain fog got so much worse. I started to feel emotionally numb: I didn't like my favourite colour anymore, I didn't enjoy the view from my window that I love, I didn't want to watch my favourite TV shows or do my favourite hobbies, I started to feel like an alien in my home surrounded by things that used to belong to me and that I used to care about but that I couldn't summon of the feeling of caring about anymore. This was made so much worse by the constant low level headache that started turning in to just constant overstimulation: I couldn't tolerate middling bright light or moderate sounds, looking at colours or patterns hurt my eyes. I had to take the bedspread off my bed because a neutral stripe pattern was overwhelming me. I had the urge to take all the art off walls because they hurt my eyes and made me feel claustrophobic and I couldn't feel the feeling of enjoying the art. I felt numb inside and constantly overwhelmed. There was one whole day when I just lay on my back and stared at the ceiling because I was so brain foggy and out of it, and this was when I stopped applying the Tgel.
The day after my last dose, I felt immediately clearer and more alert, my capacity for joy returned. The feeling of overstimulation became more manageable although it has stayed for several days. I felt the thing I thought I was *supposed* to feel on T: more grounded, thinking clearer, like even though I hated my body at the very least it belonged to me. I felt great but also freaked out. Could running on estrogen really be what my body needed? How wrong could I possibly have been? There might have still been a little T in my system at that point because the withdrawal headaches didn't kick in until the next day, it's all kind of hard to say.
Anyways it's been a few days and I still feel my usual level of pre-T dysphoria, but I am at least a little more stable and functional than I was on T and I'm trying to figure out wtf happened.
Is T just bad for me and I need to be on an estrogen system
I know low T level can make trans guys feel like hell, so was I just on too low of a dose to feel the positive effects consistently? It seems like the worst parts where when my T was lower eg. before the next dose which is sort of consistent with what I've heard from others on T but just to a lesser degree
might some of these side effects go away with time or with switching to a different form of T?
The only forms of T approved for HRT in Canada are gel and injections. There used to be a patch but it was recalled. My doctor is looking into the oral T that is approved for TRT to see if it might be ok to give that to me to try and see what happens. Because of my very bad initial reaction we are both wary of giving me an injection because there is no way to inject very small doses and then if I do have serious side effects they could last for weeks. However, I will probably want to try injections at some point if all else fails. The doctor has said that while my side effects sound disorienting and painful nothing pings for her as a serious health concern and she feels confident that giving me T is not putting me as risk of lasting serious harm to my body or health. Just a lot of severe but temporary discomfort.
I am in my thirties and have had a LOT of therapy from gender competent therapists and have done years of research and questioning. I tried identifying as nonbinary without pursuing hrt for 4 years and was confident that that didn't feel right or affirming to me. I really don't think, and my therapist doesn't think, that I'm pursuing T for one of the oft-claimed "wrong" reasons like trauma or body dysmorphia. I feel pretty certain that I really just want a male body. Is it really possible for me, a 30+ year old adult with an otherwise pretty good head on my shoulders, to be THAT wrong about myself?
I know and have heard again and again people saying that having the "right" hormones in your body should feel good, and the "wrong" hormones bad. But I also know that some people manage to stay on hormones for years before realizing they don't want to be on them, and surely not all those people can be feeling as debilitatingly bad as I did for years and years without ever considering going off hrt. I barely survived those two weeks. And so if it can be possible for some people to feel ok-ish on hrt and *not* be trans, it might not be SO impossible for me to feel like hell on it and still be trans, right?
Right now my plan is to rest a bit, get my life a bit in order, and then try HRT again. Maybe if I can't be on it for the long term I can at least be on it for some short stints long enough to get at least some voice changes or facial hair or something at least a little bit affirming. I have been googling how much it costs to get facial masculinization through surgery alone and feeling despondent. I don't want to have to look female for the rest of my life.
UPDATE 03/2025:
Yeah I'm still trans. I'm still on T.
I feel like I've had almost every possible adverse reaction and allergy in this process so here's some of what I've been up to, for your info:
I went off T for about 5 months after making this initial post. I had the wildest mood swings for about 2-3 months afterwards. Around the 2.5 month mark my therapist pointed out, hey, you just made it through a session without audibly sobbing for the entire hour! And that was when I started to feel like I was a person again. All that was after only about 3 weeks on a sub-clinically low dose of T, which I share because I want folks to know that if you're going off your hormones to "see how you feel without them," and if you're like me, you might need to give yourself a VERY long time- like many, many months, especially if you've been on hormones a while- before you're really getting an accurate sense of how you feel without hormones.
