r/EvolveGame • u/Malcmodnar • Jul 19 '16
Evolve doesn't reward fun.
I'm a new player to Evolve. I briefly tried it during the open beta, but it hasn't been until the recent free to play launch that I've gotten into the game. At first, I had a blast - my friends and I killed monsters, ate each other, got annoyed at the matchmaking until it was fixed - but I've started to notice something that really bugs me about this game. It's not a question of characters being over/underpowered or anything that happens during the game itself, but rather a problem with what happens after each game, when you get to the reward screen.
Simply put, I think Evolve's reward system is terrible. Silver keys are progression in this game, plain and simple. They're an incentive, and players are naturally going to do whatever gives them the most keys. However, the activities that currently award keys are completely unrelated to having fun in the game.
For example: your team joins a lobby. Two players disconnect because they didn't get the roles they wanted. You drop down, run around aimlessly for a couple minutes, then get your intestines torn out and tied in a pretty little bow by a wraith. You didn't have fun. You got stomped, and there really wasn't anything you could've done about it... but you got 400 keys, because you completed a challenge you probably didn't know was available.
Then, the next came comes. You're the monster. The enemy team is on your tail (or tentacle-bits, or whatever) the whole game, and you barely manage to scrape enough food together to evolve. You go on the offensive, attacking the hunters only to escape with a sliver of health. It's a tense, action-packed game of flesh-eating cat and mininuke-toting mouse, and when you managed to finally down the assault in the last few seconds before he can kill you, you're as pumped as can be. You got 35 keys, because you weren't playing Assault, Medic, or (insert monster you hate to play).
It's an entirely backwards and counter-intuitive system. Evolve doesn't reward you for a close match, a surprising comeback, or anything else that makes a good game - it rewards you for playing a certain character and/or winning, pure and simple. As a consequence, you are actively punished for making each game more enjoyable, because that means the game takes longer. Instead, you're encouraged to use the cheesiest, most crushing tactic you can to win... assuming you get a character you have a challenge for, because if you don't, you're better off just leaving the game before it starts.
I think this is the cause of a lot of the problems players are complaining about. There's no reason to toy with your opponents, because that endangers your "win x games" challenge. There's no reason to try new things, because if it doesn't work, you're just wasting time that could be spent playing y matches as z class. There's no reason to stay with a match where you're hopelessly outclassed, because you're not going to get anything but another humiliating defeat.
Evolve needs to reward the player who decides to fights tooth and nail when all the other hunters have left, the monster who toys with his enemies when he clearly has the upper hand, or the team that pulls a last minute victory from the jaws of defeat. The current system actively punishes players who do this, and encourages only abandoned games and frustration.
TL;DR: Evolve's silver key rewards incentive leaving games and abusing skill gaps instead of close calls and making each match as enjoyable as you can.
7
Jul 19 '16
Whatever happened to simply "winning" being enough, and winning your own way with your own strategy?
1
u/MajesticArticle Jul 09 '25
People want the quick dopamine hit of seeing an achievement pop up/unlocking something
23
u/Klyka Jul 19 '16
I am glad I am not letting some ingame currency dictate "fun" in a video game for me.
I have fun playing the game,I don't care about what surrounds it.
12
u/NoisyGuy Jul 19 '16
But when you have a very limited amount of character to play with and you need keys to unlock them you are obliged to care about keys so you can unlock new characters you want. OP is right in this sense.
2
u/Klyka Jul 19 '16
True.
At the same time,if the game isn't fun with the characters I have,why am I playing the game? Am I assuming that unlockng a new character will make the game fun for me? You don't grind "fun".
3
u/NoisyGuy Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16
It's more a mind issue. The human brain wants more by default, a lot of people enjoy unlock things as much as playing to do that. It's not black and white.
I think a solution would be making the hidden challenges known placing them as achievements and probably making the win worth a bit more in silver keys.
Edit: typo
1
u/Klyka Jul 19 '16
I agree.
TRS has said they will balance the key economy and I think a dev had actually listed all hidden challenges some time ago.
