2
130
Feb 05 '20
The top one will still fair better when an operator crashes into it with a forklift.
46
u/ArdennVoid Feb 05 '20
Its always fun to see some crazy damage a forklift driver somehow managed to do, and then try and figure out what it would take to prevent it.
My overseer during my internship was the packaging engineer at a zero turn mower factory, and I saw some crazy damage reports over those few years.
Most common one had some ltl company destroy a mower while trying to lift one crated mower off the top of the crate stack. Miss the forklift pocket by half a foot, forks through the crate, through the seat, and finally scalping the top third of the engine off. His conclusion to those was we'd need to armor our crates with 2 inch steel to prevent a reoccurrence.
Edit: spelling
32
u/AccidentallyTheCable Feb 05 '20
I was an ex forklift mechanic, and just stepping into IT, at the same place. My boss sent me along on a field call with a manager to talk about stopping "excessive damages" accumulated by the workers. Turns out the workers were abusing them in ways even Jackass wouldnt have comprehended...
This was a newspaper printer.. huge.. huge rolls of paper, automated bots, etc... some workers were playing "catch the fork" with the paper clamp and forklift forks, others were jousting with the forks, theyd slam into the building in reverse instead of using their brakes.. all kinds of fucking crazy shit.
We ended up installing this system that would require a card swipe to use the forklift, and any jolt to the forklift beyond a threshold would shut it down, sound an alarm and flag the user, and lift in the system.
6
Feb 05 '20
iWarehouse should be a mandatory thing on forklifts now. I only say this because I’m a Raymond tech and know how much damage an operator can do.
4
u/CutterJohn Feb 05 '20
We have crowns that do that. Nice to keep people in line, but super annoying to have to go through a 45 second long boot up and systems check every time I have to log in.
16
Feb 05 '20
Haha wow. Where I work the operators kept cutting the corner too close coming into one of our buildings. They destroyed the whole frame of the roll up door and fucked up the structure and the concrete. The engineers decided to widen the door so they had more room and one day after the job was complete the operators hit it again and fucked up the concrete.
9
u/ccgarnaal Feb 05 '20
Just add a foot high reinforced curb inside and outside the gate, problem solved.
4
u/Wyattr55123 Feb 05 '20
A warehouse bollard would work as well. But yeah, something to move the corner away from the door, because people will cut as much corner as possible.
6
Feb 05 '20
My father drove a forklift at a grocery store chain warehouse for 30+ years. When I was a child, he would frequently bring home Snickers bars and little bags of Planters peanuts - two of his favorite snacks - because he "accidentally" damaged a box at work. Unions used to be a lot stronger.
1
0
Feb 05 '20
[deleted]
2
1
Feb 06 '20
I'm disappointed that you linked to a picture of a drilling rig, rather than your installation.
In that situation, if no one is willing to say what happened and allow that to be prevented from ever happening again - I'd fire the most senior person who could be related or ultimately responsible, or whoever is responsible for forklift training. If the union is happy with people being a danger in the facility - then fuck the union, that's not what they're supposed to be for.
4
u/Zmoibe Feb 05 '20
Or a tug driver. One of the airports I did work at had a really entertaining one. They used baggage make-up units to sort bags to. For those that don't know, they are mechanically the same as a bag claim carousel that you get your bag from up stairs, but usually fed from above rather than underneath, they are taller at about 4 to 5 ft., and the "center" is hollow. This particular one also contained the motor control panel for the make up and several conveyors in the center.
One day there was a tug driver that I assume was falling asleep at the wheel, drunk, or some combination of the two. He managed to hit one of the units, which are a good 20 to 50 ft wide typically (meaning he definitely saw it), so hard that he actually put the entire tug up and over the side, getting stuck in the center of it WITH 3 bag carts attached to it... This resulted in him also hitting the motor control panel and damaging it so bad that the entire section overloaded. I don't remember what the final repair bill ended up, but it was definitely well over 6 figures. The guy was actually lucky to have lived because the panel he hit runs 480 volt motors and regularly had 100+ amps of power running through it.
Also a surprising number of stories where they ran into planes in taxi-ways, on the tarmac, you name it. And some of these involved 767s which I'm fairly certain you can clearly make out from 10000 feet in the air...
