r/Estockes • • 14h ago

Would a later stock split change which stocks pass your historical $150 screen?

1 Upvotes

Say your rule starts by screening for stocks below $150. On the date of the screen, a stock traded at $400. It split four-for-one later. A chart that restates earlier prices in today's share units will show $100 for the same session. Feed the screen that $100 and the stock passes. Use the price a trader saw that day and it fails.

For a quick check, put two columns next to each other: price as traded, and split-adjusted price. Apply the same $150 threshold to both. For the return calculation, keep prices and share counts on the same split basis so the split itself doesn't create a gain or loss.

The dollar values are illustrative. Apple used a real four-for-one split in 2020: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/07/apple-reports-third-quarter-results/

I'm on the eStockes team. If you've tried recreating a price screen from an earlier date, what field name or detail helped you tell which price you were using? If the screen is part of a daily rule you're trying to test, share one ticker and your entry condition. I can tell you whether our free guest comparison covers that rule.


r/Estockes • • 17h ago

You sold before the dividend was paid. When should a backtest let you spend it?

1 Upvotes

Suppose you owned one share before the ex-dividend date of a regular US cash dividend. You’re entitled to $2, and you sell the share for $98 on the ex-date. Assume the issuer pays two weeks later. The sale brings in $98. The dividend is still due, but the $2 becomes spendable only when it’s credited.

Here’s a simple check for a portfolio simulation: assume the $98 from the sale is available by the next order, with no other cash or margin. Could it buy a share that costs $99 before the dividend arrives? It can show $100 of value if equity includes the $2 receivable, while still having only $98 available to buy with. A test that credits spendable cash too early can show the same eventual dividend and a different set of trades.

I work on eStockes. The numbers and timing are illustrative. If you’ve tested a rule on a dividend-paying stock or ETF, where would you look to distinguish the date you earned the payment from the date it could fund another trade?

SEC Investor.gov on ex-dividend dates: https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/ex-dividend-dates-when-are-you-entitled-stock-and


r/Estockes • • 19h ago

A backtest stop can use the right price and still activate a bar late

1 Upvotes

Suppose a simulated stock entry fills at $51 at 10:00. The rule puts a stop $1.75 below the fill, at $49.25. At 10:05, the stock trades at $48.75. At 10:30, it closes back at $51.60.

Run A submits the stop just after the opening fill. The 10:05 move crosses an active stop. Run B waits until the 10:30 calculation to submit exactly the same stop. The earlier trade at $48.75 cannot trigger an order that did not exist yet. A stop trigger and the eventual fill price also belong in separate fields.

I'd trace one entry-bar trade in this order: signal time, entry fill time and price, stop activation time, then any stop trigger and exit fill. If both runs list a $49.25 stop level, the activation time explains why the first-bar results can differ. The example is hypothetical and uses a known sequence. A historical candle's low alone does not tell you when in that bar it happened.

I’m on the eStockes team. A Pine Script discussion prompted this exercise. If you're auditing someone else's results, which of these timestamps can you actually see in the report you use?


r/Estockes • • 23h ago

Can a stock cross above its 20-day moving average while its close stays at $100?

1 Upvotes

Yesterday a stock closed at $100, below its 20-day simple moving average of $100.25. Today it closes at $100 again. The close that drops out of the 20-session window is $110. Would a rule that buys on a cross above the average trigger?

Yes. The 20 closes in the old window sum to $2,005. Replace the $110 close with $100 and the sum is $1,995. Divide by 20 and the new average is $99.75. Yesterday $100 was below the line. Today $100 is above it. The new average did all the moving.

If your written rule requires the stock to rise on the signal day as well, record that as a separate condition. And if your test uses the completed close, write down when an order would first be eligible to fill. A line crossing at $100 does not guarantee an execution at $100.

I’m on the eStockes team. I’m looking for people who have tested a trading rule and are willing to try one short, free Academy reading exercise on assumptions like these. If you’re interested, what kind of test have you run and what would you like to be better at checking? I’ll suggest the exercise here.


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Why did a VOT backtest showing +0.0% pass “Made money after costs”?

