r/EngineeringManagers • • 13m ago

How are you answering "what did our AI spend actually get us?"

1 Upvotes

Question for managers whose teams use several AI coding tools.

The bills for Claude, Cursor and ChatGPT keep growing, and finance or leadership starts asking what that spend produced. Usage dashboards show tokens and seats. They don't show which work shipped because of it.

How do you answer that question today?

- Do you tie AI usage to PRs, tickets or releases in any way?

- Does one person own the AI budget, or is it spread across teams?

- Has anyone been asked to justify or cut a tool, and what did you show?

I'm researching how teams handle this and would value hearing what has and hasn't worked.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3h ago

No visibility for the work i am doing.

0 Upvotes

I joined this new team and discovered a big fundamental bug that needs a complete overhaul of the system from the ground up.

My manager assigned this to task to me ( just because i discovered it) so i am grinding on this task but my manager refuses to ackolowdege the severity of this bug ( bug is kind of underselling it) and sold this a something trivial i am working on to upper managment. I have all the metrics as to how big of this issue this is. And this is a multi month effort to rebuild whole system and do backfills on the data.

I dont want to work on this if it is being sold as something trivial ( i think because this fuckup happened under my manager so they are motivated to underplay it) but now i am stuck with it. So i am paying the price for someone else's mistake.

I am hoping to get some advice as to how to navigate this. I am worried because they are planning a big layoff and i 've not found a job yet.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 12h ago

How to enter into Management role from a coder?

0 Upvotes

Hello Managers,

I am currently working as a technical support engineer in mainframe technologies which is pretty old.

Currently have around 8 YOE and hold Bachelor in Computer Engineering.

I want to start my career into management role and less into technical role.

Can someone help how can I transition myself from tech to management role.

Have you done any certification, or hold an MBA degree ?

How to prepare a roadmap for this role?

Thank you so much. :)


r/EngineeringManagers • • 1d ago

Team health

0 Upvotes

As em how do you measure team health and ensure its good ? what do you monitor?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 1d ago

Can more developers help when one person approves every release?

26 Upvotes

One of our customers has a launch date we need to hit, so I've been looking at outside engineering help. Initially I figured two more developers meant two more people pushing features through.

Except our only senior maintainer is already at capacity. They review most PRs, answer the codebase questions, and approve releases. More implementation work could just mean a longer queue for that same person.

I was comparing embedded engineers with a dedicated team and I saw BairesDev offering both. We could direct individual contributors or give a team a bounded workstream and more room to coordinate its own execution.  I'll still own product priorities and acceptance and our maintainer would still need to be involved in integration decisions.

Would you change who can review and approve work before adding more developers?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 1d ago

Founders and eng leads: how much of your SDLC is actually automated with agents today?

8 Upvotes

I have close to a decade of experience in big tech, and I'm now building a platform to automate the SDLC.

Coding assistants are everywhere now, and PR review, builds, deployments, monitoring and on-call are all getting real automation too. I'm trying to understand how well it's working in practice.

  1. Which parts of your SDLC have you automated, and with what?

  2. What worked and what broke? False positives, trust, integration mess, cost?

  3. What would it take for you to trust an agent with PR review or on-call triage end to end?

Interested in how far teams have really gotten, and where it falls over.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 2d ago

A small thing that helped make 1:1s less awkward

43 Upvotes

I was reading a discussion about managers struggling with what to talk about during 1:1s, and I think it's a pretty common problem. You ask how things are going, talk about whatever they're working on, maybe go through a blocker or two, and then you're both sitting there trying to think of something else to say. It's been 10 minutes and you've booked 30.

One thing that can help is having a shared doc where both of you can drop topics throughout the week. It doesn't have to be anything fancy. If something comes up on Tuesday that you want to discuss properly, just add it there instead of trying to remember it for Friday.

It's also useful for following up on previous conversations. If an engineer mentioned wanting to work on a different project, or you promised to look into something for them, you can pick that up next time instead of starting every meeting from scratch.

