r/EternalCardGame • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '18
r/EternalCardGame • u/[deleted] • Feb 25 '19
I Try To Watch Twitch Streamers But Find It Unbearable
I have seriously tried to watch eternal streamers on twitch. But I find it unbearable. The streamers, for the most part, just seem bored and disengaged, like they are putting in their hours of work at a dull job.
They never talk about the cards or about strategy so I simply cannot see the point. They babble an inane stream of consciousness about their life or what they watched on Netflix.
The communal fixation on twitch drops makes me want to just bail out on Eternal no matter how much I enjoy it. I can't believe that everybody here truly wants to sit around watching this stuff. Or are the rewards so great that players feel forced to engage?
r/EternalCardGame • u/Vinizont • Jan 30 '19
DWD PLS?!
INFLUENCE STORE?!
I get complaining is not really good. BUT all we really want is an OFFICIAL DELAY! or just a Q&A i mean we are really passionat for this game and willing to spend a dime or two but what DWD is doing right now is just pissing of people! No communication is the wrong communication ALLWAYS. Has anyone seen the Metroid Prime Video from Nintendo? Thats the way u should treat ur fans and costumers! Here is a Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zLIv_UXI_So
I know we are getting a pretty good Game exp. and i´m grateful for what u are Doing @DWD !
JUST COMMUNICATE WITH UR PLAYERBASE!
r/EternalCardGame • u/Ilyak1986 • Oct 12 '17
Why Tavrod is a mistake from a design perspective
Okay, so, by now, I'm sure everyone has had a chance to see or play with the new over-pushed cow released in Tale of Horus Traver. Some may call him "Tavrod, Auric Broker", but in reality, the more apt name for him is "Tavgod, Auric Broken", whose textbox may as well be "if your opponent does not immediately play deathstrike, feeding time, vanquish, or slay, roll a 10-sided die. If it comes up 2 or higher, you win the game."
So...where to begin? An easy place to start is this: if anyone (especially me) were to suggest Tavgod, Auric Broken in the #custom-cards channel in the discord, they'd be absolutely laughed at. A beefy unit, harder to answer/kill than any other near its cost, playable in a 25 + 4 vara's favor deck, with massive upside if you get to untap and swing with him, and in the faction of all of the spot removal you can possibly want? "Yep, just another ridiculous ill-yak card", some people would say. Well, in this case, it's DWD that designed it. And while some people may be praising DWD on their design work, let's get a few things clear:
Many of us are here only because of WotC's/Hasbro's utter incompetency to adapt MtG for an online environment. While some edge-case shortcuts may not be possible to seamlessly translate into the online world, the mere fact that WotC/Hasbro can't even come up with a decent F2P model and a polished client is just inexcusable on their end. If WotC/Hasbro ever got their act together, put their heads into the 21st century, and put a polished client with an F2P business model comparable to Eternal's, I'd be playing MtG in a heartbeat, and I'm sure quite a few people here would join me. Odds are, though, this is wishful thinking, and we're playing the next best thing because it has a great business model and client.
DWD is pretty far from infallible in their design history. In slightly over a year (AKA half of one set's duration in standard), if we count nerfs that have completely changed cards or removed them from competitive tournament play as bans, we have the following list: closed beta sparring partner, witching hour (Juspas's flash in the pan aside), closed beta champion of cunning, closed beta gilded glaive, inspire, flame blast, copper conduit, charchain flail, excavate, stronghold visage, frontier jito (albeit saw fairly little tournament play to begin with), crownwatch paladin, elder's feather, closed beta morningstar, umbren reaper, and depending on where you stand, shimmerpack. This isn't to mention the numerous nerfs to cards that still remain playable (pyroknight, chacha, stash, steward of the past, soulfire drake). That's not to even mention how many decks DWD has actively gutted as collateral damage (conduit nerfs murdered Xenan killers on the spot, Chacha nerfs killed god knows how many stonescar decks that simply depended on her to not get run over, flail and stash nerfs most likely doomed kalis, TJP non-chalice visage control is most likely a distant memory). So, hopefully this little tally can convince people that despite some pro-tour names, that names merely grant a chance to be judged by the results, which have thus far, have been found wanting in my opinion, especially given the caliber of the name recognition of certain people on DWD's staff. Now, while I suppose some individuals out there might say "but all of those decks had tremendously unhealthy play patterns and were bad for the game", odds are, most people would rightfully take the other side of that.
So now that we've established that DWD has far from a spotless record, allow me to submit that Tavrod is yet another example of Heinlein's Razor, for which DWD has established a bit of a track record for.
