r/EngagementRings • • Jan 13 '26

Vendor Review - CUSTOMERS ONLY What ever you do, do not use brilliant earth. Terrible stones and worse service. Beware of sunburst halos as well.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My partner proposed in December and things went comically wrong logistically but that kinda fits us. I was really disappointed in my ring. The sapphire is really dark and has zero sparkle of any kind. If I am honest it looks like dark glass in everything but the brightest direct sunlight. But the real issue was how my ring cut me when I hit my hand on a table. I am attaching pictures of right after the injury and how it looked over 3 weeks later.

I contacted them and was 2 weeks past the 30 day cut off for returns. I had just been in the hospital so my proposal happened later than it was supposed to. I talked with multiple managers and different employees. They offered a 50% metal credit for the setting only. I was told I should try going to a pawn shop.

I am a clumsy person but I shouldn’t be afraid to wear my engagement ring. I had to extend my time at a wound care clinic because of this! The stone is so disappointing I would have been a lot more satisfied if I could have at least changed that. Please don’t give them any more business they don’t have quality products.


r/EngagementRings • • Jan 13 '26 Bravo

Advice She told me what she wants... I should just listen to her... right?

47 Upvotes

So, my girlfriend wears a lot of jewelry. None of it gold. None of it has diamonds.

She has told me in no uncertain terms that she wants any engagement ring to be sterling silver, and to contain jade. And she has said clearly that she doesn't care for diamonds.

And I've found some awesome silver and jade rings, which I believe she would absolutely love. And I absolutely love the price of these rings, which is of course wayyy lower than a gold and diamond ring.

But, I just can't shake this feeling that if I open the box and put it on her finger and it's not a diamond (gold I'm more ambivalent about) that somehow, it'll just be wrong. I don't really trust myself to know what she wants better than she does, but, somehow I feel like it might be the right call to just trust tradition... Who isn't going to be happy getting a surprise diamond, right?

So help me out here. I'm leaning towards just listening to her, getting the cheaper, still beautiful, jade and silver ring... Putting it on her finger and going through with the ceremony and all that, and then, you know what, a few years down the line when we're hopefully in a better financial situation, maybe I can get her a big gaudy diamond piece if she really does want it.

If anyone has a trick to subtly suss out what she really wants though, let me know. I'm not in a big rush to make a final decision here, but the sooner I can figure this out, the better.

TIA


r/EngagementRings • • 8d ago

My Ring - POSITIVE COMMENTS ONLY Took over 20 years for this upgrade!

2 Upvotes

6.05 Old European Cut (Natural diamond) center stone with a little over 1ct of side baguettes. 4.12ct pear cut wedding band. I have a 3mm rose gold band in the middle as a spacer. Ring size 5.75.

When we first got engaged in 2003, he promised to upgrade my ring...it took a long time, but I feel it's been worth the wait! He had a long time to save 😄


r/EngagementRings • • Jan 21 '22

My fiancé got me a ring after he got out of boot camp. I had been rocking a cheap one from Kendra Scott before this

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • May 16 '26

Question Thoughts on my new stack?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • Apr 19 '23

Question Help! Looking for an artist to make one of these Pokémon themed rings. I'm going to propose to my girlfriend in August

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • Dec 05 '25

My Ring - POSITIVE COMMENTS ONLY Engagement ring upgrade!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Given state of diamond prices, I decided to upgrade my wife’s engagement ring. We just had our first kid and it’s also the only thing I could thing of for a push present!

8.54 carat emerald cut, E vvs1.


r/EngagementRings • • Aug 23 '26

My Ring - POSITIVE COMMENTS ONLY I love my lab upgrade!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • Jul 20 '21

Miscellaneous What is with all the “no longer a lurker” posts?