1 Upvotes

I ran the daily 20-session crossover on VOT in Reality Check. The headline showed +0.0% after modeled costs, while “Made money after costs” passed. The detailed check gives the reason: it shows +0.02%. The headline rounds to one decimal place. On a $100,000 simulated balance, a return of 0.02% is roughly $20. A comparison displayed at one decimal place can hide a gap that small.

The run covered Nov 22, 2021 to Nov 20, 2026, with 74 simulated trades, 5 basis points of slippage per side and no commission. The rule showed +7.7% before modeled costs and the fund’s holding comparison showed +6.4%, with distributions included. “Made money after costs” and “Beat simply holding” ask different questions, and the second check failed here.

I’m on the eStockes team. If you already have a daily stock or ETF rule, use the editable guest setup to pick your ticker and rule and click Run historical test. No signup needed. In one line, tell me what you ran and what the rule returned versus holding. If a headline rounds to zero on your run, tell me whether the detailed check cleared it up.

Open the editable guest test


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Same RSI rule on XLP and XLK. What did switching sectors change?

1 Upvotes

Before running this, I picked one rule and two sectors. I used daily RSI(14) below 30, entered at the next open, and exited at the open five sessions later. Both runs covered Nov 22, 2021 through Nov 20, 2026, with 5 basis points of slippage on each fill and no commission. Each ETF was compared with holding itself.

XLP: 10 trades. The rule returned +31.3% after modeled costs versus +42.2% for holding. Maximum drawdown was 3.4% versus 16.3%.

XLK: 6 trades. The rule returned +48.6% after modeled costs versus +82.5% for holding. Maximum drawdown was 5.2% versus 33.6%.

Both rules spent time out of the ETF, so the smaller drawdowns could come from taking less exposure. Six and ten trades also leave plenty of room for individual trades to move the result. If you wanted to test whether the entry timing helped, how would you choose comparison entry dates? I’d start with other five-session holds in the same ETF and match the number of entries, then check how sensitive that comparison is to the period.

I’m on the eStockes team and ran both as a guest in Reality Check. If you’re already testing an ETF rule, pick your own ticker, click Run historical test, and tell me what the result showed versus holding. It’s free to run without an account.

Open Reality Check with XLP


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Two candles close where they opened. Which had the wider range?

1 Upvotes

Both daily candles open and close at $100. Candle A reaches a high of $102 and a low of $98. Candle B reaches a high of $110 and a low of $90. Both bodies are flat because the close equals the open. The high-to-low range is $4 on A and $20 on B. The closing price alone misses that difference. The daily candle also doesn’t tell you how many times price swung between those levels.

I’m on the eStockes team and we’re getting feedback on a short, free chart-reading lesson. If you’re learning to read charts and would like to try it, have you looked at daily stock charts, paper-traded, or done neither? What would you want a worked example to explain first?


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Can a 20-day moving average use prices from before a held-out test starts?

1 Upvotes

Suppose you fixed a 20-session moving-average rule before running a held-out test. The 19 closes leading into the test were all $100. The first session in the test closes at $104. What should the indicator show on that first day?

At that close, the 20-session average is (19 × $100 + $104) ÷ 20 = $100.20. Every price in the calculation was observable then. Those 19 earlier prices warm up the indicator. The strategy’s reported performance can still start on the first test date. If the rule needs the confirmed $104 close to generate an entry, a next-open simulation can only fill it in the following session.

The selection date is a separate check. If you used the held-out results to choose 20 sessions over 10 or 30, those results helped choose the rule. Label that window as part of development and reserve a fresh one if you want an independent check.

I’m on the eStockes team and looking for people who’ve run a backtest to try one short, free Academy lesson. If you’d like to help, tell me what kind of rule you’ve tested and what you’d like to get better at checking in the results. I’ll share the lesson here if it fits.


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

A US ETF can gain 10% in USD while a local-currency return is close to zero

1 Upvotes

Suppose you start with US$100 when one US dollar costs C$1.30. That’s C$130. The ETF grows to US$110. If one US dollar is now worth C$1.20, the balance converts to C$132. The same position gained 10% in USD and about 1.5% in CAD, before any currency conversion fees or taxes.

The quick check is (1 + the USD return) × (ending CAD per USD ÷ starting CAD per USD) − 1. That works for this example with one balance and no deposits or withdrawals along the way.