So, let me outline the reasons as to why Tavrod is a mistake and an example of bad design:
The card is simply too hard to interact with given its cost. 5 cost means it's the cheapest card that dodges banish. Endurance (AKA the "fuck you, primal" keyword) means it can't be hit by permafrost. Multifaction means annihilate blanks. 5 attack means suffocate blanks. 7 health means that not only does torch blank, but obliterate also fails to kill it, and even predatory carnosaur--a unit that costs 1 more, can't even bring Tavrod down. Recently, I was reading an MtG design column called Four Rules For a Balanced Format ( https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/play-design/four-rules-balanced-format-2017-09-29 ), and the first rule was that decks should have interaction. The way that Tavrod is designed--that is, to blank as much interaction as possible--and the kind of deck he promotes--loading up Bart with obscenely buffed lifesteal weapons--the resultant "counterplay" to Tavrod is "you can either remove Tavrod, or you can remove your opponent". And guess which kind of deck DWD has nerfed time and again because they've been too consistent at killing their opponent before they could untap on turn 5? See the problem? Now, if we had cards like terminate, unlicensed disintegration, and murder (among many others), Tavrod would be less of an issue. But as it stands, the interaction in the game is simply insufficient, and by the looks of things, Tavrod was designed to just make entire chunks of the game blank. Why? Again, I'll defer to Heinlein's Razor.
The upside is simply absurd. While I haven't yet gone and recorded the stats of "games I win in which I've gotten to swing with Tavrod", it's certainly felt that many games in which I got to swing with Tavrod quickly ended shortly thereafter. And while some people may bend themselves into mental contortions stating "well you only won because you were able to stick a 5-drop" or "it's not the Tavrod, it's the Bart carrying the 9/1 Falchion!" or any number of other excuses. At the end of the day, ultimately, the question is: "what the heck is the point of having units that cost more than 5 if swinging a couple of times with Tavrod is enough to close the game?" I'm sure some people have had those games that have gone to the last few cards, we topdeck Icaria and start to turn the corner, have to swing away with her for dear life, and wind up losing the game anyway because a topdecked carnosaur comes along, chomps her, revives a dawnwalker, and the Icaria player dies anyway without ever having drawn her warcries. Or they did draw her 3 warcries--which promptly hit a Rakano Artisan that ate a permafrost, or a vanquish, or any number of other situations in which a 5/5 for 7 couldn't get the kill, and her back-loaded power budget either wasn't drawn, or was just insufficient or irrelevant given the lag time. In contrast, Mr. Beefy Bullshit here not only grants a massive attack bonus, but also draws the card immediately. I mean, to put it into perspective, imagine if Icaria was a 5/7 that drew the next unit or weapon from your deck whenever she attacked. Sounds absurd, doesn't it? And keep in mind that Icaria imposes some massive deckbuilding costs in order to survive long enough to cast her. Tavrod, meanwhile is just "oh hey, minimum 25 power, with diplo seals and just jam 4 vara's favor because OPOP? Okay!". Tavrod's upside just makes absolutely zero sense when compared on a cost-benefit analysis to the one other card that buffs other units and weapons by a comparable amount.
The deckbuilding style that Tavrod encourages is A) fairly toxic (spam removal, load up an unblockable aegis unit or a nearly-impossible-to-remove battle tank with enormous weapons) and B) didn't need any help whatsoever! In the LCQ, we already saw this style of Bartgenpants deck be very successful (https://eternalwarcry.com/decks/details/uBGqeKd3GLI/argenport-midrange), as well as fairly successful in the invitational (https://eternalwarcry.com/tournaments/details/cZMzvf_nNOw/ets-season-5-invitational), again by Beylac. Furthermore, most of my invitational points this season have been based off of a similar idea of loading up units like Bart and enforcer with lifesteal weapons (bloodletter and falchion). Both times I played argenport aggro without oathbook mainboard, I was on the cusp of top 8, with a ninth place 5-2 finish, and a 4-2 finish (lost to my teammate Elunex, and was one hit away from killing him in a game 3 in which he topdecked permafrost to turn the corner). It also was the only win from Flame's side against Toth when OND Flame and OND feather duked it out. So, Bartgenpants needed no help. And considering that the armory deck also got nerfed for being too homogeneous (see: inspire, flail, stash nerfs), I highly doubt that DWD intended for Tavrod to just make armory strategies homogeneous once again.
Tavrod seems to intrude on other faction identities. As a weapons lord, it'd seem he'd be far more fitting in Rakano. Given his size, he'd seem far more fitting in some time-based faction. Having a unit that's a cross between SST and Reality Warden, and whose on-attack ability is a pair of rise to the challenges on steroids, and then have him be in Argenport seems all sorts of ridiculous.