Those three months were really scary and confusing. I was crying and having panic attacks and episodes of "impending doom" several times every day. Those intense swings into panic and despair really triggered my preexisting issues like OCD, and in the depths of that pit I felt sometimes wildly sure that I had never been trans at all and just wanted to be a pretty girl. When the mood swings stabilized that feeling started to go away and my dysphoria returned. I can really see how in a headspace like that it might be easy for someone to think they're miserable because they should/shouldn't be on hormones and get caught up vicious detrans or transmed rhetoric or whatever, not realizing that you're just feeling this way because your body is still resettling. (See how fucking miserable, superstitious, and transmed-y I was in my initial post, for reference.)
After a couple more months I was still trans and the dysphoria was really hitting again so I screwed up my courage to try again. I went back on the sub-clinically low doses of Androgel- really just a couple of tiny drops per day, 2-3 times per day to try to even out the mood swings. Less than 1/16th of a pack daily. I continued to have wicked mood swings and head aches daily, hyperactivity and hyperarousal after applying, and then intense exhaustion, despair, and doom several hours later. It was like I was a completely different person every 4 hours. Worse, the downswings of mood would trigger my OCD and this intense obsession with the idea that I wasn't trans at all and wanted to be a woman. I told myself I hadn't felt that way pre-T and pre-mood swings and very determinedly persisted, but after 2ish months of achingly increasing my tiny drops of T-gel, it just wasn't getting better. So eventually I was like, fuck it we ball try injections.
I started on 0.1ml of 100% Depo-Testosterone Cypionate injected subcutaneously, weekly. Instantly I felt better- better even that I had pre-Testosterone entirely. The first injection was still rough and I still almost always get a wicked headache/migraine in the evening after the day of injection. The first week I had a similar kind of mood swing to when I was on the T-gel, but spread over several days as apposed to several hours, which made it so much smoother and more bearable. It evened out a little as time went on but those headaches and swings have persisted.
Of note is that I did start getting hives/rashes after injections and was worried I was allergic to the cottonseed oil that was used to make my cypionate. (At first my doctor didn't believe me and I had to send her a treatment guide I found from the University of California Center of Excellence for Transgender Health that had explicit recommendations for treating cottonseed allergies in Testosterone HRT. Sadly that guide now seems to have been taken down thanks to... All The Bullshit. But there are probably other treatment guides remaining out there that have similar info. I hope.) I was concerned I might be at risk for anaphylactic shock (one time my tongue felt like it swelled up a little) so now I have to carry an epi-pen with me everywhere which, cool. We switched me of 0.5ml of 200% Testosterone Enanthate injected subcutaneously weekly (which is made with sesame oil). The switch was wicked, that week after injection was the worst headache I'd had since the very start when I posted this initial post, and when i tell you i was SCARED. But it evened out the next week and now I feel the best I've felt on T. Injection day is always a fuck, and I have to always take that day off to just chill at home on the couch and watch TV and feel dizzy and lightheaded and slowly get a migraine. I take naproxen or very rarely mar-keterolac or oxycocet for pain on injection day. But the rest of the week I'm fine. Doctor says to give it a few months before going up to a higher dose/to make sure I'm not still having allergic reactions and has referred me to an allergist, but the wait to see an allergist could take months/years because Canadian healthcare is a fuck rn.
(FWIW if you're allergic to both sesame oil and cottonseed oil, you may still have options. In one day of trans panic I called every "sterile compounding pharmacy" (special pharmacy where they have a lab to make injectable serums in-house) in a 50 kilometre radius and finally found a really nice pharmacist who told me he could make testosterone serums in all kinds of things like MCT oil and something called "ethyl-oleate." But those weren't covered by the Canadian healthcare system (not all healthcare is as "free" in Canada as you think it is) was gonna be expensive af so thankfully enanthate seems to be ok for now.)
Anyways between Androgel + Cypionate + Enanthate, I've been back on T for 5 months now and I'm finally starting to have hope. Provided, idk, my T doesnt suddenly become illegal after the upcoming Canadian election or something.... Big ups to my doctor for just giving me all the types of testosterone and painkillers and not trying to force me to stop. Get yourself a trans-affirming doctor. Be assertive. Do your research. If my disabled sickly ass can be on T, maybe you can too. Love you take care!!