I also wouldn't worry too much about filling the entire 30 minutes. Some weeks there's a lot to discuss and other weeks there really isn't. You can have a useful conversation in 15 minutes.

The shared doc is worth trying though, especially if you keep finding yourselves running out of things to talk about. Even a few bullet points can give you somewhere to start.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 2d ago

Lenny’s late-2026 job market report has me rethinking how teams are actually being built. Is anyone else seeing this?

16 Upvotes

So I finally sat down with Lenny Rachitsky’s job market report from earlier this month and a couple of things have been rattling around in my head since.

I spend most of my days around people who are trying to build engineering teams (founders, eng managers, sometimes both in one panicked person), so this wasn’t totally a surprise, but the numbers are still a bit jarring. US software engineer hiring over the last 12 months was roughly 113k, which is less than half of the 2022 peak of around 239k. And it’s apparently dropped every year since.

But the weird part is that it doesn’t feel like “nobody’s hiring.” It feels like everybody’s hiring for something different than before. A few things I keep noticing:

  • Junior roles are getting squeezed hard. One dataset I saw had junior postings down about 64% vs 2022. Meanwhile the senior share keeps creeping up. Teams seem to want fewer people who can each cover more ground.

  • “AI engineer” is basically its own category now. Pragmatic Engineer’s data showed AI engineering openings up around 60% at top companies in a year, while regular SWE openings grew like 7%. Feels like LLM basics are slowly becoming a baseline skill rather than a specialty.

  • Early-stage startups are hiring engineers again (up ~7% vs 2019 according to SignalFire), but into smaller orgs. So more hiring doesn’t mean bigger teams. Design and marketing are down way more.

  • Frontend and mobile titles seem to be fading faster than backend or data roles, at least in listings.

What I can’t figure out is whether this is a real structural shift or just a weird in-between phase where everyone’s waiting to see what AI tooling does to team size. A few founders I talk to say they’d rather have 3 strong seniors than 8 mixed-level hires. Others have tried that and said it fell apart the first time someone went on vacation or quit.

Curious what it looks like from your side:

  1. If you’re hiring, has your approach changed in the last year? Smaller team, more senior, more contractors?

  2. If you’re job hunting, does the market match what the reports say, or is it better or worse than the headlines?

  3. For those on smaller teams, are you actually shipping faster with fewer people, or is it mostly hype?

Would genuinely like to hear real experiences, since the reports only tell part of the story.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 2d ago

Its feedback time and suddenly the leads are important

16 Upvotes

I’m a tech lead working on a cloud migration project. There are 4 people in my team. The project was in red before i joined, people didn’t have enough aws skills to complete the work. Once i joined, i cleared a lot of backlog tasks, did bug fixing and cleared a lot of tech debt. And what did the team do? Nothing

People just dumped everything on me. One lady just made her team’s status “offline” and stopped doing anything. She was moved out of the project eventually. Other 2 people didn’t have the skills and just used that as an excuse for everything. They didn’t upskill. They picked up some petty task and spent a week on them. I never force a task on anyone, I would rather spend a weekend and close it myself.

Now it’s year end feedback time and suddenly these same people are pinging me for feedback. And they expect me to give them good feedback. What do you guys think?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 2d ago

When you hire a senior DevOps/platform person, what do you actually test for?

5 Upvotes

Disclosure: I’m starting a small placement firm for Canadian DevOps contractors, so I have a stake in the answers.

A hiring manager told me his problem isn’t comp or time zones. Applicants list senior-level tools and can’t operate at that level once you’re talking to them.

For those of you who’ve hired or sat on panels: what tells you in the first 15 minutes that someone is really senior? Walking through an outage they handled? Knowing why they picked a tool, not just how to run it? Something else?

And which screening step do you wish you could skip because it never tells you anything?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 2d ago

Reached my desired EM level, working on a product I don’t care much about and completely lost my spark. How to get out of feeling burned/border-out?

