r/Eragon • u/viridiania • Oct 29 '23
r/Eragon • u/Hyllian94 • Dec 31 '25
Currently Reading Got the deluxe edition of Murtagh for Xmas, and think I found a spelling error on page 250. Shouldn't this be shirt instead of shift?
English isn't my first language so I might be mistaken
r/Eragon • u/drew1928 • Jan 28 '24
Discussion Anyone else worried about the eragon tv series?
In lieu of the Percy Jackson series is anyone else concerned they will absolutely butcher the eragon series as well?
I was very excited for disney to remake both YA series into shows but I quickly realized with PJO that it is a horrible adaptation and now it has me not wanting disney to even touch eragon for risk they give it the same treatment.
r/Eragon • u/[deleted] • Jan 12 '24
Discussion I do not like the elves in Eragon
Just my opinion, but why is it that every word out of Arya's mouth is rude, condescending, or just plain mean. But, like, all the Elves are like this, right? I think Eragon and Arya are terrible for each other. Eragon was too good for her.
r/Eragon • u/No_Communication8304 • Dec 18 '22
Discussion What are you all thinking about that concept? Spoiler
r/Eragon • u/RainOk8664 • Apr 17 '24
Discussion Nasuada’s morally questionable action (spoiler book 4!) Spoiler
So, I’m reading book 4 again for probably the 5-6th time and I just finished the chapter where nasuada attempted to escape prison by using the sharpened spoon to kill the guard with the clean fingernails. How do y’all feel about this?? I find this somewhat reprehensible…to me it hinges on the fact that Murtagh already explained clear as day that escape for her was impossible and the number of guards, magic in place, location in the cell, etc were impossible to overcome. Had Nasuada not known this, I don’t think I would object to her murder of the guard and attempted escape but with all the available information, Murtagh putting his neck on the line by healing her partially and protecting her, and general well treatment by this guard, I find it wrong for her to have murdered him. If an escape plan had actually been devised and possible, I would find it acceptable but the futility of it is part of the wrongness imo. Plus now she has just asked for the torture to ramp up.
Update: wow this got a lot of people fired up. The core of this is simply saying she murdered a man with no clear goal or chance of success and she knew that beforehand. This guard was not her captor in my eyes but Galbatorix was, so killing him isn’t really “fair.” I would feel differently if it actually could have led to an escape. Also, Nasuada herself questions why she did it and Murtagh as well. I didn’t make this up everyone! It’s in the book. Lastly, she is a hero to all of us, but not necessarily to the normal soldiers and citizens, is rather an outlaw who is responsible for great turmoil, death, and uncertainty.
r/Eragon • u/Terrible-Ice8660 • Sep 20 '25
Question Why is killing a caster before you have mind control so dangerous? Spoiler
Edit: I am not saying that the rule shouldn’t exist. It makes perfect sense. All I am saying is that if you draw first with an instant death spell your opponent can’t draw second, because they are dead.
I am not saying that an instant death spell is something that just anyone can pull off, all I am saying is that if you can pull it off then it is a way of bypassing mutually assured destruction.
All you have to do is annihilate their brain so fast that they don’t have time to react and throw out a dying spell.
Obviously this isn’t always possible, but sometimes it is possible.
There are a few ways to do this here are 2 (but there are more)
-1 do an attack that quiets all the impulses in their brain causing instant death.
-2 just do a really big explosion next to their heads.
-Send a gemstone flying to the target to enact your spell, they could retaliate if they could think to put energy and a spell into some object and then teleport it too you. But if they can think of that (which is doubtful) they would still need to locate you. And you can ward against location.
Here is one way of doing a really big explosion next to their heads.
Fill up a gemstone with like half a humans energy.
Then teleport that gemstone to the center of the sun.
The gemstone will have an instant before it is destroyed and in this instant it can power a teleportation spell sending a thimble of core plasma next to the coordinates of the targets head.
Considering how you don’t need to hold energy for a long time, just a very short time, you probably don’t even need to use gemstones, you could probably use cheaper material that looses energy very fast.
If you reasonably want the convenience of holding the energy inside a gem (which also lets you build up energy over time). You can just enspell the gem to dump the energy into the sacrificial object in an instant for the attack. That same gem could also hold a second portion of energy dedicated to the first teleportation of the sacrificial object.
The sacrificial object would have to have to be one that. 1 didn’t loose that much energy in the transfer, 2 was able to hold a lot of energy per weight in the short term, 3 didn’t loose energy too quickly in the short term.
Short term energy storage is much easier than stable energy storage.
If you shove a ton of energy into a thing and it explodes, there still will be a moment before it explodes. If you are able to work quick enough a nanosecond or even shorter could be all the time you need.
(Of course you would first need to stress test a ton of materials and magically record information on them)
Sure an elf was exhausted by teleporting a dragon egg but gems are much smaller than that. And sacrificial objects working on short timescales can probably handle greater energy density than gems, before they fail by absorbing the energy, dispersing the energy, or exploding.
Edit: many people have raised many issues with my methods, but my main point remains true. If you being instant death spells into the mix it stops being a situation where an instant before death is guaranteed for them to retaliate. Instead it becomes like a Wild West duel, where whoever shoots first won’t get shot by the second guy because the second guy can’t do anything (being dead). In reality people don’t die as soon as you shoot them, but the spells do kill instantly, even though the bullets don’t.
Of course this is extremely risky when it’s even viable, and also it won’t work against people whose wards you can’t slip past or overpower.
Also my idea of teleporting mass from the sun wouldn’t work because teleportation goes the speed of light and a round trip would take 16 minutes. But the earths core would only take a 3/100 second round trip.
Less energy efficient but still a way to turn a little magic energy into a lot more explosive energy, so that you can simply overwhelm most peoples wards.
Casting a spell that stops people from casting spells (in this case by simple instant death) means that if you cast a spell before your opponent does, then your opponent will never cast a spell in retaliation.
When Eragon does casts the Hell Riders Penance Stair on Galbatorix, Galbatorix can’t retaliate.
Because Eragon had the initiative he cast first, and because he cast first there was no retaliation.
r/Eragon • u/MightyShadeslayer • Oct 20 '22
Discussion The rings of power is a failure to fans of Tolkien, myself included. I’m worried about what Disney will do w Eragon. There’s a trend happening here I hope we avoid Spoiler
Love the inheritance cycle it’s my favorite franchise by far ever period. I also love LOTR they come in at a close second. And the LOTR trilogy is my favorite movie franchise ever. I love these two fantasy series so much. But I am concerned. I’m not here to hate just to express my concerns; I might get downvoted that’s ok just tryna have an honest real discussion.
Eragon is often compared to Star Wars etc but that’s a stupid comparison when a Tolkien comparison is way more accurate and actually a very big compliment. Anyway LOTR is a big time franchise and yet with nigh on infinite money and resources and a movie precedent that this world can be done right, Amazon managed to fuck it ALL up. Rings of power is a disgrace. It completely rewrites Tolkien from page one basically and completely changes the characters and their motivations into unrecognizable shadows of what they are in the beloved source material. And this was mind you with the blessing of the Tolkien estate etc.
Now here we are with eragon. Eragon is by no means nearly as strong of a franchise as LOTR nor does it have that much bargaining power considering it’s already had a shit movie adaptation that bombed hard that we as fans pretend it doesn’t exist. LOTR had two successful movie franchises; one of them being a cinematic masterpiece and the gold standard of high fantasy.
Disney is not gonna give the eragon show anywhere near the budget or freedom of LOTR that Amazon did. And despite Christopher paolinis involvement I am very nervous bc obviously creatives being involved in the work sometimes doesn’t mean a damn thing and they’re forced to change their work by the studios. rings of power fails bc of its disloyalty to the Tolkien legendarium.
I want to stress that for the eragon show to be successful, it needs to stay true to the written work. This should permeate every facet of the production from art design to casting to costume design to dialogue to vfx to landscapes to the story itself. MIRROR JACKSONS LOTR trilogy as the standard for faithful adaptation with minor wiggle room for plot adjustments. Small omissions that hardly impact the story such as Tom bombadil are acceptable to streamline an otherwise completely faithful in spirit and plot adaptation. The LOTR trilogy got the aesthetic and casting of characters down perfectly as well as the setting and world building. For the eragon show it is vital to cast as the characters are, and design their costumes and looks with how they are described in the book. The settings should be as they were in the book. The plot should be as it was in the book. Obviously not expecting a word for word reproduction but still the story should be 80% accurate AT LEAST.