13 Upvotes

The first time I saw a post with this caption, I thought it was cute/funny but it’s just everywhere now and starting to feel a bit “othering” … As a “lurker” myself, all these “no longer a lurker,” “upgraded to fiancé,” and “finally part of the club” posts come off as sounding like there’s something about being engaged that makes you (especially women) somehow better, and I think that’s really harmful, especially for young women perusing this sub. I love browsing this sub while working on designing our ring but every time I see posts about lurkers, it makes me feel unwelcome or like a second class citizen on this sub. And the posts about being “upgraded” or “joining a club” just give me weird old fashioned vibes about women/marriage. I’m sure that’s not the intention that people have when posting with these captions but want to just put out there that this is how it comes off, at least to me. /End rant.

ETA: To clarify, I don’t see it as gloating - I know people are just happy/excited and want to share their bling. I’m genuinely happy for everyone happily posting their rings but just feel like it’s also inadvertently perpetuating weird othering and old fashioned vibes I don’t love. And it doesn’t bother me all that much - just kind of like cute ring but meh about that caption :/


r/EngagementRings • • Jul 04 '26

Advice Need advice on my choice ✨

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Generally I just want cartier for my engagement ring. But my bf told me “The money just goes to the brand name. You want a bigger natural diamond and better materials, so u can do it with any other jeweler at the same price. U can get more beautiful rings” etc. Realistically i agree with this now. But my 21yo ass just wanted cartier all the time bc I never had it. My country has no cartier, so every time I travel, I pass by cartier stores and dream ab finally buying my engagement ring from there🫠 But bc of the price range, i ended up w rings that aren’t as pretty as the ones in the pics. Or should I go for a custom ring? 😩


r/EngagementRings • • Aug 25 '26

Advice Tiffany vs. Cartier - which would you choose? I'm so torn😭💍

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

For reference, I’m a size 4.25 and would get the same carat size in either ring

First photo = Tiffany
Second photo = Cartier

Tiffany has always been my dream ring. It's the one l've pictured myself having for years, so there's definitely an emotional attachment to it. But after actually trying both on, I realized that the Cartier is slightly more comfortable on my finger and feels really natural to wear.
Now I'm stuck because I'm wondering if I should go with the ring I've always dreamed of (Tiffany), or the one that I might actually find more comfortable/easy to wear every day (Cartier). They’re both really nice.
I’m also planning to eventually pair it with either a yellow gold Cartier Love band or a pavé diamond band, so I’d love to hear which one you think would work better for stacking!

For anyone who has a knife-edge band: do you find it uncomfortable for everyday wear?


r/EngagementRings • • Aug 06 '23

Looking for Advice Should I upgrade??

Post image
1 Upvotes

I love my ring, but when I got engaged years ago lab diamonds were not nearly as accessible or affordable, so I got a natural diamond.

Nows I’m thinking of upgrading to a bigger pear center lab stone, but I can’t tell if I’m just being influenced by all the big rings I see on pages like this/social media..does this look like the right size on my hand? Would upgrading about .75 carat bigger be worth it??


r/EngagementRings • • Oct 16 '22

Advice How did other people respond to your engagement ring?

6 Upvotes

Obviously it’s only my own and my partners opinions that matter when it comes to my ring and I’m absolutely obsessed with how beautiful it is! But my friends and family that I’ve shown it too haven’t been as enthusiastic about it as I was expecting. I really thought it’d be a moment of joy we’d share but seemed more like everyone has politely said “oh it’s lovely” and that’s it. It’s a 2 carat princess cut with 6 smaller diamonds either side on the band, my partner suggested it’s because of the size? Has anyone else experienced this?


r/EngagementRings • • Apr 23 '23

Looking for Advice What engagement rings give off an old money vibe?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! My sister is getting engaged soon and said she wants a ring that gives off an “old money” vibe. She wants to achieve this look but isn’t sure what direction to go. I was saying emerald or round cut diamonds on platinum bands or gemstone rings.