22 Upvotes

(No AI) Hi! Quite a few years ago I lost the spark. I feel burned out, the role of an always available leader became a grind. Navigating between true performance of the engineers on my team and performance assessment expectations feels like the final nail in the coffin of my engineering manager career. I'm now rather following a status quo policy; most of my engineers like our relationship but I feel that I had a lot more to offer when I was earlier in my career.

As I think of why I am where I am, there are 2 possible factors (for sure there are other but those ones I'm aware of):

  1. A few years ago I reached my desired level on the reporting ladder and I said "this is it". I see no interest in pursuing more exposed roles, I'm not trying to prove anything, I just try to do what I was good at (and what I'm becoming worse at every day). I tried the level down only to realize I wanted to be back one level up. So it feels like an equilibrium of some sort.

  2. The product that my team develops is totally outside of my interest. I mean, sure, I can see the progress, my team delivers the releases and we celebrate, I try to stay as close to the team's scope as possible (it's still high-level, without hands-on engagement), but that's far from where I was before when I truly enjoyed the products we were developing. And I know there aren't many opportunities on the products I'd be interested in working on, so it's like take it or leave it. And so I take it, as the company is top notch, and so are the people and salary.

And I wonder how to get out of this trap. Chasing the C-level isn't for me so I need to find motivation elsewhere. I'm thinking that maybe I can get myself engaged in some form of product development with my team, like testing, but, man, it feels like spending effort on learning things I know I don't need. But maybe there's an inflection point somewhere there where it just clicks. Maybe it's because I don't comprehend a whole lot of things behind what my team works on. And, needless to say, there's not much time left in a work week of a manager after having 1:1s, lots of project calls, replying to emails, IMs, writing n status reports for n levels of management, etc.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3d ago

CS student who wants to build something huge. What world problem should I aim at?

0 Upvotes

I'm a CS student who wants to build something that changes how millions of people live, like the big tech companies did. What's one problem you think technology could solve but nobody has yet? Why hasn't it happened?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3d ago

PIP - help around the process.

22 Upvotes

I have been a software developer for over 28 years and have been issued a PIP. The company is a private company with around 300 people.

I am competent staff engineer, my manager is not technical. Thanks to Claude the leadership wants employees to 10x and that was fine with me as I enjoyed working etc. My manager was losing it as now he had responsibilities that he needed to be accountable for. Being the lead he kept pushing everything on me and I was fine if it was technology related. I however needed him to make decisions for cross team asks and decisions for say releases and going to the CAB meeting.

I just asked him, "hey manager who do you suggest". He went on a DM and instead of responding bullied me into my expectations etc. I wasn't ready to put with the crap as he was being unstable and asked him that I needed help in cross team coordination and project decisions.

He didn't respond to any updates after that and he today on my 1:1 put me on pip. I have a timeline based on slack chats about what all I did etc.

The improvement listed is totally subjective and has nothing concrete. Can I ask him to make the pip objective? Looks like there is no way to get out of it as he has used vague goals.

Appreciate any pointers, I am the only working person in my family and my wife is disabled and a teenage kid who just started highschool. This really affects me, I am trying to start looking elsewhere too but this market sucks.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3d ago

New dev resists using AI and his productivity is concerning

202 Upvotes

I manage a mobile team and hired a guy 3 months ago who had about 1 yr experience before joining us.

He's smart, understands our architecture fine. The issue is his output is painfully slow. Tickets that should take a day are taking him most of the week, mostly because he's manually grinding through every single line of SwiftUI/Compose boilerplate, mapping JSON models by hand, and fighting random Xcode/Gradle errors on Stack Overflow for hours.

We pay for Claude for everyone, and he flat out refuses to touch it. Told me in a 1:1 he thinks it's a crutch and wants to actually understand what he's writing.

I respect not wanting to blindly paste slop, especially at 1 YOE. At the same time, it's been 3 months and his velocity looks terrible on paper compared to everyone else.

Should I stay out of his workflow and just tell him his output isn't meeting expectations, or push him to actually use the tools so he keeps up with the pace of technology?

---

Edit: I appreciate that the majority of comments is saying "AI is the new reality". We are in 2026, and I feel the same way. So, my question is: do I let him figure that out by himself? Or do I tell him the old way of doing things is over?