Eragon deserves to be brought to life as is. Not perverted like Amazon did with the rings of power show. In the show they completely disregarded character personalities traits and motivations in favor of shit new ones. Also their aesthetic is nonexistent. Sauron should have looked a certain way as should have the elves and the numenoreans. Sauron should never look like a mortal man, the elves should be graceful BEAUTIFUL and YOUTHFUL with LONG HAIR. The numenoreans should be equally as epic not wearing ineffective scale armor or shouting dumb platitudes like “the sea is always right.”
Eragon deserves the best treatment and I just want to avoid the problems that other fantasy show adaptations are making. They only do a disservice to the fans and the works. STAND BY YOUR WORK MR PAOLINI, don’t feel you need to change anything major. The works are what are beloved and internationally known. Not some corporate brass opinions modern problems or fads.
r/Eragon • u/D-72069 • Nov 29 '23
Murtagh Spoilers I hate to be this person... Spoiler
I hate seeing people criticizing IPs in other subreddits because I feel like they're supposed to be for fans and if people don't like something they should just stay away. But I AM a fan of the Inheritance Cycle, despite finding more and more things I dislike on each reread. However, I have to speak up and say that I was VERY disappointed in Murtagh (the book). I could spend 15 minutes praising the things I liked, but then spend an hour criticizing the issues.
I don't want to completely vent my issues here, and I can never get a coherent format to work on my phone so I'll keep it brief. Here are the major issues I had:
Pointless plot lines that had no real payoff but took up so much time, lack of relationship establishment between Murtagh and Thorn, serious pacing issues, apparent retconning of previously established rules of magic, lack of detailed explanation of things, and drastically inconsistent rules of magic throughout. (Also more things that seem to be fantasy tropes borrowed from Lord of the Rings).
I will be happy to see more because some of the concepts are very cool and can be awesome if handled well, but I feel like they were fumbled a little bit here. Over the years I have reread the original cycle at least 4 or 5 times, despite their flaws. I don't think I'll ever really want to reread Murtagh, and if I do I already know I'd skip at least 75% of it.
I expect to be shot full of downvote arrows. It's okay, I understand. I just had to voice some of my thoughts somewhere.
Edit: Just adding one more thing before I move this to a forum where I have more room to explain things, I hated that "waise heill" seemed to be able to fix all damage. The reason Bron died was because that was too simple of a spell to fix all of his internal damage. And once Eragon was educated he now has to has to heal more significant wounds with much longer, complex spells as he heals each part individually. The elves all do this too so it's clearly not just Eragon's ignorance. But Murtagh can heal everything with that one phrase. That was frustrating and kind of made Brom's death have less value.
Final Edit: because it's impossible to have a meaningful back and forth on this because it's too complex, I'm including a link to my full review if anyone wants it. I won't be responding to any more comments here. Thanks.
r/Eragon • u/ddeliverance • Nov 22 '23
Discussion Does anyone else feel like Inheritance is Paolini’s weakest book?
Obviously, he was 16 when he wrote the first book, so it’s expected that each subsequent book will just get better and better.
I remember reading Inheritance when it first came out and thinking that it was stale, cliché, and the worst out of all of the series. In preparation for Murtagh, I reread all of the books and once again felt extremely dissatisfied with Inheritance.
Do others feel this way, or am I the odd one out on this? If you do feel this way, why do you think it is? I can’t come up with more than “it feels like he didn’t actually have a planned ending** and had no idea what to do once he got there” and “it has a ton of clichés.”
If you don’t feel the same way: same question— why?
**by “ending,” I mean the entire ending, not just him leaving the continent. So, that includes the final battle, the showdown (such that it was) with Galbatorix, Nasuada being chosen to lead, Fírnen bonding to Arya, Arya being chosen queen, and him leaving the continent.
Sorry if this has been asked before; I just joined the sub. Also, I haven’t read Murtagh yet (#TeacherProblems), so please no spoilers! I’m planning on reading it over Thanksgiving break.
r/Eragon • u/Mika95 • Oct 06 '19
Oromois is awful
I don't know if it was intentional but damn Oromis was awful. yes he was an effective teacher, I will never deny that, but holy crap he was not very kind of Eragon at all. This was a kid who lost everything and did more in a few month then the Elves had ever done against the Empire. No one respected him as a person, and Oromois expected only excellence of him but come on the kid was a teenager so really some attitude was going to happen, especially after those horrible convulsions and being abused by that Elf sword teacher.