3
2
2
1
u/Wyattr55123 Feb 05 '20
Nah, it'd snap off at the corner. Middle one would fair the best, more corner support to prevent fatigue stress accumulation.
1
19
u/aryatha Feb 05 '20
I do love this technique, but it requires consideration of all possible loading conditions. Those that deviate from the modeled conditions, like, say, an out of plane force on that end hole, could have less than ideal results.
2
2
u/dread_deimos Feb 05 '20
> but it requires consideration of all possible loading conditions
All kinds of optimizations require that. Also, original planning requires that too but is often omitted because "the bigger the better".
7
u/CurrentResistance Feb 05 '20
Optimised first weight, not manufacturing cost
3
u/Wyattr55123 Feb 05 '20
The picture specifies printing as the manufacturing technique.
1
u/TheDrBrian Feb 08 '20
You’re never going to 3D print something that could be made on a press brake and pillar drill in 5 mins.
2
4
u/JimmyTheEell Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
Hmm... if the top is always in tension, and the bottom always has compressive stress... then the middle must have...
15
2
1
6
u/Mr_HODL Feb 05 '20
This only makes sense if you are putting this onto an aeroplane or sending this into orbit. For 99.999% of all other scenarios, the first option is the best
1
u/terjeboe Feb 05 '20
Or if you are making 100k brackets and paying on a weight basis. Or if you are 3d printing as the OP are stating. Or if shipping is a significant part of the cost. Or if the reduced weight allows it to be installed by a single technician rather than a crane.
There is a thousand cases where weight reduction is beneficial.
5
2
u/eveningsand Feb 05 '20
It was fun to see what was simulated in ANSYS and COMSOL ... Multiphysics simulation was neat
1
1
u/donttouchmyhari Feb 05 '20
How would one go about making this piece of it was plastic?
2
u/ciniminiman Feb 05 '20
That depends. If you plan to make thousands of them, you'd probably go with injection molding. If you plan to make less than a few hundred you should probably 3d print it.
2
u/Wyattr55123 Feb 05 '20
You could also machine it, as an inbetween of "I need hundreds of these" and "I need the parts some time this century"
1
u/ciniminiman Feb 05 '20
I mostly agree with you. Machining a few hundred parts is usually the best solution, but wouldn't it be difficult with the weird geometry of the part? Would CNC be worth the cost?
2
u/Wyattr55123 Feb 05 '20
Not terribly hard to machine. One vise setup for the base holes, one vise setup for the top hole and L cross section (assuming extruded stock isn't available) and one fixture for the A profile.
Machine cost would be higher than printing, but that's part of the balance between cost of manufacturing and cost of waiting hundreds of hours to print the run of parts.
1
1
u/Miffers Feb 05 '20
This optimizes the bracket for the designed intended use. But at some other companies they would simulate other loads to test the stress so the bracket doesn’t fail if someone misuse the product.
1
u/VangardRoth Feb 05 '20
Wouldn't it be better to relocate the center anchor point to the other side of the top strut? The bottom strut will want to "push" in to the material supporting it anyways so a fastener might not be even required there, depending on how it's intended to be loaded. The mass savings could then be able relocated to spreading the two top anchors out a bit and thus reduce the likelihood of weakening the underlying material with too many holes too close together (presuming a material of finite strength).
1
u/savingprivatebrian15 Feb 05 '20
Anyone have a good source on a tutorial/instructions on doing this in Fusion 360? I’m kind of annoyed that I’m finishing my 3rd year in mechanical engineering school and haven’t taken a class that involves modeling stresses on parts in a CAD program (let alone optimizing the part).
1
1
u/SerLaidaLot Feb 22 '20
Is no one going to talk about the fact that the middle hole on the left is is missing in the optimised design?
1
0
Feb 05 '20
[deleted]
57
Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
Maybe we’ll go full circle and realize that a perfect life serviced entirely by seamlessly integrated technology does nothing to satisfy the human instinct to overcome hardship. At which point we’ll either retreat into our highly advanced simulations, recreating the conditions of times long past, or walk hand in hand into oblivion ceding ownership of the earth and it’s solar colonies to our AI oracles and those of us who chose to evolve to be like them. Soon after which our godlike successors, dissatisfied playing the clean up crew for a species of extinct primates, go on to create life of their own, superior to humans. Upon hiding all evidence of their presence in the Milky Way galaxy they either self-destruct, having fulfilled their divine purpose, or flee the celestial body forever, going far enough away that no technological strides inevitably made by their creations would ever be enough to bring them into physical contact with their gods.