So yeah, in conclusion, I'm hoping that given DWD's fairly extensive track record of significant screw-ups (at least if their own effective bannings in balance patches are anything to go by), I'm hoping that Tavrod gets a fairly heavy-handed nerf. Me personally, I'd make him a 5/6 vanilla (so you can permafrost him) that draws a minotaur from the top 5 cards of your deck and gives it 2 attack when he hits the opponent. In a minotaur tribal deck, he'd still be a value-generating machine provided you can get a few whacks in, and would still grow to be big and beefy when equipped with weapons, but will no longer be a "free play, click + space to instantly win game", will impose some deckbuilding constraints that create a new meta, and will still have incentive to be played as Argenport's only real card advantage engine while at the same time not just teaming up with the rest of argenport goodstuff (I.E. Enforcer + Bart + Instigator + weapons).
r/EternalCardGame • u/Inthethickofit • Jun 14 '18
Proposal: Bring back the old client on mobile until the glitches are resolved
Edit: The Consensus seems to be against my proposal and a Mod posted that they have a fix in the works for mobile apps
Fist I want to say to DWD:
Thank you so much for your product. I love Eternal. I play everyday. I appreciate that in the time I've played I've needed to actually pay only about $30 and that I have a lot of both in game currencies saved up (you have by far the best player friendly economy of any CCG). I recognize that we are still in Beta and as a result there can be some issues and that testing is part of what you have us for. So I come to this proposal from a place of constructive criticism and I don't want to think I or any of us are ungrateful.
The roll out of the new client doesn't seem to be going to plan. Some of the issues (like the repetitive disconnects) are things you probably couldn't have known about before rolling it out. Its something you may need us all as Beta testers to help figure out, but it does make playing right now very frustrating, If this was the only issue, I wouldn't make this proposal. But its not.
Some of the issues like the timer on destiny cards or the almost inability to play Warp cards could and should have been solved before this update was pushed out. If you had tested every major archetype in ranked you would have discovered both issues in a day or two of testing.
The warp one is (for lack of a better term) truly warping deck selection choices and make me and probably everyone else have a mini-anxiety attack as we try to play warp cards and if we have a full hand, the desire to throw our phone when we accidentally play the card farthest to the right in our hand instead of playing the warp card.
I know its not ideal, but would it be possible to roll back this latest update until its closer to ready for mass play. We're all really excited about the new set coming out and I know I along with everyone else is super excited about the wide release and hopefully marketing campaign to expand the player base. The game has so much potential, I'm sad that the r/eternal top posts are all about bugs instead of being about some crazy new combo finish someone came up with.
Again, thanks for all you do. Hoping for Eternal's continued success.
r/EternalCardGame • u/Meyou52 • Nov 28 '18
Everybody Complaining About Sigils
You people cried for them to come back since they left the store, and now you have the opportunity to get them but you don’t want to spend money? They should just not release them ever again. You sound like a bunch of children. Grow up, they’re a business, and it’s not like they just doubled the price of the sigils and are giving you nothing else.
r/EternalCardGame • u/Ilyak1986 • May 10 '18
Rando-Eternal, satisfying games, and the non-game problem still not solved
So, let me try and spin another argument on why power issues should be solved a bit better:
Simply, the example of rando-chess from Richard Garfield. That is, at the end of each game, roll a d6. If it comes up 1, the other person wins. This doesn't take away from the importance of being good at Chess--the better player will still win "over the long term", but it nevertheless makes some amount of games miserable, and by Garfield's own admission, such a game is a travesty.
In similar ways, power issues simply cause non-games. Whether you can't play at all, or whether you can barely play (EG 3 shadow sigil AP hand--sure, you got to play that interrogator, but you missed your 2 and 4 drop, and meanwhile, your opponent had one piece of interaction and otherwise executed his plan in a satisfactory manner), it's nevertheless a miserable experience. Furthermore, even if it's a one-game, short term result, when you have a few of those in a limited event (2F is very hard to do in sealed, so you most likely have to 2.5f), or lose a crucial match in a bo3 to put you at 4-2 instead of 5-1 (and into the top 8), the long term is nevertheless comprised of short-term instances. Furthermore, if your opponent plays the game as well, simply "being able to play the game" is insufficient. You need to outplay your opponent, and that's far harder with one or both hands proverbially tied behind your back.
I assert that rando-Eternal (AKA the unplayable games) should, ideally, have no place in the digital realm of TCGs/CCGs in the 21st century. DWD has shown an attempt to rectify this problem with the mulligan rule. However, the mulligan rule seems to simply punish solid deckbuilding more than help it. Make a reasonable 30 pure power Praxis power base and have to mull? Congratulations, you mulled to 2 fire sigils because fuck you. Play a 25 power aggro list? ManuS at one point cited that the moment you hit that redraw button with a rally list, you lost an entire 10% from your win rate, simply due to the risk of redrawing into 4 power (and of course, your immediate 5th on the draw).