Eragon was always being berated for being o so disrespectful but all he wanted was knowledge and understanding and yet Oromis freaked out whenever he asked for anything.
Oromis also had a low opinion of humans but seriously, it was a human that overthrew your oh so great Dragon Riders and three humans that saved you all.
He served a purpose, I get that, but wow this Elf was kind of a jerk and I wish he would have been called out for that.
Not going to lie, I do plan on making a OC that does that part... though the rest of the details are murky so it is unimportant for the time being. Are there stories that bashed oromis, I need the catharsis.
r/Eragon • u/dogman15 • Jun 01 '25
News Full "Eragon" movie available for free on YouTube officially (YouTube Movies & TV)
r/Eragon • u/moraimortis • Jun 12 '25
Discussion unpopulsr opinion: roran arc are kinda boring
unpopular opinion edit lol missed the keys entirely
ok hear me out
roran is obviously a cool af character. i can't think of anything negative about him. BUT his arcs are kinda boring sometimes. i don't like them too much because he never really experiences any mayor setbacks or failures (except maybe at the very start in carvahall), and he therefore misses opportunities for character growth or change. like in all of his chapters (yes i am purposely exaggerating a bit here) he faces some hardships, takes a severe beating, and then he's like 'omg katrina! i have to win for her!'. it gets soooo predictable and just kinda boring over the course of the series.
am i the only one thinking paolini kinda missed an opportunity here to give him more depth? bc with other character he's insanely good at letting them fail and learn and develop themselves through that.
anyway, what do you guys think? much love
r/Eragon • u/darragh73 • May 04 '23
Discussion This is hardly fair, Eragon can be such an asshole. Elva didn't owe anything to the Varden
r/Eragon • u/Exotic-End9921 • Mar 29 '24
Discussion Jason Statham as Brom
Y'all see it right?
r/Eragon • u/Bearsona09 • Sep 03 '25
Discussion Eragon is already kind of failing as the leader of the Riders.
Murtagh probably shouldn’t have been allowed to roam the realm as freely as Eragon did. Not so much because he was a threat, but because he lacked the training and education to truly understand what it means to be a Rider and to overcome their Trauma.
It might have been better if Eragon had taken him and Dorn with him beyond Alagaësia. That could also have improved how people saw Murtagh, especially if Nasuada had been able to share that he was traveling with Eragon rather than remaining tied to the Empire.
On top of that, Murtagh’s almost unquestioning obedience to Nasuada feels dangerous... he bends to her will far too easily. I don’t buy their relationship from her side for a second, which makes Murtagh’s almost blind loyalty to Nasuada feel all the more dangerous.
-
There’s also the matter of Arya serving as both Queen and Rider. While it may not pose the same risks as with Galbatorix, it still sends a complicated message. Having one person hold both positions concentrates a lot of influence, and it would have been reasonable for Eragon, as leader of the Riders, to step in and at least set clearer expectations. Even a gentle boundary there could have helped reinforce the independence of the Riders as an order.
What makes all this stranger is that the Eldunarí, with their centuries of experience, apparently had nothing to say about either situation.
Neither they nor anyone else seem to have raised much of a concern, which is odd given how much emphasis was placed on avoiding the mistakes of the past. Eragon talks about rebuilding the Riders, but he seems to focus almost exclusively on the eggs and the eldunarí, while letting the only two other Riders make their own choices without much guidance or accountability.
r/Eragon • u/Straight-Character32 • Sep 26 '25
Theory What if the traitor Murtagh recognizes is Roran?
And I know it's shocking, but... what if the one who saw Murtagh is Roran?
hat is known about the traitor? He is a man and a member of the court. At the end of the inheritance, Roran becomes Count of the Palancar Valley. The Palancar Valley is very close to Nar Gorgoth, making it more susceptible to influence than other areas, just like Sarros in Ceunon.
There are gaps in Roran's life (his stay in Therinsford and his new life rebuilding Carvahall) that we don't know if he may have been influenced by the dreamers, and Paolini certainly gave reasons for Murtagh not to visit his cousin on his way to Nar Gorgoth, but another reason that is not stated is that it would ruin the plot if, after visiting him, he could recognize Roran even while drugged.