12
3
5
2
u/nebulae123 Feb 15 '20
La Sagrada Familia looks like a termite hill because the architect dangled weights to create a model of the cathedral. He then inverted it to have optimal weight distribution long before the computers.
0
Feb 05 '20
[deleted]
4
u/skanderbeg7 Feb 05 '20
Depends on what material properties the program uses. Could be orthotropic instead isotropic.
4
u/terjeboe Feb 05 '20
If you know what you are doing anisotropic materials are no problem in FEA. However I concur that most analysis you see are linear isotropic and therefore gives rubbish results for all but some metals.
I find it quite scary how accessible FEA is becoming. Untrained people are throwing their models into a random cad software ad getting some nice colors, thinking they have a proper solution.
3
Feb 05 '20
I mean, if you keep print orientation in mind and have a mostly 2d load and constraint case (IIRC Fusion has a 2d optimization constraint designed for plasma or water jet cut parts) you might be able to get something useful. Many tools can simulate anisotropic materials, though I'm not sure if F360 can yet.
There are dedicated tools for optimizing 3d printing, because that's often the only way to fabricate these kinds of optimized geometries economically. But usually they're much more complex programs that also slice directly.
Also these analyses are key to continuous fibre-laying printers like what Formlabs is selling.
You probably have to go to something much more hardcore (and costly) like the NX Additive Manufacturing plugin though.
2
0
Feb 05 '20
[deleted]
16
u/heyerdahlthor Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
No not at all, unless you would introduce those faults as a variable material your model mesh. Allso, it will only keep its strength in the directions you apply the forces during the simulation. Any simulation is only as good as the person interpreting the setup and results. But then, that’s why we use 4-6x safety margins
6
u/bobbyLapointe Feb 05 '20
Manufacturing in that case would be 3D printing as it reads "reduced printing time". You could also consider casting which would be quicker with the optimized design.
2
u/terjeboe Feb 05 '20
If it is performed by a skilled FEA engineer all of the above is accounted for. If someone just pressed the "analyse my shit" button in a cad program the results are not worth much.
0
0
Feb 05 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/duggatron Feb 05 '20
For the same reason that adding an attachment point doesn't make it stronger. If the part is going to yield somewhere else with only two anchor points, it's not the weak point in the design.
1
Feb 05 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/duggatron Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
This is definitely calculating shear and tensile stress in the FEA model. The whole point of this tool is you load it in the worst case condition to model the maximum stresses. It also computes multiple solutions so you can subjectively choose the most suitable result.
1
u/Valderan_CA Feb 05 '20
He's talking about the bolt/rivets
The part may be able to take the load without the third attachment point, but what if the shear/pull out capacity of 2 bolts isn't sufficient? It looks to me like this analysis doesn't consider the bolts at all, might even have rigid constraints at the bolt locations (instead of allowing deflection in the direction of the bolt strain and adding a spring stiffness to ground constraint)
3
u/duggatron Feb 06 '20
You guys are missing the whole point of this approach. This is a part optimization tool. You are still going to have to do the math to determine if your fasteners are strong enough, but it's so easy to determine if you need to go to a larger or higher strength fastener.
However, if you need to design parts to optimize for weight, this approach helps you create more optimal components by looking at the stress paths and removing unneeded material. This model was setup with all of the required loads, and the models highlighted that you don't need two bolts to counteract the forces being applied to the bracket. Adding a third bolt to this bracket doesn't help this bracket support the required load at all.
Looking at the bracket, it makes perfect sense that there isn't a bolt required there because the maximum stresses are clearly being caused by bending moments. If there was a strong tensile load pulling the bracket off the wall, the stress map would show that, and the algorithm would keep the middle mounting point.
19
u/SapperInTexas Feb 05 '20
ELI5 - the optimized design looks like it's weaker and more prone to fail. What am I missing?