Edit #2: There is a big split between people who are adamant for AI, and people who suggest holding off on AI, and letting the dev learn the codebase using his preferred methods. I'm mentoring the dev, and I'll keep encouraging him to engage deeply with the code. The compromise will be that I need to accept that he's a junior, and he's just not going to be very productive for a long time. That's the hard truth I didn't want to learn, so I'm hoping he sticks around till we can see the payoff.

Thank you everyone for your comments.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3d ago

Founders and eng leads: how much of your SDLC is actually automated with agents today?

2 Upvotes

I have close to a decade of experience in big tech, and I'm now building a platform to automate the SDLC.

Coding assistants are everywhere now, and PR review, builds, deployments, monitoring and on-call are all getting real automation too. I'm trying to understand how well it's working in practice.

  1. Which parts of your SDLC have you automated, and with what?

  2. What worked and what broke? False positives, trust, integration mess, cost?

  3. What would it take for you to trust an agent with PR review or on-call triage end to end?

Interested in how far teams have really gotten, and where it falls over.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 3d ago

Folks who transitioned from coders to managers, are you also de-skilled?

19 Upvotes

I'm posting this as a former eng manager who then transitioned to staff engineer, and then got hit with the tidal wave of AI like everyone else.

AI has made many engineers dissatisfied with their jobs, because babysitting AIs is not what they feel good doing. Since the volume of code that AI produces is essentially un-reviewable, it's also made coders unable to understand their own codebases.

So, we engineers are told by AI boosters that we should cope by re-imagining ourselves as managers. Most managers don't understand the codebase either, and they have to trust their underlings to code things correctly. So what's different about agents?

To me, AI feels qualitatively different. Perhaps because, as an engineer, I’m still fully responsible for understanding what the code does.

But what do you all think? Should engineers using AI just suck it up and accept the loss of control and the feeling of mastery, like managers have? Or is AI something fundamentally different?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

Should I Get a Bachelor's in Industrial & Systems Engineering or Engineering Management Given My Experience?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm looking for some advice on which bachelor's degree would be the better choice given my professional background and future career goals.

A little about my experience:

  • U.S. Air Force: Previously active duty working on F-35 avionics and aircraft maintenance.

  • Lockheed Martin: Worked as an avionics technician on the F-35 program.

  • U.S. Space Force: Currently serving in the Reserves as an E-5. My experience includes strategic and tactical missile warning, space operations, and test and evaluation.

  • Leidos: Currently working in inventory and logistics supporting defense operations.

  • Security clearance: Active TS/SCI.

I'm currently a junior studying Industrial & Systems Engineering, but I'm considering switching to a bachelor's in Engineering Management. I'm also planning to obtain my PMP and Security+ certifications.

My goal after graduating in 2028 is to stay in the contracting world and try and work for Andruil in one of their TPM positions for space operations.

Here's my dilemma:

I already have several years of technical experience in military aviation, space operations, and defense contracting. Because of that, I'm wondering whether pursuing an Engineering Management degree would make more sense than continuing with Industrial & Systems Engineering since lately I've been more interested in management because of the type of work it is and the increase in pay.

However, I'm concerned that choosing Engineering Management might limit my opportunities when applying to defense contractors, especially for positions that require an engineering degree.

My main questions are:

  1. Given my background, which bachelor's degree would you recommend: Industrial & Systems Engineering or Engineering Management?

  2. Is an Engineering Management bachelor's with technical experienced viewed as less valuable than a traditional engineering degree by aerospace and defense companies?

  3. Would my military and technical experience compensate for having an Engineering Management degree instead of a traditional engineering degree?

  4. If my ultimate goal is technical program management or engineering leadership, would I be better off getting a traditional engineering bachelor's and pursuing an Engineering Management master's later?

I'm not necessarily trying to become a design engineer. I'm more interested in managing technical projects, working alongside engineering teams, and eventually leading programs involving advanced defense and space technologies.

