9
34
u/According_Flight_420 Mar 11 '23
If it aināt stupid if it works
26
u/drake22 Mar 11 '23
Idk, I work, and I'm dumb asf.
9
u/zenkique Mar 11 '23
Dumb af but are you stupid?
10
3
31
u/Themagicdick Mar 11 '23
Bruh how are yāall building an engine with out a torque wrench.
48
u/Esc_ape_artist Mar 11 '23
That is a torque wrench. You can see the markings on the handle.
Torque-turn or torque angle fastener tightening is a thing.
This bizarre video seems to show them doing torque angle tightening but using a torque wrench to do so.
11
u/meltman Mar 11 '23
Exactly. Weird to use a torque wrench for this but what they have done is create a ghetto torque angle wrench which is different than a normal torque wrench.
3
u/Delt266 Apr 24 '23
Luckily it's not a spring type torque wrench otherwise they would have twisted that thing way out of spec from over torquing the wrench
1
u/Sweaty-Baseball-2027 Sep 10 '23
In the video they say 20 (newtons or newton meters ) plus 70degrees
4
Mar 12 '23
Theyre using a torque wrench. For lots of fasteners in an engine, the spec is something called a torque angle, meaning you tighten to a specific torque, and then tighten past that by a specific angle. To accomplish that you usually use an angular torque wrench, which does exactly that, you set a torque value and then it starts measuring degrees after you reach that torque value. They dont have one of those, so theyre accomplishing the same thing by using a compass attached to their torque wrench.
1
u/Themagicdick Mar 12 '23
Ok yea didnāt see the torque wench. But torque angles still have a specific torque. They couldāve just done that
4
Mar 12 '23
Yes, they do have a specific torque, which is what the torque wrench is for, but because its a torque angle, they need to measure how far theyve turned since the torque wrench clicked, which is what the phone is for.
30
u/v8packard Mar 11 '23
Well that's clever
-21
Mar 11 '23
Here you dropped this, /
9
u/Rats_for_sale Mar 11 '23
Thereās no reason it wouldnāt work fine.
4
1
u/Girardkirth Mar 11 '23
Depending on the accuracy of the phones compass
2
u/ematlack Mar 12 '23
Nearly all phones are going to be well sufficient for this.
1
u/Girardkirth Mar 12 '23
How would you know that, what if it wasn't?
6
u/ematlack Mar 12 '23
Iām a robotics engineer and deal with magnetometers all the time. The one in your phone is perfectly capable of well exceeding the +/- few degree needs of torque angle bolts.
6
u/Luckymexicanguy Mar 11 '23
Been there, done that. But then I got a proper wrench as I had to disassemble the engine again.
15
4
2
3
1
1
u/dixiebandit69 Mar 11 '23
"Your Honor, I defend my client under the statute that 'It's not stupid if it works.'"
1
1
u/Dankkring Mar 11 '23
Wouldnāt a torque wrench be a lot cheaper? Not sure how much that phone cost
1
Mar 12 '23
1: it is a torque wrench, the custom part is just having the phone attached to it
2: its not permanent lol
1
1
u/tyler669420 Mar 11 '23
Lmao I used a protractor with my 2016 Tahoe šš¤·āāļø 20k miles later sheās still rippin
1
1
u/JayTheLegends Mar 11 '23
Wait is torque based on angles? I thought it was based on pressure or some such..
2
Mar 12 '23 edited Oct 26 '24
Torque is a measurement of force. However, lots of fasteners in an engine, instead of listing a torque spec, list a torque angle spec. For example, the head bolts on an engine might be 48ft-lbs + 90°, which means you need to tighten them to a torque of 48ft-lbs, and then tighten them another 90°. To measure this accurately, some torque wrenches, especially newer electronic ones, will start counting the degrees that you turn past the set torque. This is basically a redneck way of accomplishing that same thing. They taped a smartphone acting as a compass to the torque wrench, so they set the torque and then use the smartphone to measure how far theyve turned since it clicked.
1
1
u/Dangerous_Echidna229 Sep 03 '24
The angle assures maximum stretch has taken place thus assuring maximum clamp force from the fastener.
1
u/coppertech Mar 12 '23
I've done this with torque to yield head bolts, why would I buy a special angle adapter when I already have one on my phone?
