Hi all, given all the fuss of late I wanted to give a few perspectives on what BS has been doing what it has been doing, and what the implications for current and former EN users are. I don't have any privileged knowledge here, but I have a reasonable understanding of software business models. Hopefully this will help users make an informed decision about both their future plans, and the ethos of EN's new owners.
I'll split this into two areas. First, what is BS business strategy (and how that has led to recent strategic decisions. Second, how should EN users think about this + running through some of the myths/misconceptions people have.
1) What is Bending Spoons strategy?
What they are doing is a classic software investment playbook. Basically you have an software business which has been making poor returns because they have been over-investing/building costs to chase a business opportunity which either is not there or they are unable to execute on.
What you do is acquire it for a cheap price (cheap bc margins and hence profits in the business are low). They you do two things:
You dramatically cut costs and stop chasing illusiary growth (e.g. reducing headcount in expensive areas like silicon valley).
You dramatically raise prices. You do this because the user base is actually bifurcated - there is a large majority which don't may much, if anything and are never going to pay. But there is a small minority which finds EN essential and would actually be willing to pay far more than the average user.
By raising prices 2x 3x 5x (tbh no reason it cannot go much higher) you can optimise to maximum absolute revenue dollars. The corollary is you also lose the lower paying users and kill off the prospect of future growth. But that is the point - your strategy is based around a recognition you do not want to optimise for growth you want to optimise for squeezing as much profit out of the existing user base.
This is a very rational business strategy for the owner, if not necessarily for all users. What Musk is doing with Twitter is in some ways a variant of this. Actually Broadcom is currently in the midst of executing exactly this playbook at its VMWare acquisition - if you want a taste of proper angst jump across to VMWare subreddits and have a read.
2) What are the implications of this for EN users (past/future) + addressing some common myths
Of course this strategy does not suit all users, so I want to address a few of the myths being thrown about. Even if you decide to stay you should go into this eyes wide open, particularly is EN is a critical part of your workflow.
a) No, free users are not freeloaders: A common pushback I'm seeing to departing users is "oh good to see you freeloaders leaving good riddance". This is dumb. If the free tier didn't exist they the EN system all the high pay users enjoy would not exist.
The business was built by acquiring paid users via a freemium model (large number of free users sign up; small percentage converts to paid). If there had not been a free offer to attract these users then there wouldn't have been paid users and revenues to support the building and running of the system (beyond initial third party investment). For paid users they literally only have their product they have thanks to those "freeloader" free users.
Edit: Also in terms of cost bear in mind given this is largely a note taking application ongoing costs even for free users are going to be relatively low. Just consider a single 20TB capacity drive (costing IDK $300) could in theory store 400 million 50kb text notes. Even assuming redundancy and paying some degree of cloud service overhead, cold storage really isn't that expensive nowadays.
b) Yes, changing the free tier at short/no notice was a hostile move: To be clear BS have every right to change the terms of the free tier as and when they want. My house, my rules. However nuking the free tier to 1 notebook/50 notes with zero notice (yes we saw it but the majority of free users are not on this sub) was an egregious move.
If you aspire to be a credible user application you give notice for major business model changes - maybe weeks maybe months. I mean Microsoft is giving businesses two years notice for the End of Life for Windows 10.
Doing something as major as this overnight is a hostile move - it was clear that there would be a number of users who have processes built around EN who would have to leave on the back of this. You don't tell users to change their processes with no warning. This says a lot about what BS thinks about their users.
c) If you are a paid user you should not think this hostility does not apply to you: Pulling on this thread a bit more, it is clear that BS is actively hostile towards free users. However if you are a paid user don't think this attitude does not apply to you - some of these free users were loyal advocates for EN. Some may have been occasional, former or future paying users. Its not the fact they weren't paying which means BS is hostile to them. Its that they were not paying enough.
So don't think that because you pay, BS thinks about you any differently. If they are prepared to raise prices on free users to maximise revenue, don't be surprised if they raise prices on paid users in future in order to pursue the same strategy.
d) No you should not assume BS is incentivised to continue investing in EN: Going back to where I started, the two parts of this strategy are minimising costs and maximising revenue. It's explicitly based around a realisation that BS is not seeking to pursue growth. For existing users you should be aware that BS it not incentivised to invest in the product, or at least not to the same degree previous owners were.
The degree to which this comes about is unclear at this point. There are a number of variations of the software investment strategy I have outlined above. The most extreme is "cigar butt investing" where you acquire a declining business for pennies on the dollar, embark on an extreme cost/cutting price increase strategy and extract enough profit to cover your purchase price before the business dies. On the other hand you can adopt a more sustainable strategy where the business still mainains at the current run-rate (or even modestly gows) but profits are much higher.
For users who remain, your best case is modest investment in the product, with growth coming from increasing prices on existing users (remember - new user acquisition is dead). Your worst case is that BS extracts a couple of years of revenue turns a profit on this investment and let the business die. As I said, I do not know how their precise strategy is calibrated, but users who stay should be aware that EN dying and the new owners making a tidy return are not mutually exclusive outcomes. You should plan accordingly.
Hopefully this is of help to people as they consider their future choices. That is all.