I'd really appreciate hearing from engineering managers, technical program managers, or anyone working in the aerospace and defense industry.

Sorry for the long post I just do not have anyone near me I can ask advice from.

Thanks!


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

what's the tax-compliant way to hire an engineer abroad?

3 Upvotes

I manage a backend team of 8 people at a US company, and the best candidate we've had in months for a senior role lives in Toronto.

Our CTO is happy to hire her, but our CFO pushed back as soon as he heard Canada, as we have no entity there and he doesn't want her on a contractor agreement when she'd work full time on the team like the rest of us.

From what he told me, putting her on payroll properly means withholding Canadian income tax and paying into the Canadian pension plan and employment insurance every pay period.

Our team doesn't have anyone who knows how to do that.

He wants to go through an employer of record and has asked Remote and Workmotion for quotes, since both came up when our HR lead asked around in a founders' group.

Before I go back to the candidate with a timeline, I'd like to hear from managers who've hired outside their own country how long the EOR setup took and whether it changed anything about managing that person day to day.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

Not happy with quality standards in the new team, do I raise the issue with managers?

12 Upvotes

I moved to a new team internally and it's been six months. The application is customer facing with high throughput but is not mission critical.

The team as a whole, from PO, SM, Devs, QA do the bare minimum to make sure the new features or fixes are resilient. The DoD, acceptance criteria, QA tests are always about the happy path. Which obviously as a developer I will test! My concern is with the corner cases, stress test, idempotency, auth, security, etc... not a single test apart from the happy path is tested.

And often they come back as customer issues. And then we realise "oh we missed this obvious corner case" or "oh no we are leaking a token in the logs".

How do I raise this with my manager without sounding like a rant, or blame. What if they think that I am the problem. Or should I just chill and accept this is what it is.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

AI agent workflows across company teams. We're trying to standardize this across the company, but it's really tough. What are your experiences with how your teams are responding and managing to standardize the workflow?

3 Upvotes

How do you align all company teams to adopt a single workflow, so that the output generated by AI agents is tracked and consistent across teams? It seems like one of the most difficult challenges facing a company: everyone tries to do it their own way. Often, each team works completely differently with AI and doesn't have a standardized workflow. In my opinion, this reduces the quantity and quality of output across teams.

My team is having success, and others in the company are curious about our method of working with AI agents. We've created a comprehensive workflow. Some are starting to adopt it.

Our current solution is initial tech grooming, where the whole team sits down together, discusses a technical issue and strarts a grilling session with claude using repository involved, ADRs DDD pages. So we produce ADRs, Domain Driven Design pages, and very detailed tickets. Each ticket contains important pieces of code that the agent will need to write, so our PR review is almost zero. Then, when we're ready, we release the agents.

Is this a common problem for other companies, or is mine the only one having this problem at the moment?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

What's really the point of one on ones if nothing comes if it?

5 Upvotes

As an IC, I've been noticing a trend of when I mention things I'd like to work on (higher level stuff), it gets acknowledged but nothing really changes. Therefore the one and ones feel pointless to me. Even if they can't have me working on it I much prefer they directly tell me why etc.. any thoughts on how to move forward with this?


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

Something I've learned about helping engineers make decisions

29 Upvotes

I've been running remote engineering teams for around 10 years, and one thing I've struggled with is figuring out how much guidance to give engineers when they're stuck on something.

When you've been an engineer yourself, it's pretty tempting to just explain how you'd solve a problem, especially when you've dealt with something similar before. And sometimes that's exactly what the person needs.

But I've noticed that engineers sometimes come to me with a problem they've already thought through. They've got a couple of options in mind, they're just not sure which one to go with.

In those cases, I like asking what they've considered so far and what's making the decision difficult. You'd be surprised how often someone already has a reasonable solution and just wants to talk it through with somebody.

Sometimes there's a good reason they're hesitant. Maybe they're missing some context, or it's a decision that affects another team, or they simply haven't had to make that kind of call before.