1
1
u/Photo_Beneficial Mar 12 '23
Whats up with the torque wrench clicking so much while tigethening? I thought they'd only click when they reached the desired torque.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Drummond269 Mar 22 '23
I just set the stop point for my ratchet and count the clicks...4 degrees per click on a 90 tooth head. That being said, if it works than it works. He should have clipped the tails on the zipties tho...anything less is shoddy
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Severe_Letter_7985 May 08 '23
I was told by an old supervisor who built and rebuilt dirtbike engines "his whole life", he said regardless of the torque spec, anything and everything can be set with "snug, and then 1/4 turn."
1
1
u/Thecoopoftheworld789 May 24 '23
Must have to use new bolts or the old will be too stretched to use like Volvo on their head bolts.
1
u/Extension_Economy_82 Jun 27 '23
Torque to yield fasteners can be reused if the manufacturer permits it, but then it's only a certain number of times (like 2-3).
1
u/Nicholas_Cage_Fan May 29 '23
Probably a better idea to get the extra degrees with a normal ratchet, rather than using your torque wrench
1
u/ike-mike Jun 16 '23
Just so everyone knows, one flat on a six sideded bolt is 60 degrees š¤«
I usually just put a mark on a flat of the bolt and one on the socket and do torque to yield that way.
1
1
1
0
u/YouAreHorriblexD Mar 11 '23
So itās measuring angle, not torque ? So it isnāt a torque wrench?
You could use a protractor attached to a crescent wrench and get the same result
4
u/Only_Jury_8448 Mar 11 '23
Some components on certain cars require a multi-step torque application, typically wheel bearings and cylinder head bolts. You apply a designated torque measurement, back off the fastener a given amount, and then move the wrench whatever number of degrees from the back off point. These guys are just using a smartphone app in place of having a torque angle meter.
3
u/Mutjny Mar 11 '23
BMW straight 6 crank pulley bolt has like weird spec where you torque it to some value, back it off a quarter turn, torque angle 50, then another 50, then torque angle 90. Its madness.
1
u/Only_Jury_8448 Mar 11 '23
It definitely seems to be a European thing, mostly. My buddy just replaced a wheel bearing on his mk4 Golf and it had a similar process; torque tight, back off some amount of turns, then some angle, then a low torque.
1
u/patx35 Mar 11 '23
Make sense in some ways. First torque is to make sure that the crank pulley is fully driven into the crankshaft snout. Then loosened and tightened 180-190 degrees. But 190 degrees in one shot is difficult, so it's split up to multiple steps.
1
1
u/Dangerous_Echidna229 Sep 03 '24
I have never seen a spec that calls for the fastener to be backed off and then the angle applied. Who does this?
1
u/YouAreHorriblexD Mar 11 '23
Thatās exactly what i said. They could use a protractor to measure it if they wanted to. Or just mark the bolt like every engine I have ever built. This is not measuring torque at all.
1
Mar 12 '23
You're right, the compass isnt measuring torque. The torque wrench the compass is attached to is measuring torque.
0
u/Only_Jury_8448 Mar 11 '23
You could, but it might be tricky to keep the protractor in place to be accurate. I've never seen an engine build using a protractor, but I guess it's possible. No one is claiming that the angle "measures torque". The reason is explained here
0
u/YouAreHorriblexD Mar 11 '23
ā¦. The title calls it a custom torque wrench ffs š¤¦āāļø lol.
2
u/Only_Jury_8448 Mar 11 '23
I mean, it is. It's a torque wrench with a makeshift angle gauge in the form of a smartphone app. I'm not sure why you think it's so dumb, especially since it's kinda of rare to have a protractor on hand in a shop. Most people have access to a smartphone.
-1
1
Mar 12 '23
Yes, its a torque wrench, with the customization of having a compass on it to measure degrees. Itts a custom torque wrench.
1
Mar 12 '23
Its a torque wrench with a compass on it to let it act like an angular torque wrench. You couldnt achieve the same effect with a crescent wrench because the spec is degrees after a specific torque
110
Mar 11 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
42
u/Zinoviev85 Mar 12 '23 edited Mar 12 '23
Sooo, Iāve been turning wrenches for a while, and Iāve never heard of ātorque angle.ā Iām not saying you guys are wrong, but if youāre right Iām going to learn something.