Considering that DWD has banned decks for creating unenjoyable game states (under the catch-all of "repetitive game states"--such as with echo excavate and echo revenge), that they're still perfectly alright with non-games occurring due to the very foundational resource system, no matter how disciplined the deckbuilding, is still my primary frustration with this game (even ten thousand wins later).
To those that say "but then maybe resource-based CCGs aren't for you", I feel that's the same thing as someone saying "maybe Chess isn't for you" if they'd advocate removing the roll of the d6 at the end.
And while some individuals may fail to envision a system in which it's possible to punish greedy deckbuilding while not causing collateral damage to properly built decks, I assert that somewhere between the double nickel shuffle (perfect mana weave, illegal in MtG), and complete randomness, we have some sort of system that can reduce the number of extreme variance outliers (EG topdecking a pocket of 4 power in your 26 power, 4-favor AP mid deck, or your 29 source Rakano Plate, getting stuck at 2 after a mull with Praxis Midrange, etc.), while still discouraging "25 power 10x 5-drop" nonsense.
Ultimately, the question I ask is this:
Would people rather play Eternal--or would you rather play rando-Eternal?
r/EternalCardGame • u/Ilyak1986 • Feb 03 '18
Reaction to Patch Changes Abridged (just for you Scarlatch)
Draft: welcome, format still sucks due to lack of fixing and interaction. Tribal on-rails = unpleasant compared to 1-1-1-1 emergent synergy and 2-1-2-1 goodstuff greedmonster heaven. 3213 is the least fun I've had with draft in a long time.
Witch nerf: awful because it removes lines of play just to pander to those that don't put in the time to understand a card's intricacies which would only take a few uses with the card.
Steward nerf + stonepowder alchemist buff: really bad. For all of DWD's emphasis on play patterns, you're removing safety valves and methods of interacting with a synergy deck on its less conventional axis of attack, implying that the "counterplay" is to kill an echo-revenge player before they do anything. Uninteractive, who-goldfishes-first games are not interesting. Safety valves are good. Hosing safety valves is not.
Dawnwalker change: TT influence threshold would be welcome to prevent edge cases (EG Hooru deck discarding two dawnwalkers to Kosul Brigade). TTT would be understandable. TTTT is awful, since it hoses actual dedicated time decks, such as Xenan Killers, instead of decks that just tried to cheat dawnwalker into play. Time-based decks are also struggling right now due to saturation of argenport removal, and nerfing them is a stupid idea at this point in time.
Instigator nerf: especially stupid. There are already plenty of anti-aggro tools (combrei healer, devoted theurge, lightning storm, spirit guide, etc.), most of which do not see maindeck ladder play. Stonescar is not a good deck when opponents respect its early game and interact with it, and hasn't been good since Horus. Rakano and Skycrag aggro will fill the oni ronin hole just as quickly. Aggro decks are already awful in tournament settings when opponents can sideboard to respect them, and either Eternal will get bo3 tournaments one day, for which aggro is dreadfully positioned, or will lose a chunk of its playerbase that expects sideboard tournaments.
Bond unit buffs: they still suck. You're only playing them if your opponent lets you keep an obvious buff enabler in play. If that happens, you're most likely winning already.
Lack of Tavrod nerf: absurd. Most of the dedicated community completely expected a change to a card that dodges clean answers from more than half the factions in the game. That this card was first approved by a chain of DWD designers and then not changed despite having a warping influence on the metagame because of flawed data analysis is the blackest mark among black marks in this patch.
Other comments: data analysis requires domain expertise to interpret the results. Lack of Tavrod popularity, for example, may mean lack of access to him (I.E. players don't have 20,000 gold to throw out), or simply boredom with the deck upon reaching masters.
Worst patch in a while.
r/EternalCardGame • u/Shadowcran • May 03 '17
My biggest problems with Eternal....
I'm hoping there are others who share my dilemma(s)
I can't figure out which dual color is my favorite. I think Xenan, but will need upcoming additions before final judgement.
I can't decide what to play. I'll win a match, then immediately want to switch to another deck. TOO MUCH VARIETY!!!!
I can't stop making deck adjustments. I simply can't.
I can't stop coming up with ideas. I'm playing a match and an idea just pops in. If the opponent is playing something unique, then even more ideas happen. It's not fair!!!
r/EternalCardGame • u/DeezNutzIncorporated • Jan 01 '20
OPINION Endra is broken. Nerf her. The card is completely a mistake.
