Sorry this is long, but for managers, I’m sure it’s an interesting read.
I’m a Combustion Engineer at a gas turbine manufacturer. Have been here for 3 years and it’s the first job I’ve had post graduation (bachelors and masters). I have a guy who sits behind me and is an informal “mentor” so to speak. He’s been there for 10 years, has a PhD, and is the only other true combustor guy. I’m a very independent worker (even being relatively new), and I like to figure things out myself because I believe that is a better way to learn than consistently asking questions. Ive been told I’m very independent and highly detailed in performance reviews, and I have been occasionally told to try to check in more with him, although my manager said, and I quote “this is really just me trying to find any bit on constructive criticism”. My reviews have always been solid. I definitely meet with my mentor as I’m working on projects to give him a run down of where I’m at and I take that time to ask any questions I do have (I’d say roughly once a month or so). In essence, I normally don’t need much guidance if at all with all of the things I work on outside of a few pointers occasionally.
I have been working a CFD study that I personally think is very straight forward. Him and I are in a bi-weekly meeting with two others from a different team and we give updates on combustor related items. We’re are at a very primitive stage with this new design. Mostly, this meeting is kind of a large brainstorm session between us and the project team to discuss what concepts may work and may not work based on very preliminary analysis results. No senior leadership or anything in this meeting. I didn’t mention to him that I had completed the study last week. It only took about a week, and I got through it with ease. The meeting comes around and I had my short ppt slide deck on the screen. He looks very puzzled and asks me “what’s this?” Keep in mind he 100% knew what I was working on as we discussed it in the previous meeting. I told him what it was for, and asked him if he was not expecting me to discuss these results. He said “no, I just didn’t realize you were done”. He was clearly agitated when saying this. He sat there in silence as we waited for everyone, and after a few mins said something along the lines of “just for future reference, I’d like to be looped in on what you’re doing here before we discuss it in this meeting”. I asked him if he felt like that because he didn’t trust what I was going to present, because that’s honestly how it came off. We got into a small argument after this (no shouting or cussing…was pretty benign), but his argument was that he didn’t want me making decisions or claims in the meeting without informing him….even though this isn’t a meeting where we are making any concrete decisions or claims, nor is any senior leadership involved. The meeting commenced and everything went alright. He didn’t have anything to say about my work really.
After the meeting, he said sorry and that he knew where I was coming from and that he didn’t mean it like that. I said sorry as well, and told him I wasn’t trying to usurp him or go around him at all. I just truly felt it was a straightforward analysis and I had no intent of making any bold claims or anything of that nature about my results (which isn’t common in these meetings). I thought at this point, we moved on. Today, two days after the meeting, I get a meeting invite with him and my manager tagged as optional. It’s a bi weekly meeting between our other scheduled biweekly combustor meeting that is so “him and my manager can be informed of my progress”. Is it just me, or is it kind of scummy to bring my manager into something like this? I didn’t really view it as something that was a huge deal, but he’s obviously now got my manager involved. Should I say something to my manager or should I just shrug this off? Kind of irks me tbh, but I’m truly not someone who likes to stir the pot with management. I definitely don’t appreciate it though, and kind of feel like I maybe need to defend myself now that management is involved.
Thanks for your thoughts in advance.