I know it's crazy, but it could be a huge plot twist if the assault team that's going to be formed in Murtagh 2 (Murtagh, Uvek, and Roran) is created, and Roran ends up being an ally of the dreamers.
Edit to include some arguments that I later thought of for the comments.
After the war, Murtagh went into self-imposed exile, so his acquaintance with Nasuada's court must have been prior to that. During his stay with the Varden, he may have met Jormundur if he visited him in his cell or on the battlefield, but beyond that, I wouldn't know what it would be like to be part of Nasuada's court, since at that time Ahijad was still the leader.
So he knows Nasuada's court because of the clashes Murtagh has had with the Varden. In the burning plains, he sees Roran kill the twins but does not know that he is Eragon's cousin. Murtagh may have seen Roran near Nasuada during his attacks on the Varden since she is often present at important events and therefore think that he is a member of the court. (Roran is present when Nasuada receives the werecat king Grim Halfpaw in Belatona. After the siege of Aroughs, he is part of the council that plans how to take Dras-Leona. When Nasuada is kidnapped, he is part of the conclave that decides that Eragon will be the leader of the Varden. When Eragon returns from Vroengard, he is also included in the council that receives him).
What we don't know is whether Murtagh would have recognised Roran if he had stopped in Carvahall, or whether he would have had to be introduced when he asked to meet him.
In Jeod's letter in the deluxe edition of The Inheritance, it is said that nothing is known about Roran in Ilirea, which fits with the idea that the trip to Nar Gorgoth could go unnoticed, unlike if it were Jormundur, who, if he were travelling with companions, would be more noticeable if Nasuada investigated who had recently left the capital.
I could also write a post about Orrin, since his departure from Surda might go more unnoticed by Nasuada, as he is accompanied by an entourage of nobles. he only accepted Nasuada as queen because Arya and Orik supported her, so an alliance with the Dreamers to oust Nasuada would make sense, not to mention that Murtagh recognises that the wine is from the southern islands, which are now part of Surda. Orrin is truly thirsty for power, unlike Jormundur, who did not want to lead the Varden and supported Nasuada.
What I said about Nasuada's court would also apply to Orrin. We do not know if Murtagh really knows who Orrin is or simply seen him near Nasuada the times he has attacked the Varden
r/Eragon • u/Flaky-Piglet5749 • Sep 08 '23
Question Blodhgarm’s lie
When eragon first meets blodhgarm eragon says that he saw him at the blood oath celebration and blodhgarm said it was his cousin or sister or something with brown fur. But in eldest it says the wolf-elf that eragon saw was blue, like blodhgarm. Why did he lie? Was this previously confirmed?
r/Eragon • u/Andriaka_Thornblood • Jan 10 '25
Question Song Lyrics
I was listening to this song on Pandora. I had to double check cause I thought I heard it but could have been not entirely paying attention since I was driving from work. Nope I was right. Eragon is in the lyrics. Which begs the question, whose the other 2 short kings besides Hrothgar?? I guess Orik but...is Galbatorix a short boi!!?? 🤣
r/Eragon • u/ImplementHaunting558 • 2d ago
Question Whats even the point of Birgits existence other than be a plot device?
She blames Roran for the death of Quimby and demands a blood feud, and occasionally pops up every often to menacingly stare at Roran, only to spare his life at the end which everyone saw coming.
Her only existence is to be a plot device and an inconvenience for Roran whenever the story shifts to his pov, a lot of other people from carvahall lost their loved ones too, yet birgit keeps her feud throughout the refugee crisis, holding up an honor code for a village that doesnt even exist?
She should've changed her mind after seeing her son willing to sacrifice his life for Roran, or after Katarinas pregnancy.
Her entire purpose was to spike the cortisol of young readers who didnt see the setup coming earlier 🥀
r/Eragon • u/Theangelawhite69 • Apr 28 '23
Question Does anyone else not like Sapphira?
She’s always criticizing Eragon, despite being alive for like 30 seconds, and frequently does the same things she chastised him once for doing. It’s great that she’s a loyal friend and all, but her personality is very holier-than-thou, and when she gets angry she does not communicate healthily at all.