All that needs to be said. Completely stupid design. Like honestly what were you thinking Eternal. I don't want to play this game if you make dumb broken cards like this.
r/EternalCardGame • u/leprerklsoigne • Jul 24 '17
I'm not enjoying the game lately
and I think it's because of the changes. the main reasons I don't like these changes are:
I don't get to draft as much no matter how you slice it we get less entries overall, I also don't like the new draft format it feels like everything is a pile and games are basically who can start the snowball first/who can get color screwed less/who can drop the bomb first instead of the old format which I felt was basically who can build the best deck with the most focused plan.
Creating decks just seems really unrewarding right now, before the patch you could create some garbage and know even if your winrate is bad you eventually get a couple of silver chests, now I feel like I should just netdeck and aim for the highest winrate because I'm desperate for gold.
You no longer have control of how fast you build your collection. Sure you get a good value boost by the pack every day but this makes me feel like I have to play a game a day not that I want to play. This is probably really bad for new players as well, if someone doesn't have set 1 and they really like the game it's going to take them a longgg time to aquire it and there's nothing they can really do to change that if they don't like playing gauntlet, or of course paying money
Gauntlet is good value and I'm glad some people enjoy playing it but personally I get no satisfaction out of beating A.I. so for me it's just out of the question, I want to play against real players.
The only thing I really like about the patch is the cards seem like they will be healthy for constructed and create some new stuff, and all of their design is pretty balanced.
I feel like people are shunning anyone who has a negative opinion b/c DWD is a great company and made a great game (this is all true) but this doesn't mean they cannot make a mistake. In my opinion this is a bad direction the game is now going and now is the only time we can get them to change it.
Any recommendations on how to make the game fun again? and how do you honestly feel about it?
r/EternalCardGame • u/Sunyveil • Mar 11 '19
The Influence Store, Drop Campaigns, etc. can be great for us and we need to appreciate it more.
https://www.twitch.tv/videos/394029156
Been busy lately and have been meaning to get my thoughts out because I think the Influence Store update is fantastic for the game, or could be if people had the right mindset for it. Talked for ~1 hour today about why I like what DWD has done with the Influence Store / Drop Campaigns and how we can get the most out of it.
TL;DW:
People that enjoy watching a specific streamer will still do so
People that give financial support to content creators will still do so
Watch/support content that you enjoy
Create content that you enjoy creating
Streamers that create the best content will rise to the top, faster than before
r/EternalCardGame • u/PernilleOoo • Jun 16 '19
OPINION dwd should have spent $100000 on marketing not a tounrament convince me im wrong?
https://i.imgflip.com/33kjh1.jpg
its embarassing how fast this game is tanking a month before
such a big money tournament
https://steamcharts.com/app/531640#1m
lowest monthly average ever and its going to drop more
r/EternalCardGame • u/leon95 • Jun 01 '19
CONTENT Anyways, let's talk rotation and why I think it's bad
Hi, I'm Anyway.
But you may know me as AnywayTheWindbro, leon_95 or just some random dumbass with a blue name who sucks at arguing on Discord. I love Dragons and other similar jank, am kind of active on the Discord and actually have gotten a degree since my last article. Rest assured, all this didn't stop me from not reaching Masters, so you still don't have to take me seriously. Finally, obligatory apology for being bad at words since I'm a scientist (B.Sc. officially makes me one), not a writer. Also, excuse my hyperbole in some cases and prepare yourself for a lot of dry text. As always, a TL;DR is at the end.
Before you ask, I'm back to talk about yet another controversial and polarizing topic. This time, I want to talk about Rotation, why it's not likely gonna happen and why it probably shouldn't even happen in Eternal. Also, as always, I want to talk about how most people who ask for it don't understand what they are asking for. Don't get me wrong, I'm not telling you anything like "my opinion is worth more than yours because your opinion is garbage" and you're free to form your own opinion. However, hear me out, since most people asking for rotation are just jumping on the bandwagon of things like "other games do that too and it works for them" or "do you want to play with Torch forever". And in my opinion those are not really valid points, which is why I'm writing this whole thing here. I would like people to think about what a rotation would imply and how it may or may not solve the problems they have with the game. Of course not everyone who wants rotation has a problem with the game, and this is not supposed to be a jab or insult towards those people. You guys have a right to want rotation, just as I have a right to not want it. I just want to speak out my mind against hypocrisy.
I said that in my last article already, but any sort of rotation would be a massive nerf to the game, since it takes away many tools, no matter how you look at it. And as I had said times and times again, I would like for there to be more, not less tools. Rotation, at it's core, is nothing more than an artificial way to mix up the meta and freshen up the game, which is fine in and by itself. However, as I've talked to some people propagating for rotation, I realized how most of them say things like "I don't wanna see torch ever again" or "Rotate out the entire Set 1", which in my eyes is utter nonsense. Especially since on the topic of reprinting cards that rotated out, people told me "or they can just make a new card that is similar", when I point out that rotation should imply that cards need to also be rotated back in. And this is the infuriating thing that lead me to writing up this wall of text. So, now that I'm done with venting and being overly emotional, let's get to the Beef.
First things first, the first argument I heard for rotation is that the meta feels stale (again) and that some people want to rotate out Set 1 or even the Sets 1 and 2 to fix this. This argument fall in line with the ever-so-popular question "Do you really want to play with Torch forever?" and really makes me roll my eyes because cards like Torch and Harsh Rule are not responsible for the meta being stale. And removing those cards won't magically make other completely unplayed cards see play. Sure, rotation will force people to adapt and replace Torch with cards like Char or Harsh Rule with End of the Story. And yes, this will kind of lower the game's power level. However, this will change nothing about the staleness of the game, especially since the decks most of the people complain usually play mostly new cards in the first place. Palace Hooru decks will still play Korovyat Palace, Svetya's Sanctum and Stormhalt Knife and Winchest (FJS) will still play Vara, Vengeance-Seeker, Smugglers and Xo of the Endless Hoard. And even if there might be better decks out there, people will still play the same old decks because that's what worked for them.
Taking away some of the cards from Set 1 will only make it harder to deal with cards that are already borderline problematic and being held in check by those exact cards people want to rotate out. To demonstrate this: what do you do against an opponent on the play who plays Teacher of Humility turn 2? Especially if your second turn power is Depleted? If you're in Fire, Torch it, if in Primal, Permafrost it. If in Shadow, Suffocate. Take those away, and you have to just concede turn 2 because your deck can't ever deal with a play like this? You see, if you rotate out Set 1, cards like Teacher may become impossible to respond to. Of course this can be solved with DWD printing new cards to solve this problem or even reprint old cards. But then again, what's the point of rotating out the old cards if we have to get a near-identical replacement? The only thing this accomplishes is us having to craft those replacements, because they're required to deal with cards that would be oppressive otherwise. And if you now think "Why not just nerf the problematic cards?", I'll tell you the problem with that: If you have to rebalance most of the cards for the rotation not to break everything, rotating is maybe not a good idea.
Another argument that makes me roll my eyes is the "Magic/Hearthstone/Shadowverse does that too" statement. We have established times and times again that Eternal and Magic are very different games and environments. While they can and do learn from each other, not everything applicable in one game is applicable in the other. The same goes for the digital card games, which all have a massive amount of differences among each other and thus can't always be compared. Magic is a tabletop game in the first place, which makes balance changes basically impossible, so if a card is overtuned, it has to be banned or dealt with until it rotates. And while some other digital card games rotate as well, I'm not very sure about it really making sense to rotate just for the sake of making the game more interesting. I have not much experience with the other card games, as I only played HS for something like a year, and even that was more than 2 years ago. My point still stands, though: you cannot say that a decision is good by comparing it to others. There is only one Eternal, and no other game is exactly like it, no matter how similar they might be.
Rotation also is supposedly going to make the game cheaper for new players, which in my opinion is complete bogus. Making the starter decks completely unusable in the supported format right after the tutorial doesn't really make sense, does it? Or did you forget that all 10 of the starter decks consist of 100% Empty Throne cards? And if DWD makes new Starter decks after each rotation, how would that even fit with the tutorial? As you can see, it's going to be a massive pain to make an introduction into the game in a way that doesn't lock new players out of playing the main supported ranked format if rotation becomes a thing. Not to mention that by rotating out the more powerful commons and uncommons will make budget decks only even more expensive.
Of course, there's the actually more interesting argument of "rotating cards to make other weaker cards see play", which does bring up a valid point, and to which my ideal solution would be to incentivise them seeing play in a way that does not take away options. Either by buffing them to a degree that they have a niche usage or by printing cards that want you to play with otherwise sub-par cards. For example, Crystalline Chalice used to be such a card, where people even went as far as saying that a deck built around it wants to run mostly otherwise unplayable draft chaff. A more recent example would be Evenhanded Golem, who basically disallows you to play Merchants and thus Markets in the same deck as him for being a 2-cost 2/2 that draws you two cards on play. New cards have always made some cards that have otherwise never seen play suddenly appear in decklists, like Warhelm which was suddenly played after Highland Sharpshooter and Hojan, Crownbreaker became a thing, not to mention Merchants and Smugglers enabling several cards that were otherwise too narrow to ever see play in a format without sideboards. Speaking of which, if rotation ever happens and it happens the way people are suggesting, Merchants will eventually rotate out, and I don't think anyone wants to go back to playing completely without Markets.