What rings do you guys think give off this energy? Thanks!


r/EngagementRings • • May 13 '26

Advice Do we think this is a good wedding ring stack ?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

All opinions and feedback are welcome, thank you :)


r/EngagementRings • • Jan 23 '23

Buying Experience Reddit has made me feel guilty for owning a mined diamond.

13 Upvotes

My fiancé proposed at the end of last year, neither one of us were educated about diamonds until recently and he never thought about it. Just knew what style and cut I liked and truly nailed it, and even was under the impression that it was ethically sourced with the knowledge he did have. But after lurking in the ering sub, diamond, and moissanite and becoming educated I’m starting to feel really guilty about it and I wish it was information we both knew before. So do your research! And become educated before making a pig purchase if you can help it.


r/EngagementRings • • Sep 15 '25

Pick One Opinions on these gorgeous rings

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I'd love to hear everyone's opinion on these rings! 💍✨️

I went browsing at Pandora with my boyfriend... and I've tried on a lot of rings that caught my eye.

My top 5 rings are in the picture above.

I was immediately in love with the first one! And i tried the other rings afterwards. My boyfriend also thought these were very lovely. However we both feel like the last 3 rings had a childish vibe, especially the pink one.

My boyfriend liked the blue flower ring more than the bowtie rings, but he thinks they both look like something for a teenage girl. I personally thought the blue flower ring gives off a luxurious appearance. He loves the toi et moi heart ring and i liked it as well, but it still looks childish to me.

But the second one... we both love this one! It's a simple ring, but it's still very unique! This ring is both my and bf's top 1 ring!

However I'm still unsure if i want the first or second ring, and i already told my boyfriend either the first or second ring.

How do you feel about these rings?


r/EngagementRings • • Nov 10 '22

My Ring What do y’all objectively think of my diamond? GIA report and clarity characteristics plot included along with lots of ring pics!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • Jul 30 '23

Looking for Advice Still don’t have my ring

3 Upvotes

My husband and I got married in court in May and are planning a religious ceremony for next year. He is European and that is we also live. Here, engagement rings aren’t a custom. For the court ceremony we picked out bands, but my band is looking lonely 😓. My best friend has told him about an engagement ring and he says that he doesn’t get it because I picked out the ring I wanted. I don’t want to buy it myself because I want it from HIM, and I don’t want to ask for it. My birthday is around the corner, and I’m crossing my fingers that he has read all the signs.

EDIT. I do not have a problem talking to my husband, what I do have a problem with is asking for material things. Be it birthday presents, Valentine’s, etc. These things I let him-and everyone who knows me buy on their taste and desire. Communication between my husband and I is not the issue.


r/EngagementRings • • Aug 01 '23

Looking for Advice Finished designing her engagement ring. Do you think she’ll say yes?

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Been with my girl for 3 years now and decided that we should get married. I have no idea how much engagement rings cost, my friend group said this is around the price they paid for their fiancée/wives ring. I know this is the style of ring she wants. I’m just wondering do I do a plain band or just keep the band with the diamonds? She loves jewelry always has so I’m thinking the band with diamonds would be a nice touch. Any opinions.


r/EngagementRings • • Mar 31 '23

My Ring Perfect for ME

Post image
9 Upvotes

And that’s what counts. I tend to “misplace” even the most important things, so wearing these has reduced a lot of stress. Easily and inexpensively replaced - I couldn’t be happier.


r/EngagementRings • • 3d ago

Advice Do most people finance rings

6 Upvotes

I want to get married soon, my partner has been looking at rings but all the ones that I like end up costing so much. Do people just drop 4k on a wedding band and engagement ring? That’s normal? I’m being serious, this is kind of upsetting how pricey they are.


r/EngagementRings • • Jan 19 '23

Miscellaneous Some of the rings I think are absolutely beautiful. Boyfriend has been saying he sees me as his future wife🥺💕. I’m just saving these here to look back on later :)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/EngagementRings • • Jan 30 '23

Looking for Advice Indifferent between two engagement rings - help needed!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes