r/Evanescence • • Nov 28 '23

Are there any Swifties here?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been a casual Taylor Swift fan since her debut album, but only became a hardcore Swiftie this year after attending her Eras tour. I would even say she’s my favorite artist now, with Evanescence being my favorite band.

Just curious if anyone here is a fan and if so, what are your favorite Taylor Swift songs/albums?

I’ve heard people say her song Haunted sounds the most like an Evanescence song, which I kind of agree with, but it’s not one of my favorites. My favorite song right now is probably Daylight, and my favorite albums are Reputation, 1989, and Folklore/Evermore.

ETA: thanks everyone for the great discussion! As I was expecting, Reputation is pretty popular among Ev fans. 🐍🖤 I think maybe that has more to do with the aesthetic than the sound? let me know if you disagree.

To those who are quite offended by this post and discussion, I’m very sorry you weren’t able to ignore it. 🤷‍♀️


r/Evanescence • • Mar 23 '26

Decline in lyrical qualtiy

0 Upvotes

In my opinion, Amy has always had potential as a lyricist, but she has not always met it. I like her writing because it feels genuine and relatable, but to be honest, it's not the strongest. She has a pool of clichés she's consistently pulled from. Her vocabulary is limited, using words like darkness, lies, pain, bleed, etc.

I think her best lyrics are in The Open Door, where she explored more existential themes. This album shows me she can genuinely be a great writer. There's still drama, but it's more sophisticated and grounded as a whole. Hello, Imaginary, and Breathe No More are also examples of how poetic she can get when she really wants to. I'm not sure how much Terry/Ben contributed lyrically, though.

After hearing the snippet for the new song I can confidently say there has been a major decline in the quality of Evanescence lyrics. The writing has become extremely straightforward and one-dimensional, even more so than Fallen. As someone said from another thread, she's basically always pissed at someone, and that's really the extent of the specificity in the lyrics. This has been going on since Ev3. I don't feel like the lyrics really come from any real passion or pain, but are more so just trying to sound as anthemic and defiant as possible. It doesn't feel like her heart is in it anymore.


r/Evanescence • • Dec 10 '25

In the song "Going under" Does anyone else hear "Wake up the walrus"?

0 Upvotes

Maybe I'll wake up for once (wake up for once) is the actual lyric. But I swear for years I've been thinking shes been saying Wake up the walrus.


r/Evanescence • • Jul 09 '26

Okay real talk, yall! What do we have to do to make them get rid of WOY and BWY from this tour setlist? ;)

0 Upvotes

They literally did the TBT tour for a couple of years yet they chose to perform not one but TWO the most boring TBT songs on this tour and decided not to play any deep cuts from our beloved self-titled Ev3? 😭


r/Evanescence • • Apr 22 '26

New Ben Moody's interview is coming !

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Evanescence • • Jun 23 '26

Current-Evanescence through the eyes of a lifelong fan (rant?)

3 Upvotes

Hey guys. So I've been a fan since around when The Open Door had just been released. I was like 8-10 back then lmao. I loved Fallen and The Open Door a lot, but TOD was the album that left a mark on me. It shaped my music taste. I grew up liking similar influences to Evanescence, even outside of the rock or metal genres. The dark, brooding, pain translated into anger/power sort of vibe. Anyways, fast forward we get to third album. I was disappointed because it sounded nothing like Evanescence but it was still Evanescence. So I still listened. It grew on me. I still till this day dislike the straightforward hard rock approach in that album that lacks any of the compositional complexity that we have in TOD. But, we still got bangers, lots.

Fast forward to Bitter Truth. Even bigger disappointment. I'm not gonna address the one flaw everyone talks about on this album. This was the first time I felt like Evanescence became a totally different band and lost their sound, or perhaps, threw it out the window. We only got crumbs of their old work in some songs because she always has something up her sleeve.

After TBT, I was genuinely on the fence with the band. I don't wanna sound dramatic but the emotional tie I have with them is huge. I choose to be this attached to them, because they give meaning to many years of my life that were robbed by trauma. They were one of very few things I had growing up that genuinely represented anything nice at all, so I had to hold on to that. Anyways, after TBT I genuinely wished Amy was going through a creative hiccup and we'd get that familiar sound again, but not just reheating nachos, rather new stuff that still sounds like classic Evanescence, at least.