The other actually concerning problem that is "fixed" with rotation is the question of Powercreep or Feature Creep, and I can't disagree that rotation is a solution in this case. However, I would like to say that in a game where balance changes are possible, Powercreep should not be an issue unless it's intentional (for example in order to sell more of the new stuff), in which case rotation would actually be preferable. And while Feature Creep may be a concern, it usually only becomes a problem when some mechanics get neglected in order to create new ones. I understand that not everyone likes having a complex game, but tuning down the power level with rotation also tunes down the complexity level, as it still removes options while not adding anything.
Finally, Mark Rosewater wrote a great article back in 2012 about the pros and cons of rotation in Magic and if you read through that, they kind of equal each other out for MtG. However, if you look at it from an Eternal perspective, the cons outweigh the pros by a large margin, since several of the pros are mostly invalid in a digital environment.
To summarize, the pros he lists in that article are Shifting the Metagame, Fixing Mistakes, Providing Focus for Lore, Easing Introduction and Making New Sets More Relevant. Of those, of course, the Shifting the Metagame and New Set Relevancy aspects are fully applicable to a digital game and I'm not going to argue with that. The Lore Focus aspect may be potentially utilized with DWD stepping up their storytelling game in recent time, however most people asking for rotation don't care for the lore anyway. (I have yet to see someone to genuinely ask to rotate out Rolant and his related cards because he's dead, for example) On the other hand, As I have already mentioned before, the Fixing Mistakes point is not applicable in a game where you can change cards "with a click". In a digital card game, this argument would only become valid if the game is broken beyond any possible repair and desperately needs a reset. The Introduction aspect is another one that is mostly irrelevant, however this one does stand slightly more ground. While with a growing card pool the learning curve also rises, the old cards are not discontinued in a digital game, unlike in a paper card game. It is easier to join into an Eternal format (pun intended) in a digital environment, where older cards do not inflate in cost, but instead all still cost equal to the new ones.
However, the other, negative sides of rotation mentioned by MaRo, are all fully applicable for a digital card game. The main one would be that rotation Obsoletes Cards, and nobody likes to be told that "you can't play with your favourite cards any more". While a second permanent format would allow people to use all cards in their collection, it still feels bad if the main supported format bans half the card pool, which is incidentally the half of the card pool you have in your collection. Rotation also Prevents "Pet Decks", meaning that if you, say, like something like Skycrag Midrange, Praxis Tokens or maybe even Feln Control, you may be out of luck when your cards rotate and those decks become unplayable. On the same vein, if you want to play in the Standard format, you will have to invest into new cards to keep your decks up-to-date. Finally, it Speeds Up The Metagame and Creates Rough Spots, meaning that a rotating format has a metagame which changes faster than it takes to figure out, which admittedly is not that bad of a thing for some people. However that also results in a metagame which has way less tools to quickly deal with problems. This hits especially hard when some factions lack certain types of interaction during a period of time where it desperately needs it, which in turn may actually create an imbalance.
So, while the pros and cons have a net positive in Magic, when looking from the side of a digital card game like Eternal, it swings in the other direction.
I would also like to add that we had it confirmed by LSV that DWD doesn't want to make it so that there are ever cards in your collection you can't play with, no matter what they plan rotation-wise. While he explicitly said that he cannot confirm or deconfirm any plans on rotation back then, it did confirm that everyone's 4-of Torches will never wither in your collection, banned from being played. And I can't stress than more, but I believe that adding tools is much better for a game than removing those and thus any kind of rotation is just an artificial mean to make the game feel fresh.
In the end, even if we get some form of rotation, people will still find something to complain about and say how the game is becoming stale. There is no way around it, and someone will somehow always be upset about something in the game. People complained about our beloved Sandstorm Titan for what feels like ever, and they ever stop, they'll find another bogeyman to shout about. Even if rotation happens, people will continue complaining about how the game is or feels stale. Thank you for reading.
TL;DR: Rotation is bad and (most of) you should feel bad for asking for rotation, since just because it makes sense in Magic, doesn't automatically make it a good idea in Eternal. Rotation won't fix the "broken meta" because meta isn't broken in the first place (and the meta decks won't even lose anything of significance with a rotation). It will in fact likely break the meta because cards like Teacher will probably become overpowered due to them not having any answers. Rotating out set 1 would also destroy any potential for growth since starter decks are 100% set 1. Underplayed cards can be made playable by incentives other than "the better card is rotated out, deal with it". Most things rotation is supposed to fix should be able to be fixed with balance patches instead. And finally, check out MaRo's article about rotation and their reasons for doing it in Magic. DWD doesn't want us to feel bad about owning cards that can not be used.
r/EternalCardGame • u/LateNightCartunes • Apr 10 '20
OPINION Am I alone in detesting unitless control decks?
No other deck makes me want to quit playing, salty post but it’s just so strikingly unfun. What is it about kill draw kill draw kill draw wipe wipe draw wipe draw draw wipe wipe draw wipe draw wipe win that irritates me so much more than any other gameplan?