Edit: it appears torque angle is a thing when building internal combustion engines. I stand by my career of not having to reassemble filthy, stupid internal combustion engines. NO REGRETS!!!
9
u/deevil_knievel Mar 12 '23
Definitely not for only engines.
Lots of critical applications use it as it's more accurate and will have less deviation in a joint with multiple fasteners.
If you work on electric motors, no. If you work on turbines, yes you would be familiar with torque angle.
3
u/ExoHertz Apr 20 '23 edited Apr 20 '23
Anytime you're dealing with stretch bolts you torque and then angle them.
Most cylinder head bolts are stretch bolts.
On diesels they'll be like, 180ft lbs. 90 degree, 90 degree, 90 degree, 90 degree, break and drink water with a cliff bar, 90 degree.
I'd say most, if not all engines, are internal combustion.
I think steam engines would be external combustion. Thinking about it now.
That Said!
Stretch bolts aren't supposed to be reusable, but they can be reused in practice. If you reuse a stretch bolt and it was done correctly (torque + angle), doing it again won't do anything. It's already stretched. So you should replace them, or otherwise try and math your actual torque.
Which you'd need to measure your loosening torque and basically add 10% to your torque off number and then apply it with tightening. (100 ft lbs loosening torque is now 110 ft lbs tightening torque, for example).
I've edited this a couple times now.
1
1
3
2
1
1
u/UndefinedSpoon Aug 22 '23
Usually torque to yield (TTY) bolts, like head bolts on an LS motor for example. The torque is the first step, then from what I've been told the torque angle is where the plastic deformation occurs.
0
31
Mar 12 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
17
u/atguilmette Apr 13 '23
ā18 pounds plus a quarter turnā other nonsense
12
u/sugartramp420 May 11 '23
Default if no instructions is turn ātil it knocks then back of a quarter. 100% chance of working 50% of the time.
4
5
u/Rubbertutti May 01 '23
I've never seen a sequence that requires backing off
2
u/GhostShiftz Jun 16 '23
Some hub seals and bearings call for a torc to spec then backed off to a certain degree. The initial torque value is to ensure the seals/bearings are properly seated, then backed off too not crush/seize the new component.
2
u/Rubbertutti Jun 17 '23
Nope never heard or seen a torque to spec and back off sequence for head bolts or bearings.
Taper wheel bearing need to be tightened up till it binds and then backed off. But thereās no torque spec.
2
1
u/Dangerous_Echidna229 Sep 03 '24
I have seen specs for tapered wheel bearing torque and then back off
1
u/Need2play24 Jul 29 '23
Ive seen some bmw crank shaft bolts with an odd tightening sequence, I'm not a mechanic though so take it with a grain of salt
1
2
u/nmyron3983 Jun 25 '23
Yea, every torque angle spec I've seen is something like "40 ft lbs + 45°"
You hit your click, then pop the angle gauge between the torque wrench and socket, and turn till you hit 45°, and then your fastener is stretched into the threads.
1
1
u/Head_Cause_2069 Aug 09 '23
Subaru asks to back off bolts in many of the ej and fa toque sequences. Heads and cam carriers. It's to relieve stress put on the aluminum part from torquing the middle bolts first. They also have multiple stages of angled torques for heads. The middle 2 bolts get an additional 45 degrees after everything.
2
May 29 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/Dangerous_Echidna229 Sep 03 '24
Who calls for you to back off after torquing? Never saw it required.
1
3
2
u/Indo_ismycountry Jun 30 '23
i have seen in several japanese workshop manual for their car stated exactly like that. they tends to use "X lbs/ft and then tighten with fastener X degrees"
i use arc ruler back then, it's sounds stupid and in practice i look like stupid monkey trying to repair a car but it works.. the annoying part if we use used bolts, it doesn't do well with certain X degrees.
3
2
1
u/Dangerous_Echidna229 May 02 '25
You do not back the fastener off. Usually used with torque to yield bolts which shouldnāt be reused.
1
2
1
u/Delt266 Apr 24 '23
Just buy the timorque angle guage from Amazon or Snapon. Geez. This is just being cheap or lazy
1
48
u/darryl1105 Mar 11 '23
When do you stop, at magnetic north ?