Before you make a passionate statement, I’m specifically seeking comments that address the following. Let's debate this respectfully, please:
Animals, especially the ones typically consumed by humans, exhibit compassion, joy, fear, suffering, love, respect, depression, self sacrifice, and so on. This is both toward other humans they have relationships with as well as to their own kind and other animals in their environment. This wide and complex array of externally validated expressions of their interior world indicate that humans and animals share at the very least these foundational qualities of consciousness. While the debate on meta-cognition, awareness of awareness, is ongoing and varies significantly across species, it's clear these animals possess intention, process experience, develop personality, and are capable of a range of emotions, as a baseline aspect of their existence.
Just yesterday I saw this post where a pig delivers hay everyday to its disabled brother. This signifies intention, compassion, respect, community, etc. A “humane” act, if I may.
https://www.reddit.com/r/nextfuckinglevel/comments/1s9yjyf/loyal_pig_always_makes_sure_his_disabled_brother/
I have heard the argument that many of you think eating meat is ethical and, surprisingly, that you also care about how much suffering these animals endure in factory farm environments. I find this belief to be extraordinarily contradictory, cognitively dissonant, and this is the main point I would like to address. I hope you can respectfully debate me.
The contradiction:
If you believe in ethical farming practices, it means you acknowledge these beings are capable of suffering and that it's ethically wrong to cause them unnecessary suffering. But, at the same time, it is still ethical to kill them for consumption, a consumption that is not only unnecessary for survival, but exclusively in the category of "for pleasure".
Unless you are a subsistence farmer/hunter existing outside of the market economy, your meat eating can by no means be deemed necessary, as there are vegetarian alternatives that are proven to sustain an optimally healthy existence, which means it is choice of preference, which reduces meat consumption to an act of selfish hedonism, in my respectful opinion.
I was a meat eater for most of my life. But, in my adulthood, did not consider what I was doing was ethical. I knew it was wrong, but just didn't care. As someone in pursuit of a more ethical life, I realized there are people who do consider their unnecessary meat consumption as ethical, and I would like to understand if or how you rationalize that?
No judgment, we're all (I hope) doing our best to be the best person we can be, and that's part of the reason we're in this sub.
Thank you for your respectful contributions.