Hey guys. So I've been a fan since around when The Open Door had just been released. I was like 8-10 back then lmao. I loved Fallen and The Open Door a lot, but TOD was the album that left a mark on me. It shaped my music taste. I grew up liking similar influences to Evanescence, even outside of the rock or metal genres. The dark, brooding, pain translated into anger/power sort of vibe. Anyways, fast forward we get to third album. I was disappointed because it sounded nothing like Evanescence but it was still Evanescence. So I still listened. It grew on me. I still till this day dislike the straightforward hard rock approach in that album that lacks any of the compositional complexity that we have in TOD. But, we still got bangers, lots.
Fast forward to Bitter Truth. Even bigger disappointment. I'm not gonna address the one flaw everyone talks about on this album. This was the first time I felt like Evanescence became a totally different band and lost their sound, or perhaps, threw it out the window. We only got crumbs of their old work in some songs because she always has something up her sleeve.
After TBT, I was genuinely on the fence with the band. I don't wanna sound dramatic but the emotional tie I have with them is huge. I choose to be this attached to them, because they give meaning to many years of my life that were robbed by trauma. They were one of very few things I had growing up that genuinely represented anything nice at all, so I had to hold on to that. Anyways, after TBT I genuinely wished Amy was going through a creative hiccup and we'd get that familiar sound again, but not just reheating nachos, rather new stuff that still sounds like classic Evanescence, at least.
When Sanctuary came out, I had like 17 different reactions. But at this point I think we're all used to stomaching the music first before we can form an opinion, which honestly I don't do with any other artist and I hate that I get to experience this with the one band I love most. At first, I didn't like any of the album, then, I liked the majority, and now I'm back to all my initial impressions of that album again.
I think even though Sanctuary is a step up from the last two albums, that she's still as creatively all over the place, and choosing to ditch interesting, complex music for a kind of Imagine Dragons stadium rock typa thing. Her anger and lyricism in this album is channeling stereotypical millennial writing, and I mean, she IS an older millennial anyway so it's not like I'm being unfair. I know she's making music for herself and not for others, and that taste is a subjective thing after all this is just music, but I also feel like she hasn't been very on point with her creative choices. I don't know if she knows what her old fans want either. Also, I feel like most artists have a clear sound, know what's expected of them, and have a good understanding of their own creative direction, but with Amy, this is becoming increasingly debatable. I could go on and on about how there were so many missed opportuniities on this album for amazing guitar solos but for some reason it's like the guitarists are too shy to overpower her even though this is the first time she's not been belting throughout the entire album and letting the band breathe since Fallen.
I genuinely don't know what to think of this album. The lyricism isn't bad. but it's not that good either, and kinda tired sometimes. The only strong lines in my opinion are from Self-Destruct and Forever Without You. The instrumentals were very good but had the opportunity to go even harder with the breakdowns and solos. Some breakdowns had me going "wait that's it?".
She's said in a recent interview that underneath the black and goth aesthetic that she's a true optimist, and I think that's what this band has been lacking for decades. I don't want her to be sad or depressed, obviously, but at Evanescence's core is melancholy, pain turned into power, sadness disguised as anger. This was always their formula, and why I believe Afterlife took off so well and was compared to Bring Me To Life and Going Under on so many levels, because it had that exact sauce.
I've just been accepting that I don't know what to feel about them anymore. I'm in a weird place between I love them and wanna be a fan forever because of what they mean to me and I just don't think their music is serving me anymore. They're making good stuff, but it feels off. I'd genuinely like to know if others out there share my same thoughts or feelings about them. If you disagree with me, that's okay and it's not my intention to spread any hatefulness or negativity, I genuinely love this band or else I would've been doing anything else but write a whole essay about why I'm not connecting to their art anymore.
I think it's okay that bands change and long term fans can outgrow them, I think a lot of us may be in that stage, but a part of us wants to hold on. I really do want to.