Edit: What the fuck kind of card is Prodigious Sorcery? And it’s FAST????
r/EternalCardGame • u/Ilyak1986 • Nov 11 '23
OPINION If DWD is going to objectively and utterly neglect throne, can it at least be receptive to community-submitted patches? Between not providing IronMan an answer at all regarding reverts, and answering my question with "we'll let throne players kick rocks NOW" /w the horrid power inequality, whatnext?
So...yeah.
The latest patch was just damning in its silence IMO regarding throne.
Throne--the mode in which the vast majority of DWD's work product for Eternal actually exists, and the mode in which you play against your opponent more than you play fumbling against your own power, just got completely neglected--to the point of not even getting a single mention in the patch notes.
Not even a "we're keeping an eye on throne" so the ctrl + F in the browser doesn't turn up 0/0. (And if DWD actually was keeping an eye on throne, they'd note that Shadows of the Spire is now broken in half thanks to excellent power from marks working better for more than 3 factions, and the recruit mechanic being exactly the low-attack-high-cost-unit mechanic that shadows of the spire needed to reach critical mass.)
And see, the funny thing is, despite the utter neglect DWD subjects throne to, despite the absolutely laughable power base differentials (some factions possessing paintings, vows, and marks, while other factions possess none of those), despite the utterly laughable balance inconsistencies (Shadows of the Spire? Absolutely A-okay. Rost and Siege Breaker with overwhelm? 0/2 Eager deputy? 3/4 Helena? 5-cost Helio or Backbreaker? 1-cost bore? Bullseye that can take out any relic with cost 4 or less? 2/2 Darkblade Cutpurse, 6/6 Tasbu? 3/3 Argenport instigator? 5/6 Vara Vengenace Seeker? Vara Fate-Touched that actually works on playing any shadow unit whenever? Utterly unacceptable!), despite DWD basically acting like throne barely even exists, it's still, IMO, by far the more entertaining, and strategically interesting format.
To that end, if DWD is going to neglect throne to the point of not even reverting basically innocuous cards (nimble conscript went from 3/4 to 3/3, crooked alleyguide from 3/3 to 3/2), can they at least enact community balance changes once per month after looking them over?
Because right now, I don't buy the argument that DWD "doesn't just want to change numbers around willy nilly" when there are plenty of nerf reverts that would be safe, and unnerfing expensive combo pieces such as Vara Fate-Touched and Talir Who Sees Beyond (new text: your T units without Unleash have Destiny--Xo of the Endless Hoard showed that you can backport new mechanics) feels like it'd be pretty safe if things like Overloader, Rebuild, and Spire Shadows are fair game.
Basically, I feel like throne can provide the most comprehensive Eternal experience--you can play aggro, you can play control (equalize, Hooru, others?), you can play combo (or at least, imestr8 can, and if he can't, that's a problem), and you can certainly play midrange (right now, only if it's Spire Shadows).
However, DWD neglecting throne and not even acknowledging the way that recruit broke the critical mass threshold for spire shadows and the way that marks have made it practically trivial to get FJTPS by turn 3 feels like "if the developers won't acknowledge something, can they let the community maintain the game instead"?
Because not interfacing with the community while ALSO refusing to maintain the mode itself feels almost malicious IMO.
r/EternalCardGame • u/JonahVeil • Feb 06 '19
Fast Speed Dark Return x2 Should have never been printed.
This display is just so out of whack, it has caused FJS to just simply never get outvalued. It's also the strongest piece of removal out of all the displays (on average)...
At this point, if you're not jamming this display plus 8x FJS smugglers in your deck, you're playing half the game everyone else is.
Btw, At top 30 masters, 80 percent of my games are FJS or Rakano. This meta is horrendous.
r/EternalCardGame • u/pyrovoice • Jun 19 '18
Magic is fun because cards interact with each others. In Eternal, not so much
Building in magic is a lot of fun because your decks have a them and synergies, meaning not all cards will be good in your deck, and some that are not good everywhere else can still be good. This also mean that your deck is more than the sum of all its cards.
The main problem with Eternal is that decks are mainly "Put the best stuff there is in factions", with little interactions between them. True, each faction will be different in its gameplay, but that is not enough to have a good feeling when deckbuilding.
There are some cards that are very interesting to build around (Calice being a prime example), but they are often not pushed enough or you simply won't see them enough in a 75 cards deck.
Edit : Well, I'm glad to see that most answers have a different opinion :) maybe I play too much Commander
r/EternalCardGame • u/Comet__ • Mar 07 '18
Dead Reckoning Plot Spoiler Spoiler
STOP. USING. FEMALE. CHARACTER. DEATHS. AS. MOTIVATION. FOR. MALE. CHARACTERS.