A separate VOO historical run in eStockes shows where to check the currency. The chart is in USD. Over Nov 22, 2021–Nov 20, 2026, the 50/200-day crossover returned 58.1% after modeled costs versus 58.6% for holding VOO. The rule had two simulated trades, with completed-close signals, next-open fills, 5 basis points of slippage per side, and zero commission. I didn’t convert this run to CAD or test currency hedging.

I’m on the eStockes team. If you already have a daily rule in mind, try your own ticker in the free guest form. Click Change rule if a result is already showing, then Run. If you’re willing to share the result, tell me which rule and ticker you used and whether it beat holding.

https://estockes.com/backtesting?symbol=VOO&preset=golden&utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=rc_own_rule_20261120&utm_content=estockes_voo_currency_reporting


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

The same four trade returns finished at $92.16. The order changed the drawdown.

1 Upvotes

Suppose four trades return +20%, +20%, −20%, and −20%. Start with $100, reinvest the whole balance each time, and ignore costs for this illustration.

Two gains, then two losses. $100 → $120 → $144 → $115.20 → $92.16. The biggest drop from a previous trade-close peak is 36.0%.

Alternating gains and losses. $100 → $120 → $96 → $115.20 → $92.16. The biggest drop from a previous trade-close peak is 23.2%.

The same four return multipliers give the same ending balance. The sequence determines where the peaks fall. These values are measured at trade closes. An actual daily equity chart can show larger losses in between. When a test looks promising, I look for the peak and trough dates on the equity chart before judging the drawdown figure.

I’m on the eStockes team. As a separate historical example, I ran the 20-day moving-average rule on QQQM from Nov 22, 2021 through Nov 20, 2026. The tested rule returned +52.4% after modeled costs and had an 18.3% max drawdown. Holding QQQM returned +57.9% with a 35.0% max drawdown.

If you have a U.S. stock or ETF rule of your own to check, open the free guest setup, choose a ticker and supported rule, and press Run historical test. In one line, tell us the ticker, rule and whether it finished ahead of or behind holding.

https://estockes.com/backtesting?symbol=QQQM&preset=sma20&utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=rc_own_rule_20261120&utm_content=estockes_trade_order_drawdown


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Why the same stock chart can look steeper on one scale

1 Upvotes

Take four hypothetical prices at equally spaced times: $25, $50, $100 and $200. The dollar gains are $25, $50 and $100. Each step still doubles the price.

On a linear price axis, the three steps take up increasingly more height because the dollar moves get larger. On a log axis, the steps take up the same height because each is a 100% gain. Switching the scale changes the spacing, and the prices and returns stay the same.

Try one more pair. Which is the bigger percentage move: $50 to $100, or $200 to $300? What would you check on the axis before judging by the line’s steepness?

I’m helping the eStockes Academy team get beginner feedback on a short free chart-reading lesson. If you’d like to try it, tell me what you’ve actually done so far, such as opening a chart, paper trading or placing an order, and the first chart question you’d want answered.


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

A two-session hold can run from Thursday to Monday

1 Upvotes

If a written rule says “hold for two days,” specify whether those are calendar days or trading sessions, and when the clock starts. The difference is easy to miss when every trade in your example happens midweek.

Here are two rule-triggered exits from the same historical VTI test. The rule enters at the next open after a daily close with RSI(2) below 10, then exits two sessions after entry.

Oct 15, 2026 (Thursday) → Oct 19 (Monday). Friday is the first subsequent session; Monday is the second.

Nov 2, 2026 (Monday) → Nov 4 (Wednesday). Tuesday is the first; Wednesday is the second.

Both are two-session holds, although one spans four calendar days and the other spans two. In a trade list I’d check the exit reason before applying that count. The last VTI trade in this sample closed at the end of the test window, an exception to the normal exit. The sample covers Nov 19, 2021 through Nov 19, 2026 and assumes 5 bp of slippage per side and zero commission.

I’m on the eStockes team. If you want to reproduce the example or check a daily rule of your own, press Run historical test in the free guest editor. If you try your rule, one line is enough: the ticker, the rule, and whether it finished ahead of holding.