When Sanctuary came out, I had like 17 different reactions. But at this point I think we're all used to stomaching the music first before we can form an opinion, which honestly I don't do with any other artist and I hate that I get to experience this with the one band I love most. At first, I didn't like any of the album, then, I liked the majority, and now I'm back to all my initial impressions of that album again.

I think even though Sanctuary is a step up from the last two albums, that she's still as creatively all over the place, and choosing to ditch interesting, complex music for a kind of Imagine Dragons stadium rock typa thing. Her anger and lyricism in this album is channeling stereotypical millennial writing, and I mean, she IS an older millennial anyway so it's not like I'm being unfair. I know she's making music for herself and not for others, and that taste is a subjective thing after all this is just music, but I also feel like she hasn't been very on point with her creative choices. I don't know if she knows what her old fans want either. Also, I feel like most artists have a clear sound, know what's expected of them, and have a good understanding of their own creative direction, but with Amy, this is becoming increasingly debatable. I could go on and on about how there were so many missed opportuniities on this album for amazing guitar solos but for some reason it's like the guitarists are too shy to overpower her even though this is the first time she's not been belting throughout the entire album and letting the band breathe since Fallen.

I genuinely don't know what to think of this album. The lyricism isn't bad. but it's not that good either, and kinda tired sometimes. The only strong lines in my opinion are from Self-Destruct and Forever Without You. The instrumentals were very good but had the opportunity to go even harder with the breakdowns and solos. Some breakdowns had me going "wait that's it?".

She's said in a recent interview that underneath the black and goth aesthetic that she's a true optimist, and I think that's what this band has been lacking for decades. I don't want her to be sad or depressed, obviously, but at Evanescence's core is melancholy, pain turned into power, sadness disguised as anger. This was always their formula, and why I believe Afterlife took off so well and was compared to Bring Me To Life and Going Under on so many levels, because it had that exact sauce.

I've just been accepting that I don't know what to feel about them anymore. I'm in a weird place between I love them and wanna be a fan forever because of what they mean to me and I just don't think their music is serving me anymore. They're making good stuff, but it feels off. I'd genuinely like to know if others out there share my same thoughts or feelings about them. If you disagree with me, that's okay and it's not my intention to spread any hatefulness or negativity, I genuinely love this band or else I would've been doing anything else but write a whole essay about why I'm not connecting to their art anymore.

I think it's okay that bands change and long term fans can outgrow them, I think a lot of us may be in that stage, but a part of us wants to hold on. I really do want to.


r/Evanescence • • Dec 13 '25

Umm... about this performance...

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

So, nobody is gonna say that this performance was not it? Like at all? I mean, why perform the new gunship version instead of the original? Cutting those STUNNING guitar parts by Will is a crime! And what exactly is wrong with a louder playback? Strings have always been a huge part of Evanescence. I don't think anyone would be angry at them for using it. Why would they lower those stunning choir parts like that? I don't get it. The whole performance sounds empty. They did pick it up a little at the end but even then it wasn't enough. I guess the sound people clearly effed it up too but at this point, that can't be the only reason.

This performance has Fight Like A Girl vibes. Which is not what they should've done with Afterlife. Whatsoever. I'm barely holding onto hope that the new album will have Afterlife vibes.


r/Evanescence • • Oct 30 '22

What's with Evanescence going through members?

0 Upvotes

I love Evanescence, but it doesn't feel like a band anymore. It feels like Amy Lee band. They're constantly firing members and replacing them, and I don't know why.

The only reason I can think of is that Amy rules with an iron fist, and what Amy wants, Amy gets. And that's fine I guess if it's her band, but that's not what being in a band is about imo.

Conclusion: Evanescence goes through members like toilet paper, and it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Anyone else feel the same or have anything to add/argue?


r/Evanescence • • Jun 14 '26

Concert Final Song

0 Upvotes

I think Blind Belief is a better closing song than Wide Open Heart, even though they have a similar meaning. I was thinking they’d be better off closing the concert with Blind Belief instead or finding a way to mesh the two songs together.