3
u/3parkbenchhydra Jul 19 '16
Yeah, I think we need to be careful about wanting things to manufacture fun for us. If you're enjoying playing the game, then it really doesn't matter that you had to play 3 more matches than you thought in order to unlock that sick Laz skin. Or whatever.
Conversely, if you're not enjoying the gameplay, no amount of silver keys is going to make that better in the long run.
4
u/Samael1990 Jul 19 '16
The challanges system really rewards players for playing in intervals of time, it should be more spread out - more silver for a match itself (win, class bonus, round bonus, whatever else) and less for challanges.
3
u/slider2k Jul 19 '16
Fun gameplay is the reward in itself. But I would't argue that game currency rewards are heavily skewed towards quests, achievements and leveling, and it needs to balanced more fairly.
2
u/G65434-2 Jul 19 '16
unrelated to having fun in the game.
"Having fun" is a matter of perception, if you don't "have fun" doming the monster, maybe you'll "have fun" escaping it as the monster.
2
u/MrAkenatom Jul 19 '16
something like a 50% bonus to play without preference should be implemented, or a bonus to beat the monster as the last hunter alive
4
u/Groudas Jul 19 '16
This bonus to no preference is a splendid idea. Basically this could substitute all those "play with X, y, z challenges. Please make a post about this.
Edit: this bonus could be called" jack of all trades bonus" or something.
2
1
Jul 19 '16
Personally, I like the challenges as is. I've found I get burned out after a while, but it's nice to get something cool every day and then have some specific roles to focus on. I think without that in place I would play assault for a week straight and then quit altogether. It's almost like Hearthstone in the way they incentivize moderate play.
1
u/Dathouen Jul 19 '16
Very well put. I can't agree with this more.
I only hope the devs are actually listening. This needs to be upvoted more.
1
Jul 19 '16
You should be rewarded for winning. The game should incentivize you to play well. Fun should be it's own incentive.
1
u/Inveet Jul 19 '16
My main gripe is just how huge the gap between completing hidden challenges, and winning games is. I have a base understanding that the keys are likely balanced around leveling and challenges so that you'll get plenty of keys in the beginning, and less as you go through the game, but isn't the divide just a bit ridiculous right now?
I've had games where I fought as you say; tooth and nail, and only been rewarded with 10 lousy silver keys. Likewise I've had games where the monster gave up right away, and with no challenge involved, I've gotten 800+ keys for various challenges etc. I feel like it would make for a much more satisfying reward system if you could go into a game knowing that you'll at least have a 'moderate' reward. Right now you're completely unknowing whether you'll be given piles upon piles of keys, or barely any at all.
0
u/caliboyjosh10 Jul 19 '16
This has to be the worst incentive to play games. I agree that getting close calls and intense matches should be rewarded. Have "Comeback Match Bonus", it's so easy to do and then every game ending wouldn't be this disappointing thing every time
0
Jul 19 '16
[deleted]
1
u/curiosikey i make videos Jul 19 '16
I don't play other f2p games for a reason.
1
u/rubidoux Jul 19 '16
So why do you play this one?
1
u/curiosikey i make videos Jul 19 '16
Legacy player. I liked it long ago.
I dislike the currency model and I've mentioned it with several developers. I'm waiting to see what they end up doing with it.
1
u/rubidoux Jul 19 '16
They're going to keep it and add micro transactions, just like every other f2p. I don't get what the issue is. Once you look beyond the shitty 10-20 for a match and realize you get decent rewards for just playing, it's fine. I unlock at least a character a day with a couple hours of play. If you don't want to play assault/support for the periodic reward, don't.
9
u/Kyoj1n Jul 19 '16
You need to be careful you don't run into the problem Dead by Daylight had for a while.
People figured out the optimal things to do to get the most point in a round and just farmed those. So people would wait to escape or killers would camp players and let them go or some such.
If people found out that as monster you got the most points by getting full strikes on all the players rather than winning quickly you'd get monsters postponing winning to farm a subpar team.