I wouldn't turn every question into a coaching session though. If someone's blocked and needs a straightforward answer, just give them the answer. I can imagine how annoying it would be to ask your manager a simple question and get five questions back instead.

But for decisions where there's room to think things through, I've found these conversations useful, especially with engineers who are starting to take on more responsibility.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 4d ago

Thoughts on a small confrontation between myself and a fellow co-worker

1 Upvotes

Sorry this is long, but for managers, I’m sure it’s an interesting read.

I’m a Combustion Engineer at a gas turbine manufacturer. Have been here for 3 years and it’s the first job I’ve had post graduation (bachelors and masters). I have a guy who sits behind me and is an informal “mentor” so to speak. He’s been there for 10 years, has a PhD, and is the only other true combustor guy. I’m a very independent worker (even being relatively new), and I like to figure things out myself because I believe that is a better way to learn than consistently asking questions. Ive been told I’m very independent and highly detailed in performance reviews, and I have been occasionally told to try to check in more with him, although my manager said, and I quote “this is really just me trying to find any bit on constructive criticism”. My reviews have always been solid. I definitely meet with my mentor as I’m working on projects to give him a run down of where I’m at and I take that time to ask any questions I do have (I’d say roughly once a month or so). In essence, I normally don’t need much guidance if at all with all of the things I work on outside of a few pointers occasionally.

I have been working a CFD study that I personally think is very straight forward. Him and I are in a bi-weekly meeting with two others from a different team and we give updates on combustor related items. We’re are at a very primitive stage with this new design. Mostly, this meeting is kind of a large brainstorm session between us and the project team to discuss what concepts may work and may not work based on very preliminary analysis results. No senior leadership or anything in this meeting. I didn’t mention to him that I had completed the study last week. It only took about a week, and I got through it with ease. The meeting comes around and I had my short ppt slide deck on the screen. He looks very puzzled and asks me “what’s this?” Keep in mind he 100% knew what I was working on as we discussed it in the previous meeting. I told him what it was for, and asked him if he was not expecting me to discuss these results. He said “no, I just didn’t realize you were done”. He was clearly agitated when saying this. He sat there in silence as we waited for everyone, and after a few mins said something along the lines of “just for future reference, I’d like to be looped in on what you’re doing here before we discuss it in this meeting”. I asked him if he felt like that because he didn’t trust what I was going to present, because that’s honestly how it came off. We got into a small argument after this (no shouting or cussing…was pretty benign), but his argument was that he didn’t want me making decisions or claims in the meeting without informing him….even though this isn’t a meeting where we are making any concrete decisions or claims, nor is any senior leadership involved. The meeting commenced and everything went alright. He didn’t have anything to say about my work really.

After the meeting, he said sorry and that he knew where I was coming from and that he didn’t mean it like that. I said sorry as well, and told him I wasn’t trying to usurp him or go around him at all. I just truly felt it was a straightforward analysis and I had no intent of making any bold claims or anything of that nature about my results (which isn’t common in these meetings). I thought at this point, we moved on. Today, two days after the meeting, I get a meeting invite with him and my manager tagged as optional. It’s a bi weekly meeting between our other scheduled biweekly combustor meeting that is so “him and my manager can be informed of my progress”. Is it just me, or is it kind of scummy to bring my manager into something like this? I didn’t really view it as something that was a huge deal, but he’s obviously now got my manager involved. Should I say something to my manager or should I just shrug this off? Kind of irks me tbh, but I’m truly not someone who likes to stir the pot with management. I definitely don’t appreciate it though, and kind of feel like I maybe need to defend myself now that management is involved.

Thanks for your thoughts in advance.


r/EngineeringManagers • • 5d ago

Interview with Student Taking Engineering Ethics

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am a college student and I am currently enrolled in an engineering ethics course. I need to interview an engineer regarding their experience with ethics within their field. I have not been able to connect with anyone for the life of me. I come from a background where I don’t have any engineers in my family nor close circle so I am hoping Reddit can help me with this assignment. I am hoping to meet asap since I have this assignment due tmr and left it last minute as any college student does.

Any help is appreciated!