BUT...

When Amy stands up on the piano before Wide Open Heart and delivers the right powerful speech, it could become another epic, iconic moment.

What do you guys think? Or is it just me not being used to Wide Open Heart yet?


r/Evanescence • • Jun 29 '26

My honest thoughts after listening to 'The bitter truth' for the first time

1 Upvotes

Hi. I haven't really listened to 'The bitter truth' at all. And now that the new album is out, I wanted to listen to it first.

  1. Artifact/the turn - I love the intro. 8/10 for an intro

  2. Broken pieces shine - I imagine broken glass shining with this song. It's nice 6.8/10

  3. The game is over - this song is so rock and roll and kind of 90s vibes, but it sounds like a filler song if you know what I mean so average points 5.5/10

4.Yeah Right - it's a fun song ngl 7.2/10

5.Feeding the dark - so far the best song in the album. It's funny because in Albanian dark means dinner 9.2/10

6.Wasted on you - it's okay. I like the bridge the most. There's smth

missing in this song.I wouldn't have made it the first single at all. 7/10

7.Better without you - 6.8/10 I feel the same with this song like broken pieces shine

8. Use my Voice - the chorus is really annoying 4.5/10

9.Take Cover - it does sound like a cover of some song 1.8/10

10.Far from heaven - when I first listened to this song, I found it too sad, but it's beautiful. It's raw, honest and 8.9/10

11.Part of me - perfection the best song in the album 10/10

12.Blind belief - I only like the beginning the rest is a bit cringey 1.9/10


r/Evanescence • • Jan 15 '25

New Rule?

0 Upvotes

Can mods are a rule to avoid getting random recomendations like "This sounds like Evanescence..." or "This sounds like Amy Lee..." like i don't care i'm here for Evanescence only


r/Evanescence • • Jun 07 '26

EV as Amy's Journey

0 Upvotes

After listening to Sanctuary, I had the idea to listen to Evanescence's entire discography (just the full/deluxe albums), and I could pretty much trace the journey of the band, and where Amy specifically was at each point.

Fallen - I see this as primarily a Ben Moody album with Amy as the voice. If you're mainly a songwriter, you'd always want a voice to complete your songs. This is essentially how the band functioned before Ben's departure, and we can hear it in both the sound and in some of Amy's lyrics.

The Open Door - This is Amy trying to steer Evanescence toward her vision. I think this is still the most "artsy-fartsy" album the band has made (said with all affection), even compared to their other work. Here, Amy is telling us that she's THE choir nerd in the band and has more to offer than what we saw on Fallen. It's her properly introducing herself to us without Ben breathing down her neck.

Evanescence - This is her "she's annoyed at the fans, she's pissed at the label, she dislikes herself (kinda)" album. We can see her trying to make it as rock as possible so the label would get off her case. For me, it was good for the band because we can finally hear the other members contribute unlike in previous records where it was just her and one other person, with everyone else adding instrumentals later.

Synthesis - At this point, they parted with their label and were operating as free agents. For me, this is them showing us what they could do outside of rock just because they can. Obviously, I know this is an Amy Lee passion project, but I'm so happy that the guys were all on board. At the time, I was excited to see what they'd do once they went back to rock after they wrapped up the tour.

The Bitter Truth -This feels like a pre-Sanctuary album where we can already hear elements from their earlier work (Pre-Fallen, Fallen & The Open Door), but the band, or really, Amy, is still trying to rein it in. By "rein it in," I mean not using synths, layers, and strings too much. I think at this point, Amy was already seeing the earlier music as an important element of the EV sound, but that would have meant going back to the memories made when that music was created, and I feel like she didn't want to go back there. It was still a good album, though I only have two songs that are favorites of mine. We also hear Amy writing lyrics about what's happening in the world instead of inside herself. I've always wondered what she would write about if she were in a happy place and this is that album. But she's still half-in and half-out; there are songs that go outward and some that stay inward.