Editable VTI example in Reality Check


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

Help test two free Academy lessons: reading candles and checking backtest results

1 Upvotes

I’m on the eStockes team. We’re looking for five people who are new to the markets and five who already have some trading or backtesting experience. Each person will get one free lesson and one short question about how they understood it.

If you’re interested, reply here with two things before reading:

  • What you’ve actually done so far, for example looked through charts, tried a paper account, made trades, or tested a rule.

  • One thing you want to be able to do or understand next.

A sentence is enough. You can leave out balances, positions and account information. I’ll reply in this thread with the lesson that fits and the exercise. Afterward I’ll ask where the explanation got hard to follow, whether the English or the concept caused the difficulty, and what would have made it clearer. You can use either lesson without creating an account.


r/Estockes • • 1d ago

What did cash earn while your backtest was out of the market?

1 Upvotes

Imagine a daily rule leaves $10,000 in cash for a full quarter. A hypothetical 4% annual cash rate adds about $100 over that quarter before compounding, even though no trade took place. Different cash assumptions can change the comparison when the rule spends a lot of time out of the market.

When I read a test, I check three things: the share of time invested, what the model pays on idle cash, and the return from holding the same ticker over the same dates. If the tool lets you set the cash rate to zero, a second run can show how sensitive the conclusion is to that assumption.

I’m on the eStockes team. In Reality Check, the Cash line under How it was compared shows the assumption used in the result. The example I checked credits the previous session’s three-month Treasury bill rate while out of position. If you already have a daily test on a US ticker, what does your tool assume about cash and how did the rule compare with holding?


r/Estockes • • 2d ago

QQQ guest test: can you tell whether one completed trade gained or lost?

1 Upvotes

A result summary tells you how the rule did versus holding. The trade list lets you see how that result was built. A tiny example with one share at a time and no costs: a buy at $100 and sale at $105 makes $5. A second buy at $100 and sale at $95 loses $5. The rule breaks even, while a single share held from the first $100 buy through the last $95 sale loses $5. Those are made-up prices.

I’m on the eStockes team. If you have a minute, run the free 20-session QQQ example below, then pick one completed trade and reply with the entry and exit prices shown and whether it gained or lost before costs. If you can’t find the prices, tell me what the result showed instead. No account needed.

https://estockes.com/reality-check?s=QQQ&r=sma20&shared=1&lang=en


r/Estockes • • 3d ago

One backtest check: when did the signal become a fill?

1 Upvotes

Suppose a daily rule signals entry when a completed bar closes at $100. The next session opens at $105, and the position later exits at $110. You can reproduce the difference with exit / entry - 1:

  • A fill at the signal close gives 110 / 100 - 1 = 10%.

  • A fill at the next open gives 110 / 105 - 1 = 4.76%.

Same signal, same exit, hypothetical prices and zero costs. The entry assumption alone changes the result by 5.24 percentage points. When the rule needs the completed daily close before it can decide, check whether the backtest explains how a fill at that close would be possible.

I help the eStockes team. If you want to try one quick check, open the free Reality Check example, expand Method, costs and all trades (the label includes the trade count), and tell us when you think the entry is modeled. If the timing was hard to find, tell us where you expected it to appear. The historical example opens without an account.


r/Estockes • • 4d ago

Buy and hold vs. a trading rule: what Reality Check actually compares

1 Upvotes

Two people gave us the same feedback today: the results look clean, but the labels make it hard to tell what’s being compared. Here’s the plain-English version.

Buy once and hold: buy the same stock at the start of the test and keep it through the end. This benchmark does not model trading costs. It is not the same as adding money every month.

Follow a rule: the simulator buys only when your chosen condition is met and sells according to your settings. It uses the same historical dates, with estimated trading costs included. If a rule mentions SMA(20), that just means the average closing price over the last 20 trading days.

The result shows what those two approaches would have done in that past window. It doesn’t forecast what a stock will do next.

Try the free eStockes demo without an account: https://estockes.com/reality-check

If you try it, tell us what still needs a plain-English label.

eStockes team


r/Estockes • • 20d ago

Reading a historical rule result: four checks before the headline

1 Upvotes

I'm Elon, founder of eStockes. Here's a short checklist for reading the anonymous Reality Check demo without treating a simulated result as a forecast.

  1. Check the price-history window. The dates of the daily bars tell you which market period was tested. A separate computation date tells you when the calculation ran; it does not establish that every price is current.

  2. Read the cost assumptions. Our demo models commission and slippage. That does not mean every real cost, tax or execution constraint is included.

  3. Check the comparison basis. The current example shows the rule after modelled costs next to holding the same ETF over the same dates, before holding costs. Those cost treatments are different, so the headline alone is not a complete like-for-like net-cost comparison.

  4. Keep the conclusion limited. A historical simulation describes that test under its assumptions. It does not establish future returns or tell you whether a trade suits you.

Try this reading exercise without an account: https://estockes.com/landing

Before looking at the verdict, explain in one sentence what is being compared. Which label, date or assumption would you want clarified? Honest criticism is welcome. Please leave out account details and personal financial information. No purchase, signup or trading is needed for this discussion.


r/Estockes • • 27d ago

Chart date vs page refresh: which one are you reading?

1 Upvotes

I'm Elon, founder of eStockes, a stock research and analysis workspace.

When comparing research notes, a chart's bar date and the time a page response was assembled are different facts. Opening a page doesn't establish that its underlying prices just updated. An older bar can also be normal when a market is closed.

One useful habit: record the symbol, candle interval, the exact bar-time label (including its timezone), and when you viewed it. If a label or freshness information is missing, write 'not shown' rather than assuming it is a live quote.

Optional interface check: open https://estockes.com/chart?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=research_context_20261025&utm_content=owned_timestamp . Which displayed label would you use to judge the newest available bar's age, and is it clear what that label means? If a loading state or sign-in blocks you, report that point instead.

You can give this feedback without signing up, purchasing, connecting a broker or trading. This is candid usability feedback, not a rating or endorsement request. Please don't share account or financial details.

This post is about reading data context, not a stock recommendation or a claim that the feed is live or verified.


r/Estockes • • Oct 20 '26

One tiny chart test: what does 1D mean to you?

1 Upvotes

I'm building Estockes for people who are new to researching stocks.

Before interpreting a chart, check the symbol, the candle interval and the dates shown. A daily candle is not the same as viewing only one day of history.

Try one small usability task: open this AAPL chart and see whether you can tell how much time one candle represents.

https://estockes.com/chart?symbol=AAPL&interval=1D&utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=chart_feedback_20261021&utm_content=candle_interval

Reply with the first label or control that confused you, and what you expected instead. If it does not load or you encounter a sign-in request, tell us that first step. You do not need to purchase anything or work around it. Please do not share account or financial details.

AAPL is an interface example, not a recommendation. Academy lessons are public, free and in English; some other features require an account or paid plan.

Honest negative feedback is welcome. This is optional product feedback, not a request for a rating, follow or endorsement. Educational only, not investment advice.


r/Estockes • • Oct 20 '26

Start here - learn stocks from zero and help shape Estockes

1 Upvotes

Welcome to r/Estockes. I work on Estockes and created this space for stock-market beginners to ask questions and give honest product feedback. You do not need to know the jargon to join the conversation.

A useful first step is to separate two questions: “What does this company do?” and “What is its share price doing?” A price chart alone does not explain the business.

Try one small task: open Estockes, choose “Start the free course”, and read the opening section of the first lesson. Then tell us which word or instruction was unclear. The Academy lessons are free, public and in English; other research tools may require an account or paid plan. No signup, purchase, deposit or trade is needed for this lesson task.

https://estockes.com/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=official_community_20261020&utm_content=start_here

If you’d like to test a lesson with us, reply in the Academy testing thread with what you’ve tried so far and one thing you want to understand. It’s fine if you haven’t tried anything yet. We’ll suggest a free lesson and one short exercise.

Compare a rule with holding. Open the free Reality Check editor. Choose a U.S. stock or ETF you follow and a supported daily rule. If a result is already showing, select Change rule first, then press Run historical test. In the comparison thread, share one line with your ticker, the rule you ran, and which finished ahead. You can run it as a guest.

For useful feedback, include what you tried, what you expected and where you got stuck. Positive and negative feedback are equally welcome. Never post passwords, account details or financial documents.

This is an educational and product-feedback community, not a place for personalized investment advice, return guarantees, stock pumping or unsolicited sales messages.