Sanctuary - This is Amy Lee in a healed place. Knowing that she fell in love again with the earlier music (thanks to producers who are millennials, the age group who grew up with their music as kids and teenagers), we can see she's embraced those elements again. We hear it sonically, and literally in "Forever Without You," which confirms where she stands regarding her relationship with the early music and the people she made it with. This album respects the band's past (not running away from it, which was a feeling I got from TBT, where they used early sounds while simultaneously running from them) while telling its present story and looking forward to the future. If Sanctuary is Amy Lee in a healed place, I'm so excited how the next album or the next project would sound.

That's about it. What are your thoughts? This was written in a rush as I'm doing what millennials are good at doing: doing household chores while listening to the heaviest music.


r/Evanescence • • Aug 09 '26

Am I the only one?

10 Upvotes

Not trying to get hate here. I love Evanescence. I literally have The Open Door logo tattooed.

Am I the only person who just cannot get into the new album?

I've tried multiple times and I'm just not feeling it AT ALL


r/Evanescence • • Oct 05 '24

Saveee meee

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Evanescence • • Dec 05 '25

Is there a FLAG version without the rap?

0 Upvotes

I like FLAG except for the rap part. I'm sorry but Kflay ruins the song. As soon as that part comes on, all I hear is annoying screaming. It's just noise to me. I want to hear Amy not some bad rapper.


r/Evanescence • • Jun 09 '24

The problem with Ev's later lyrics

0 Upvotes

I feel like Amy's inspiration well is completely dry now. The last 2 albums were so generic and bland.

Like Fallen, was the culmination of all her childhood and teenage angst. TOD was her dealing with fame, the Ben situation, a major breakup with Shaun and getting married.

Then self title was about what? One song allegedly about human trafficking (you can't guess that from the lyrics), a bunch of fake break up songs (like who is she even talking about? not Shaun still?), love songs...

Then TBT was again a bunch of fake break up songs that when I heard them I could only think 'Girl you've been happily married for years, what are you talking about???' One vaguely political song and one song about not selling out? Ok. I just think she has a very cherished sheltered life and doesn't have anything to talk about anymore. Good for her but not good for the band.


r/Evanescence • • Jun 19 '26

We need Amy to finally respond to Erin

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
0 Upvotes

Please help me help this random girl on tik tok I saw who posted this. I need to see this come full circle and Amy reply to her.


r/Evanescence • • Apr 25 '26

3.5 Hour Deep Dive Interview With Evanescence Co-Founder Ben Moody!

Post image
0 Upvotes

On episode #230 of The Joel Martin Mastery Podcast I do a 3.5 hour deep dive interview with Ben Moody. He's the founding guitarist and songwriter for the diamond selling band Evanescence. Their debut album FALLEN has sold over 17 million copies making it the 7th best-selling album of the 21st century. The album featured the massive global hits "Bring Me to Life", "Going Under", "My Immortal" and "Everybody's Fool"!

As a songwriter and producer, Ben has worked with Kelly Clarkson, Avril Lavigne, Celine Dion, Anastacia, Lindsay Lohan, Daughtry, Halestorm and Flyleaf. He also founded the supergroups The Halo Method and We Are the Fallen!

You can watch the interview at https://youtu.be/JmRq-SRQWL8

We cover his entire life, career and discography starting with his earliest musical memories, through to meeting Amy at a summer camp, the success of Fallen, leaving the band, focusing on songwriting and producing, starting his other 2 bands and then what he's up to now. The Evanescence part of his life is from the 47 minute mark to the 1 h 27 minute mark.

If you enjoy today’s episode, please take a moment to subscribe, like, comment and share!


r/Evanescence • • Sep 05 '26

List songs from best to worst

Post image
3 Upvotes

Now that we've had the album for a little bit, how would you sort the songs from best to worst?


r/Evanescence • • Oct 01 '26

Is it just me, or does Molly Dunsworth look a lot like Amy Lee?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Evanescence • • Sep 09 '26 Regret

I have to be honest with myself, Ev’s newer releases are disappointing.

0 Upvotes

I promise I’m not just trying to be a hater here, I’m curious on how others feel. I’ve been a MASSIVE fan since I was a teen.

I kind of assumed the more recent releases haven’t really resonated with me as an adult as I haven’t really given them my full attention as I would’ve done as a teen. But I saw them live last night and it made me realise- I just feel like some of that magic has gone.

And I don’t expect them to create a Fallen or TOD part 2. I understand bands evolve and change over time but definitely with the most recent albums (and to an extent ev3 but I did love that album as a teen too) it just feels like very generic alt-rock. In earlier records the piano felt like such an integral part of the Ev sound but now it just sounds like piano embellishment that you could find on any other rock record. The piano ballads just sound like piano ballads, they don’t have the same impact that tracks like Good Enough had on me (like that song inspired me to learn to play piano)

Most of the set last night seemed to be newer songs- and look, I can’t complain, I went to an evanescence gig and they played evanescence songs. Amy’s voice was absolutely phenomenal and they put on a good show (also got to hear Like You live holy shit!)

I went with my bf who has never listened to Evanescence (aside from bmtl) and when I mentioned if a song was older/newer he just straight up said “well the older songs just sound better” so I am reluctant to say that I might just be blinded by nostalgia on this.

Anyway, this feels very negative and I don’t want to be. I’ve absolutely loved evanescence for years, Amy has always been my absolute idol, so it feels odd to be so disappointed. I just wondered if anyone else feels the same.


r/Evanescence • • May 03 '21 Heartwarming

Bold statement: Evanescence might not have a career without the guy on Bring Me To Life

9 Upvotes

The original without him is bland compared to the version with him. And clearly the numbers show that....all elitist/rock-purist opinions aside.

Edit: You really only get one crack at a first impression. If they released the original version, it would've maybe been a moderate hit at best which means they probably wouldn't have even made it to a third single (My Immortal).


r/Evanescence • • Jun 15 '25

Just a question

0 Upvotes

Why is it that every time someone comments respectfully about "not caring about Amy's political views" or just disagreeing with her, you guys just go on a rampage with down votes and insults? I'm not American, in my country we have our own issues to deal with at the moment and I couldn't care less what Amy supports or doesn't support politically, I just like her music, that's all. And there are other fans like me who are here for the music, not the politics, but when we say it out loud and in a respectful way you guys get upset and I don't know why. Are we all supposed to be free to comment here, or is there some rule I'm missing?


r/Evanescence • • Sep 04 '26

Sorry I just cannot believe this 2nd single

0 Upvotes

Out of the other 9 amazing songs, they picked TMWYHE to be the second single?! I genuinely do not understand the appeal of this song.

Chorus - not the strongest, nothing special
Darkness/ gothic-feeling - NONE
Strings - NONE
Cool electronics effects - NONE
Bridge - underwhelming
Guitar - repetitive and also not groundbreaking

Literally every other song in this album is more interesting and better than this song. I just don’t understand. It feels the least Evanescence song. Nothing in this song gives off the special Evanescence feeling.

Edit:

  1. More listen on platform doesn’t mean the song is good. It’s was just more promotion for the song and people got to listen to it easier. I can easily see people saying “oh it sounds good but just meh and generic”. It has none of the elements that made Ev special or popular in the first place. So do you want more people to hear a song that just made them think “oh Evanescence is now just a generic rock band and has lost their uniqueness”? That’s why so many “fan fav” songs have become “hidden gems” or “deserved more popularity”.

  2. They came out with unique sound and style and that’s what made them stood out and succeeded, eg Going Under/ BMTL. Even back then Amy said she did not want to have the male rap part because it wasnt them and she wanted Imaginary to be a single. Now they have full control and they still went for the more “generic and commercial” direction in terms of singles?!!!

  3. I am not saying nowadays they will still get a lot of fans. But wouldn’t you want those “non-fans” to hear the actually Ev sound that we love and let them know that Ev is STILL special and has their own unique style and that has never changed? Without being singles, the actually gems like Rapture, Sanctuary, Self Destruct will AGAIN become hidden and less known to the general public, just like Imaginary, Whisper, The Only One, Your Star, TEOTD, Never Go Back, Feeding The Dark, Part of Me etccc